• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Bleeding Heart Tightwads

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,287
14,705
146
Originally posted by: CADsortaGUY
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Eliminate the tax deduction for those charitable contributions...

Allowing anyone to deduct their "donation" to a religious organization, then NOT taxing the religious organization for that donation, amounts to a government subsidy of the religious organization.

I have zero problem with people tithing, donating, whatever...just do away with the deduction for it.

What about other non-profit orgs?

No difference...eliminate ALL charitable deductions...

Of course, I'm also in favor of eliminating the deduction for mortgage interest...or at least on anything beyond the primary residence.
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,983
55,383
136
Originally posted by: senseamp
Other's money? Last I checked I pay taxes too, about 40%.

Apparently the argument is that to support collective action on something you have to support individual action on it.

The argument is mind blowingly moronic, but sadly enough still the argument.
 

BeauJangles

Lifer
Aug 26, 2001
13,941
1
0
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

Trust me, I have no delusions, but I figure that it took me two minutes to type that and maybe it will make a difference. And by maybe, I mean definitely not. :(
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Originally posted by: CADsortaGUY
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

You mean like the last 8 years of your side's "constructive exchange"? :laugh:

Seriously though -it's quite entertaining to see all the twisted panties over this...
Yeah that's the Christmas Spirit, spread the good cheer:roll:
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,983
55,383
136
Originally posted by: CADsortaGUY
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

You mean like the last 8 years of your side's "constructive exchange"? :laugh:

Seriously though -it's quite entertaining to see all the twisted panties over this...

Hey look who it is.

I almost mentioned you in my previous post due to your long and storied record of exactly this sort of retarded shit, but I knew you didn't need my help. Thanks for rewarding my faith in you, CAD.
 

Genx87

Lifer
Apr 8, 2002
41,091
513
126
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Eliminate the tax deduction for those charitable contributions...

Allowing anyone to deduct their "donation" to a religious organization, then NOT taxing the religious organization for that donation, amounts to a government subsidy of the religious organization.

I have zero problem with people tithing, donating, whatever...just do away with the deduction for it.

The deduction is an incentive to get people to donate vs the govt having to do it. Would you rather a third party do it with money from those who want to donate or some govt official with his many layers of incompetency from everybody?

That said I donate to many things that are not religious. Not all donations are to religions.
 

Genx87

Lifer
Apr 8, 2002
41,091
513
126
Originally posted by: CADsortaGUY
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

You mean like the last 8 years of your side's "constructive exchange"? :laugh:

Seriously though -it's quite entertaining to see all the twisted panties over this...

Yeah the next 4 years will be fun watching the back peddaling and side changing. Suddenly it is time for constructive debate and not flamebait lol
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Originally posted by: Genx87
Yeah the next 4 years will be fun watching the back peddaling and side changing. Suddenly it is time for constructive debate and not flamebait lol
Well if Obama's record is as dismal as Bushes it will be justified.

 

PingSpike

Lifer
Feb 25, 2004
21,758
603
126
I'm actually somewhat surprised, but I haven't really seen any good arguements against this in the thread. So far we have "repost" "OP is an asshole" "iraq war" and "they only give to churches and then the built giant gold churches". I kind of agree that the last point is basically refuted since a lot of nonprofit places really don't serve the needy at all.

As a cheapass, I have no business throwing stones, I only ever donate to animal shelters. But the scramble is kind of amusing here.

 

Specop 007

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2005
9,454
0
0
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.
 

Specop 007

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2005
9,454
0
0
Sen. Hillary Clinton.
"We're going to take things away from you on behalf of the common good."

These are not the type of people I want to work with. As much as I would want to work with Chavez, Hitler, Mao Zedong, Che, Stalin.........
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,287
14,705
146
Originally posted by: Genx87
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Eliminate the tax deduction for those charitable contributions...

Allowing anyone to deduct their "donation" to a religious organization, then NOT taxing the religious organization for that donation, amounts to a government subsidy of the religious organization.

I have zero problem with people tithing, donating, whatever...just do away with the deduction for it.

The deduction is an incentive to get people to donate vs the govt having to do it. Would you rather a third party do it with money from those who want to donate or some govt official with his many layers of incompetency from everybody?

That said I donate to many things that are not religious. Not all donations are to religions.

Nothing says people have to stop donating just because they lose the tax deduction for it...if people REALLY want to donate, they will. Just eliminate the government subsidy.
 

Genx87

Lifer
Apr 8, 2002
41,091
513
126
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: Genx87
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Eliminate the tax deduction for those charitable contributions...

Allowing anyone to deduct their "donation" to a religious organization, then NOT taxing the religious organization for that donation, amounts to a government subsidy of the religious organization.

I have zero problem with people tithing, donating, whatever...just do away with the deduction for it.

The deduction is an incentive to get people to donate vs the govt having to do it. Would you rather a third party do it with money from those who want to donate or some govt official with his many layers of incompetency from everybody?

That said I donate to many things that are not religious. Not all donations are to religions.

Nothing says people have to stop donating just because they lose the tax deduction for it...if people REALLY want to donate, they will. Just eliminate the government subsidy.


You are correct however the argument isnt over that at all. It is whether you want to coerce people with a tax incentive or beat them over the head with a hammer to donate.

I prefer and have always prefered the coercsion. Because it still gives people a "choice" in the decision. So far our system isnt bad. We donate a lot of money to private institutions that relieve pressure on our already bloated govt from having to do it.
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,287
14,705
146
Originally posted by: Genx87

You are correct however the argument isnt over that at all. It is whether you want to coerce people with a tax incentive or beat them over the head with a hammer to donate.

I prefer and have always prefered the coercsion. Because it still gives people a "choice" in the decision. So far our system isnt bad. We donate a lot of money to private institutions that relieve pressure on our already bloated govt from having to do it.

Yep...folks like Jimmy Swaggart, Jim and Tammy Faye Baker, and all the rest reap huge benefits from government subsidies...(I know, the Bakers are long dead..just an example)

 

umbrella39

Lifer
Jun 11, 2004
13,816
1,126
126
Originally posted by: Fear No Evil
Here, I'll add some real troll to the thread. You'd think liberals would give more considering how much money they take in by selling senate seats. (Cue rimshot).

Why don't you just ask the mods if you can start posting from your banned account? See if they are in a giving mood this time of year.
 

Genx87

Lifer
Apr 8, 2002
41,091
513
126
Originally posted by: BoomerD
Originally posted by: Genx87

You are correct however the argument isnt over that at all. It is whether you want to coerce people with a tax incentive or beat them over the head with a hammer to donate.

I prefer and have always prefered the coercsion. Because it still gives people a "choice" in the decision. So far our system isnt bad. We donate a lot of money to private institutions that relieve pressure on our already bloated govt from having to do it.

Yep...folks like Jimmy Swaggart, Jim and Tammy Faye Baker, and all the rest reap huge benefits from government subsidies...(I know, the Bakers are long dead..just an example)

People also like the Red Cross your point?
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,983
55,383
136
Originally posted by: Specop 007

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.

Seek professional help. You are dangerously paranoid and your description of the people who live around you is badly deluded.

I'm completely serious.
 

umbrella39

Lifer
Jun 11, 2004
13,816
1,126
126
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Specop 007

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.

Seek professional help. You are dangerously paranoid and your description of the people who live around you is badly deluded.

I'm completely serious.

I like it. Let those like him keep spouting off at the mouth. Each time someone like him speaks in public or makes a post on the internet they lose more and more votes. We've been listening to this tripe for 6+ years now. When the dust has settled, there won't be many more like him left. Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. Merry Christmas.
 

ayabe

Diamond Member
Aug 10, 2005
7,449
0
0
Sure conservatives donate more, you know how many millions of dollars it takes to torpedo gay marriage legislation, ask Rick Warren.

Though don't be surprised if he refuses to open the books, can't jeopardize their tax exempt status you know.
 

Specop 007

Diamond Member
Jan 31, 2005
9,454
0
0
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Specop 007

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.

Seek professional help. You are dangerously paranoid and your description of the people who live around you is badly deluded.

I'm completely serious.

Ok. Will you pay for it? Donation maybe?
 

ayabe

Diamond Member
Aug 10, 2005
7,449
0
0
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Specop 007

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.

Seek professional help. You are dangerously paranoid and your description of the people who live around you is badly deluded.

I'm completely serious.

Well with the coming apocalypse and all, I have a feeling Specop and Butterbean may be the only survivors.

But somehow, I bet they will soldier on, mate, and continue the species. Too bad none of us will be alive the reap the fruits of their labor and the Uber American that will no doubt be part Chuck Norris, part Reagan, and 100% hermaphroditic.
 

DealMonkey

Lifer
Nov 25, 2001
13,136
1
0
I Googled, looking for a study showing how much churches, on average, spend on charity and other things.

How Churches Spend Money
John C. LaRue, Jr.

After completing the long process of preparing an annual church budget, you may wonder how your congregation compares to others. Here's one way. YOUR CHURCH has just completed a major study on church budgets, including such topics as indebtedness, insurance, property values, and pastor salaries. This report, based on that study, is the first of a series on churches and money.

According to the study, staff compensation accounts for more than 40 percent of an average church's budget. Large churches with annual budgets of more than $500,000 appropriate an average of 40 percent of their budget to staff pay. This is slightly less than the typical 46 percent that's allocated by smaller churches with annual budgets of less than $500,000.

Building Costs

Keeping a church facility going grabs the second largest piece of the budget pie; about $2 of every $10. Churches, large and small, dedicate about the same percentage of their budgets to paying off, maintaining, and protecting their property.

Link

It appears running a church exhausts about 60% of an average church's budget, leaving only 40% for charity, but who knows how much of that is actually spent on charitable efforts? Certainly lends credence to the argument that meeting in a grassy field instead of an ostentatious edifice would go a long way towards sending more of the church's money to places where it does the most good.

Another study by the same site, looked at nearly 1,200 churches and how they spend their money. This gets really interesting.

Our Study

Those figures are high compared to what we learned from the study YOUR CHURCH recently completed on churches and their budgets. A total of 1,184 surveys were mailed, with a response rate of 23 percent. A more detailed analysis of those findings will be presented in a series of Special Reports, beginning in this issue ("How Churches Spend Money"). But, briefly, the study shows that the average-size budget of the churches surveyed is $292,790. Here's how the pie is divided:

43 percent for staff compensation
20 percent for facilities (rent, mortgage, utilities, upkeep)
16 percent for missions
9 percent for church programs
6 percent for administration and supplies
3 percent for denominational fees
3 percent other.

Link

I'd say that 16% for "missions" is where the church is spending money that benefits those who need it most. You might argue that the 9% for church programs might help people too, depending on what programs they're referring to.

But at best, you have 16%-25% of an average church's budget going towards helping people. And you have to wonder how many of their "missions" are truthfully just evangelical missions to proselytize and not truly charitable missions where they're helping the less fortunate.

Kinda pathetic if you ask me. It appears something on the order of 75%+ of a church's budget goes to simply maintaining the church itself. Frankly, that money isn't helping anyone, except the people who mistakenly worship the building itself and not their god.
 

BeauJangles

Lifer
Aug 26, 2001
13,941
1
0
Originally posted by: Specop 007
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.

These people are basically 50% of the country you profess to love. Their words, ideas, and actions have helped shape that history your cherish so deeply, but you claim to "hate" them.

If you hate them, you hate what makes America special and what has been one of our nation's strengths since its inception.
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Originally posted by: Specop 007
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Why even bother posting such inflammatory drivel? If you really believe liberals are evil, then you basically hate 50% of this country.

Instead of posting this crap, why not try to find some things that you have in common with liberals and agree to disagree on other things? That way, we, as a country, might move to a more productive dialogue versus the current "you suck," "nuhh uhhh you suck more" shit that goes on.

Do you really think that he's interested in that, at all? I mean this seriously, do you actually think that he posts here because he wants to participate in a constructive exchange of ideas?

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.
You weren't in the Dallas area yesterday were you?

 

DealMonkey

Lifer
Nov 25, 2001
13,136
1
0
Originally posted by: Specop 007
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Specop 007

Nope. I DO hate 50% of the country. I fucking despise them. When bad shit happens to them it make sme happy. :)

Why you ask? Because the enemy of my enemy is my friend logic. These people want to tell me the word God is bad, they want to take my money tog ive it to worthless slackass deadbeats and they want to tell me how much safer the world is without guns. They want to tell me the .gov is the best thing in the world and I should let the .gov tell me how to live my life.

FUCK ALL THAT. The people who want to take away my rights, take away my money and make me a slave to the government are NOT my friends.

Seek professional help. You are dangerously paranoid and your description of the people who live around you is badly deluded.

I'm completely serious.

Ok. Will you pay for it? Donation maybe?

I doubt there's any therapy for hateful folks like yourself, except perhaps a lobotomy.