Cheating girlfriend: what would you have done? (update: what I did)

Shy

Golden Member
Dec 4, 2000
1,428
0
76
Just to start this off, I am not looking for advice here. I have already dealt with this situation on my own and have (more or less) come to terms with it. But the ATOT community is great and diverse, and I'd really like to know what you guys would have done in my situation. I am not often afforded the oppurtunity of hearing what other people would do, and I'm truly interested as to what some people would have done.

UPDATE: SEE BOTTOM OF THREAD IF YOU'D LIKE TO KNOW WHAT I DID

Let me preface this with the following: although my age and the age of my girlfriend is not important as far as I am concerned, it may benefit some of you to know that we are both currently students in college.

I have been dating a very special woman for the past eight months. We've had a great relationship and I have little doubt that she is "the one". However...

The way our relationship started out was a little... interesting. One night we were up together after spending the night watching the sun come and and talking the whole time. We were in her room, lying in her bed when I leaned over and kissed her.

Unfortunately, she had a boyfriend at the time. We'll call him "Chuck". Fortunately for me, the relationship was nothing serious and had been only going on for about a month at the time. A few days later she broke up with him. Tragically, he never really got over it and hasn't said a single thing to either of us since.

Through the course of our relationship I learned that this boy "Chuck" wasn't the first she had cheated on. In high school, she had done this once before to a boyfriend. Needless to say, this worried me greatly. Without a doubt, the biggest fear on my part was that someday she would do the same thing to me. However, on numerous occasions, she promised me that she loved me too much to ever do that to me. She gave me her word that she would never, ever cheat on me.

It took a while, but after perhaps the third time she made such a promise, I finally began to believe her. Up until recently, I trusted her completely. This trust was, without a doubt, a very important basis for our relationship.

Our relationship continued without incident throughout the year. We never argued and spent not only all of our free time together, but also a lot of time together when we should have been in class or doing homework. By this time, we had conceeded to the fact that we were definately "in love" and were already making plans for the future (trips to Europe, where we would live together when we get out of college, etc.)

However this summer definately has taken a toll on the relationship. I have a full time job at home, and she decided to work for 9 weeks at a summer camp. This camp is a five hour drive away. To cut this story a little short, we have not seen each other in a month. We have talked on the phone a few times every week and correspond via e-mail almost every single day.

Last Sunday, however, she called me crying. The unthinkable had happened. She cheated on me.

We always had a rule in our relationship that if we ever cheated on the other person, we would tell them immediately. Thankfully, she upheld her side of the bargain.

What happened is this: Saturday night she went out to a bar with some friends. She has never been able to handle her alcohol very well, and became quite intoxicated after only a few drinks. I'm sure most you know where this story is headed, and I certainly did when she began to tell it.

Well, she went back to the camp on a bus the camp provides to the workers. When she got back, she got to talking with a male staffer. Apparently they stayed up fairly late talking. The were wandering around the woods, and I guess he was helping her walk because she was stumbling. Eventually, he took her off the path to a large rock to sit down. At this point, he leaned over to kiss her. I guess she moved away, and started to explain to him that she had a boyfriend, and couldn't, but apparently he didn't pay much attention. He moved in again and kissed her. Now, I have no way of knowing but I trust her story completely. She tells me that after a second or two to comprehend what was going on, she got angry and pushed him away, and then broke down crying. He didn't try to kiss her again and was apparently apologetic at this time, claming her had no idea that she was serious when she told him that she had a boyfriend.

She then went home. I guess she wasn't able to sleep that night, and the whole next day she wasn't able to eat, until she called me and told me.

So, the short version of the story is this: My girlfriend promised me that she would never cheat on me, and then after being away from me for a few weeks, kisses another guy.

So what would you have done? I won't present any of the options I saw at the time, since I don't want to bias my audience.

Anxiously waiting your opinions,
-Shy
 

Kntx

Platinum Member
Dec 11, 2000
2,270
0
71
I woulda drove my ass up there, punched that guy in the neck. Taken my girlfriend out back and shown her who was the man.
 

tasslex

Senior member
Jun 1, 2001
342
0
0
She cheated with you on another guy, so it stands to reason that she will cheat on you with another guy as well. I had to learn this one the hard way too. :frown:
 

pulse8

Lifer
May 3, 2000
20,860
1
81
Well, if what she says is true, I feel that she can be forgiven for that if HE kissed her. I would be really angry at her for allowing herself to be put into that situation, but from what you said, she sounded VERY remorseful about it. Every situation is different, but you can always just give it another shot and see how it goes.
 

jaybert

Diamond Member
Mar 6, 2001
3,523
0
0
that really isnt cheating.....sounds like the guy was trying to take advantage of a drunk girl if that story is true...
 

Urinal Mint

Platinum Member
Jan 16, 2000
2,074
0
0
If she's telling you the truth, which I'll have faith and assume, then I'd have to say the girl really cares for you. I mean, she came right out and told you what she did.

I'm willing to forgive people so long as they can admit their mistakes and learn from them... the question is, would my girlfriend have learned from this? I think her crying and carrying on is a signal that she knew better to begin with and her thinking wasn't very clear because of the alcohol.

First thing I do is sit down and talk to her about her alcohol tolerance... it obviously affects judgment, right? You can't tell people what to do, but I think that if she really cares about you she'll be more careful what she does with booze when you aren't around. You aren't her daddy, but at the same time you do care for her deeply (I assume) and you want the best for her.

I hope everything turns out well for you, man.
 

ATLien247

Diamond Member
Feb 1, 2000
4,597
0
0
Sounds to me like she had no intention on kissing this other guy. Depending on other circumstances that you might not have mentioned yet, I would believe her and continue on with the relationship. Now, if you don't believe her story, then by all means kick her to the curb.
 

mchammer187

Diamond Member
Nov 26, 2000
9,114
0
76
I dont see it as being bad, and it would be hard for me not to forgive her, if she is telling you the truth. But assuming she is I would forgive her.

1. She was drinking.
2. She told you right away.
3. He kissed her.
4. She did not dump you for him.
5. She pushed him away.

I wouldnt let something like that really bother me unless you feel she is lying to you or you believe it went farther than she told you it went.
 

Viper GTS

Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
38,107
433
136
Sounds more like it was his doing, not hers. However, allowing herself to get into the situation wasn't terribly intelligent on her part.

What would I have done? Forgiven her. But I would ask that she be more careful in the future, & make sure things like that didn't happen again before I made any long term plans that involved her.

Viper GTS
 

Kntx

Platinum Member
Dec 11, 2000
2,270
0
71
Why does no one agree with me???

PUNCH THAT MOFO IN THE NECK!!!
 

hungrypete

Diamond Member
Aug 4, 2000
3,001
0
0
something similar happened to me recently. Mine was slightly worse, but still only a kiss. I'm still with her. I *don't* trust her right now. We're both in college and have been together for 4 years.

It's a rough position. The jerk who kissed my girl is away for the summer. I *will* scare the hell out of him when he comes back, regardless of whether I am still with this girl. That's part of the price in making moves on a woman you know is taken.

I think you should *try* to forgive her, and to trust her, unless something like this happens again. If she's really *the one*, you'll find a way to forgive her, right?
 

herself

Member
Jun 20, 2001
86
0
0
I think there are some very important factors here hunnie...

She was very drunk... so drunk she had to have assistance in walking, as she was stumbling... So he assisted her... and then knowing how drunk she was, tried to kiss her - omg at him for taking advantage of a drunk woman, how sad is that? And on top of that, he didn't even succeed the first time... she pushed him away and told him he had a boyfriend. Then he did it *again* ... !!! And he managed to kiss her that time... but she pushed him off AGAIN and called you right away. Frankly, I would be thanking god I had a girlfriend that loved me so much that she came right out and told me, and I'd be planning a 5-hour car ride down to kick HIS ass for disrespecting any woman... but especially yours! :|

Tamara
 

MrCraphead

Platinum Member
Sep 20, 2000
2,977
0
76
I agree with you, Kntx. :)

If the story was true, then I would say forgive her b/c she was obviously drunk and didn't know what she was getting into. However, she was able to clear her mind up enough to make the right decision later, when it mattered.

So, you think you could PM me with how you handled the situation? I'm all interested now......as is the AT community as well. :)
 

Urinal Mint

Platinum Member
Jan 16, 2000
2,074
0
0
Do like women do to men... dangle it over her head for the rest of her life. Bring it up at inopportune times. Use it as leverage in getting what you want.





Of course, I'm just teasing on this one.
 

GL

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,547
0
0
My ex fell for another guy when we were going out and didn't even cheat on me in the generally accepted way. But it still hurt like hell to know that for a few months, her heart was somewhere else. That being said, it doesn't sound like your gf is emotionally attached to this guy and so I'd still go out with her.
 

jonMEGA

Golden Member
May 21, 2001
1,232
0
0
heres a song for you

Ginuwine - What's So Different?

but seriously, I would give your girl another chance. If she feels bad about what happend, I would give her another chance.....

Good Luck,
 

Atlantean

Diamond Member
May 2, 2001
5,296
1
0
What a bitch, and you were surprised that she cheated on you? once a cheater, always a cheater!`
 

VRoOMdesigns

Guest
Aug 2, 2000
806
0
0
Man what are you so worked up about?

She got messed up and some clown tried to move in on what's yours.

Mchammer sums it up nicely:

<<
1. She was drinking.
2. She told you right away.
3. He kissed her.
4. She did not dump you for him.
5. She pushed him away.

>>
 

Johnlee

Platinum Member
Oct 10, 1999
2,007
2
0
I like that lol. Punch him in the neck. Then put his head on the curb ala American History X and BLAM.:D

As for the girl...a certain Prodigy song comes to mind.;)

jk, that sounded pretty innocent. The dude, on the other hand...

edit:I also like what Urinal Mint suggested. lol.
 

huanaku

Golden Member
Jan 20, 2001
1,208
0
0
She was drunk. He hit on her. Man, if she had the guys to call you and tell you about it .... That says something. Most wouldn't say anything at all.
 

BreakApart

Golden Member
Nov 15, 2000
1,313
0
0
Broken up with her on the spot. Then remained friends if possible, in time if we give it another go so be it.

Read a study about adultery-(i'll try and find the link i read), one of the top 5 reason people cheat. &quot;Habit&quot;... &quot;Relationship problems&quot; wasn't even in the top (5).

Forgiveness does/should not require you to lower your relationship standards. Perhaps our standards are different...

If you love something let it go, if it returns to you-(after it learns not to be a dam cheat) then it was ment to be. Slightly modified. :)

Good Luck...
 

Tauren

Diamond Member
Jan 30, 2001
3,880
1
0
If it was ONLY a kiss and due to intoxication: I would talk to her and tell if it happens again, it's over.
 

goshdarnindie

Senior member
May 6, 2001
652
0
0
Tell us who this guy is. Your on the AT network, one of us is bound to know him, and then it would be really freaky if he got a lot of &quot;I know what you did last summer&quot; messages in different places. hehehe
 

bunker

Lifer
Apr 23, 2001
10,572
0
71
I agree with most here. It doesn't sound like she did anything terrible and deserves forgiveness for being forthcoming about the situation.

How long are you gonna make us wait for your decision?????:)