Are you mexican?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,082
136
Originally posted by: Capt Caveman
Wow.
Sorry if it sounded harsh but we already have enough problems in this country and the illegals arent helping. We got more than enough American criminals to deal with and I'd like to send back the 11 million foreign criminals as a way to start.

 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Hispanics are anyone from any Spanish speaking country, including Spain and Mexico. It is not an offensive term. You could also call her latina, and that is not offensive.
 

Blieb

Diamond Member
Apr 17, 2000
3,475
0
76
The problem is that she's a bitch, not that she's Hispanic.

Now, if you call her a "perra" and she gets pissed ... then yes, she's got a little Spanish in her ...
 

TechBoyJK

Lifer
Oct 17, 2002
16,699
60
91
Originally posted by: mugs
Hispanics are anyone from any Spanish speaking country, including Spain and Mexico. It is not an offensive term. You could also call her latina, and that is not offensive.

She later posted that "Hispanic is a useless term coined by the US government for use in census, and is equally as ignorant and offensive as the word "Oriental"
 

AstroManLuca

Lifer
Jun 24, 2004
15,628
5
81
Originally posted by: TechBoyJK
Originally posted by: mugs
Hispanics are anyone from any Spanish speaking country, including Spain and Mexico. It is not an offensive term. You could also call her latina, and that is not offensive.

She later posted that "Hispanic is a useless term coined by the US government for use in census, and is equally as ignorant and offensive as the word "Oriental"

She's a retard. Why don't you ask her if there's anything that DOESN'T offend her?
 

moshquerade

No Lifer
Nov 1, 2001
61,504
12
56
Originally posted by: AstroManLuca
Originally posted by: TechBoyJK
Originally posted by: mugs
Hispanics are anyone from any Spanish speaking country, including Spain and Mexico. It is not an offensive term. You could also call her latina, and that is not offensive.

She later posted that "Hispanic is a useless term coined by the US government for use in census, and is equally as ignorant and offensive as the word "Oriental"

She's a retard. Why don't you ask her if there's anything that DOESN'T offend her?

i don't think he's challenging her on any of this stuff. : /
 

TechBoyJK

Lifer
Oct 17, 2002
16,699
60
91
Originally posted by: moshquerade
Originally posted by: AstroManLuca
Originally posted by: TechBoyJK
Originally posted by: mugs
Hispanics are anyone from any Spanish speaking country, including Spain and Mexico. It is not an offensive term. You could also call her latina, and that is not offensive.

She later posted that "Hispanic is a useless term coined by the US government for use in census, and is equally as ignorant and offensive as the word "Oriental"

She's a retard. Why don't you ask her if there's anything that DOESN'T offend her?

i don't think he's challenging her on any of this stuff. : /

I'm not.. I was just wondering why she would have been offended by my cultural ignorance based on what I said. Sure, I'm ingorant to most cultures. I haven't traveled much nor studied many other cultures. Why she would personally attack me about it is what was confusing.
 

PlasmaBomb

Lifer
Nov 19, 2004
11,636
2
81
Originally posted by: TechBoyJK
Originally posted by: mugs
Hispanics are anyone from any Spanish speaking country, including Spain and Mexico. It is not an offensive term. You could also call her latina, and that is not offensive.

She later posted that "Hispanic is a useless term coined by the US government for use in census, and is equally as ignorant and offensive as the word "Oriental"

The only person being ignorant here is her.

The term Hispanic was not coined by the US government.

Oriental literally means someone from the orient (the east), and was not coined by the US government.

That would be a bit like you being offended at being called Occidental (person from the west).
 

PlasmaBomb

Lifer
Nov 19, 2004
11,636
2
81
Originally posted by: PlasmaBomb
Originally posted by: TechBoyJK
I wanted to edit my op..

What about the comparison of Mexican to American.

Someone is from Mexico, they are Mexican? Someone is from America, they are American? I feel silly for asking such simple questions but I got flamed for the comparison.

It started with a girl stating on her status

"Ha! "girl be Lookin half black and philipiNa" ...uM I'm neither, but nice combo...good guess"

I replied "You look mexican/caucasian to me... Which I think is a better combo."

She replies "uh i dont think its a better combo....technically aren't Mexicans = Caucasian?"

I reply "Is hispanic the better word? I'm not sure of the technicality, but I'm thinking mexican is like saying american. Not sure."

Her friend replies ""Caucasian?" oh my god i've never heard of a more ignorant term. Caucasus is a region between Europe, Asia, and the Middle East.... so I'm guessing you have no idea what people look like from there.... perhaps did you mean "European American" or "White?" why are people so scared of using the correct terms and think that made-up terms are a more pc way of referring to people?"

And then replies again "Jason... you might not know this but you are either racist, sexist, or very VERY culturally ignorant... please do yourself a favor, and spare us the frustration and offense, and keep your mouth shut on these topics until you culturally educate yourself."

/facepalm

European American's are Caucasian. White people are Caucasian. Caucasian is the CORRECT TERM, if anything european american is the shitty pc term.

How are you being sexist :confused:

Next time don't have two posts OP.
 

TechBoyJK

Lifer
Oct 17, 2002
16,699
60
91
Me
Self righteous much? I've never been so confused as to how, someone as smart as you, would not realize how condescending and self righteous you would look by going on your little rant about my cultural ignorance. I posted everything that was said on a busy, culturally diverse webforum, and people are equally as confused as to why you would take such offense to what I said, even mexicans and people that study mexican culture. I can send you the link if you want. I'm not trying to fight with you, as I enjoy debate, but the personal attacks are a bit over the line, don't you think? The only reason I'm not giving you the link now, is because I think you would freak out if you saw what other people thought about what you said to me.

You could have easily, and politely corrected me, rather than going on some self righteous rant about cultural awareness because you have some other underlying problem with me. Sorry I don't know everything about everyone.

We're a far ways away from staying up late and talking on the phone like we used to, or sitting at the coffee house hanging out while you cracked my knuckles.


Her
"like i said- if you offend people's race and sex, because of biases or simply ignorance, (how could i know which?) people tend to handle it as such, and offense. should i say thanks for handling as though of no importance the things that you have the privilege of not being affected by since you're white and male? you have made it clear that you just don't get or don't care about the sex issues in western religion. and write off an entire perspective of struggling women by saying "oh she's good at playing devils advocate." well i'm not playing, this is something that i've had to struggle with because i'm not lucky enough to have a penis. and then as though these issues are some amusing game to you, you move right on to race issues...whatever, jason. if you don't like people standing up to your offensive viewpoints, then stop saying them so publicly."


Me
HER NAME HERE! I did not choose to be born white or male so if you think I have some kind of elitist perspective about one sex, race or another, you are mistaken. I DO think that women should be submissive to their husbands, and this assumes a peaceful and respectful marriage, but that's it. I don't think women should be submissive to men in general though. I love to see women succeed and be independat. You are completely over reacting about the race thing though, and I'm not sure why someone of your intellect would react like that. I even acknowledged my ignorance by saying 'not sure', and rather than politely correcting me, you went on some very insulting, self righteous attack. You should know I take what you say seriously, respect it, and give it consideration. You don't need to attack me personally.


Her
ok- i don't know what goes on in your head, but how you present your views would make one believe that you do have an elitist perspective, and you don't even care that how you present it to the public is offensive to people who are actually affected by those things. you can believe whatever you want about how wives should be, and whatever you want about people of other cultures... lets just leave it at that, i'd rather not get upset over someone's views who is completely removed from the issues and unaffected either way.


Me
Again, what exactly did I say about race that was offensive? I posted everything I said in a forum and nobody found offense in what I said, then went on to make fun of your over-the-top responses, even mexicans.

Her
well you have the support of internet mexicans. good for you. its an issue of culturally-perpetuating language. like the argument of whether black people can say *****. some would say that its a word that has different meaning when used among themselves and its ok. others would say its perpetuating oppression among themselves. but either way its not for non-blacks to address. anyway. really, jason, just drop it. you've offended me enough and cant even comprehend why. that should be an indicator that you are very removed from the issue and to further push it would be revealing the extent of your ignorance and lack or respect for cultural differences.

Me
Are you seriously crazy? That or are you are just a little bit self righteous about the issue? What again did I say about race that was offensive? Tell me again. I'm not making light about anything. Do you want that link?
 

npoe1

Senior member
Jul 28, 2005
592
0
76
She is just crazy. I?m Mexican, and Hispanic is not an insult, she mustn't know what it means or she might hate to other Latin American countries with so much rage and the sole idea of being categorized with them is enough to make her nuts.

By the way, I?m on the understanding that many Latin American countries hate Mexico. It seems to be truer for Puerto Rico, but it might just be boxing related.
 

n yusef

Platinum Member
Feb 20, 2005
2,158
1
0
Many people don't like the the label "Hispanic" because they see it as Eurocentric. Slate explains:

Hispanic is an English word that originally referred to people from Spain and eventually expanded to include the populations of its colonies in South and Central America. Latino is a Spanish word?hence the feminine form Latina?that refers to people with roots in Latin America and generally excludes the Iberian Peninsula. For many, Hispanic has negative connotations because of its Eurocentrism. Others prefer it because it's gender-neutral. Latino, meanwhile, is perceived as a more authentic-sounding, Spanish-language alternative.

I'm disappointed, but not surprised, that it took so many posts to get a real answer.

OP, I would hardly call this forum "culturally diverse." And LOL @ "I DO think that women should be submissive to their husbands."
 

dr150

Diamond Member
Sep 18, 2003
6,570
24
81
It depends on how the person says it.

If a blonde bimbette or redneck calls you a Mexican with her nose up in the air, then you know she's putting you down as a poor illegal peasant that's beneath her. Then you of course will be offended.

It's all about how they approach you.
 

npoe1

Senior member
Jul 28, 2005
592
0
76
She might just be one of those persons who speak with a dictionary on her left hand and protest because companies takes jobs offshore and when companies keep the jobs inshore they protest because other poor countries doesn?t have to eat because jobs are being keep inshore.
 

hanoverphist

Diamond Member
Dec 7, 2006
9,867
23
76
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: hanoverphist
Originally posted by: Insomniator
Pretty sure calling a Hispanic (or anyone...) a Mexican is a biigggg insult. The other way around is.... a compliment?

its just a matter of area. hispanics (i thought) are spanish descent, not from mexico. im half "mexican", my dads parents were both from there. but, my dads side is mainly spanish, so i guess im part mexican, part hispanic and part german. either way, i dont care if people call me hispanic, latino, beloved patriot, half breed... its all just me. im an american. i never hear people use beloved patriot anymore either, i guess that term is gone.

Well, beloved patriot, half-breed, and beloved patriot are derogatory.

Hispanic just means of Spanish decent. Latino just means a person of Latin-American or Spanish speaking decent. Neither of these terms is considered derogatory.

i know this, i just added the others because i dont care if people call me those names... i guess im not easily offended.
 

QueBert

Lifer
Jan 6, 2002
22,987
1,180
126
Originally posted by: n yusef
Many people don't like the the label "Hispanic" because they see it as Eurocentric. Slate explains:

Hispanic is an English word that originally referred to people from Spain and eventually expanded to include the populations of its colonies in South and Central America. Latino is a Spanish word?hence the feminine form Latina?that refers to people with roots in Latin America and generally excludes the Iberian Peninsula. For many, Hispanic has negative connotations because of its Eurocentrism. Others prefer it because it's gender-neutral. Latino, meanwhile, is perceived as a more authentic-sounding, Spanish-language alternative.

I'm disappointed, but not surprised, that it took so many posts to get a real answer.

OP, I would hardly call this forum "culturally diverse." And LOL @ "I DO think that women should be submissive to their husbands."

Wow, somebody on ATOT who knows what the fuck they're talking about. Most intelligent Mexican people will take offense at the term Hispanic. I don't think many would make a stink about it though, or even mention how you shouldn't call them Hispanic. Sort of like calling an Asian personal Oriental. I have had my asshole ripped in the past by 3 asian females because I referred to them as Oriental.
 

CRXican

Diamond Member
Jun 9, 2004
9,062
1
0
Originally posted by: Ktulu
Yes of Mexican decent, no Hispanic is not offensive. I'm pretty damn sure if you're Mexican chances are you're Hispanic. I personally am Hispanic anyways.

That's what I'm thinking. I'm half Mexican but the Mexicans in my family are very fair skinned so no way they're native blood. Spanish is my guess.

I choose "Hispanic" on apps and forms and such that ask that sort of thing. No choice for Mexican...
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: QueBert
Originally posted by: n yusef
Many people don't like the the label "Hispanic" because they see it as Eurocentric. Slate explains:

Hispanic is an English word that originally referred to people from Spain and eventually expanded to include the populations of its colonies in South and Central America. Latino is a Spanish word?hence the feminine form Latina?that refers to people with roots in Latin America and generally excludes the Iberian Peninsula. For many, Hispanic has negative connotations because of its Eurocentrism. Others prefer it because it's gender-neutral. Latino, meanwhile, is perceived as a more authentic-sounding, Spanish-language alternative.

I'm disappointed, but not surprised, that it took so many posts to get a real answer.

OP, I would hardly call this forum "culturally diverse." And LOL @ "I DO think that women should be submissive to their husbands."

Wow, somebody on ATOT who knows what the fuck they're talking about. Most intelligent Mexican people will take offense at the term Hispanic. I don't think many would make a stink about it though, or even mention how you shouldn't call them Hispanic. Sort of like calling an Asian personal Oriental. I have had my asshole ripped in the past by 3 asian females because I referred to them as Oriental.

Someone should mention that to the Hispanic Language Institute that keeps sending me postcards offering to teach me English. :roll: Hispanic is the proper term to refer to a group of people that overlaps with but is not identical to latino. Educated Mexicans understand that.
 

n yusef

Platinum Member
Feb 20, 2005
2,158
1
0
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: QueBert
Originally posted by: n yusef
Many people don't like the the label "Hispanic" because they see it as Eurocentric. Slate explains:

Hispanic is an English word that originally referred to people from Spain and eventually expanded to include the populations of its colonies in South and Central America. Latino is a Spanish word?hence the feminine form Latina?that refers to people with roots in Latin America and generally excludes the Iberian Peninsula. For many, Hispanic has negative connotations because of its Eurocentrism. Others prefer it because it's gender-neutral. Latino, meanwhile, is perceived as a more authentic-sounding, Spanish-language alternative.

I'm disappointed, but not surprised, that it took so many posts to get a real answer.

OP, I would hardly call this forum "culturally diverse." And LOL @ "I DO think that women should be submissive to their husbands."

Wow, somebody on ATOT who knows what the fuck they're talking about. Most intelligent Mexican people will take offense at the term Hispanic. I don't think many would make a stink about it though, or even mention how you shouldn't call them Hispanic. Sort of like calling an Asian personal Oriental. I have had my asshole ripped in the past by 3 asian females because I referred to them as Oriental.

Someone should mention that to the Hispanic Language Institute that keeps sending me postcards offering to teach me English. :roll: Hispanic is the proper term to refer to a group of people that overlaps with but is not identical to latino. Educated Mexicans understand that.

I'm not saying that most Latinos do or should reject the label "Hispanic." Rather, there are legitimate reasons to not identify as "Hispanic" (and legitimate reasons to not identify as "Latino"); we should respect people's self-identification.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: n yusef
I'm not saying that most Latinos do or should reject the label "Hispanic." Rather, there are legitimate reasons to not identify as "Hispanic" (and legitimate reasons to not identify as "Latino"); we should respect people's self-identification.

If she called herself latina and he kept calling her hispanic, then she might have something to complain about. He apparently didn't know she was Mexican, so he probably didn't know she was latina either. He used a less specific term, and there is nothing wrong with that.
 

QueBert

Lifer
Jan 6, 2002
22,987
1,180
126
Originally posted by: n yusef
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: QueBert
Originally posted by: n yusef
Many people don't like the the label "Hispanic" because they see it as Eurocentric. Slate explains:

Hispanic is an English word that originally referred to people from Spain and eventually expanded to include the populations of its colonies in South and Central America. Latino is a Spanish word?hence the feminine form Latina?that refers to people with roots in Latin America and generally excludes the Iberian Peninsula. For many, Hispanic has negative connotations because of its Eurocentrism. Others prefer it because it's gender-neutral. Latino, meanwhile, is perceived as a more authentic-sounding, Spanish-language alternative.

I'm disappointed, but not surprised, that it took so many posts to get a real answer.

OP, I would hardly call this forum "culturally diverse." And LOL @ "I DO think that women should be submissive to their husbands."

Wow, somebody on ATOT who knows what the fuck they're talking about. Most intelligent Mexican people will take offense at the term Hispanic. I don't think many would make a stink about it though, or even mention how you shouldn't call them Hispanic. Sort of like calling an Asian personal Oriental. I have had my asshole ripped in the past by 3 asian females because I referred to them as Oriental.

Someone should mention that to the Hispanic Language Institute that keeps sending me postcards offering to teach me English. :roll: Hispanic is the proper term to refer to a group of people that overlaps with but is not identical to latino. Educated Mexicans understand that.

I'm not saying that most Latinos do or should reject the label "Hispanic." Rather, there are legitimate reasons to not identify as "Hispanic" (and legitimate reasons to not identify as "Latino"); we should respect people's self-identification.

Mexicans are Mexican, Puerto Ricans are Puetro Ricans. Hispanic is a very generic and broad term. And the majority of Latino/Latina people I know take great pride in their heritage. To a lot of Mexicans, calling them Hispanic would be smiliar to calling a Puerto Rican Cuban or Dominican. A lot have told me "my Ancestors were Aztec" (or Mayan etc)
 

GrumpyMan

Diamond Member
May 14, 2001
5,780
266
136
I'm Argentinian and if anyone calls an Argentine a Mexican, you've got a fight on your hands. And vice versa I'm sure. Hispanic for Spain. Latino for everyone north of Argentina and south of Texas.
 

hanoverphist

Diamond Member
Dec 7, 2006
9,867
23
76
Originally posted by: GrumpyMan
I'm Argentinian and if anyone calls an Argentine a Mexican, you've got a fight on your hands. And vice versa I'm sure. Hispanic for Spain. Latino for everyone north of Argentina and south of Texas.

so you look very similar in physical features, can easily be mislabeled by the majority of the world, yet you would start a fight because someone mistook you for a different country's people? thats a bit on the derrr side to me... get over it, tell them you are argentinian (a latin american country, btw) and move on with your day. pride in roots is one thing, but taking it to the extreme of fighting over it is just asinine.
 

QueBert

Lifer
Jan 6, 2002
22,987
1,180
126
Originally posted by: hanoverphist
Originally posted by: GrumpyMan
I'm Argentinian and if anyone calls an Argentine a Mexican, you've got a fight on your hands. And vice versa I'm sure. Hispanic for Spain. Latino for everyone north of Argentina and south of Texas.

so you look very similar in physical features, can easily be mislabeled by the majority of the world, yet you would start a fight because someone mistook you for a different country's people? thats a bit on the derrr side to me... get over it, tell them you are argentinian (a latin american country, btw) and move on with your day. pride in roots is one thing, but taking it to the extreme of fighting over it is just asinine.

No different than calling a Korean Chinese, or a Japanese Korean. I've done it before and had them absolutely blow up over it. They claim they look nothing alike and I'm ignorant as shit for not being able to tell them apart. But I don't see enough of them enough to be able notice the differences.

Go to a Scottish Pride Festival and call one of them Irish. I bet it'll lead to a fight, even if it's just verbal. And if you ever call an Irishman Scottish, you can expect to come to fisticuffs. lol