Originally posted by: jrphoenix
Xbit's Conclusion: doom 3
Dooming Conclusion
So, Doom III is finally here. It makes positive impression, but those, who played the original Doom 10 years ago may just be too old for this kind of action, while the guys and gals who spent months played Counter Strike and FarCry pretty recently may just find the new Doom a little bit monotonous? Frankly speaking, the gameplay is pretty primitive: linear passing-through and very trivial solutions along with the amount of killings is definitely not something that today?s games deliver. Doom III would look good in 2001, 2002. But not in 2004.
Originally posted by: Lothar1974
People are expecting too much, it's just a game ment to have fun killing things and see some cool graphics. I think the graphics are great and the play is good.
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer. I've played for the last three hours since I got home with it, and I cannot see how anyone could be disappointed. If you dont have the reflexes it takes to manage the flashlight and a weapon, that is your own incompetency shining, not iD's.
The game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer.![]()
Originally posted by: Hadsus
If the game wasn't called "Doom 3" and the developers weren't "id" (or however you want to capitalize it), I wonder what kind of impressions/reviews we'd be getting here today.
Originally posted by: brigden
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer. I've played for the last three hours since I got home with it, and I cannot see how anyone could be disappointed. If you dont have the reflexes it takes to manage the flashlight and a weapon, that is your own incompetency shining, not iD's.
The game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer.![]()
No, I disagree. The game looks nice, but it's far too repetitive. The gameplay is severely lacking. Don't get me wrong; it's good, but they could have done better.
Further proof that these guys produce great engines and lackluster games.
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Originally posted by: brigden
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer. I've played for the last three hours since I got home with it, and I cannot see how anyone could be disappointed. If you dont have the reflexes it takes to manage the flashlight and a weapon, that is your own incompetency shining, not iD's.
The game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer.![]()
No, I disagree. The game looks nice, but it's far too repetitive. The gameplay is severely lacking. Don't get me wrong; it's good, but they could have done better.
Further proof that these guys produce great engines and lackluster games.
What the f*ck? Was it supposed to be an RPG? Its Doom, you shoot stuff! More stuff comes, and you shoot that stuff too.
If it were anything else more or less, it would not have been Doom.
I think you all are judging this game negatively for being something it wasn't supposed to be. Not every game has to have some huge level of complexity. Doom 3 is a fun scary romp, and it couldnt be better at being what it is.
Originally posted by: jrphoenix
Xbit's Conclusion: doom 3
Dooming Conclusion
So, Doom III is finally here. It makes positive impression, but those, who played the original Doom 10 years ago may just be too old for this kind of action, while the guys and gals who spent months played Counter Strike and FarCry pretty recently may just find the new Doom a little bit monotonous? Frankly speaking, the gameplay is pretty primitive: linear passing-through and very trivial solutions along with the amount of killings is definitely not something that today?s games deliver. Doom III would look good in 2001, 2002. But not in 2004.
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer. I've played for the last three hours since I got home with it, and I cannot see how anyone could be disappointed. If you dont have the reflexes it takes to manage the flashlight and a weapon, that is your own incompetency shining, not iD's.
The game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer.![]()
Originally posted by: brigden
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer. I've played for the last three hours since I got home with it, and I cannot see how anyone could be disappointed. If you dont have the reflexes it takes to manage the flashlight and a weapon, that is your own incompetency shining, not iD's.
The game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer.![]()
No, I disagree. The game looks nice, but it's far too repetitive. The gameplay is severely lacking. Don't get me wrong; it's good, but they could have done better.
Furthering my opinion that these guys produce great engines and lackluster games.
Originally posted by: brigden
Originally posted by: zenwhen
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer. I've played for the last three hours since I got home with it, and I cannot see how anyone could be disappointed. If you dont have the reflexes it takes to manage the flashlight and a weapon, that is your own incompetency shining, not iD's.
The game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
Doom 3 is the best reason to own a computer.![]()
No, I disagree. The game looks nice, but it's far too repetitive. The gameplay is severely lacking. Don't get me wrong; it's good, but they could have done better.
Further proof that these guys produce great engines and lackluster games.
I'm not acting snooty, I'm just glad that I have found a perfect arguement against those that choose to argue against me. A way to make them see what if feels like.The only thing more annoying than people who act all snooty and superior because they believe in God are the people who act all snooty and superior because they don't believe in God.
Morrowind is so much different, because Silent Hill is linear. There is only one way to go, you just have to find it.Proof positive I have ADD...... I couldn't handle Silent Hills because of that first 30 minutes and lost interest in it. Now I've lost disc 2 of the game and can't reinstall it. Same with Morrowind, too much plodding around trying to get a clue as to what I was suppose to do.
Painkiller is the biggest POS I have ever encountered. The game lacks story and emmersion. It has graphics and monsters. Only reason it was given such a high score was that while you were killing monsters, you can collect souls and stuff. F collecting. Reminds me of Mario64 where I had to collect 100 coins just to get a star. How annoying is that. I can't believe someone actually made a game of that too. Nice graphics though.Well, I just spent a ton of money to upgrade my system to handle the latest crop of predictable computer games because at least I'm still interested in the direction of greater graphics sophistication. I haven't bought Doom 3 yet because I'm trying to get done with Far cry (got that damnn valcano in sight so it won't be long...) and I have Painkiller on the back burner. I don't feel like I've got to rush out and buy it after reading this thread - it can wait.
I am so sad then, that you have left Silent Hill out of your life. One of the best series ever.just hope one day that a game will come out that strives for artistic merrit
I felt like it, but I didn't. Didn't want to ruin the game by reminding myself that it was.Was there anyone who did not kill that first tech when you get the gun?
Seems like MOH:AA gameplay style, which was F-ing fun and lasted a while, but not anymore. It makes sense since they started like 5 years ago with the game.Dooming Conclusion
So, Doom III is finally here. It makes positive impression, but those, who played the original Doom 10 years ago may just be too old for this kind of action, while the guys and gals who spent months played Counter Strike and FarCry pretty recently may just find the new Doom a little bit monotonous? Frankly speaking, the gameplay is pretty primitive: linear passing-through and very trivial solutions along with the amount of killings is definitely not something that today?s games deliver. Doom III would look good in 2001, 2002. But not in 2004.
Duh, that's what the game was supposed to be. All atmosphere. And as proven before with HL, atmosphere can make or break a game.Hmm. No, the more I play, the less impressed I am. While the visuals are incredible and the audio is fantastic, it seems ID spent more effort on atmosphere than gameplay.
It would be another HL.If the game wasn't called "Doom 3" and the developers weren't "id" (or however you want to capitalize it), I wonder what kind of impressions/reviews we'd be getting here today.
lolThe game has a horrifying atmosphere, challenges around every corner, and immerses you in its world. I found myself wasting ammo is places shooting into dark corners because I heard my own footsteps after switching from my PDA.
The only proof of that was Quake II's single player. Maybe you should wait and finish the game before you start giving it a bad name.The gameplay is severely lacking. Don't get me wrong; it's good, but they could have done better.
Further proof that these guys produce great engines and lackluster games.
I never thought that I would ever use this: Same Sh|t, Different Smell. The gameplay was cool back then and it still is now to a certain degree. But now you have all this other stuff to immerse you in the game. It makes you feel more like you're inside and actually experience, thereby providing a new experience for you.That's the problem: You experience the same events over and over and over again.
Factor out improved visuals and audio, and you essentially have the very same game as the original - from 1993!
Walking through corridors, finding PDA's (read: key cards), fighting demons in hidden closets behind you, and collecting random piles of ammunition and health.
It's the same game! Having had years to come out with this product, one expects evolved gameplay. Other companies have produced FPS games featuring evolved gameplay, why can't ID, the father of the genre.
Originally posted by: JeffCY
Maybe I stand alone... but I've been missing this old style of gameplay for a while now. I want my shotgun/chaingun/rocket launcher (well I haven't actually found this yet so I can't confirm its existence), I don't want to drive around in vehicles, I don't want to use real guns like in Far Cry (enough of those guns in Counter-Strike)... I just want to kill my scary monsters and I want to have fun killing them! I get no satisfaction out of using my binoculars then picking people off in Far Cry. I get TONS of satisfaction when I notice the slow zombie crawling towards me... and then point my shotgun at the zombie's head and taking it off. I love the parts where they introduce a new monster, and it goes to a cut scene and you can't run from it... but can only watch it run at you... then suddenly you're back in control with the huge thing in front of you ready to tear you apart. I don't know, it's possible that this exists in Far Cry later on in the game, perhaps I'll try that game again after completing Doom 3. But for now I'm craving more Doom 3.![]()