about to start watching LOST

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

techs

Lifer
Sep 26, 2000
28,559
4
0
I'll give you a hint about this show:

it isn't about the island and all the crazy shit.
it's about people. there is a reason the show is first and foremost a drama. the crazy is just to add a plot.
when you watch the show for the people, everything changes. It becomes one of the finest television shows to ever been created, because the characters are so damn detailed. There's a lot more to the show than "crazy shit happens!", anyone who actually cares can see the characters are written with philosophy, psychology, religion, and all the social theories in-between serving as what drives them.

It's why I loved the recent Battlestar Galactica series. Politics and social behavior are the driving thoughts behind the characters.

You can of course ignore all that and just enjoy what is happening on the show, but it's very hard to ignore, or even be ignorant, of such concepts on Lost when half the characters are named after very important theorists and most of those theories are drawn upon for behavior quite often. The writers are nearly genius for that alone.
Then again, I am insanely interested in social and individual behavior theories, so this show gets to entertain me on multiple fronts. :)


Eh. What can you say to people?
Remember, these are the people who watch American Idol in record numbers.
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,783
6,341
126
When this Season ends, there's gonna be a hole in my life right next to SG1 and SG Atlantis. Better be some show in the Fall to replace its' awesomeness.
 

techs

Lifer
Sep 26, 2000
28,559
4
0
When this Season ends, there's gonna be a hole in my life right next to SG1 and SG Atlantis. Better be some show in the Fall to replace its' awesomeness.

The Ben and Hurley Show. On the CW at 8pm starting this fall.
Special guest star, Smokie!
 

MJinZ

Diamond Member
Nov 4, 2009
8,192
0
0
I'll give you a hint about this show:

it isn't about the island and all the crazy shit.
it's about people. there is a reason the show is first and foremost a drama. the crazy is just to add a plot.
when you watch the show for the people, everything changes. It becomes one of the finest television shows to ever been created, because the characters are so damn detailed. There's a lot more to the show than "crazy shit happens!", anyone who actually cares can see the characters are written with philosophy, psychology, religion, and all the social theories in-between serving as what drives them.

It's why I loved the recent Battlestar Galactica series. Politics and social behavior are the driving thoughts behind the characters.

You can of course ignore all that and just enjoy what is happening on the show, but it's very hard to ignore, or even be ignorant, of such concepts on Lost when half the characters are named after very important theorists and most of those theories are drawn upon for behavior quite often. The writers are nearly genius for that alone.
Then again, I am insanely interested in social and individual behavior theories, so this show gets to entertain me on multiple fronts. :)

Then there's the ironic names like:

John Locke
Jack Shephard
Tom Friendly
Rousseaus
 

cronos

Diamond Member
Nov 7, 2001
9,380
26
101
I'll give you a hint about this show:

it isn't about the island and all the crazy shit.
it's about people. there is a reason the show is first and foremost a drama. the crazy is just to add a plot.
when you watch the show for the people, everything changes. It becomes one of the finest television shows to ever been created, because the characters are so damn detailed. There's a lot more to the show than "crazy shit happens!", anyone who actually cares can see the characters are written with philosophy, psychology, religion, and all the social theories in-between serving as what drives them.

It's why I loved the recent Battlestar Galactica series. Politics and social behavior are the driving thoughts behind the characters.

You can of course ignore all that and just enjoy what is happening on the show, but it's very hard to ignore, or even be ignorant, of such concepts on Lost when half the characters are named after very important theorists and most of those theories are drawn upon for behavior quite often. The writers are nearly genius for that alone.
Then again, I am insanely interested in social and individual behavior theories, so this show gets to entertain me on multiple fronts. :)

This is exactly how I feel.
 

dainthomas

Lifer
Dec 7, 2004
14,930
3,909
136
did I miss something? What's "ironic" about their names?

1. Tom Friendly wasn't.
2. John Locke advocated the separation of church and state, and that human nature was governed by logic. Our Locke thinks faith rules all.
3. Rousseau believed that man in his natural state was moral and good. Our Rousseau was a nutcase who ran around trapping and killing people.

Not sure about Shephard.
 

destrekor

Lifer
Nov 18, 2005
28,799
359
126
1. Tom Friendly wasn't.
2. John Locke advocated the separation of church and state, and that human nature was governed by logic. Our Locke thinks faith rules all.
3. Rousseau believed that man in his natural state was moral and good. Our Rousseau was a nutcase who ran around trapping and killing people.

Not sure about Shephard.

Ah that's what I figured was being hinted at, but wasn't sure.

A lot of the individual names and the theories attached to the names aren't directly shown by those people, rather... it seems the theories are serving as discussion points. Also, some of the conceptual ideas of the real namesakes are pointed to as a focus, however not necessarily by any particular person.

Shephard, on the island, seems to live up to the ideas of John Locke.
But most interesting, in season 6's side-jumps, you see a version of John Locke that really seems to showcase the logic side of life.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
I don't need no stinkin' spoiler tags:

Locke discovers the fountain of youth. Jack decides to become a woman, since he cries so much anyway. Vincent begins to talk and calls Shannon a whore. Kate reveals she came back to island for lesbian sex with Claire. Bernard realizes Rose is black. Hurley admits that he ate most of the people who disappeard on the island. Sawyer admits he never wears a shirt because they "chafe'. Ben admits he is evil because no one really likes him.

hold on hold on hold on... Shannon's back? What a hot piece of ass.
 

shadow9d9

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2004
8,132
2
0
I'll give you a hint about this show:

it isn't about the island and all the crazy shit.
it's about people. there is a reason the show is first and foremost a drama. the crazy is just to add a plot.
when you watch the show for the people, everything changes. It becomes one of the finest television shows to ever been created, because the characters are so damn detailed. There's a lot more to the show than "crazy shit happens!", anyone who actually cares can see the characters are written with philosophy, psychology, religion, and all the social theories in-between serving as what drives them.

It's why I loved the recent Battlestar Galactica series. Politics and social behavior are the driving thoughts behind the characters.

You can of course ignore all that and just enjoy what is happening on the show, but it's very hard to ignore, or even be ignorant, of such concepts on Lost when half the characters are named after very important theorists and most of those theories are drawn upon for behavior quite often. The writers are nearly genius for that alone.
Then again, I am insanely interested in social and individual behavior theories, so this show gets to entertain me on multiple fronts. :)

The problem is that the characters have not been consistent, with jack being the biggest wishy washy character. The characters do not stay true. They are abused at the whim of the ridiculously poor plot.

BSG was the 2nd best show of the last 2 decades.
 

techs

Lifer
Sep 26, 2000
28,559
4
0
I don't need no stinkin' spoiler tags:

Locke discovers the fountain of youth. Jack decides to become a woman, since he cries so much anyway. Vincent begins to talk and calls Shannon a whore. Kate reveals she came back to island for lesbian sex with Claire. Bernard realizes Rose is black. Hurley admits that he ate most of the people who disappeard on the island. Sawyer admits he never wears a shirt because they "chafe'. Ben admits he is evil because no one really likes him.

hold on hold on hold on... Shannon's back? What a hot piece of ass.

Nah, she's a real "movie star" now. Too good to show up on a lowly tv show.
Though I hear Boone will appear some more.
Also, Libby is supposed to make an appearence. Hopefully, they will clear up the Libby mysteries since they were real wtf moments, then they just killed her off.
 

MJinZ

Diamond Member
Nov 4, 2009
8,192
0
0
1. Tom Friendly wasn't.
2. John Locke advocated the separation of church and state, and that human nature was governed by logic. Our Locke thinks faith rules all.
3. Rousseau believed that man in his natural state was moral and good. Our Rousseau was a nutcase who ran around trapping and killing people.

Not sure about Shephard.

Shephard (sheep herder) is supposed to be a leader but he sucked so much ass at leading it was comical.
 

joesmoke

Diamond Member
Nov 2, 2007
5,420
2
0
Did I miss the part where they explained what made Walt so special to The Others?
 
Nov 7, 2000
16,403
3
81
thats the best way to watch any TV show. first season will hook you, your faith will be tested in season 2 and 3, then hopefully it all is worth it. good luck avoiding series spoilers by the end of this season tho..
 

pontifex

Lifer
Dec 5, 2000
43,804
46
91
The show has extremely poor writing and it goes plotless from season 3+. They pretty much spend half of each episode walking through forests after that. They take a thin plot and extend it within an inch of its life.

They follow a formula post season 3 of big reveal that turns into nothing... try to waste time through the episode, give another big reveal cliffhanger. The show has absolutely no direction.

People just really don't know what a good show is anymore.. the fact that people think Lost is quality is unbelievable.

what is a good show then?
 

Miramonti

Lifer
Aug 26, 2000
28,653
100
106
I'll give you a hint about this show:

it isn't about the island and all the crazy shit.
it's about people. there is a reason the show is first and foremost a drama. the crazy is just to add a plot.
when you watch the show for the people, everything changes. It becomes one of the finest television shows to ever been created, because the characters are so damn detailed. There's a lot more to the show than "crazy shit happens!", anyone who actually cares can see the characters are written with philosophy, psychology, religion, and all the social theories in-between serving as what drives them.

It's why I loved the recent Battlestar Galactica series. Politics and social behavior are the driving thoughts behind the characters.

You can of course ignore all that and just enjoy what is happening on the show, but it's very hard to ignore, or even be ignorant, of such concepts on Lost when half the characters are named after very important theorists and most of those theories are drawn upon for behavior quite often. The writers are nearly genius for that alone.
Then again, I am insanely interested in social and individual behavior theories, so this show gets to entertain me on multiple fronts. :)

It was about the people.

Then they
moved the island
. Literally. WTF was that? Then they
skipped to the future and back to the past
etc.,....WTF was that?

They explained the
time travel
but imo left the
island relocation
to be the elephant in the room and walked away without due explanation and attention/curiosity. And now,
Loche isn't Loche, its just his bodily appearance
. WTF. Throw in the fact that
haughty Juliette
fell for
redneck Sawyer
...this probably lost me more than anything, LOL.

And now it is a bunch of crazy unpredictable sci-fi sh!t. Its a mere riddle now, and the show is about tickling viewers with clues while trying to get them to figure out what exactly the big picture is every week.

Its not a bust and I'm still curious, but I'm far from the pins and needles after each episode that I once had. I had an affinity for some of the characters but at this point really couldn't give a crap who dies and who lives (except maybe
hugo
...the
guy
needs to live. :p)
 
Last edited:

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
^ the above is pretty much why I lost interest. It seemed like they're just dragging it on even though they said what... 7 seasons and done like they've got a master plan from the beginning... they didn't need all this time.

One more thing... i heard they explained the significance of the numbers? What was it?
 
Last edited: