Quite apart from your totally misreading what you quoted (as pointed out earler), you've got your facts wrong here, LMK. Even when race, income and locatin are all held constant, charter schools do worse. From the NYT article:Originally posted by: LordMagnusKain
pure ignorance.the reason parents enter their kids there is because they are not run with the current philosophy "the kids should have a good time in school, we can't flunk someone, or punish them for not wanting to learn"
The reason many charter schools do worse than the average school is 3 fold:
1.) They try to attract students from the poorest and most poorly-parented districts
2.) Parents often force their kids into schools that target one direction while the kids are entirely not interested in that charter.
3.) The pay for teachers and over all money available is generally much less for charter school.
BUT:
when you combine lower pay, lower quality students, and students that are focusing on a vocation they aren?t interested in and still have higher scores than the schools around them. then you know their is something being done right. Even if the average scores across the board are lower than when averaged in with suburban and rich schools.
And one thing gets way overlooked about charter schools. They make their money on the backs of their teachers. I know, a friend of mine just completed her third year teaching for one.Because charter schools are concentrated in cities, often in poor neighborhoods, the researchers also compared urban charters to traditional schools in cities. They looked at low-income children in both settings, and broke down the results by race and ethnicity as well. In virtually all instances, the charter students did worse than their counterparts in regular public schools.
They hire young, idealistic, enthusiastic teachers, pay them far less than their compatriots, and overburden them with expectations of after hours "volunteer" work. These teachers eventually get burnt out, and move on to better paying opportunities. It is NOT a sustainable paradigm.
On a personal note, it seems you benefited mightily from your charter school experience, and I am happy for you for that.