While the fat PS3s have been quite durable, PS2s were absolute garbage, comparable to the 360. Maybe the Slims will be like their heavier brother, but the memory of the PS2 is still rather fresh in my mind and may give me pause to get rid of a rather proven platform for one that may or may not be flaky. Honestly, if it was Nintendo I would completely agree with you, neither Sony nor MS have a track record that screams to me to trust a new design they offer by default(rather unfortunately, this is the reason I don't have a BC PS3 now, I wasn't going to buy into what I saw as a likely unreliable platform at $500).