Convince me that I don't want a Golf GTI

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
... what else have you driven in the hot-hatch segment?

Only some lukewarm hatches, like the Mazda 3 Sedan, and a very long time ago, a buddy's 5-speed Freshcort. Yes, I want to drive a few before I make a decision, but I'm trying to not make this decision.

I was more interested in the Focus ST, but those aren't being made over here anymore, so I don't want to go down that route (I'm sure there wouldn't be any problem with parts--it's Ford. But still). I won't consider the Cruz because I won't buy a Chevy. I just won't.

I wanted to go back to a Honda with a Civic because I am most familiar with the way Hondas drive and their clutch's, but those things were styled by a brainless teenager.
 

JCH13

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2010
4,981
66
91
Only some lukewarm hatches, like the Mazda 3 Sedan, and a very long time ago, a buddy's 5-speed Freshcort. Yes, I want to drive a few before I make a decision, but I'm trying to not make this decision.

I was more interested in the Focus ST, but those aren't being made over here anymore, so I don't want to go down that route (I'm sure there wouldn't be any problem with parts--it's Ford. But still). I won't consider the Cruz because I won't buy a Chevy. I just won't.

I wanted to go back to a Honda with a Civic because I am most familiar with the way Hondas drive and their clutch's, but those things were styled by a brainless teenager.

Focus and Fiesta ST, Mazdaspeed3, and WRX should be up your list. I liked those better than the GTI from a driver's perspective.
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,136
622
126
But to Doug's point, the Golf is the most civilized (and nondescript) of the bunch. Just depends on what your priorities are.

I just wouldn't VW in the first place ;)
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
Focus and Fiesta ST, Mazdaspeed3, and WRX should be up your list. I liked those better than the GTI from a driver's perspective.

Speed3 was/would be my top choice, but Mazda hasn't made one since 2006? 2009? I don't want one that old, with no certainty that they are going to start making them again...plus all the ones near me are pretty high mileage, understandably. I really, really, really like the Mazda interiors, exteriors, and most everything really. I would probably go for the Speed over anything, if they had younger models.

I'd probably choose the Focus ST, too, but again, Ford stopped making them here and to add salt to the wound, the Uk/Euro 2019 ST looks absolutely stunning from a performance perspective. I like the Fiestas, too, but too small. I don't need it to be the perfect, absolute best performer for a hot hatch, but like I guess most people that gravitate towards the Golf, I want it to be better at doing everything all together than all the other cars. Yeah, it's the "VW stigma" that really holds me back. Especially with the older generation around me and weighing in, that grew up with the beetle and the microbus in the 60s and on, ...they will never forget, lol.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
But to Doug's point, the Golf is the most civilized (and nondescript) of the bunch. Just depends on what your priorities are.

I just wouldn't VW in the first place ;)

yup, that's what I aim for. I watched his video last week--I like watching Doug's videos.

are you saying that you know the person that's selling the same Golf R that he tested there?
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,136
622
126
Sort of. I know him by association as some of his parts on my car. That's the reason he bought it, to develop parts for it. On to the next project for him.
 

JCH13

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2010
4,981
66
91
Speed3 was/would be my top choice, but Mazda hasn't made one since 2006? 2009? I don't want one that old, with no certainty that they are going to start making them again...plus all the ones near me are pretty high mileage, understandably. I really, really, really like the Mazda interiors, exteriors, and most everything really. I would probably go for the Speed over anything, if they had younger models.

I'd probably choose the Focus ST, too, but again, Ford stopped making them here and to add salt to the wound, the Uk/Euro 2019 ST looks absolutely stunning from a performance perspective. I like the Fiestas, too, but too small. I don't need it to be the perfect, absolute best performer for a hot hatch, but like I guess most people that gravitate towards the Golf, I want it to be better at doing everything all together than all the other cars. Yeah, it's the "VW stigma" that really holds me back. Especially with the older generation around me and weighing in, that grew up with the beetle and the microbus in the 60s and on, ...they will never forget, lol.

MS3 was made through 2013.

Why the hesitation with an older model? If you find a well-cared-for example you can save a lot of money and have a perfectly reliable vehicle.
 

pauldun170

Diamond Member
Sep 26, 2011
9,332
5,420
136
Speed3 was/would be my top choice, but Mazda hasn't made one since 2006? 2009? I don't want one that old, with no certainty that they are going to start making them again...plus all the ones near me are pretty high mileage, understandably. I really, really, really like the Mazda interiors, exteriors, and most everything really. I would probably go for the Speed over anything, if they had younger models.

I'd probably choose the Focus ST, too, but again, Ford stopped making them here and to add salt to the wound, the Uk/Euro 2019 ST looks absolutely stunning from a performance perspective. I like the Fiestas, too, but too small. I don't need it to be the perfect, absolute best performer for a hot hatch, but like I guess most people that gravitate towards the Golf, I want it to be better at doing everything all together than all the other cars. Yeah, it's the "VW stigma" that really holds me back. Especially with the older generation around me and weighing in, that grew up with the beetle and the microbus in the 60s and on, ...they will never forget, lol.


IMO - Speed3 are garbage. Fun cars? Yes. Fast Cars? Yes. Something you want to keep for a long time....nope. Along with old MazdaSpeed6's, they are best left to the tuner and "Once you replace X part and mod bro" crowd. Might as well get the GTI.
Everyone misses their Speed3 but over the years, but I don't know too many people who held on to them over long haul. As a bystander there seems to be a "use by date " on them before headaches begin.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
MS3 was made through 2013.

Why the hesitation with an older model? If you find a well-cared-for example you can save a lot of money and have a perfectly reliable vehicle.

IMO - Speed3 are garbage. Fun cars? Yes. Fast Cars? Yes. Something you want to keep for a long time....nope. Along with old MazdaSpeed6's, they are best left to the tuner and "Once you replace X part and mod bro" crowd. Might as well get the GTI.
Everyone misses their Speed3 but over the years, but I don't know too many people who held on to them over long haul. As a bystander there seems to be a "use by date " on them before headaches begin.

all of the ones that I am seeing within 50 miles of me, quick search, bottom out at 86k, but most are ~115k and up to 150k miles. Seriously: no thanks. And again, they are old gen Mazda interior styling. I already have that. Since you actually live inside the car when operating it, and not driving from the roof or the hood like in Mad Max, it's kind of important. Also, the 2 or 3 low mileage ones (80k-90k) report accident/frame damage for each. eh....Yeah, it would be a huge savings to go that rout, but when I'm swapping out to a car that puts 30%+ the mileage of what I already have, and a repaired(?) frame, for something that "feels a bit more fun" to drive, and nothing else...it seems like a worse decision than my already terrible decision making that lead to this thread in the first place. :D

Yes--Mazda Speed would be in my consideration, but like I mentioned earlier, the GTI actually ticks off all the boxes (cliche: that's the point). It may be beaten in raw performance by a solid number of cars in this class by now, though the Mk 7 and 7.5 are actually being tested at 230-240hp, stock, despite VW's claim of 220 and 228 (the 2018 7.0 and 2019 7.5)--so they are actually sandbagging it seems, which is weird. Anyway, that isn't the point. The one consistent single point among all the reviewers for the Golf, the WRX, the Type R or Civic Sport, Hyundia(s), and whatever others, is that the ride is noticeably better and the interior is actual quality in the Golf--most argue that it is basically luxury class interior. Also, it still seems to drive and handle a wee bit better than the others, so despite lacking in raw hp or torque, it can still outperform most others, depending on the test. the DSG sprints better than competitors while being heavier and lacking 30 or 40 more hp, too (The Grand Tour showed this with the polo, but again, that could actually be more of an issue of VW actually sandbagging on the power, but most likely a bit of both)

If Mazda made Speed3 or 6 with their current styling, it would be different...also price-wise of course because I don't think those would be selling new at about $6-9k off MSRP, like the GTI

I will say though...that Veloster N looks really fricking intriguing. The performance + kinda damages the price, but it looks like a crazy fun car. Interior is sad, though, supposedly back-crushing ride....and 3 doors? I don't know--maybe I could like that, but it still seems a bit too small for what I want. It is distracting though...but it is also new only, for now. They fart a lot. I'm not sure if that's what I want? Yes, it sounds more fun, but I feel like I should act my (relative) age, no?

The Veloster Turbos or whatever they are called seem OK, but are only 2 door? Yes, I know that is kind of the point with this class--but not what I want.
 
Last edited:

SearchMaster

Diamond Member
Jun 6, 2002
7,791
114
106
As the owner of a '13 Focus ST that has been a great car...

Don't get the GTI. Or an ST. The purpose of a car like the ST or GTI is, in my opinion, to be a good daily driver that happens to have a fun factor. You don't drive enough to make this applicable to your situation. I would get a more fun used car that will hold its value almost indefinitely with the low miles you drive and if you REALLY need hauling capabilities, get a second car/truck or borrow/rent something on occasion (Home Depot pickup truck, $19 for 75 minutes). You don't really want to haul 2x4s in your brand new hot hatch anyway and they won't fit all that well anyway without scratching everything up. Hell I borrowed my ex's minivan when I last needed to carry building materials.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
That's a valid point. Why not a used Vette?

searchmaster makes many logical points, all of which I thoroughly reject. ...for no reason.

as for a Vette, it goes back to the "I will never own a Chevy." I also just don't like the idea of owning sports cars, much less driving around in them. Well, obvious sports cars. That just isn't me.

....Ferrari is excluded from that consideration, however.
 

JCH13

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2010
4,981
66
91
IMO - Speed3 are garbage. Fun cars? Yes. Fast Cars? Yes. Something you want to keep for a long time....nope. Along with old MazdaSpeed6's, they are best left to the tuner and "Once you replace X part and mod bro" crowd. Might as well get the GTI.
Everyone misses their Speed3 but over the years, but I don't know too many people who held on to them over long haul. As a bystander there seems to be a "use by date " on them before headaches begin.

0d7.jpg


I bought my MS3 new in June 2009 and kept it through November 2017. Besides regular wear items like brakes and oil changes I had to replace all of the dampers/struts. Otherwise it gave me no trouble. I mostly saw tuners who got a little crazy with mods kill things, but anyone who was reasonable about their ownership had few unplanned maintenance items.

DashboardLight doesn't have data on MS3, just everything lumped into the Mazda3 model, sadly. However, the Mazda3/MS3 is rated more reliable than the GTI or Golf. Although the 2008-2012 Golf looks pretty decent compared to the Golf average.

Not that Mazda is on average an amazingly reliable brand, but it is rated higher than VW! http://www.dashboard-light.com/reports/Mazda.html
 

SearchMaster

Diamond Member
Jun 6, 2002
7,791
114
106
searchmaster makes many logical points, all of which I thoroughly reject. ...for no reason.

as for a Vette, it goes back to the "I will never own a Chevy." I also just don't like the idea of owning sports cars, much less driving around in them. Well, obvious sports cars. That just isn't me.

....Ferrari is excluded from that consideration, however.
Hey I tried ‍.

For what it's worth, I posted a similar thread when I was considering purchasing my ST in 2013 and obviously nobody convinced me not to buy it. I don't regret it at all - it's been fun, economical, and aside from some rattles that have developed in the last year (primarily due to crappy A/S tires, the previous soft summer tires were fine) it has been completely uneventful in a good way.

I don't drive that much, I've been working from home the entire time I've had the car, but I've still averaged over 13000 miles a year or 4x what you drive. What this means is that 90% of my driving is taking my son to and from school, or driving to and from the grocery store - neither of which activity inspires spirited driving (I drive like an old lady through neighborhoods because children, dogs, and deer). Every few months I'll drive through windy mountainous roads and the car is great then.

I'm a bit biased against VW because the only two people I know personally who have bought a new one regretted it within a year, but both of those purchases were 10+ years ago so maybe they've improved a lot. I do like the latest generation of GTI and from what I've read, a flash tune turns it into a beast. Many ST owners have moved to the other side as a result. At 3K miles a year, I can't imagine it would give you any trouble.
 

pauldun170

Diamond Member
Sep 26, 2011
9,332
5,420
136
0d7.jpg


I bought my MS3 new in June 2009 and kept it through November 2017. Besides regular wear items like brakes and oil changes I had to replace all of the dampers/struts. Otherwise it gave me no trouble. I mostly saw tuners who got a little crazy with mods kill things, but anyone who was reasonable about their ownership had few unplanned maintenance items.

DashboardLight doesn't have data on MS3, just everything lumped into the Mazda3 model, sadly. However, the Mazda3/MS3 is rated more reliable than the GTI or Golf. Although the 2008-2012 Golf looks pretty decent compared to the Golf average.

Not that Mazda is on average an amazingly reliable brand, but it is rated higher than VW! http://www.dashboard-light.com/reports/Mazda.html

You bought it new. You cared for it. You loved it.
You bought it raspberries when it told you it wanted to add a little something to its oatmeal. It treated you well. I believe you when you said it was a good car to you.
I'm tempted to say...I might love your old MazdaSpeed3 too (but only if the headliner is in good shape. I'll be damned if I spend another minute in a Mazda with droopy headliner)

I've heard the same thing from the occasional VW GTI\BMW 3series\Range Rover owner.
Never a Mini owner. Those cars are cursed.

My opinion is that the MazdaSpeed3 as it exist today, only on the used car market with plenty of miles on them are a bad buy and should be considered garbage. Mod bro culture is strong and a lot of the MazdaSpeed3's on the market have had their wibbly bits fondled in inappropriate ways by owners. I believe, in my completely crappy opinion, based on "hanging out with mechanics, wasting a lot of time on the internet window shop[ping MazdaSpeed3 and scouring forums,
and old man set in my ways shaking sticks at things" mindset that MazdaSpeed3 reliability is obscenely influenced by the owner. Based on CX7 and MazdaSpeed6's, I'm also leaning towards Mazda turbos of that era are best leased when new. Avoided when used.
For someone who wants a platform. Mazdaspeed3's are a potential starting point.
For someone who wants a gas and go car. I can't support the MS3.

We were a Mazda household from 1993 to 2018.


Now excuse me as I go scouring the internet for low mileage Mazdaspeed3's.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
Hey I tried ‍.

For what it's worth, I posted a similar thread when I was considering purchasing my ST in 2013 and obviously nobody convinced me not to buy it. I don't regret it at all - it's been fun, economical, and aside from some rattles that have developed in the last year (primarily due to crappy A/S tires, the previous soft summer tires were fine) it has been completely uneventful in a good way.

I don't drive that much, I've been working from home the entire time I've had the car, but I've still averaged over 13000 miles a year or 4x what you drive. What this means is that 90% of my driving is taking my son to and from school, or driving to and from the grocery store - neither of which activity inspires spirited driving (I drive like an old lady through neighborhoods because children, dogs, and deer). Every few months I'll drive through windy mountainous roads and the car is great then.

I'm a bit biased against VW because the only two people I know personally who have bought a new one regretted it within a year, but both of those purchases were 10+ years ago so maybe they've improved a lot. I do like the latest generation of GTI and from what I've read, a flash tune turns it into a beast. Many ST owners have moved to the other side as a result. At 3K miles a year, I can't imagine it would give you any trouble.

Yeah, I read through your thread a few times, because I was considering an ST, up until Ford announced that they were essentially abandoning the entire US market of sensible people, and while I've kept an eye on them, they are quickly disappearing from stock around me. We had some bad Fords growing up, so I had a pretty long anti-Ford thing, but over the last decade they had really turned it around, especially with the Mazda relationship. I like that that they were the only US manufacturer to not need a bailout in 2008-2009, because they had spent the previous several years focusing on quality and reliability, unlike the others that were just: here some more of the crap like we keep making but you better buy it because America! herp. Now, they've pissed me off again.

I do drive a bit more than I used to when in CA (~70% of so of the current Mazda's lifetime), because now I will drive down to NC from MD every couple of months and back, and I do have to drive a bit further out to do the ~monthly large errand runs. But still, much of that driving is like yours, and I definitely drive like grandma in neighborhoods around here. It's just not worth driving like I used to back when I was 17-20. ...but the route down to NC can be pretty nice, but much longer, if I avoid 95 much of the way. ....so that has me thinking. The Shenandoah's aren't that far away either....

My one friend who does have this long, strange, VW obsession had some mixed experiences. He has/had a Jetta that he loved, but I don't really know the history of it (I believe he eventually replaced it with a Fit, forget why. Family or something). In his filthy hippy days, c. 1998-2003, he had purchased a '73, I think, microbus, with 2 of 4 working cylinders, iirc. The plan was to drive up and down the east coast for Phish and related shows. ....it kinda worked. I think they made it from Raleigh to Merryweather (in Maryland), but it took about 8 or 9 hours, and included a tow on the way back. I didn't go on this trip. It did break down a few times locally, well more than that, and I'm not sure that I ever agreed to go on a long trip in that thing (3+ hours), because it was just lunacy. To be fair, you have to be a bit mental to want something like that, with its history well established in the canon--but I do get it.

For the most part, I would demand that I make those trips in my 94 Accord EX--Miami or wherever--which, similar to Pauldin's Mazda(s), suffered from pealy leather trim on the doors. Not sure how that happened, adhesive gave out or something.
 
Last edited:

JCH13

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2010
4,981
66
91
This whole thread...

Zinfamous: please make logical arguments to dissuade me from this decision

Everyone: here are many good, logical, reasons to say no

Zinfamous: don't care lololol

Just post pics when you buy your GTI, and then copies of your bills when it gets sad from only being driven 3k/year :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: zinfamous

JCH13

Diamond Member
Sep 14, 2010
4,981
66
91
You bought it new. You cared for it. You loved it.
You bought it raspberries when it told you it wanted to add a little something to its oatmeal. It treated you well. I believe you when you said it was a good car to you.
I'm tempted to say...I might love your old MazdaSpeed3 too (but only if the headliner is in good shape. I'll be damned if I spend another minute in a Mazda with droopy headliner)

I've heard the same thing from the occasional VW GTI\BMW 3series\Range Rover owner.
Never a Mini owner. Those cars are cursed.

My opinion is that the MazdaSpeed3 as it exist today, only on the used car market with plenty of miles on them are a bad buy and should be considered garbage. Mod bro culture is strong and a lot of the MazdaSpeed3's on the market have had their wibbly bits fondled in inappropriate ways by owners. I believe, in my completely crappy opinion, based on "hanging out with mechanics, wasting a lot of time on the internet window shop[ping MazdaSpeed3 and scouring forums,
and old man set in my ways shaking sticks at things" mindset that MazdaSpeed3 reliability is obscenely influenced by the owner. Based on CX7 and MazdaSpeed6's, I'm also leaning towards Mazda turbos of that era are best leased when new. Avoided when used.
For someone who wants a platform. Mazdaspeed3's are a potential starting point.
For someone who wants a gas and go car. I can't support the MS3.

We were a Mazda household from 1993 to 2018.


Now excuse me as I go scouring the internet for low mileage Mazdaspeed3's.

I think that we're in violent agreement, hehe. Civics suffer the same way. If I could find a clean SI I'd buy it in a heartbeat for a second track/toy car... but good f'n luck!
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146
This whole thread...

Zinfamous: please make logical arguments to dissuade me from this decision

Everyone: here are many good, logical, reasons to say no

Zinfamous: don't care lololol

Just post pics when you buy your GTI, and then copies of your bills when it gets sad from only being driven 3k/year :p

Hey, I never promised that this would be a fair fight. ...and it's not like I'm already not dealing with that.

I promise to finish my taxes, though, and set up a consult/job for an electrician to re-wire my kitchen, then new countertops, then the floor (myself), before jumping on a new car--hopefully this depletes a significant amount of my potential deposit.

It's a promise

...now back to Autorader/CarGurus to refresh today's offerings and see if new desperation is apparent...
 

olds

Elite Member
Mar 3, 2000
50,114
776
126
This whole thread...

Zinfamous: please make logical arguments to dissuade me from this decision

Everyone: here are many good, logical, reasons to say no

Zinfamous: don't care lololol

Just post pics when you buy your GTI, and then copies of your bills when it gets sad from only being driven 3k/year :p
Zin's just trolling. He knows they are junk. Not to mention a girl's car.
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,729
31,094
146