Do you believe in a higher being?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But how can it be the same God if...

Jews believe in just the Father
Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are three persons in one God

I don't see how that quite works out.

A lot of christians are UNItarian ;)
 

neonerd

Diamond Member
Apr 24, 2003
8,746
1
0
I don't because I'm one of those asshats who needs physical/scientific proof for everything and anything. The only reason I believe that there are ET's, because the scientific probability that we're the only living organisms in this universe is so little that there's a MUCH greated probability that something/someone else is out there.
 

BrokenVisage

Lifer
Jan 29, 2005
24,771
14
81
There's only one all powerful force in the universe and science has already discovered it; Gravity.
It created the Sun, planets, and the stars in the sky, it just needs a lot of time to do it.
It's nice to think there's an actual God running heaven with pearly gates waiting for us when we die, but please..
The theory of a God or god-like dieties was born from the concepts in religions.
And since any religion is just a metaphor of life, it shouldn't be taken seriously.
I'm not here to tell anyone their wrong but this is how I see things, I can't just pretend to believe in a force with a conscious.
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Originally posted by: Vaerilis
No.
In case one really exists, it's not a matter of belief, anyway.
What someone "wants to believe" can not alter reality.

I agree. Either there is some "higher being" or there is not. No amount of belief either way will ever change that. Personally, I see no point in believing in one (much less "worshipping" one).
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Originally posted by: clarkey01
I?m not up for flaming and offended people and their beliefs, but when I pick up a bible and try and read its?.Doesn?t convince me.

I want to believe there is a god, I want to believe that we?re all born good and are looked down upon by a higher being for who we really are.

Anyone else confused like me ?

Try this:

What created life? - complex chemical reactions

What created those reactions? - physics

What created the laws of physics? - Since there seems to be no cause of physics, the rules are all "preset", they must have been designed. There you have God.
 

mwtgg

Lifer
Dec 6, 2001
10,491
0
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But how can it be the same God if...

Jews believe in just the Father
Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are three persons in one God

I don't see how that quite works out.

A lot of christians are UNItarian ;)

So where does Jesus fall in line here? Or the Holy Spirit?
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What created the laws of physics? - Since there seems to be no cause of physics, the rules are all "preset", they must have been designed. There you have God.

You are not proving the existence of God. You are assuming God, because you cannot explain why the laws of physics are what they are.
 

QuitBanningMe

Banned
Mar 2, 2005
5,038
2
0
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: clarkey01
I?m not up for flaming and offended people and their beliefs, but when I pick up a bible and try and read its?.Doesn?t convince me.

I want to believe there is a god, I want to believe that we?re all born good and are looked down upon by a higher being for who we really are.

Anyone else confused like me ?

Try this:

What created life? - complex chemical reactions

What created those reactions? - physics

What created the laws of physics? - Since there seems to be no cause of physics, the rules are all "preset", they must have been designed. There you have God.

No physics is created by existance. You can potentially have any number of different "physics". Once you have existance you have relationships between whatever makes up that existance.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But how can it be the same God if...

Jews believe in just the Father
Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are three persons in one God

I don't see how that quite works out.

A lot of christians are UNItarian ;)

So where does Jesus fall in line here? Or the Holy Spirit?

Jesus would be Yahweh's son . . . the Holy Spirit is an "active force" (in Greek it is a "neuter")

Unitarians believe as the Jews and Islam . . . there is ONE god (the father)
__________________
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
Originally posted by: Fritzo
What created the laws of physics? - Since there seems to be no cause of physics, the rules are all "preset", they must have been designed. There you have God.

You are not proving the existence of God. You are assuming God, because you cannot explain why the laws of physics are what they are.
to the "believers": What was BEFORE god? Who created him? Where did he "come" from?

Same speculative nonsense:p
:roll:
 

mwtgg

Lifer
Dec 6, 2001
10,491
0
0
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But how can it be the same God if...

Jews believe in just the Father
Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are three persons in one God

I don't see how that quite works out.

A lot of christians are UNItarian ;)

So where does Jesus fall in line here? Or the Holy Spirit?

Jesus would be Yahweh's son . . . the Holy Spirit is an "active force" (in Greek it is a "neuter")

Unitarians believe as the Jews and Islam . . . there is ONE god (the father)

True, but you said a lot of Christians have Unitarian beliefs, and I don't see how that's true.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But how can it be the same God if...

Jews believe in just the Father
Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are three persons in one God

I don't see how that quite works out.

A lot of christians are UNItarian ;)

So where does Jesus fall in line here? Or the Holy Spirit?

Jesus would be Yahweh's son . . . the Holy Spirit is an "active force" (in Greek it is a "neuter")

Unitarians believe as the Jews and Islam . . . there is ONE god (the father)

True, but you said a lot of Christians have Unitarian beliefs, and I don't see how that's true.

well, that's what YOUR bible teaches . . . there is zero to minimal support for the 3-in-1 theory in the bible . . . the idea of the Trinity comes straight out of ancient pagan beliefs.

Most gods in Pagan religions come in threes . . . just like the trinity . . .

there is a reason it is called a "mystery"
:roll:
(it makes no sense and breaks tradition with judaism of which christianity is an offshoot)
 

artikk

Diamond Member
Dec 24, 2004
4,172
1
71
A flamefest... how unconventional. Relax people. Put your flamethrowers down and step away from flamebait. It's almost time to go to sleep and you're still arguing. Give it a rest.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: russianpower
A flamefest... how unconventional. Relax people. Put your flamethrowers down and step away from flamebait. It's almost time to go to sleep and you're still arguing. Give it a rest.

a flamefest would include things like . . .

'You're a moron'

. . . it hasn't deteriorated yet . . . quit your complaining . . . . it's a pretty simple exercise, really - explaining "why' you believe in a "higher being" or not. :p
:roll:
 

EGGO

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2004
5,504
1
0
Do I believe in one? No
Do I think one may exist? Who knows. I don't particularly care either.

And that's what it means to be agnostic.
 

Bacardi151

Senior member
Dec 15, 2003
540
0
0
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Originally posted by: clarkey01
I?m not up for flaming and offended people and their beliefs, but when I pick up a bible and try and read its?.Doesn?t convince me.

I want to believe there is a god, I want to believe that we?re all born good and are looked down upon by a higher being for who we really are.

Anyone else confused like me ?

Try this:

What created life? - complex chemical reactions

What created those reactions? - physics

What created the laws of physics? - Since there seems to be no cause of physics, the rules are all "preset", they must have been designed. There you have God.

golden example of somebody falling back on their religion because they don't have another answer for it. *sigh*
 

Bacardi151

Senior member
Dec 15, 2003
540
0
0
Originally posted by: Armoth
I don't want to get flamed either, but I ask this question in all seriousness without the intent of sounding preachy, but only to hopefully provoke some thought.

Ok, how about this question...what if you're wrong?

Sure, you have free will and can choose to believe what you want. You can have faith in God (Christianity), faith in man (Humanism), one of the many other "gods" out there (too many to list), or believe there's simply no god at all (atheism). So you choose to believe in one of the other gods or no god and end up being wrong...and there is only one true God, well, then you have to come face to face with him and be judged. If a Christian is wrong? Then what's the result then? Simply become "one with the universe," or just become dust and that's it, achieve total enlightenment, cross over to another dimension, meet the aliens....what? What's the worse thing that could happen if a Christian is wrong? And what's the worse thing that can happen if Christianity is right and you aren't?

I'm just curious what ATOTers have to say, hopefully, at least some are serious here...

Discuss amongst yourselves.


thank you for pointing out that you believe in your religion because you're a chicken sh*t. you're scared that if you're an atheist and you're wrong you'll go to hell, but if you're a christian and you're wrong nothing will happen.

that also shows how insincere your faith is.
 

Armoth

Senior member
Jan 22, 2003
663
0
71
Originally posted by: Bacardi151
Originally posted by: Armoth
I don't want to get flamed either, but I ask this question in all seriousness without the intent of sounding preachy, but only to hopefully provoke some thought.

Ok, how about this question...what if you're wrong?

Sure, you have free will and can choose to believe what you want. You can have faith in God (Christianity), faith in man (Humanism), one of the many other "gods" out there (too many to list), or believe there's simply no god at all (atheism). So you choose to believe in one of the other gods or no god and end up being wrong...and there is only one true God, well, then you have to come face to face with him and be judged. If a Christian is wrong? Then what's the result then? Simply become "one with the universe," or just become dust and that's it, achieve total enlightenment, cross over to another dimension, meet the aliens....what? What's the worse thing that could happen if a Christian is wrong? And what's the worse thing that can happen if Christianity is right and you aren't?

I'm just curious what ATOTers have to say, hopefully, at least some are serious here...

Discuss amongst yourselves.


thank you for pointing out that you believe in your religion because you're a chicken sh*t. you're scared that if you're an atheist and you're wrong you'll go to hell, but if you're a christian and you're wrong nothing will happen.

that also shows how insincere your faith is.

Well, someone certainly enjoys judging others... Did I say "My faith is based completely on fear"? Not at all! I asked one specific question to try to generate some conversation. I don't know why you stopped jackin off long enough to type, but I wish you hadn't.

I don't know why I bother posting in these threads since there are so many asshats here that just want to flame others. They couldn't carry on a civilized, intellectual conversation if their lives depended on it...

It has nothing to do with fear. It was simply one question about how one uses their free will and what the ultimate consequences are for that decision.
 

BurnItDwn

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
26,354
1,863
126
I am not in any way shape or form confused about this subject.

There is no higher being.
 

Bacardi151

Senior member
Dec 15, 2003
540
0
0
Originally posted by: Armoth
Originally posted by: Bacardi151
Originally posted by: Armoth
I don't want to get flamed either, but I ask this question in all seriousness without the intent of sounding preachy, but only to hopefully provoke some thought.

Ok, how about this question...what if you're wrong?

Sure, you have free will and can choose to believe what you want. You can have faith in God (Christianity), faith in man (Humanism), one of the many other "gods" out there (too many to list), or believe there's simply no god at all (atheism). So you choose to believe in one of the other gods or no god and end up being wrong...and there is only one true God, well, then you have to come face to face with him and be judged. If a Christian is wrong? Then what's the result then? Simply become "one with the universe," or just become dust and that's it, achieve total enlightenment, cross over to another dimension, meet the aliens....what? What's the worse thing that could happen if a Christian is wrong? And what's the worse thing that can happen if Christianity is right and you aren't?

I'm just curious what ATOTers have to say, hopefully, at least some are serious here...

Discuss amongst yourselves.


thank you for pointing out that you believe in your religion because you're a chicken sh*t. you're scared that if you're an atheist and you're wrong you'll go to hell, but if you're a christian and you're wrong nothing will happen.

that also shows how insincere your faith is.

Well, someone certainly enjoys judging others... Did I say "My faith is based completely on fear"? Not at all! I asked one specific question to try to generate some conversation. I don't know why you stopped jackin off long enough to type, but I wish you hadn't.

I don't know why I bother posting in these threads since there are so many asshats here that just want to flame others. They couldn't carry on a civilized, intellectual conversation if their lives depended on it...

It has nothing to do with fear. It was simply one question about how one uses their free will and what the ultimate consequences are for that decision.


i didnt say you SAID you have your faith through fear, but it was definitely implied through your post when you said "what's the worse that can happen if a christian is wrong? and what's the worse that can happen when an atheist is wrong?" obviously you shouldn't even be balancing those two in order to rationalize which one to go with. you go with one or the other because of faith or proof, something you obviously LACK seeing that you're doing it by being on the "safe" side. tsk tsk. i hope you enjoy living your life by a set of rules in fear
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: Bacardi151
Originally posted by: Armoth
Originally posted by: Bacardi151
Originally posted by: Armoth
I don't want to get flamed either, but I ask this question in all seriousness without the intent of sounding preachy, but only to hopefully provoke some thought.

Ok, how about this question...what if you're wrong?

Sure, you have free will and can choose to believe what you want. You can have faith in God (Christianity), faith in man (Humanism), one of the many other "gods" out there (too many to list), or believe there's simply no god at all (atheism). So you choose to believe in one of the other gods or no god and end up being wrong...and there is only one true God, well, then you have to come face to face with him and be judged. If a Christian is wrong? Then what's the result then? Simply become "one with the universe," or just become dust and that's it, achieve total enlightenment, cross over to another dimension, meet the aliens....what? What's the worse thing that could happen if a Christian is wrong? And what's the worse thing that can happen if Christianity is right and you aren't?

I'm just curious what ATOTers have to say, hopefully, at least some are serious here...

Discuss amongst yourselves.


thank you for pointing out that you believe in your religion because you're a chicken sh*t. you're scared that if you're an atheist and you're wrong you'll go to hell, but if you're a christian and you're wrong nothing will happen.

that also shows how insincere your faith is.

Well, someone certainly enjoys judging others... Did I say "My faith is based completely on fear"? Not at all! I asked one specific question to try to generate some conversation. I don't know why you stopped jackin off long enough to type, but I wish you hadn't.

I don't know why I bother posting in these threads since there are so many asshats here that just want to flame others. They couldn't carry on a civilized, intellectual conversation if their lives depended on it...

It has nothing to do with fear. It was simply one question about how one uses their free will and what the ultimate consequences are for that decision.


i didnt say you SAID you have your faith through fear, but it was definitely implied through your post when you said "what's the worse that can happen if a christian is wrong? and what's the worse that can happen when an atheist is wrong?" obviously you shouldn't even be balancing those two in order to rationalize which one to go with. you go with one or the other because of faith or proof, something you obviously LACK seeing that you're doing it by being on the "safe" side. tsk tsk. i hope you enjoy living your life by a set of rules in fear

Agreed, I can't understand wanting to believe in what's safest rather than in what you feel is the truth. Santa Claus is a nice idea, beats poverty during the holidays - you believe in him too?
 

Gunslinger08

Lifer
Nov 18, 2001
13,234
2
81
Jews and Christians have a drastically different view on just about everything.

Christians:
Possible to have a personal relationship with God, through Jesus (because he was mortal and God at the same time).
Old Testament was metaphorical (for most denominations.. not all).
No matter what you do, you can still be saved, if you just ask forgiveness (unless you're Catholic and believe in the seven deadly sins).

Jews:
Conformity. Much more "religion" and "tradition."
Not evangelical (this is changing though).
Old Testament is Truth, word for word, as are newer "oral laws" which comment on the OT.
Sin is a bigger deal, and harder to deal with/repent.
 

apoppin

Lifer
Mar 9, 2000
34,890
1
0
alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: joshsquall
Jews and Christians have a drastically different view on just about everything.

Christians:
Possible to have a personal relationship with God, through Jesus (because he was mortal and God at the same time).
Old Testament was metaphorical (for most denominations.. not all).
No matter what you do, you can still be saved, if you just ask forgiveness (unless you're Catholic and believe in the seven deadly sins).

Jews:
Conformity. Much more "religion" and "tradition."
Not evangelical (this is changing though).
Old Testament is Truth, word for word, as are newer "oral laws" which comment on the OT.
Sin is a bigger deal, and harder to deal with/repent.

Christianity is a sect of Judaism . . .