Cheating girlfriend: what would you have done? (update: what I did)

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

ratkil

Platinum Member
Jan 12, 2000
2,117
0
76
"ask yourself this question, is this the girl or the kind of girl that have always imagined would be the mother of your children? "
Um, casting stones are we AaronP? Not like we are talking about a 30 something homemaker, I am guessing these are college kids so their actions don't seem all that improper to me, though once again she did open herself up to something potentially very bad. :-(

vi_edit, granted it shouldn't be the girls fault, but unfortunately in the world we live in they have to watch out for themselves and she wasn't......
 

Thump553

Lifer
Jun 2, 2000
12,839
2,625
136
Only in Iran would that be considered cheating. Presuming she is telling the truth, some joker tried, unsuccessfully, to take advantage of a drunken, lonely woman.

Don't become a control freak, as that is at least as damaging to relationships as this sort of "cheating" is.
 

GasX

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
29,033
6
81
This thread didn't die yet?

zoinks! she didn't do anything. get over it. move on.

All this dribble about it being symptomatic of deeper issues is making my head hurt.

Are you married? Are you engaged? Did she F. the guy? Did she do anything other than play defense?

The fact that she felt bad and told you about it (which is nothing...) says everything.

She's a keeper.

Don't believe there is a mountain underneath this molehill!
 

miniMUNCH

Diamond Member
Nov 16, 2000
4,159
0
0
Drinking Rule #1: If your going to drink a lot (ladies especial), make sure you drink in the company of close friends, who are not getting drunk themselves, who will "watch your back".

Overall, a drunk kiss isn't too bad. I thought you were going to say she slept with him...I was about to get sick to my stomach...I hate when wonderful relationships get screwed up like that.

I would say to her, "So that's it? Well, I understand...drinking does impare your judgement. He moved on you. You resisted. I'm glad that's all that happened. I love you...you know that. You know you don't handle drinking very well...so be careful in the future. I don't want anything to cloud our relationship."

Then I'd move on...it is actually considerable that, given her past behavior, she remained faithful to you. In a weird way...this adds some proof to the pudding...she resisted temptation in a compromised position.

Back to the drinking thing...

I cannot stress this enough for the ladies, especially the attractive ones: Cover Your Ass when drinking...particularly in the company of horny (read drinking) men. In college, I pulled guys off of two of my female friends (not girlfriend, just close classmates) on different occassions. In both situations, my female friend was pretty drunk and some relatively sober guy tried to take advantage of them. In one instance, the guy had just got her into a bedroom; in the other instance, the guy had her undressed enough to start doing his "business"...that guy got his butt unceremoniously kicked by me and a couple of my friends.

Girls...watch out and be careful.
 

Jothaxe

Golden Member
Apr 5, 2001
1,274
0
0
After reading only your post Shy:

She didnt cheat judging by the story you have related. Its just a matter of whether the story is strictly true. My gut instinct would be to trust her, since you seem to have a good foundation with her.

-jothaxe
 

UnixFreak

Platinum Member
Nov 27, 2000
2,008
0
76
I would like to know... what do you think she told "chuck" about what happened with you?

I see a pattern here.

<<dodges flying eggs and rocks>>
 

mcveigh

Diamond Member
Dec 20, 2000
6,457
6
81
Hey weren't you &quot;jerry springer&quot; last night!

OK OK it was just a kiss, I'd be mad but she did tell you.

also you should have expected it, a tiger doesn't change it stripes.
 

SCSIfreek

Diamond Member
Mar 3, 2000
3,216
0
0
I dont mean to be a jackass but from the way you put the story everything seems to be covering her ass. What the hell are you doing at night with another guy in the woods? ok you had couple drinks and you cant handle it ---->simple answer to this is that you'll need to puke or go to bed. I dont think a girl will start walking around the woods nor can they be talking all night long if they were drunk. Like someone else had said before, how do you know its the true story? she could be pulling your legs. I mean girls will try anything to cover their asses, even guys would do that if you had cheated on your girl. I wont trust her no more if I were you. Trust is something you earn and I think she need to earn that trust back else she'll just do it again later down your life. prepare yourself for the worse.
 

mjquilly

Golden Member
Jun 12, 2000
1,692
0
76


<< I dont mean to be a jackass but from the way you put the story everything seems to be covering her ass. What the hell are you doing at night with another guy in the woods? ok you had couple drinks and you cant handle it ---->simple answer to this is that you'll need to puke or go to bed. I dont think a girl will start walking around the woods nor can they be talking all night long if they were drunk. Like someone else had said before, how do you know its the true story? she could be pulling your legs. I mean girls will try anything to cover their asses, even guys would do that if you had cheated on your girl. I wont trust her no more if I were you. Trust is something you earn and I think she need to earn that trust back else she'll just do it again later down your life. prepare yourself for the worse. >>



seriously, mind your own damn business (well, sort of, you were thrown into the mix). It'll save you alot of trouble later (ie, not being enemies with either side once the break-up happens - it's gonna happen dude).
 

MrCodeDude

Lifer
Jun 23, 2001
13,674
1
76
I say let it be, it was a guy who was trying to take advantage of a drunk girl.. That really isn't cheating.
-- mrcodedude
 

y2kc

Platinum Member
Sep 2, 2000
2,547
0
76
There was no &quot;cheating&quot; here. I hope you didn't lay a guilt trip on this girl. The guy was clearly in the wrong. You say you trust her but her past history has planted a seed of doubt in your mind that is now in full bloom because of what someone else did. Leave her, why? because you will never trust her. Spare her and yourself.
 

BaDNaN0TH0N

Senior member
Mar 11, 2001
373
0
0


<< I dont see it as being bad, and it would be hard for me not to forgive her, if she is telling you the truth. But assuming she is I would forgive her.

1. She was drinking.
2. She told you right away.
3. He kissed her.
4. She did not dump you for him.
5. She pushed him away.

I wouldnt let something like that really bother me unless you feel she is lying to you or you believe it went farther than she told you it went.
>>



i agree, its not like she went after some guy, now that would be much worse, and at least she told you about this, she didnt have to. what she did shows that she has a lot of guts and really likes.
 

RossGr

Diamond Member
Jan 11, 2000
3,383
1
0
You do not need to forgive her as she has done nothing which needs forgiving. The only one in question now is you, should she forgive you for being a total A$$ over this. I would say she should run like hell. If you consider this cheating you don't have a clue what the world is about and are no where near ready for any form of a commited relationship.
 

EvanFerguson

Banned
May 14, 2001
956
0
0
I don't see how you could be mad at all.......you did the same thing foo


you both deserve a punch in the ear
 

Shy

Golden Member
Dec 4, 2000
1,428
0
76
Although I would love to respond to a few threads specifically (namely the &quot;hey moron, she didn't cheat on you, stop being a crybaby&quot; ones), I think you'll see why I don't really see any need to. Many people seem like they would have handled it similarly, other people clearly wouldn't have.

Although, Evan, maybe a punch in the ear wouldn't be so bad :D

Anyway, here's what I sent out to everyone who PM'ed me before I left work yesterday:

------------------------------------------------------
So what did I do?

Well, at first, I felt extremely betrayed. It is hard for me to express in words how important to me her promise was that nothing like this would ever happen.

But I didn't get angry. And I didn't lash out.

That night, while on the phone with her, I told her I wouldn't break up with her and that I was still as in love with her as I had been all along. But I also told her that I needed more time to deal with it. That night I could barely sleep.

The next day, I could not think about a single other thing. I was unable to get a single bit of work done all day, and lapsed into a depression I hadn't felt since Junior High. Although I don't know why, and I certainly am not happy about it whatsoever, but I contemplated driving my car off the road while driving home from work. I couldn't get what had happened out of my head. It was driving me crazy.

When I got home, I was able to get things off my mind. I spent some time with my younger brother and just tried to keep the whole situation out of my head.

That night when she called, I had nothing to say. I had thought about it the whole day long, but I couldn't come up with anything.

And then I broke down and started to cry. But after a while, things began to look up. We talked about what had happened and what we were going to do.

I eventually decided that, much like a few people pointed out, she hadn't really cheated on me. Sure, it was irresponsible of her to drink and end up out in the woods with this guy. And of course, she certainly could have tried harder to avoid his advances. And although I will never accept, &quot;I was drunk&quot; as an excuse for actions, I realized that hardly anything had happened at all. I still couldn't deal with what had happened, but I told her I forgave her and that I would try and not hold it against her. She knew how much it hurt me -- she tore my heart out when she told me, but she was truly sorry, that is one issue where I have no doubt whatsoever.

So what now? Well, things between us are certainly getting better. I got over my depression in another day, and now we're able to talk as if nothing had happened. I have had doubts these days as to whether I think that she's &quot;the one&quot;, but she's certainly the most amazing girl I've ever met, and I'd place bets on us still being together years from now.

But I did make an ultimatum. She once again promised me that this would not happen. I believed her the first time, and I do believe her now, but I have made it known that if this ever happens again, thats it. I will absolutely break up with her and not look back. It was hard enough to deal with this once, and I refuse to have to deal with it again.

A lot of people suggest that I beat this guy up. Although I would love to, I am certianly not one to lose my temper in such situations and despite my martial arts training, I have never been in a fight. I intend to keep things this way.

So we're still happily together. Thank all of you for listening.
-Shy
 

Kanalua

Diamond Member
Jun 14, 2001
4,860
2
81
You're a wuss...now she knows she can walk all over you. you never cheated on a girl, got busted, she forgave you, then you go out and do it again....repeat over and over a couple times...?

You're setting yourself up, there's tons &quot;the ones&quot; out there...I think the going rate is up a bit to a $1.37 a dozen...adjusting for inflation...
 

Shy

Golden Member
Dec 4, 2000
1,428
0
76


<< You did the right thing Shy.... >>



Only time will tell I suppose
 

Shy

Golden Member
Dec 4, 2000
1,428
0
76


<< You're setting yourself up, there's tons &quot;the ones&quot; out there...I think the going rate is up a bit to a $1.37 a dozen...adjusting for inflation... >>



thats funny.. I had no idea women were cheaper than gas!
 

Urinal Mint

Platinum Member
Jan 16, 2000
2,074
0
0


<< You're a wuss...now she knows she can walk all over you. you never cheated on a girl, got busted, she forgave you, then you go out and do it again....repeat over and over a couple times...?

You're setting yourself up, there's tons &quot;the ones&quot; out there...I think the going rate is up a bit to a $1.37 a dozen...adjusting for inflation...
>>


I guess that last statement is why Mormons believe in polygamy, eh?
 

Kanalua

Diamond Member
Jun 14, 2001
4,860
2
81
Shoot...can't handle one woman, none the less two, three, four...


haven't read up on your mormonism lately (like the last hundread years or so)?

Cheaper than gas, milk, bottled water....geez....lots of stuff....

seriously man, you're gonna get burnt on this one....can you tell I'm not a huge fan of second chance relationships?;)
 

Urinal Mint

Platinum Member
Jan 16, 2000
2,074
0
0
Nah, I'd rather stick to the old stereotypes :)

It was just meant as a jab (I noticed the Provo, UT) and nothing more. You can't blame a guy for being in love.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Don't beat the guy up - he isn't responsible for what happened unless he forced himself on your girlfriend (what you said in first message didn't sound like forcing); only she is.

Anyway as others mentioned and its good to see you also believe she didn't cheat on you. I mean _technically_ she did because she kissed the guy but then its not like she really wanted to, so it was more of a passive kiss just in that she failed to pull away fast enough. Anyway its good you guys aren't gonna break up over it if you're sure she won't do it again. No point in ruining a relationship over a small moment such as that.
 

Kanalua

Diamond Member
Jun 14, 2001
4,860
2
81
That's true....can't say I didn't do some pretty desperate things for love...

Provo....check this out picture

BYU student and all...The pics of when I was in Ireland...the Provo IRA is a extremeist IRA group...