Audiophiles can't tell the difference between Monster Cable and coat hangers.

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Squisher

Lifer
Aug 17, 2000
21,204
66
91
I've got a bunch of Monster Cable speaker wire and interconnects, but I bought it so long ago that back then it was moderately priced.
 

I4AT

Platinum Member
Oct 28, 2006
2,631
3
81
Audiophiles make me laugh. I can imagine the bullshit they were spewing while listening through a coat hanger. "The highs are crisp and bright with a wide soundstage. The bass is tight not muddy and airy, the lows and mids roll with a warm well defined resolution! Amazingly chocolatey detail with a more recessed upper midrange, spectacular separation! Cherry textured dynamic frequencies, sounds wonderful after 347 hours of stop-watched burn-in."
 

dug777

Lifer
Oct 13, 2004
24,778
4
0
Originally posted by: rockyct
Well, at least this is better than headphone audiophiles paying $500 for a power cable for their amplifier. That's right a six foot cord between the outlet and the amp.

Whatever next? You own dedicated generation, transmission, and distribution line? ;)
 

SlickSnake

Diamond Member
May 29, 2007
5,235
2
0
Monster Cable Z1 series speaker wire
This is what I use. The higher end Z series monster cables (Z2, Z3, Z4, ect.) use basically the same design, but the outer jackets become more expensive along with the connectors. I needed a heavy duty cable for long runs. And in a long run, the Z1 cable sounds noticeably better with greater clarity and definition than a standard cheapo 16 gauge speaker wire. You can hear improved bass and treble using these speaker cables. And for surround use you can hear improved dialoge and imaging. Most noticable is the fact it is a louder cable at the same volume levels on the reciever versus cheapo 16 gauge especially using 20 foot plus runs. It is also heavily shielded and insulated which is important if you have a lot of video and audio cables running side by side out of the reciever.

There are vastly more expensive cables made than Monster Cable. I can't quite figure out what all the Monster hate is about, other than the fact some pricey retail outlets choose to sell the cables at the suggested retail price. That does not mean you can't get Monster for a LOT less elsewhere. Why not rag more on the shady retail sellers for not lowering the retail price of the cables in the first place? I never paid retail for a single Monster Cable I ever bought. Usually I pay 1/4 to 1/3 of the retail cost just buying it on Ebay or some volume internet discounter out there. I bought a 250 foot spool of Z1 for long runs for about 50 cents a foot, brand new! That's $2 less per foot than the retail price. And at that price point, there simply is not a better speaker cable made of that quality for that price. Even the short Z1 runs I bought for the speaker mains never exceeded $1 a foot, including the gold plated connectors.

I also use these for both of my subwoofers on my 2 HT systems: Zbass100 Audiophile Powered Subwoofer Interconnect I did have a bit of trouble finding these cheap, since they were hard to find in the first place, and ended up paying about half retail price at $50 each for 12 foot runs. I had cheaper sub cables hooked up before, and the change of sub cables were not only noticable, I had to completely recalibrate my subs for them! But don't take my word for it. The simple fact is you can't possibly know what you are talking about when you trash their overall cable quality and retail price, unless you try it and hear it for yourself.

Additionally, concerning the Monster Power Bars they also work, as advertised. Even the low end Monster stuff like this can clean up most of the noise you would otherwise hear running from your AC power. I used to have a lot of line noise which was virtually eliminated using just the stage 2 power bars. Of course, you can pay $1500 retail and get the stage 5 stuff, too. Or just shop around a bit and find it for 1/3 off, or more.

For the quality you are buying with the lifetime warranty on cables and $250,000 equipment insurance on the power equipment with a 5 year warranty, you can only go wrong by buying some other cheap brand that might not be around to honor their warranty when the lightning surge takes out your entire HT.

So anyone spouting off here about how you don't get what you pay for with a Monster Cable has obviously not had a high quality cable in the first place to compare it to. And they also most likely can't figure out shopping on the internet well enough to not pay retail for it, when they need to buy it. I am sure for most people the cheapest Monoprice quality level works just fine. Just keep in mind not everyone is trying to hook up the cheapest made consumer products with the cheapest Monoprice cables. On something electronic of high quality at the higher end of the price range, you very well might notice various problems with the cheapest cables you can buy. And even Monoprice has cables for the same applications at different price points. Why do you think that is, hmmm? But if you do buy cheap, and it works fine for you, that's just great, too. Just don't be dense enough to actually pretend you always get what you pay for when you pay cents instead of dollars for every product you buy. It obviously just don't work that way. Even at Monoprice.

 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
lol i never thought of coathangers as wiring..thats damn creative:)


overhyped garbage...
monster cable, barak obama...chumps everywhere.
 

UncleWai

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2001
5,701
68
91
The speakers, amp, source, recordings are the only worthwhile purchases for me. Wires are just snake-oil in my opinion, I just use really thick gauge wires to make my own cables.
 

Corbett

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2005
3,074
0
76
Originally posted by: SlickSnake
Monster Cable Z1 series speaker wire
This is what I use. The higher end Z series monster cables (Z2, Z3, Z4, ect.) use basically the same design, but the outer jackets become more expensive along with the connectors. I needed a heavy duty cable for long runs. And in a long run, the Z1 cable sounds noticeably better with greater clarity and definition than a standard cheapo 16 gauge speaker wire. You can hear improved bass and treble using these speaker cables. And for surround use you can hear improved dialoge and imaging. Most noticable is the fact it is a louder cable at the same volume levels on the reciever versus cheapo 16 gauge especially using 20 foot plus runs. It is also heavily shielded and insulated which is important if you have a lot of video and audio cables running side by side out of the reciever.

There are vastly more expensive cables made than Monster Cable. I can't quite figure out what all the Monster hate is about, other than the fact some pricey retail outlets choose to sell the cables at the suggested retail price. That does not mean you can't get Monster for a LOT less elsewhere. Why not rag more on the shady retail sellers for not lowering the retail price of the cables in the first place? I never paid retail for a single Monster Cable I ever bought. Usually I pay 1/4 to 1/3 of the retail cost just buying it on Ebay or some volume internet discounter out there. I bought a 250 foot spool of Z1 for long runs for about 50 cents a foot, brand new! That's $2 less per foot than the retail price. And at that price point, there simply is not a better speaker cable made of that quality for that price. Even the short Z1 runs I bought for the speaker mains never exceeded $1 a foot, including the gold plated connectors.

I also use these for both of my subwoofers on my 2 HT systems: Zbass100 Audiophile Powered Subwoofer Interconnect I did have a bit of trouble finding these cheap, since they were hard to find in the first place, and ended up paying about half retail price at $50 each for 12 foot runs. I had cheaper sub cables hooked up before, and the change of sub cables were not only noticable, I had to completely recalibrate my subs for them! But don't take my word for it. The simple fact is you can't possibly know what you are talking about when you trash their overall cable quality and retail price, unless you try it and hear it for yourself.

Additionally, concerning the Monster Power Bars they also work, as advertised. Even the low end Monster stuff like this can clean up most of the noise you would otherwise hear running from your AC power. I used to have a lot of line noise which was virtually eliminated using just the stage 2 power bars. Of course, you can pay $1500 retail and get the stage 5 stuff, too. Or just shop around a bit and find it for 1/3 off, or more.

For the quality you are buying with the lifetime warranty on cables and $250,000 equipment insurance on the power equipment with a 5 year warranty, you can only go wrong by buying some other cheap brand that might not be around to honor their warranty when the lightning surge takes out your entire HT.

So anyone spouting off here about how you don't get what you pay for with a Monster Cable has obviously not had a high quality cable in the first place to compare it to. And they also most likely can't figure out shopping on the internet well enough to not pay retail for it, when they need to buy it. I am sure for most people the cheapest Monoprice quality level works just fine. Just keep in mind not everyone is trying to hook up the cheapest made consumer products with the cheapest Monoprice cables. On something electronic of high quality at the higher end of the price range, you very well might notice various problems with the cheapest cables you can buy. And even Monoprice has cables for the same applications at different price points. Why do you think that is, hmmm? But if you do buy cheap, and it works fine for you, that's just great, too. Just don't be dense enough to actually pretend you always get what you pay for when you pay cents instead of dollars for every product you buy. It obviously just don't work that way. Even at Monoprice.

BWAHAHAHAHAHHAA!

Did you use those cables to hook up your bose system?
 

Throckmorton

Lifer
Aug 23, 2007
16,829
3
0
Originally posted by: gorcorps
"Studies" like this make me sad... and the people who call themselves 'audiophiles' and eat this shit up makes me even sadder. Before I go ranting here, I just want to say while I don't consider myself an audiophile I am more picky than most. But I AM a metallurgical engineer and have quite a bit of experience when it comes to metals, alloys, and how they're made and used.

First, while it may be a surprise to some of you that a coat hanger could produce that good of sound, it really shouldn't. A conductive metal will conduct, that's all there is to it. Gold conducts a bit better than copper which conducts better than lots of other metals but the fact of the matter is that many cheap metals will conduct well enough for speaker wire for most to not tell the difference. But that doesn't mean there's no reason to go with the cheap metals every time... you pretty much get what you pay for here. As mentioned before Gold is highly corrosion resistant. Add that with great conductance and you have a perfect metal to use for such applications. Copper and Gold are both also of the "face centered cubic" crystal structure which is known to be of higher ductility than other metals. This means they can be bent, twisted, and formed more easily without worrying about breaking them. Try to bend a coat hanger at the same spot a few times and it'll snap long before copper or gold wire of the same gauge. So with gold and copper you have a material that conducts electricity well, and can be warped without much worry. Can you really ask for a better material for a cable?

So where does your money for monster cables go? Into shielding which is quite important, warranties which many other companies don't offer, and durability. I use monster cables for my guitar setup because I can step all over them, run over them with chairs, etc without having to worry they'll short out. And if they do? It gets sent to monster for a replacement.


I have a hard time believing you are an engineer of any kind if you believe that speaker wires are ever shielded

 

SlickSnake

Diamond Member
May 29, 2007
5,235
2
0
Corbett said:
BWAHAHAHAHAHHAA!

Did you use those cables to hook up your bose system?

Hardly. You obviously know as little about Bose, as HT and cables in general. Bose HT in the box, has its own cables. And they are proprietary to the HT system. :p

 

Corbett

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2005
3,074
0
76
Originally posted by: SlickSnake
Corbett said:
BWAHAHAHAHAHHAA!

Did you use those cables to hook up your bose system?

Hardly. You obviously know as little about Bose, as HT and cables in general. Bose HT in the box, has its own cables. And they are proprietary to the HT system. :p

It was a joke. You are just too concerned with selling your snake oil to see that I guess.
 

MrChad

Lifer
Aug 22, 2001
13,507
3
81
My experience with Monster Cable is that they generally make high-quality, well-constructed products. They're just sold at outrageously high prices.
 

SlickSnake

Diamond Member
May 29, 2007
5,235
2
0
Originally posted by: Corbett
Originally posted by: SlickSnake
Corbett said:
BWAHAHAHAHAHHAA!

Did you use those cables to hook up your bose system?

Hardly. You obviously know as little about Bose, as HT and cables in general. Bose HT in the box, has its own cables. And they are proprietary to the HT system. :p

It was a joke. You are just too concerned with selling your snake oil to see that I guess.

Ohh, right. Some funny there. Yea. :thumbsdown:

But like I said, unless you hear the difference for yourself like on a sub application compared to flimsy and cheap RCA cable, you can just remain the septic skeptic comic for all I care. I don't have to listen to your HT in a jam box that runs on batteries, thankfully. :eek:

Monster can also arrange for a personal demo of their power applications ability to clean up noisy power, if you happen to be in their supply chain. Just for know it all doubters like yourself.
 

SlickSnake

Diamond Member
May 29, 2007
5,235
2
0
Originally posted by: yllus
Engadget: Audiophiles can't tell the difference between Monster Cable and coat hangers

It looks like a group of 12 self-professed "audiophiles" recently couldn't tell the difference between Monster 1000 speaker cables and plain old coat hangers. Yeah, coat hangers.

The group was A-Bing different cables, and unbeknownst to them, the engineer running the test swapped out a set of cables for coat hangers with soldered-on speaker connections. Not a single one was then able to tell the difference between the Monster Cable and the hangers, and all agreed that the hangers sounded excellent.

I know that the defenders of Monster Cable are going to jump all over the source here, but it certainly rings true to my own experiences. During my term in retail I was up close and centre with Monster products and was hard pressed to ever find a difference in quality between their stuff and generic cabling. The power bars were the funniest bit.

BTW, there would be little difference in the solid wire coathanger and just another hard wired run on the circuit board on the amp. In fact, for a short run, it might actually sound better for bass effects. The real question is, what exactly is the hanger made from and just how conductive is it? Would they get the same tester response if they ran hanger wire in a run for 20 or 30 feet? They could easily get this hanger wire in a large spool from the hanger manufacturer to test this.

And why such a stupidly small group of 12 self-professed "audiophile" testers for such an earth shaking test? That is not even a decent representative sample for such a "definitive" test. Talk about "bogus". They could have done this test at some audio electronics convention, and got thousands of "audiophile" expert testers to test this, instead of 12 cherry picked plants for it.

Another reason I find it hard to believe they accomplished this amazing feat is because they didn't bother to provide pictures to prove how their system was set up, in the first place. We just have to take their "word" for it all. What speakers and amps did they use? Something sonicaly crappy where you couldn't hear the difference if they ran kite string and tin cans together for the speakers and wire? :laugh:
 

PottedMeat

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
12,363
475
126
Originally posted by: SlickSnake
Monster Cable Z1 series speaker wire
This is what I use. The higher end Z series monster cables (Z2, Z3, Z4, ect.) use basically the same design, but the outer jackets become more expensive along with the connectors. I needed a heavy duty cable for long runs. And in a long run, the Z1 cable sounds noticeably better with greater clarity and definition than a standard cheapo 16 gauge speaker wire. You can hear improved bass and treble using these speaker cables. And for surround use you can hear improved dialoge and imaging. Most noticable is the fact it is a louder cable at the same volume levels on the reciever versus cheapo 16 gauge especially using 20 foot plus runs. It is also heavily shielded and insulated which is important if you have a lot of video and audio cables running side by side out of the reciever.

Audiophiles always say meaningless crap like that. Those statements are idiotic. If you hear a difference between lamp cord and monster cable, then you diddn't hook them up correctly. And where does that cable say it's shielded?

The only good thing about Monster Cables is that you can abuse the crap out of them, break them, then get a replacement. Thats it.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
98,955
17,377
126
Originally posted by: Agentbolt
Originally posted by: Rubycon
What I find really funny about all this speaker wire stuff is people spend all this money to ensure the best connection between their box and receiver yet never peep inside either component to see how its wired! :laugh:

The pros use SJO cable - like your garden variety extension cord. Most is SJ (300V rated) but in high power installs we like to use 600V rated stuff. (SJO) Virtually indestructible as are the Speakon connectors on each end. Twist and click - goes nowhere even if someone trips on the wire - box keeps on ticking and the unfortunate individual does a face plant on the stage. :Q

You are really weird.

What do you mean? Robycon is speaking from experience...
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
98,955
17,377
126
Originally posted by: Safeway
Monster cables can cost as much as the television they are connected to. The only thing in this category I would ever buy would be an advanced surge protector/energy scrubber. Separate grounds for audio equipment drastically decreases fuzziness and buzz.

isn't it cheaper to hire an electrician to install a true ground for you?
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
Originally posted by: PottedMeat
Originally posted by: SlickSnake
Monster Cable Z1 series speaker wire
This is what I use. The higher end Z series monster cables (Z2, Z3, Z4, ect.) use basically the same design, but the outer jackets become more expensive along with the connectors. I needed a heavy duty cable for long runs. And in a long run, the Z1 cable sounds noticeably better with greater clarity and definition than a standard cheapo 16 gauge speaker wire. You can hear improved bass and treble using these speaker cables. And for surround use you can hear improved dialoge and imaging. Most noticable is the fact it is a louder cable at the same volume levels on the reciever versus cheapo 16 gauge especially using 20 foot plus runs. It is also heavily shielded and insulated which is important if you have a lot of video and audio cables running side by side out of the reciever.

Audiophiles always say meaningless crap like that. Those statements are idiotic. If you hear a difference between lamp cord and monster cable, then you diddn't hook them up correctly. And where does that cable say it's shielded?

The only good thing about Monster Cables is that you can abuse the crap out of them, break them, then get a replacement. Thats it.


some really beleive the hype. since one guy says they are great and they can tell the diffrnece then he has to. that way he is a ELITE audophile and knows about this stuff and we don't.


 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,074
9
81
Originally posted by: PottedMeat
Originally posted by: SlickSnake
Monster Cable Z1 series speaker wire
This is what I use. The higher end Z series monster cables (Z2, Z3, Z4, ect.) use basically the same design, but the outer jackets become more expensive along with the connectors. I needed a heavy duty cable for long runs. And in a long run, the Z1 cable sounds noticeably better with greater clarity and definition than a standard cheapo 16 gauge speaker wire. You can hear improved bass and treble using these speaker cables. And for surround use you can hear improved dialoge and imaging. Most noticable is the fact it is a louder cable at the same volume levels on the reciever versus cheapo 16 gauge especially using 20 foot plus runs. It is also heavily shielded and insulated which is important if you have a lot of video and audio cables running side by side out of the reciever.

Audiophiles always say meaningless crap like that. Those statements are idiotic. If you hear a difference between lamp cord and monster cable, then you diddn't hook them up correctly. And where does that cable say it's shielded?

The only good thing about Monster Cables is that you can abuse the crap out of them, break them, then get a replacement. Thats it.

But, but ... the image! The dialogue!

Wait, we are talking about audio, not my new HDTV? Oh. Sorry.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
98,955
17,377
126
Originally posted by: gorcorps
"Studies" like this make me sad... and the people who call themselves 'audiophiles' and eat this shit up makes me even sadder. Before I go ranting here, I just want to say while I don't consider myself an audiophile I am more picky than most. But I AM a metallurgical engineer and have quite a bit of experience when it comes to metals, alloys, and how they're made and used.

First, while it may be a surprise to some of you that a coat hanger could produce that good of sound, it really shouldn't. A conductive metal will conduct, that's all there is to it. Gold conducts a bit better than copper which conducts better than lots of other metals but the fact of the matter is that many cheap metals will conduct well enough for speaker wire for most to not tell the difference. But that doesn't mean there's no reason to go with the cheap metals every time... you pretty much get what you pay for here. As mentioned before Gold is highly corrosion resistant. Add that with great conductance and you have a perfect metal to use for such applications. Copper and Gold are both also of the "face centered cubic" crystal structure which is known to be of higher ductility than other metals. This means they can be bent, twisted, and formed more easily without worrying about breaking them. Try to bend a coat hanger at the same spot a few times and it'll snap long before copper or gold wire of the same gauge. So with gold and copper you have a material that conducts electricity well, and can be warped without much worry. Can you really ask for a better material for a cable?

So where does your money for monster cables go? Into shielding which is quite important, warranties which many other companies don't offer, and durability. I use monster cables for my guitar setup because I can step all over them, run over them with chairs, etc without having to worry they'll short out. And if they do? It gets sent to monster for a replacement.

Que? Speaker wires are not shielded...Interconnects are shielded, but Monster's interconnects are not better built than say Belden ones. Personally, I use RG-59 with plenum, aluminum shielding + 95% copper braid shielding. I don't think you can do much better than that in a non pro environment.