I went to Gamestop to see about the trade-in deal on Sunday and the clerk said that the only exceptions for trade-in were 2002 and earlier sports titles. I asked about wrestling games and he said that they were fine.
Since I don't have any old PS2 games to trade, my g/f's dad gave me his copy of Silent Scope and after verifying the deal at GS, went over to the Target in the same shopping center to look for these mythical "$4.88 games". Either you guys like in Fantasyland or you don't know how good you've got it, cuz here in the Real World, the cheapest they had was "Racer Revenge" for $13.88. Ugh.
Playing a hunch, I went back to Gamestop and looked thru the user PS2 games and found a few losers for $8. I picked one up and went to the counter and asked the clerk, "What's to stop me from buying this game and immediately trading it back for the $20 credit?" He said, "Well...nothing. Some of the employees figured this out, but you're the first customer to ask about it."
So, I traded Silent Scope, bought the other game for $7.20 plus tax (w/ GameStop discount card) and promptly flipped it back for DOA XBV. My end cost will be ~$18.25. BAM!!! Interesting note: Someone said that games traded had to be worth more than $5, but the receipt clearly mentioned how much was added to the regular trade value - Silent Scope would've brought only $5 and the one I picked off the shelf would've garnered only $3.
Here's the kicker - as my g/f and I left, another clerk was shelving games by the door and as we passed, he turned and (I'm not making this up!) softly APPLAUDED:Q and said, "Well played." Man, when you've got the CLERKS applauded your pimpage, that's trey cool!!!