Manning/Brady > Rodgers > Roflsburger/Rivers > Ryan > Stafford > Vick or Schaub > Cutler....
A few tweaks. Rofflesburger solidly over Rivers, because Rivers loses his cool when things go badly; maybe Stafford over Ryan, maybe not.
Big problem - you forgot Brees. And I'd definitely put Brees over the Rofl/River slot, sitting right behind Rodgers.