Brett Favre retires

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,075
11
81
Originally posted by: jjones
He had a great year, last year. Always good to go out on an up note.

And he is getting old. Too old to play in the cold. Too old to hold the ball.
 

phreaqe

Golden Member
Mar 22, 2004
1,204
3
81
Originally posted by: Queasy
Well, now we find out if Aaron Rodgers is for real or not.

the thing i see happening and it will be unfortunate, is that the expectations are going to be very high. he will never be able to live up to the career favre had. i think that alot of packer fans will be mad at him when he does not put up favres numbers in his first season. i will b happy if he can put up a sold season but i obviously dont expect his to put up pro bowl numbers.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Originally posted by: jjsole
Originally posted by: fatpat268
I thought he would've given it one more year based on how good his last season was.

Except for not winning a championship, it was one of his best ever. Retiring now is surprising, given how well he and his team did last year, and how wide open the NFC is.

I guess it makes that NFC championship game a little easier to swallow since the Giants went on to win the Superbowl. Better to lose to a winner than lose to a loser.

He had an amazing season. Certainly better to go out on this one than last year.
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,890
5,001
126
Originally posted by: phreaqe
Originally posted by: Queasy
Well, now we find out if Aaron Rodgers is for real or not.

the thing i see happening and it will be unfortunate, is that the expectations are going to be very high. he will never be able to live up to the career favre had. i think that alot of packer fans will be mad at him when he does not put up favres numbers in his first season. i will b happy if he can put up a sold season but i obviously dont expect his to put up pro bowl numbers.

I dunno about that too much. Packer fans are pretty understanding and smart and borderline forgiving. NOBODY in WI expects Rodgers to come in and be Favre II that can assure you.
 

phreaqe

Golden Member
Mar 22, 2004
1,204
3
81
Originally posted by: vi_edit
Originally posted by: jjsole
Originally posted by: fatpat268
I thought he would've given it one more year based on how good his last season was.

Except for not winning a championship, it was one of his best ever. Retiring now is surprising, given how well he and his team did last year, and how wide open the NFC is.

I guess it makes that NFC championship game a little easier to swallow since the Giants went on to win the Superbowl. Better to lose to a winner than lose to a loser.

He had an amazing season. Certainly better to go out on this one than last year.

yup. i really dont feel taht bad about loosing to the giants anymore since they went on to stop the unstoppable patriots. it really makes me feel good that they even kept it as close as they did in that game. i am looking forward to next yet with the talent that they have.
 

phreaqe

Golden Member
Mar 22, 2004
1,204
3
81
Originally posted by: Homerboy
Originally posted by: phreaqe
Originally posted by: Queasy
Well, now we find out if Aaron Rodgers is for real or not.

the thing i see happening and it will be unfortunate, is that the expectations are going to be very high. he will never be able to live up to the career favre had. i think that alot of packer fans will be mad at him when he does not put up favres numbers in his first season. i will b happy if he can put up a sold season but i obviously dont expect his to put up pro bowl numbers.

I dunno about that too much. Packer fans are pretty understanding and smart and borderline forgiving. NOBODY in WI expects Rodgers to come in and be Favre II that can assure you.

i will give you that the fans here are pretty forgiving, but after this last season i think the expectations for enxt season will be alot higher. that is alot of pressure for rodgers. i hope he is a great QB, and hope he can be the next favre, but i really dont expect it. i just worry that some of the other fans will think that. i will whole heartidly say that packers fan are some of the best. they will love the team through good seasons and bad.
 

rasczak

Lifer
Jan 29, 2005
10,437
23
81
Originally posted by: phreaqe
Originally posted by: Homerboy
Originally posted by: phreaqe
Originally posted by: Queasy
Well, now we find out if Aaron Rodgers is for real or not.

the thing i see happening and it will be unfortunate, is that the expectations are going to be very high. he will never be able to live up to the career favre had. i think that alot of packer fans will be mad at him when he does not put up favres numbers in his first season. i will b happy if he can put up a sold season but i obviously dont expect his to put up pro bowl numbers.

I dunno about that too much. Packer fans are pretty understanding and smart and borderline forgiving. NOBODY in WI expects Rodgers to come in and be Favre II that can assure you.

i will give you that the fans here are pretty forgiving, but after this last season i think the expectations for enxt season will be alot higher. that is alot of pressure for rodgers. i hope he is a great QB, and hope he can be the next favre, but i really dont expect it. i just worry that some of the other fans will think that. i will whole heartidly say that packers fan are some of the best. they will love the team through good seasons and bad.

well, considering what they know now, they will be more forgiving than most teams. they know that rodgers is not favre. they'll root for him just like they did for favre because he is a packer.

dems some loyal fans up der.

i for one am torn as well, by his leaving. on one hand he had a great career and i wanted to see him win one more super bowl.

on the other hand. I have his topps stadium club rookie card :D:D HOF here we come!! (as well as a nice chunk of change for his card if i ever decide to sell it lol)
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,890
5,001
126
i will give you that the fans here are pretty forgiving, but after this last season i think the expectations for enxt season will be alot higher. that is alot of pressure for rodgers. i hope he is a great QB, and hope he can be the next favre, but i really dont expect it. i just worry that some of the other fans will think that. i will whole heartidly say that packers fan are some of the best. they will love the team through good seasons and bad.

We HAVE loved them through thick and thin. Thats well documented no question. I think Rodgers will get a fair shake around here... he'll have unimaginable pressure for sure, but I think he's a pretty level headed kid after spending years with Favre. From watching/reading interviews I think he "gets it" now more than ever. He played well when called upon thats for sure. Was it stellar? No. But it wasn't his office.

McCarthy is the key here... lets see how good of a coach he really is. Not just with Xs and Os but with dealing with the players and situation at hand.

Gonna be a fun year.

 

phreaqe

Golden Member
Mar 22, 2004
1,204
3
81
Originally posted by: Homerboy
i will give you that the fans here are pretty forgiving, but after this last season i think the expectations for enxt season will be alot higher. that is alot of pressure for rodgers. i hope he is a great QB, and hope he can be the next favre, but i really dont expect it. i just worry that some of the other fans will think that. i will whole heartidly say that packers fan are some of the best. they will love the team through good seasons and bad.

We HAVE loved them through thick and thin. Thats well documented no question. I think Rodgers will get a fair shake around here... he'll have unimaginable pressure for sure, but I think he's a pretty level headed kid after spending years with Favre. From watching/reading interviews I think he "gets it" now more than ever. He played well when called upon thats for sure. Was it stellar? No. But it wasn't his office.

McCarthy is the key here... lets see how good of a coach he really is. Not just with Xs and Os but with dealing with the players and situation at hand.

Gonna be a fun year.

it really will be a fun year. i wil admit i am more excited for next season now just to see what this team is capable of. i will agree we HAVE loved them. that is one thing i love about being a packer fan. i will also agree he stepped up in the dallas game and that was alot of pressure to come in to. lol. the more i read your posting the more i agree with you andi am changing my mind about the fans and him. i think he will at least get a fair chance to prove himself, if not a open arms welcoming.
:beer: for next season.
 

Miramonti

Lifer
Aug 26, 2000
28,653
100
106
According to a voicemail left with espn's Chris Mortenson by Favre, just as the story was breaking, Favre says its 'not about randy moss', and is about the overall mental wear and tear over 17 years of trying to be a champion, and the time put in to preparing for another season.

Favre says it has nothing to do with Moss, but he was recently rooting for the Pack to sign him, and his retiring now suggests that it did have to do not getting a player like Moss imo. Net net, if they actually had signed Moss, there's no way Favre would be retiring, and he'd probably be very excited about going into this season.
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,890
5,001
126
it really will be a fun year. i wil admit i am more excited for next season now just to see what this team is capable of. i will agree we HAVE loved them. that is one thing i love about being a packer fan. i will also agree he stepped up in the dallas game and that was alot of pressure to come in to. lol. the more i read your posting the more i agree with you andi am changing my mind about the fans and him. i think he will at least get a fair chance to prove himself, if not a open arms welcoming.
:beer: for next season.

Mark my words, the second Aaron Rodgers is announced as starting quarterback in Lambeau on opening day the crowd will go NUTS for him. He will have the FULL support of the state and Packer fans worldwide out of the gate (that is unless he starts REALLY sucking... but even mediocrity people will back him).

We're the Packers, not the Raiders/Vikings/Dallas/Jets/<insert jackass team here> :)


 

dbk

Lifer
Apr 23, 2004
17,685
10
81
Why would you retire after being so damn close to the Super Bowl?
 

tboo

Diamond Member
Jun 25, 2000
7,626
1
81
Originally posted by: phreaqe
Originally posted by: tboo
I guarantee that Wisconsin newspapers & TV stations will now do stories on depression, suicide & how to spot & deal with it. I remember they did it back when the Packers lost to Denver in the superbowl.

i dont remember that, but i was pretty young at that point too. i believe it though. i can already see the headlines in tomorows papers.

I do. I was around 26 back then & I worked for a newspaper. I also remember seeing newscasts on wbay & wluk
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: dbk
Why would you retire after being so damn close to the Super Bowl?

because the odds on getting that close again are low. not to mention he is very old for a QB.

he has been considering retirement for the last few years. this is a good year to do it.

 

Kelemvor

Lifer
May 23, 2002
16,928
8
81
This is a very sad day not only for the Packers but for the whole NFL. He is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time and sill surely be missed across the league and the country. :brokenheart:
 

phreaqe

Golden Member
Mar 22, 2004
1,204
3
81
Originally posted by: tboo
Originally posted by: phreaqe
Originally posted by: tboo
I guarantee that Wisconsin newspapers & TV stations will now do stories on depression, suicide & how to spot & deal with it. I remember they did it back when the Packers lost to Denver in the superbowl.

i dont remember that, but i was pretty young at that point too. i believe it though. i can already see the headlines in tomorows papers.

I do. I was around 26 back then & I worked for a newspaper. I also remember seeing newscasts on wbay & wluk

i am only 22 now, so i was a bit young around then, and i was not all that into football when i was that age. i can really believe it though knowing the fans in this state.
 

lupi

Lifer
Apr 8, 2001
32,539
260
126
Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
 

LegendKiller

Lifer
Mar 5, 2001
18,256
68
86
Originally posted by: jjsole
According to a voicemail left with espn's Chris Mortenson by Favre, just as the story was breaking, Favre says its 'not about randy moss', and is about the overall mental wear and tear over 17 years of trying to be a champion, and the time put in to preparing for another season.

Favre says it has nothing to do with Moss, but he was recently rooting for the Pack to sign him, and his retiring now suggests that it did have to do not getting a player like Moss imo. Net net, if they actually had signed Moss, there's no way Favre would be retiring, and he'd probably be very excited about going into this season.

Not about Moss my ass. The story breaks the day Moss signs a contract with the Pats *and* moss' agent says he could have gone for more money...hmmm...where would that counter offer come from?

I believe it was about Moss, who decided that playing 1-2 seasons for the Packers, Favre retiring then having to deal with the ? of Rodgers wasn't a good enough proposition to being with Brady and having a good shot at being a champion in the next 3 years.