Does America wonder WHY?

Page 5 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,859
6,395
126
Oh, nevermind just saw who you were talking about . BTW, you should keep him/her, a dissenting voice is a good thing in a democracy. :)

Red Dawn: BTW, if you really wanted something worthwhile, you wouldn't ask for Molsons. Rickards Red or Kokanee(amongst others) or much better. :)
 

tk149

Diamond Member
Apr 3, 2002
7,253
1
0
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold
i was 5 when i came to the US. about 10 yrs ago, i went back to Seoul, Korea and lived there for 5 yrs, don't talk about me as if i know nothing about what happens overseas.

truth is, most europeans haven't a CLUE why americans are so fanatical about america. well guess what, people like me are fanatical about america because we've LIVED in other countries and KNOWS that no where else would we be given the type of opportunities we are here.

I would say i represent a relatively large %age of americans too, many many americans are within 2 generations of their country of origin. They know either first hand or from the stories of their parents the kind of CR4P people put up with in other countries. Is it any wonder that these people are CRAZY about America.

Ditto! I'm second generation, and everytime I get back from a trip to my parent's countries of origin, I want to get down on my hands and knees and kiss U.S. soil. But then I remember that airport security is watching me, and would probably think that I'm on drugs or something.
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Red Dawn: BTW, if you really wanted something worthwhile, you wouldn't ask for Molsons. Rickards Red or Kokanee(amongst others) or much better.
I'm not really a beer drinker though I do enjoy an occasional Guiness:)
 

FrancesBeansRevenge

Platinum Member
Jun 6, 2001
2,181
0
0
Originally posted by: tk149
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold
i was 5 when i came to the US. about 10 yrs ago, i went back to Seoul, Korea and lived there for 5 yrs, don't talk about me as if i know nothing about what happens overseas.

truth is, most europeans haven't a CLUE why americans are so fanatical about america. well guess what, people like me are fanatical about america because we've LIVED in other countries and KNOWS that no where else would we be given the type of opportunities we are here.

I would say i represent a relatively large %age of americans too, many many americans are within 2 generations of their country of origin. They know either first hand or from the stories of their parents the kind of CR4P people put up with in other countries. Is it any wonder that these people are CRAZY about America.

Ditto! I'm second generation, and everytime I get back from a trip to my parent's countries of origin, I want to get down on my hands and knees and kiss U.S. soil. But then I remember that airport security is watching me, and would probably think that I'm on drugs or something.


Bingo.

What Europeans seem to forget is most Americans share NOTHING in common other than being American. We are from all countries, all cultures, all walks of life and many different systems of belief.
But one thing we all share is love for our country. This is the land that took in my poor forefathers and allowed them the freedom to build thier dreams with hardwork. I owe a debt to this country. Unfortunately, I am too much of a wimp to pay it (the military scares the hell out of me) but thankfully plenty of Americans are willing to die for this country's ideals.
 

PlatinumGold

Lifer
Aug 11, 2000
23,168
0
71
Quote

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold

Quote

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Most Americans haven't a clue(as many prove here) as to why some hate them, as I haven't a clue why Americans seem to hate any kind of criticism. Answers like "jealousy" are weak attempts at dismissal, but fail to come to any understanding of the subject. Frankly, I think they rather enjoy being hated, it seems to satisfy their long held belief that they and they alone keep the world from chaos.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



That's such a HUGE generalization. i was 5 when i came to the US. about 10 yrs ago, i went back to Seoul, Korea and lived there for 5 yrs, don't talk about me as if i know nothing about what happens overseas.

truth is, most europeans haven't a CLUE why americans are so fanatical about america. well guess what, people like me are fanatical about america because we've LIVED in other countries and KNOWS that no where else would we be given the type of opportunities we are here.

I would say i represent a relatively large %age of americans too, many many americans are within 2 generations of their country of origin. They know either first hand or from the stories of their parents the kind of CR4P people put up with in other countries. Is it any wonder that these people are CRAZY about America.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



True, it is a broad generalization. Those, such as yourself, have good reason to be "fanatical", because you know things. Unfortunetly it seems that those who have a family history of being Americans don't have that same knowledge. Their reason for fanaticism lies with military/economic might, something which many(especially Europe) have not too fond memories of(not so much the might as the fanaticism of the might).

Basically put, most immigrants to the US, Canada, Europe, and Australia(and others) think very highly of their new found homeland(I could have put Newfoundland hehe)for very good reason, but longtime residences can not truly appreciate those reasons so they find other reasons.

This applies to any nation, even during the height of the British Empire many people throughout the world hated them, yet the few immigrants probably found Britain to be a great place to live. That doesn't mean that the colonized were jealous of Britain or that Britain, as a place, sucked, but they were upset at British interference in their aspirations to self-determination. Whether British Empirical rule "improved" their lives, it often did, was immaterial, no one likes to be rendered moot by a far off unseen power. Colonial Americans are an example of this feeling/state of mind.

You're still missing the point. Of the American Aters here, what percent would you predict have immigrant parents, grand parents or great grandparents.

I'm willing to bet over 70% of the American AT population are children of immigrants w/in the last 100 years.

soo, where do you think the prevailing attitude of AMERICAN ATers comes from???

You Europeans have fallen into the MYTH that there is a representative NATIVE AMERICAN population here. not true. Even the true native americans don't represent the American population as a whole. THIS COUNTRY IS MADE UP OF IMMIGRANTS.
 

A5

Diamond Member
Jun 9, 2000
4,902
5
81
Look at it this way...we basically went off and formed our own country because we didn't want to pay a few pence of tax on paper and tea (AKA Americans love the 'cash monies') ;)

(Well, that plus we didn't think we were Parliament's bitch ;))

Note: I realize that there was a LOT more to it than this, but this was just a joke :)

<-- Been in AP US History for a month :p
 

PlatinumGold

Lifer
Aug 11, 2000
23,168
0
71
Look at it this way...we basically went off and formed our own country because we didn't want to pay a few pence of tax on paper and tea (AKA Americans love the 'cash monies')

Ironic how most of those that were leading the revolt against British Tea were COFFEE farmers huh. and that Coffee was MORE expensive than Tea at the time. hmmmm. wonder who's self interest they were really serving.

Not that I'm complaining about the results mind you, i believe a LOT of good things happen thru peoples Selfish Self interest (the ayn rand in me coming out i guess), but let's not delude ourselves.
 

Cyberian

Diamond Member
Jun 17, 2000
9,999
1
0
"If you question anything the government has done (unless of course it pertains to social welfare), you are met with a wave of McCarthyisms."

Could you explain / define your meaning of McCarthyism in this instance?
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,859
6,395
126
Platinum: 100 years is a long time, even 2nd generation citizens, for a large part don't have a clue. My father immigrated from Hungary in 56 and though he described to me what his life was like I still have no real understanding what his life was like in Hungary. Perhaps if he had married a fellow Hungarian immigrant I would know more and likely would have been taken back to meet family or what not, but he chose to marry a Canadian(4th generation immigrant from the US).

Certainly there are likely many American's with an idea of what's up who are x generation, but there are too many who don't.
 

Ok, you want the US out of the worlds affairs? Fine, say we leave. We only get 25% of our oil from the middle east anyway...let Europe and Japan starve themselves out of oil because the region goes to sh!t. Fine by me, with the money we save we can devolep new alternative enery sources.

Whats that? Out of Asia too? Ok, fine. We will leave China to take care of the local region and make sure justice is served, all the while selling Mcdonalds cokes to thier populations.

The balkens too? Ok. we will let Europe deal with them, since they seem to have done a fine job with thier militaries so far.

Isreal? Yes, we will let the Arab countries do as they will with the remaining Jews. And when they are all nuked, they cant come crying to us.

The US protects more than just its interests here people. It does far more than you realize and takes the blame for doing the dirty work of Japan, Europe and various other countries. When the rest of the world can show us that they can defend thier interests and not let another WW happen, then I suppose we could back down. Until then, dont b!tch, because most of what you have right now is because the US was there when people needed it.
 

hans007

Lifer
Feb 1, 2000
20,212
18
81
Originally posted by: shinerburke
1. Because we are the most wealthy, powerful, and successful nation on the planet.
2. People are jealous of us because of reason #1

that and we tend to figure that since we are #1 and #2 that we are right about everything and try to spread our ideas to the rest of the world because we are "big brother" to the world


 

Phokus

Lifer
Nov 20, 1999
22,994
779
126
Originally posted by: shinerburke
1. Because we are the most wealthy, powerful, and successful nation on the planet.
2. People are jealous of us because of reason #1

Typical American Jingoist tripe from shinerburke. You think the terrorists go, 'hey these guys have lots of money! lets go blow them up!'?

Wow, you really are dense.

 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Why does Bush/whatever American President is applicable at the time not goi to any Earth summits and take note of what is said. If America does so much, surely it could take things that are said at the summits and get them into action, to help poorer people and stop pollution at least a little bit. Instead they DO keep their oil and pollution, and don't appear to be doing much new energy development, despite bieng wealthy powerful and economically sound.
If America does want to help people, why not help people who are suffering due to drought or famine etc, raher than those who bring it upon themselves by war and hatred for other people?
I know those who were at war might then cause problems, but well I can't think of ho wthat could be sorted.
Maybe America does help places, but it has to remember they are not actually the only ones, and that other places do there part as well. And I love my country probably just as much as any American would. I'm English and I want to stay English (unless I move to Canada), because I think MY country is great, and gives me the freedom I want.

(btw, before you start having ago at me for crap facts or anything, I'm young and I have my own viewpoint, so if anything I have said is wrong, by all means correct me, but don't flame)
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
btw, before you start having ago at me for crap facts or anything, I'm young and I have my own viewpoint
And obviously that view is the inner walls of your small intestine.
 

Chaotic42

Lifer
Jun 15, 2001
35,305
2,438
126
Originally posted by: Lonyo


(btw, before you start having ago at me for crap facts or anything, I'm young and I have my own viewpoint, so if anything I have said is wrong, by all means correct me, but don't flame)

How old are you? Young people know nothing about anything. We only think we do. Each year I grow up so much, I look back just 1 year and wonder how I could have been so naive.

Wait till your 40 to start messing with politics. ;)

 

JellyBaby

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2000
9,159
1
81
Lonyo, America does of all the things you mentioned both through private and government sources. Often these are giveaways, sometimes they're loans, but often the aid comes with strings attached. It's the "strings attached" part that gets the world's pink undies in a bunch.

But what do you expect? Money doesn't fall from the sky. Governments don't possess Magic Money, it all comes from the sweat and tears of the private sector. A private sector who want something back for the hard-earned dollars they send to their Uncle.

You'll learn as you grow up that life isn't always black and white. Various shades of grey are everywhere and everything is a compromise.
 

budice

Banned
Sep 5, 2002
95
0
0
I read most of the posts, but this is just an answer to the original question, on one particular level. If you don't understand the level, maybe we're just not on par with each other.
WHY:
People lead such desperate lives that they can be brainwashed into learning a talent such as piloting a passenger airliner. Then taking that talednt for the sole purpose of flying it into a building killing all aboard and an unknown number inside the building. All for the belief in something as ludicrous as receiving 72 virgins in the afterlife with their bravery.
Do you see how stupid that is?
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold

You're still missing the point. Of the American Aters here, what percent would you predict have immigrant parents, grand parents or great grandparents.

I'm willing to bet over 70% of the American AT population are children of immigrants w/in the last 100 years.

soo, where do you think the prevailing attitude of AMERICAN ATers comes from???

You Europeans have fallen into the MYTH that there is a representative NATIVE AMERICAN population here. not true. Even the true native americans don't represent the American population as a whole. THIS COUNTRY IS MADE UP OF IMMIGRANTS.

My great-grandparents immigrated here from Russia during the Bolshevik revolution - my great-uncle and... great-cousins, I believe, were shot by the Bolsheviks for refusing to give up their land.
 

Mill

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
28,558
3
81
Originally posted by: Zakath15
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold

You're still missing the point. Of the American Aters here, what percent would you predict have immigrant parents, grand parents or great grandparents.

I'm willing to bet over 70% of the American AT population are children of immigrants w/in the last 100 years.

soo, where do you think the prevailing attitude of AMERICAN ATers comes from???

You Europeans have fallen into the MYTH that there is a representative NATIVE AMERICAN population here. not true. Even the true native americans don't represent the American population as a whole. THIS COUNTRY IS MADE UP OF IMMIGRANTS.

My great-grandparents immigrated here from Russia during the Bolshevik revolution - my great-uncle and... great-cousins, I believe, were shot by the Bolsheviks for refusing to give up their land.

My family has been here since the 1700's.
 

Ben50

Senior member
Apr 29, 2001
421
0
0
Well I've read through this entire thread and I have come out more confused than enlightened. So far, the main reason I can figure that people hate us is that we think we are special and important. For the most part, I do feel that America is special and important. We may even be the most important/special. But even if we are, it is only slightly more than any of the other major countries. Also, many people in this thread seem to think that because we are important, that means we are better than other countries. This is most certainly not the case although I can see why people might think this. Our government tries to "sugar coat" many things about our country and how good it is. America is not perfect but it often pretends to be. While some people call this hypocrisy, there is a very good reason for it. When people believe something is good, they are willing to protect and fight for it. When people believe something is bad, they are willing to destroy and abuse it. Our nation relies on the fact that people like being here and want to keep it a good place to live as every strong country does.

I also notice that many people think capitalism is a bad system. In this thread alone, I've seen complaints about our lack of a centralized medical system, our poor schools, and our low wages for many people in this country. Guess what, our country isn't perfect so stop trying to nit pick every little thing that is wrong. I would like to see you come up with a perfect system (or even a better system for that matter). Our nation is very competitive so we try to do everything well. I think that is a common trait among all humankind.

I could probably say more, but I think I'll leave it at that for now. Feel free to rip apart my post and enlighten me where you feel I am mistaken.

Of course, I am a 20 year old American citizen so I am obviously right about everything I said. ;)
(If you can't tell because this is an internet message board, the above line is meant to be a joke and is almost certainly not true.)
 

popok

Junior Member
Sep 8, 2002
8
0
0
Originally posted by: Lonyo
Does America wonder why they are the ones to be the most at risk from other countries? Does anyone know why or how it could be changed?

May be because of that ;)
 

JellyBaby

Diamond Member
Apr 21, 2000
9,159
1
81
Originally posted by: Moonbeam
Nice map, popok About sums it up. LOL
Well I hope it's not that bad but it does point out how others on this planet we share view us, if only in parody. :)