To throw in a vaguely relevant two cents: my war has only 560 and I was destroyed by a rogue with 0 resilience (at least that's what he said). I just respecced to ARMS/FURY from Fury/Prot mainly because i'm tired of using Fury in pvp. Very much rusty with Arms...end up grasping for what to press and when. Any advice for a new arms war?
I would love to give some tips, but TBH, I have been gone from WoW since last June (and before that I was playing my DK). I am a long time warrior but most of my pvp experience was at Lvl 70.
I have been Arms for a total of 2 days now so I don't value my own opinion much at this point! Honestly, my gear isnt' really optimized for PvP atm either. A few things I will say:
-after being TG Fury I feel like I hit with a limp noodle as Arms--even MS seems weak. As another poster said, i didn't spec for slam. I have personally never liked that ability unless it was a rage free, instant proc.
-I spec'd into 2nd wind and whatever the first tier talent is called for increasing healing effects on you. I also glyphed my victory rushs to increase healing by 50% and I am seeing 12-15k HEALING from a victory rush which is pretty dang awesome IMO. I did some open world PvP against a lock last night and this ability saved me.
-I love the new "throwdown" ability (5s stun)
-I wouldn't even know a good strategy for rogues anymore, if they have had half as many changes as Warriors they have tools/strats against us that I am unfamiliar with. I know that if I was going to 1v1 a rogue the first thing I would do would try to disarm him and get thunderclap/demo shout and a rend on him. Because our bladestorm can be disarmed, I would want to save that until after he disarmed me. I would also save throwdown for an all out effort to burst a rogue down--ie, after he is at 50% health or so. Otherwise he'll vanish/sprint/blind etc. and get away if he see's he's going to lose.
-I haven't even bothered creating a macro to switch to 1h/shield for spell reflect. I just go down swinging against mages who destroy me easily.
-I've heard Mastery is a good stat to reforge into for Arms
-Rage hasn't been a problem at all for me so far
-I am saving up to get the Wrathful Axe (297 dps or so?) which will be a huge upgrade my my ilvl 232 axe..
Although Arms is nice, i'm almost ready to head back to Fury land. I don't enjoy dpsing a heroic with Arms (dps went way down for me) and Fury isnt' that bad for PvP from what I've seen.
There are some new pvp talents int he Fury tree (at least they werent' there last I played) such as the talent that resets the CD on intercept, the talent to reduce healing by 20% from auto swings, and the healing available through bloodthirst (I've never glyphed this up to see how well it will heal yet), and of course piercing howl.
If you want to laugh at my scrub gear and see the spec I am trying out, I am Splatter on Dunemaul.