America the greatest nation?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Excelsior

Lifer
May 30, 2002
19,047
18
81
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Excelsior
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Excelsior

Let me ask you one thing...

Would you trade your life in San Diego for a life in any of those cities?

I've never been to any of those cities but if I had an opportunity to go live and work in Sweden or Finland yeah, I'd probably do it. Just the experience alone would be worthwhile.

Permanently?

Sure, why not?

I was just asking.
 

Excelsior

Lifer
May 30, 2002
19,047
18
81
Originally posted by: MixMasterTang

America does have its? problems, but it has a ton of positives as well.
Nobody can name a country that is "the best" because it is a subjective opinion. What's the best for you may not be the best for me.

I think most people base their opinion of America being the best is because of our Constitutional rights and all of the freedoms we have. Some people don't care about these and some do, but I think that is a big factor in a lot of people's opinions.

But I think thats just it. People are using "greatest" and "best" interchangeably...and in this situation I wouldn't.

Obviously no country is perfect, for a perfect country would be impossible to achieve. But few can argue that the US is the most influential nation in the world, therefore it is the greatest. No, not "best"..but objectively the greatest. How influential a nation can be isn't subjective.
 

soonerproud

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2007
1,874
0
0
Originally posted by: foghorn67
Originally posted by: soonerproud
We also need to be aware we have lost a lot of those freedoms to more Federal encroachment. There are some countries that are actually surpassing us in some areas of our freedoms. The Patriot act is an example of trading our liberties and freedoms in the name of security. We need to be careful that we do not trade our liberties in any area for the promise of security. It is our liberties that make us great and not our Government.

ummm, have you seen some of the civil liberties at threat in other western nations?

If you are talking about the UK, it was not them I was basing this on. The UK is far worse than we are on Government encroachment. But if you look at countries like Norway, Sweden or even Canada (In some areas) there is a lot less restrictions on individual freedoms and more restrictions on the police and the government. In Canada, the police are not even allowed to harass it's citizens the way cops here in the US do.

None of these countries surpass us in all areas but in some ways they do.
 

Darwin333

Lifer
Dec 11, 2006
19,946
2,330
126
People considered to be living in "poverty" in the US live like kings compared to most of the people living in "poverty" on that list. Cable television is considered a necessity in the US, that should say something.
 

BurnItDwn

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
26,355
1,867
126
We may be #1 in electrcity overall, but if you look at it "per capita" you'll see per person, we are #8. Also, most of the world's population lives much closer to the equator than the average American. Thus, by default, there will be more energy usage just for the sake of heating.
Sure we are wasteful, but as a people, we are less wastefull then places like Qatar or Luxembourg ...

In other words .... the stats that you linked are generally made to look like the US is bad, however, when put into prospective, things aren't as bad as they are initially made out to be.
 

CptObvious

Platinum Member
Mar 5, 2004
2,501
7
81
Having been out of the U.S. for going on three months now, I think it's a good place to live, but perhaps not the best place. The great thing about America IMO is the cultural diversity in the big cities. I miss that aspect the most while living abroad. Things I don't miss are the overly censored and P.C. culture, the legal system in general and the self-entitlement many Americans display. Every day I read the U.S. news and the issues in some of the top stories seem stupid and trite (e.g., student being tasered at my alma mater, UF).
 

CPA

Elite Member
Nov 19, 2001
30,322
4
0
Originally posted by: soonerproud
Originally posted by: foghorn67
Originally posted by: soonerproud
We also need to be aware we have lost a lot of those freedoms to more Federal encroachment. There are some countries that are actually surpassing us in some areas of our freedoms. The Patriot act is an example of trading our liberties and freedoms in the name of security. We need to be careful that we do not trade our liberties in any area for the promise of security. It is our liberties that make us great and not our Government.

ummm, have you seen some of the civil liberties at threat in other western nations?

If you are talking about the UK, it was not them I was basing this on. The UK is far worse than we are on Government encroachment. But if you look at countries like Norway, Sweden or even Canada (In some areas) there is a lot less restrictions on individual freedoms and more restrictions on the police and the government. In Canada, the police are not even allowed to harass it's citizens the way cops here in the US do.

None of these countries surpass us in all areas but in some ways they do.

Canada harasses it's citizens with higher tax levels and stricter government control of business.
 

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
Originally posted by: CPA
Originally posted by: soonerproud
Originally posted by: foghorn67
Originally posted by: soonerproud
We also need to be aware we have lost a lot of those freedoms to more Federal encroachment. There are some countries that are actually surpassing us in some areas of our freedoms. The Patriot act is an example of trading our liberties and freedoms in the name of security. We need to be careful that we do not trade our liberties in any area for the promise of security. It is our liberties that make us great and not our Government.

ummm, have you seen some of the civil liberties at threat in other western nations?

If you are talking about the UK, it was not them I was basing this on. The UK is far worse than we are on Government encroachment. But if you look at countries like Norway, Sweden or even Canada (In some areas) there is a lot less restrictions on individual freedoms and more restrictions on the police and the government. In Canada, the police are not even allowed to harass it's citizens the way cops here in the US do.

None of these countries surpass us in all areas but in some ways they do.

Canada harasses it's citizens with higher tax levels and stricter government control of business.

and strict control of healthcare.
 

meltdown75

Lifer
Nov 17, 2004
37,548
7
81
I don't feel harassed. *shrug*

Canada and the US are both great to live in. I live near the border and let me assure you that it truly is the best of both worlds. :heart:

Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...
 

ahurtt

Diamond Member
Feb 1, 2001
4,283
0
0
Originally posted by: nkgreen
What does electricity consumption and military spending have to do with being great? I guess having more hot water heaters and having the best military in the world is a bad thing. :roll:

America! Only country in the world where we heat up our hot water!
Now if you'll excuse me I need to go put some toast in the toaster.
 

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...

That's the way it works. Word gets out that that X city will provide abundant social services (whether true or not) and the illegals and others flock to it to take advantage. There was a town in the northeast (name escapes me) that had a similar problem with Somalis. Word was passed around the Somali community of this town's generous social services and the over ran the town.
 

meltdown75

Lifer
Nov 17, 2004
37,548
7
81
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...

That's the way it works. Word gets out that that X city will provide abundant social services (whether true or not) and the illegals and others flock to it to take advantage. There was a town in the northeast (name escapes me) that had a similar problem with Somalis. Word was passed around the Somali community of this town's generous social services and the over ran the town.
Right. Everyone's looking for their own piece of freedom or dreams or whatever... and you can't really blame them for seeking it out... I guess it is just strange how they are claiming refugee status because of the illegal immigrant crackdown... they are being forced out of the US, but "refugee" just sounds weird when you think about it. Who knows how long they have been in the US. Would they even be able to go back to Mexico, ie. would the Mexican government just be like, "hey... welcome back... sorry you got booted out of the promised land... now here's a burrito..."
 

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...

That's the way it works. Word gets out that that X city will provide abundant social services (whether true or not) and the illegals and others flock to it to take advantage. There was a town in the northeast (name escapes me) that had a similar problem with Somalis. Word was passed around the Somali community of this town's generous social services and the over ran the town.
Right. Everyone's looking for their own piece of freedom or dreams or whatever... and you can't really blame them for seeking it out... I guess it is just strange how they are claiming refugee status because of the illegal immigrant crackdown... they are being forced out of the US, but "refugee" just sounds weird when you think about it. Who knows how long they have been in the US. Would they even be able to go back to Mexico, ie. would the Mexican government just be like, "hey... welcome back... sorry you got booted out of the promised land... now here's a burrito..."

Yeah, that's what cracked me up about the story. These Mexicans made their way up from southwest FL (panhandle I assume). Wouldn't it have just been easier to go back to Mexico?
 

meltdown75

Lifer
Nov 17, 2004
37,548
7
81
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...

That's the way it works. Word gets out that that X city will provide abundant social services (whether true or not) and the illegals and others flock to it to take advantage. There was a town in the northeast (name escapes me) that had a similar problem with Somalis. Word was passed around the Somali community of this town's generous social services and the over ran the town.
Right. Everyone's looking for their own piece of freedom or dreams or whatever... and you can't really blame them for seeking it out... I guess it is just strange how they are claiming refugee status because of the illegal immigrant crackdown... they are being forced out of the US, but "refugee" just sounds weird when you think about it. Who knows how long they have been in the US. Would they even be able to go back to Mexico, ie. would the Mexican government just be like, "hey... welcome back... sorry you got booted out of the promised land... now here's a burrito..."

Yeah, that's what cracked me up about the story. These Mexicans made their way up from southwest FL (panhandle I assume). Wouldn't it have just been easier to go back to Mexico?
ROFL... trekking across the entire Eastern US to claim refugee status in Canada :laugh:
 

soonerproud

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2007
1,874
0
0
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...

That's the way it works. Word gets out that that X city will provide abundant social services (whether true or not) and the illegals and others flock to it to take advantage. There was a town in the northeast (name escapes me) that had a similar problem with Somalis. Word was passed around the Somali community of this town's generous social services and the over ran the town.

Which is why social services should be restricted to only citizens or legal immigrants. Even Mexico will not allow non-Mexicans to attend school, free access to healthcare and property rights.
 

soonerproud

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2007
1,874
0
0
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Originally posted by: Queasy
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Now if we could only do something about all these Mexicans coming to Windsor claiming refugee status...

That's the way it works. Word gets out that that X city will provide abundant social services (whether true or not) and the illegals and others flock to it to take advantage. There was a town in the northeast (name escapes me) that had a similar problem with Somalis. Word was passed around the Somali community of this town's generous social services and the over ran the town.
Right. Everyone's looking for their own piece of freedom or dreams or whatever... and you can't really blame them for seeking it out... I guess it is just strange how they are claiming refugee status because of the illegal immigrant crackdown... they are being forced out of the US, but "refugee" just sounds weird when you think about it. Who knows how long they have been in the US. Would they even be able to go back to Mexico, ie. would the Mexican government just be like, "hey... welcome back... sorry you got booted out of the promised land... now here's a burrito..."

Yeah, that's what cracked me up about the story. These Mexicans made their way up from southwest FL (panhandle I assume). Wouldn't it have just been easier to go back to Mexico?

Why go back to extreme poverty and corruption when you get handed to you the riches of the US or Canada?
 

meltdown75

Lifer
Nov 17, 2004
37,548
7
81
This city apparently gets reimbursed 80% of the housing and food costs for the refugee families here... but there are thousands more (allegedly) on the way and it is uncertain how long they will be here.

I think there's room somewhere on the west end for a Mexican town :p
 

m1ldslide1

Platinum Member
Feb 20, 2006
2,321
0
0
*in manliest voice possible with hint of redneck accent:*

If you don't like it, then get out
 

glutenberg

Golden Member
Sep 2, 2004
1,941
0
0
Originally posted by: CPA
Originally posted by: Casawi
I am not an American and : Why not if you can get away with it. However I do think there need to be some adjustments, the U.S is gambling too much and makes it vulnerable to ...
It can turnout good, if they manage to control the oil business and keep it in US $... but this route will most likely cost a lot of lives and can lead to a bigger WAR.

This is why America is the greatest. People from other countries are so worried about what we do that they feel inclined to overlook their own country's problems to tell us how to fix our own.

You know you are on top when everyone else takes swipes at you.

By your logic, Iraq must be the greatest country of all time since the US felt the need to swoop in there and fix their problems. ;)
 

AMCRambler

Diamond Member
Jan 23, 2001
7,715
31
91
What are you nuts? Half those reasons you listed are why we are the greatest nation on earth!

Poverty? Look at all the countries above us on that list you link? Holy smokes! The US is nearly at the bottom. ????

#38 in life expectancy? Because we're all dying of heart disease and cancer because of the rich foods we can afford and all the tobacco we smoke, chew, snort whatever!

Debt, well you've got us there. The people of the US have a big problem spending more money than they have. But why the hell do the foreign investors keep giving us this massive line of credit? They must eventually think they will get they're money back.

Highest electricity consumption? Haha, since when is electricity consumption a bad thing? We are a highly technological nation. Massive server farms, huge oil refineries, massive industrial corporations. They all use electricity. It's just another indicator of the wealth of our nation. Electric services to houses in the US have grown over the years too now that things that were once luxuries are now affordable everyday appliances. Air coniditioning being one of the biggest of these.

#1 in oil consumption? We've got the money to afford big old SUV's and Cadillacs so that's what we drive. Fuel efficiency has meant nothing to this nation until recently as gas was so affordable we didn't care how inefficient our vehicles were. Europe has been paying high gas prices for a long time now. Just another indicator of the wealth of our country.

#1 in millitary spending? Exactly! No one screws with the US because we've got the most technologically advanced millitary on the face of the planet. Yeah you're going to say well terrorists have been taking shots at us. They're the only ones who can with a reasonable hope of survival(well not the suicide bombers) and we're rapidly learning how to fight them better. You will never see another war like WWI or WWII because of our millitary. Their's always nuclear annihilation I guess, but what would be the point? Everybody would go down with us!

#1 in CO2 emissions? Because we're all so damn stinking rich we can afford big honking V8 luxury cars that have no fuel efficiency.

I could go on. But really, all these number you point to do not indicate that we're not the greatest, they indicate we are one of the wealthiest. Now if by great you mean ethical, well then you may have a point. Last time I checked though, money is power, not ethics. The countries with the biggest check books and the most powerful millitaries have been the ones to write the history books.
 

Mikey

Senior member
Jun 16, 2006
996
1
0
This is definitely a great country, but far from perfect. Like everyone and everything, improvements can always be made. I don't always agree with our government, but that's just because the government isn't always doing what's best for this nation. I think what makes those the most American are those who critique this government and criticize on its failures. Why? Because it's more important to fix the failures than to promote the good that's been done.
 

Xylitol

Diamond Member
Aug 28, 2005
6,617
0
76
That IQ thing is retarded. Everyone takes a different test depending on their country. I took an IQ test and got like a 130.
The point is that the US has had the most number of USEFUL inventions by American inventors, the US has had the most important
geniuses, the US has the highest GDP by almost 2x 2nd place (Japan). Heck, California would be in the G8 if it was its own country.

There might be lots of poverty, but you can still achieve the American Dream (especially in Las Vegas - lots of open jobs, low mortgages, good school system, etc.)
You just have to try hard to become happy

IT'S ALL THE CHOICES THAT AMERICANS MAKE THAT CAUSE THEIR UNHAPPINESS
38th lowest life expectancy - Many Americans become fat and fugly by eating badly which leads to a crap load of medical problems that nothing but diet and exercise can stop after a certain point (The ones that DO eat and exercise are usually happier with themselves)

Highest Debt - USA because of poor choices made by Mr. President

Highest Electricity Consumption - So what? It's part of the American Dream.

Oil Consumption - Because we like to live the American Dream by having nice and fast cars unlike Europeans who have to worry about space / traffic. Thus, they wouldn't find a good purpose for having a sports car if they could have a SMARTCAR. (I personally believe that Americans should start using less gas-guzzlers but that's just me)

Highest Military Spending - Who cares? We're in a war. We have to have troops stationed all over the world (ie: South Korea, Japan, etc.)

Highest in CO2 Emissions - Idiot - It might be the current situation but China is increasing at a HIGH POSITIVE rate while the US is actually going at a LOW NEGATIVE rate. At least we're doing something about it. Also, what need did China have of any CO2 emitting things until recently? We are LIVING THE AMERICAN DREAM

13th in Beer Consumption - Ever notice that the top 12 are almost all from European nations or close descendants of them? (ie: Australia ----> UK)