• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Chorus of Islamic followers freak out about Pope's comments

Page 7 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: Aimster
You have failed to show me where the Ayatollah in Iran and the President of Iran have said anything negative towards anyone that is not a Muslim. All you have done is bring up Israel.

For god's sake lighten up on the bolding, and quoting....

Go back and read the linked transcript -- death to America implies death to non-muslims....
 
Originally posted by: Aimster
Show me how anyone who is powerful inside Iran has said "death to Jews" otherwise all you are trying to do is bring Israel into this and turn it into a political debate that has nothing to do with the main purpose of this thread.

I know you love talking about Israel, but this is not an Israel thread.

"Non-Muslims cannot be called human beings but are animals who roam the earth and engage in corruption." - said by Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati, a close aide to Iran's Supreme Leader, Seyyed Ali Khamenei, at a ceremony in north-eastern Iran to commemorate the 'martyrs' of the Revolutionary Guards and the war against Iraq (1980-88).

?We have a strategy drawn up for the destruction of Anglo-Saxon civilization and for the uprooting of the Americans and the English. The global infidel front is a front against Allah and the Muslims, and we must make use of everything we have at hand to strike at this front by means of our suicide operations or by means of our missiles. There are 29 sensitive sites in the U.S. and in the West. We have already spied on these sites and we know how we are going to attack them.? - said by Hassan Abbassi, a leading adviser to Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.

"Once we have defeated the Anglo-Saxons the rest will run for cover,? - Hassan Abbassi

?I will stop Christianity in this country? - Ahmadinejad

etc, etc, etc...
 
Originally posted by: dna
Originally posted by: Aimster
You have failed to show me where the Ayatollah in Iran and the President of Iran have said anything negative towards anyone that is not a Muslim. All you have done is bring up Israel.

For god's sake lighten up on the bolding, and quoting....

Go back and read the linked transcript -- death to America implies death to non-muslims....

Im sorry but death to America implies death to non-Muslims?

You got proof of that or is that something you are assuming?

Because there are tens of thousands of non-Muslims living inside Iran and they are alive. So unless you got something to go against that then all you are doing is assumign whereas I have provided facts that say "death to America" does not equal "death to non-Muslims"

& Again.. America is a country not a religion!!!
 
Originally posted by: palehorse74
Originally posted by: Aimster
Show me how anyone who is powerful inside Iran has said "death to Jews" otherwise all you are trying to do is bring Israel into this and turn it into a political debate that has nothing to do with the main purpose of this thread.

I know you love talking about Israel, but this is not an Israel thread.

"Non-Muslims cannot be called human beings but are animals who roam the earth and engage in corruption." - said by Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati, a close aide to Iran's Supreme Leader, Seyyed Ali Khamenei, at a ceremony in north-eastern Iran to commemorate the 'martyrs' of the Revolutionary Guards and the war against Iraq (1980-88).

?We have a strategy drawn up for the destruction of Anglo-Saxon civilization and for the uprooting of the Americans and the English. The global infidel front is a front against Allah and the Muslims, and we must make use of everything we have at hand to strike at this front by means of our suicide operations or by means of our missiles. There are 29 sensitive sites in the U.S. and in the West. We have already spied on these sites and we know how we are going to attack them.? - said by Hassan Abbassi, a leading adviser to Iranian Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.

"Once we have defeated the Anglo-Saxons the rest will run for cover,? - Hassan Abbassi

?I will stop Christianity in this country? - Ahmadinejad

etc, etc, etc...

Where did you find those quotes at? Some propaganda website?

Any credible sites? I believe not.
 
Originally posted by: palehorse74
Originally posted by: Aimster
Who pays for a family member when they decide to blow up a hospital or school? The Muslim world or one man? I don't see why you are linking the two. so maybe you could explain.

Who blows themselves up? Muslim world or a handful of Muslims from a SELECT FEW countries that do not even equal 15% of the Muslim world (the select few).

I dont care about the house of Saud or Pakistan. That has what to do with Islam and religious leaders? The leaders of Pakistan are not religious leaders and neither are the leaders of Saudi Arabia.

Saudi Arabis is a wahhabi country. The majority of Muslims are not even close to being Wahabbi so why do you continue to bring them up?

Are you bringing up the minority to make the majority look bad? Because that is what u are doing.
I really dont know what half of what you just wrote even means given the context of our debate.. in fact, I think you are typing whatever comes to mind regardless of relavence...

that said, my entire point is that every single one of those countries is run by a "religious leader" of one form or another; -- thats just not true..in any shape or form!!!and that NONE of them have done jacksh*t in the big scheme of things to eradicate fanaticism.

I have never stated that this is a "problem with all Muslims," however, it IS a Muslim Problem!

the supposedly peaceful 99% need to step up and squash the fanatical 1%, and they need to do so NOW. It is my contention that it must begin with their leadership, but hoping for that is a frickin pipedream... their leadership are all corrupt impotent douchebags.

 
The point is that no one would give a r8t's a8se if some Muslim leader said something about non-Muslims. And most certainly they would not rant and rave like the morons in the Muslim world are doing now against the Pope (whose words are being ignored even by increasing no of Catholics).
 
Originally posted by: magomago
And I'll echo that opinion by Rainsford in that it seems like some here WANT holy war. Most Muslims aren't out to "Git ya" "kill ya" "convert ya" (thats right 😉 After we kill you, we will attempt to convert you). Those who are can be for a variety of reasons: they can TRY to use the Quran to justify their actions, and the sad part is they are sucessful because now we think it is Islam that is the fault for what is going on rather than the people themselves who are twisted
Would you say the same thing, if every Muslim who came to America, or went anywhere in Europe, needed an armed body guard? And no, I don't mean a Muslim American, nor an Arab American. I mean any American who doesn't look Middle Eastern. Would you? I very highly doubt it.
 
Originally posted by: tvarad
The point is that no one would give a r8t's a8se if some Muslim leader said something about non-Muslims. And most certainly they would not rant and rave like the morons in the Muslim world are doing now against the Pope (whose words are being ignored even by increasing no of Catholics).

You have no proof.
Assumptions.

& I will bet money that if a Muslim leader said something about non-Muslims that the world would care.

Let's say some Ayatollah inside Iraq said "Christians are pigs" and he came to the U.S to visit. I suppose nobody is going to give a damn, right? Wrong.
 
Originally posted by: Aimster
Do you know how many crazy Churches are in the U.S where peopel believe in some crazy wacko crap? If you want to link Osama to religious leaders I might as well link those fanatical Churches to Christianity.
Has Osama ever issued a Fatwa? Ok, then, he is a "religious leader." period. And many of his closest advisors and leaders are themselves clerics. So yes, while Osama himself never officially became a cleric, that sure as hell dioesnt stop him from pretending to be one, and it doesnt stop half of the Muslim world from considering him to be one.

heck, he even signed his 1998 fatwa of "Jihad Against Americans" as Sheikh Usamah Bin-Muhammad Bin-Ladin... go figure.

so... Osama can be considered a "religious leader."

you fail!

lol
 
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Really, OK what about Osama and the rest of his flock.

Aren't they considered some kind of God like religious Leaders in their minds?
Whether they are godlike in their own minds makes no difference. They are godlike to nearly every human who lives in the Middle East, which is far worse.
 
palehorse74 - whom I don't necessarily agree with in other respects 🙂 - has pointed out quite poignantly that
the supposedly peaceful 99% need to step up and squash the fanatical 1%, and they need to do so NOW. It is my contention that it must begin with their leadership, but hoping for that is a frickin pipedream... their leadership are all corrupt impotent douchebags.

Until that is accomplished, the West - and the Far East as well! - has no reasons to consider the Islamic world as being more than what transpires from my earlier Syriana quote. The rest is just words...

Aimster, you want clarifications?
Many people here know that I am Canadian (by choice), pan-European, atheist (or at the very least "secular humanist"), occasional critic of current American policies and socio-economic-cultural models... but if it ever boils down to a war between Middle East and West, I will fight to my last drop of blood on the side of the West, and I'll die, if necessary, defending this society against Islamo-fascists and what they stand for.

Here is where I draw my line in the sand. Be very careful, those of you willing to cross it.

I believe the Pope is expressing a similar feeling.
 
Originally posted by: palehorse74
Originally posted by: Aimster
Do you know how many crazy Churches are in the U.S where peopel believe in some crazy wacko crap? If you want to link Osama to religious leaders I might as well link those fanatical Churches to Christianity.
Has Osama ever issued a Fatwa? Ok, then, he is a "religious leader." period. And many of his closest advisors and leaders are themselves clerics. So yes, while Osama himself never officially became a cleric, that sure as hell dioesnt stop him from pretending to be one, and it doesnt stop half of the Muslim world from considering him to be one.

heck, he even signed his 1998 fatwa of "Jihad Against Americans" as Sheikh Usamah Bin-Muhammad Bin-Ladin... go figure.

so... Osama can be considered a "religious leader."

you fail!

lol

lack of knowledge about Islam

I am assuming you meant Jihad because a Fatwa .......

Nobody can declare a Jihad against non-Muslim. Only religious leaders can declare a Jihad.

*the head of a mosque is not a religious leader*
*Saddam Hussein is not a religious leader* - He declared Jihad. He obviously didn't know the rules of his own religion.

Stop trying to prove me wrong when you don't know the facts. You just look foolish.
Obviously I know more about the topic in this thread than you so why do you continue to try? If this was a gun thread then you would probably have the upper hand.

A Fatwa is more like an opinion. What in the world did you think a Fatwa is?
 
Originally posted by: dna
Originally posted by: Aimster
and who am I? Do tell.

That's a very deep question....

You remind me of Dave Chappel's bit Celebrity Trial Jury Selection (bottom right of the page).

You simply ask for ridicilous amount of proof, therefore you have an agenda.

EDIT: the R. Kelly part in particular, where he demands 20 witnesses.

What is my agenda?
According to you it must be to defend Muslims.
 
Originally posted by: Aimster


Im sorry but if I put down Israel I am not putting down the Jews. Your thinking disgusts me.

:shocked: Isn't Isreal a country created for and ran by the Jewish people? How do you figure that you can critisize one and not the other?
 
Originally posted by: AnitaPeterson
palehorse74 - whom I don't necessarily agree with in other respects 🙂 - has pointed out quite poignantly that
the supposedly peaceful 99% need to step up and squash the fanatical 1%, and they need to do so NOW. It is my contention that it must begin with their leadership, but hoping for that is a frickin pipedream... their leadership are all corrupt impotent douchebags.

Until that is accomplished, the West - and the Far East as well! - has no reasons to consider the Islamic world as being more than what transpires from my earlier Syriana quote. The rest is just words...

Aimster, you want clarifications?
Many people here know that I am Canadian (by choice), pan-European, atheist (or at the very least "secular humanist"), occasional critic of current American policies and socio-economic-cultural models... but if it ever boils down to a war between Middle East and West, I will fight to my last drop of blood on the side of the West, and I'll die, if necessary, defending this society against Islamo-fascists and what they stand for.

Here is where I draw my line in the sand. Be very careful, those of you willing to cross it.

I believe the Pope is expressing a similar feeling.

What makes you think Muslims do not live in the West? Millions of Muslims live in the "West". In fact Muslims serve in the armed forces of the West and would die for the West as well... so....

Agian you said M.E again... Majority of the Muslims are not from the M.E!!

It sounds like you have a problem with Arab culture and their suicide bombings and somehow link that to Islam as a whole.
 
Originally posted by: 1EZduzit
Originally posted by: Aimster


Im sorry but if I put down Israel I am not putting down the Jews. Your thinking disgusts me.

:shocked: Isn't Isreal a country created for and ran by the Jewish people? How do you figure that you can critisize one and not the other?

I critize the U.S on a daily basis .. in fact many people in here do. Yet when it comes to Israel if you don't agree with it then you must be anti-Jewish (this is the idea many people have).

The fact is we do not live in the M.E. Israel was created in a Muslim world. The problem with Israel is that it is a holy land not only for the Jews but for the Muslims and the Christians as well.

The fact that neighboring Muslim nations are fighting Israel the world thinks Jews and Muslims were born to hate each other.

The entire issue is a problem of land. Not a problem of religion.
 
Originally posted by: Aimster
I am assuming you meant Jihad because a Fatwa .......

Nobody can declare a Jihad against non-Muslim. Only religious leaders can declare a Jihad.

*the head of a mosque is not a religious leader*
*Saddam Hussein is not a religious leader* - He declared Jihad. He obviously didn't know the rules of his own religion.

Stop trying to prove me wrong when you don't know the facts. You just look foolish.
Obviously I know more about the topic in this thread than you so why do you continue to try? If this was a gun thread then you would probably have the upper hand.

A Fatwa is more like an opinion. What in the world did you think a Fatwa is?

LOL..wow.

A fatwa is a formal declaration made by an Islamic religious leader, scholar, or legal specialist.

In 1998, Osama Bin Laden issued a Fatwa that called for war (jihad) against the Americans. So, apparently he must be a "religious leader" since only they can issue fatwas calling for Jihad, and have said Fatwas listened to by so many. In fact, throughout my travels in the ME and CA, I met a vast number of Muslims who consider Osama to be a religious leader and a hero.

I do not believe that you know more about this topic. In fact, I'm sure that you do not. You just think that you do given your own ethnic background. Newsflash: That, in itself, does not make you an expert on this subject. In fact, it probably creates more biases than you are mentally able to overcome...
 
Originally posted by: magomago
And I'll echo that opinion by Rainsford in that it seems like some here WANT holy war. Most Muslims aren't out to "Git ya" "kill ya" "convert ya" (thats right 😉 After we kill you, we will attempt to convert you). Those who are can be for a variety of reasons: they can TRY to use the Quran to justify their actions, and the sad part is they are sucessful because now we think it is Islam that is the fault for what is going on rather than the people themselves who are twisted
Would you say the same thing, if every Muslim who came to America, or went anywhere in Europe, needed an armed body guard? And no, I don't mean a Muslim American, nor an Arab American. I mean any American who doesn't look Middle Eastern. Would you? I very highly doubt it.[/quote]
 
Originally posted by: Aimster
Agian you said M.E again... Majority of the Muslims are not from the M.E!!

It sounds like you have a problem with Arab culture and their suicide bombings and somehow link that to Islam as a whole.

Most of us are educated and mature enough to distinguish between fanatical Islam and the rest of the world's Muslim population. Very few people here still lump them all together.

However, the problem comes from the fact that fanatical Islam exists throughout the entire world, not just in the ME. The Arab core is certainly at the forefront of fanatical Islam, but by no means do they have the market cornered. There are fanatical elements of Islam in nearly every nation on earth.

So, given that fact, it is necessary for the ENTIRE MUSLIM WORLD to crack down on said fanaticism. Every single country that has a fanatical element within its borders must step up and destroy said fanatical element.

Therefore, this is a problem that ALL Muslims must face, and it is one that every single Muslim should be held responsible for eradicating. It is the duty of EVERY MUSLIM to step up and destroy the fanatics amongst them... everywhere...EVERY ONE!

period.
 
Originally posted by: palehorse74
Originally posted by: Aimster
I am assuming you meant Jihad because a Fatwa .......

Nobody can declare a Jihad against non-Muslim. Only religious leaders can declare a Jihad.

*the head of a mosque is not a religious leader*
*Saddam Hussein is not a religious leader* - He declared Jihad. He obviously didn't know the rules of his own religion.

Stop trying to prove me wrong when you don't know the facts. You just look foolish.
Obviously I know more about the topic in this thread than you so why do you continue to try? If this was a gun thread then you would probably have the upper hand.

A Fatwa is more like an opinion. What in the world did you think a Fatwa is?

LOL..wow.

A fatwa is a formal declaration made by an Islamic religious leader, scholar, or legal specialist.

In 1998, Osama Bin Laden issued a Fatwa that called for war (jihad) against the Americans. So, apparently he must be a "religious leader" since only they can issue fatwas calling for Jihad, and have said Fatwas listened to by so many. In fact, throughout my travels in the ME and CA, I met a vast number of Muslims who consider Osama to be a religious leader and a hero.

I do not believe that you know more about this topic. In fact, I'm sure that you do not. You just think that you do given your own ethnic background. Newsflash: That, in itself, does not make you an expert on this subject. In fact, it probably creates more biases than you are mentally able to overcome...

You dont know what it is you are talking about

a Fatwa is an opinion and that is a fact. Any Muslim in here will tell you that.

Saddam Hussein issued a Jihad against invading American troops. According to Islam he could not do so and therefore his Jihad was illegal.

What part of that do you not understand? Apparently you fail to argue about anything else and have resorted to calling Osama an Islamic religious leader. I laugh at you.

Ive corrected you numerous times about Islam but you continue to ramble on and on about it as if you know what it is you are talking about.
 
Originally posted by: palehorse74
Originally posted by: Aimster
Agian you said M.E again... Majority of the Muslims are not from the M.E!!

It sounds like you have a problem with Arab culture and their suicide bombings and somehow link that to Islam as a whole.

Most of us are educated and mature enough to distinguish between fanatical Islam and the rest of the world's Muslim population. Very few people here still lump them all together.

However, the problem comes from the fact that fanatical Islam exists throughout the entire world, not just in the ME. The Arab core is certainly at the forefront of fanatical Islam, but by no means do they have the market cornered. There are fanatical elements of Islam in nearly every nation on earth.

So, given that fact, it is necessary for the ENTIRE MUSLIM WORLD to crack down on said fanaticism. Every single country that has a fanatical element within its borders must step up and destroy said fanatical element.

Therefore, this is a problem that ALL Muslims must face, and it is one that every single Muslim should be held responsible for eradicating. It is the duty of EVERY MUSLIM to step up and destroy the fanatics amongst them... everywhere...EVERY ONE!

period.

Since you really believe you know what it is you are talking about:

A) Define fanatical Islam
B) How can you tell who is a fanatic Muslim and who is not?

If you can answer the two questions above then you have just solved the problem you are talking about.
 
I'm not really sure what Aimster is trying to defend, here..

The point is that Muslims are burning the Pope in effigy, because they claim to be offended by what he had to say. My observation, given this incidend, the cartoon incident, and the Salman Rushdie incident, is that many Muslims appear to be completely unable to tolerate any criticism of Islam itself. In fact, they perceive such criticism as offensive.

My opinion is that Islam itself is a cancer, and that humanity would be better off without it.
 
Back
Top