I used to be in favor of the death penalty, but I cant say I am anymore.
I've quite simply heard too many occasions where an innocent man gets executed, and that is in my book completely and utterly unacceptable. If it means that we can never execute anyone, so be it. It is bad enough being wrongly imprisoned, but wrongful execution should NEVER happen!
On top of that, I dont think its any sort of deterrent whatsoever. Life in prison is more of a deterrant to me than death. Besides, as someone already said, if youre going to murder a few people, you dont weigh your options and think to yourself.
"Well, life in prison I can deal with, but 20 years of death row before execution is absolutely not going to work for me."
If people must have the death penalty, I would certainly be in favor of a cavaet that someone who shows genuine rehabilitation look Tookie appears to have, they should be commuted to life, in the same sense that good behavior can get you out early on parole.
Many people deserve to die, but we can never be 100% sure of who those people are.
I myself know Ive done plenty of stupid things 10 years ago that I would never even think of doing today.