The problem with this is that people are labeling themselves not quite based on how they react to polls but how they see themselves based on how they interpret a typical stereo typical Moderate, Conservative, and Liberal as being.
However if you poll people on the issues without bringing labels into the equation usually the poll results in most people poll answering the poll in the way a liberal leaning person or at the very least a moderate Liberal would answer poll.
According to this article
Most Americans Are Liberal, Even If They Don’t Know It
granted this article is a few years but we can still say that most of the polls are still less than 4 or 5 years old.
The Article contains links to all of the polls so you can see. And it's a fairly lengthy list of issues From Taxes to Workers Rights to Social programs...
Some examples to which (as stated previously) you can find the link within the article to the supporting poll.
- 82 percent of Americans think wealthy people have too much power and influence in Washington.
- 59 percent of Americans—and 43 percent of Republicans—think corporations make “too much profit.”
- 66 percent of Americans think money and wealth should be distributed more evenly.
- 96 percent of Americans—including 96 percent of Republicans—believe money in politics is to blame for the dysfunction of the U.S. political system.
- 78 percent think some wealthy people don’t pay their fair share of taxes.
- 87 percent of Americans say it is critical to preserve Social Security, even if it means increasing Social Security taxes paid by wealthy Americans.
- 76 percent believe the wealthiest Americans should pay higher taxes.
- 61 percent of Americans—including 42 percent of Republicans—approve of labor unions.
- 74 percent of registered voters—including 71 percent of Republicans—support requiring employers to offer paid parental and medical leave.
- 60 percent of registered voters favor “expanding Medicare to provide health insurance to every American.”
- 60 percent of Americans believe “it is the federal government’s responsibility to make sure all Americans have healthcare coverage.”
- 76 percent of voters are “very concerned” or “somewhat concerned” about climate change.
- 77 percent of gun owners support requiring background checks for all gun buyers.
- 65 percent of Americans—including 42 percent of Republicans—say immigrants strengthen the country “because of their hard work and talents.”
- 58 percent of Americans believe that abortion should be legal in all or most cases.
- 62 percent of Americans—including 70 percent of independents and 40 percent of Republicans—support same-sex marriage.
So based on the above examples of how people tend to answer polls on the individual issues (instead of how people see themselves on a political spectrum) a fair majority of people are arguably more liberal than they tend to believe and based on that I believe that a candidate who promotes liberal/populist ideas can bring in Moderate/Independent voters as well as the Base of the Democratic Party.
As long as that candidate actually believes in his or her positions (aka is not just pandering) and can articulate well why they believe in those positions
That is my hypothesis based on how people answer polls on
separate issues without asking them about political labels
Remember Trump acted like a populist (he was lying of course). While his opponent planted her flag squarely in just left of center (mostly) political positions in regards to economics.
OP based on David Brooks' statements I believe that he, like most people answering the label polls, are paying more attention to the labels rather than the issues.
_____________