• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Discussion Your pure honey test?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Honey is merely highly concentrated sugar with some hydrogen peroxide and gluconic acid.

Approximately 82 grams of sugars are contained in 3.5oz of honey. A smattering of B vitamins and vitamin C are also present.

In these times, supply of energy is readily available, too easily available, in fact.
 
I don't know why I haven't been getting updates to this thread.

Anyway, here in UAE, they sell "fresh milk tea" as a lot of people don't like the taste of dairy creamer.

So I ask this cafeteria guy to give me some fresh milk tea with honey instead of sugar.

He's like, "It will ruin the fresh milk and the taste. You won't like it at all."

I insisted. So he made it for me.

Doesn't taste bad at all. Still not sure why he was trying to dissuade me.
 
kaynutrition.com

Honey vs. Sugar: Which is Healthier?

When it comes to honey vs. sugar, is one healthier for you? Here is everything you need to know in the great honey vs. sugar debate.
kaynutrition.com kaynutrition.com

Gram for gram, honey is just plain better.

As always, excess of anything can lead to problems.

Fascinating study showing the protective effects of honey against cytotoxicity and aiding the liver in combating toxins: https://www.scirp.org/pdf/abb_2014022011164230.pdf

Sugar and Honey are not the same thing, most honorable @sdifox

Let us agree on that and bring the discussion to a close. This is not a win/lose competition. I just want everyone to realize that moderate honey consumption is beneficial for the human body and its health.
 
You believe whatever you want to believe. When something is 80-85% sugar, it is basically sugar.

1000008766.png


You see that? In 100g of honey there are 82g of carbohydrates. Out of those 82g, 0.2g is dietary fiber. Rest is sugar.

I can't believe you cannot read that...
 
Last edited:
There are trace ingredients in natural honey that might prove beneficial.
They are also in such small amounts that any major benefit is unlikely to be experienced.
igor_kavinski said:
kaynutrition.com

Honey vs. Sugar: Which is Healthier?

When it comes to honey vs. sugar, is one healthier for you? Here is everything you need to know in the great honey vs. sugar debate.
kaynutrition.com kaynutrition.com

Gram for gram, honey is just plain better.

As always, excess of anything can lead to problems.

Fascinating study showing the protective effects of honey against cytotoxicity and aiding the liver in combating toxins: https://www.scirp.org/pdf/abb_2014022011164230.pdf

Sugar and Honey are not the same thing, most honorable @sdifox

Let us agree on that and bring the discussion to a close. This is not a win/lose competition. I just want everyone to realize that moderate honey consumption is beneficial for the human body and its health.
Click to expand...

The study you cite uses DOX on rats. That's a chemotherapy drug and they were applied to young healthy rats.

The study would thus be irrelevant for whatever relevant situation of "healing" honey has. If somebody already has cancer and is undergoing chemo, this study applies to rats and healthy rats being fed a poison. If it's to support healing other things, that's not relevant because those mechanisms were not bothered with in the study.

A young healthy organism is going to handle a sugar bomb much better than a diabetic or cancer patient, because in both situations, the increase in blood sugar is a bad effect. It causes damage and even cancer in diabetics. Cancer cells thrive off glucose and radioactive glucose is used to help detect cancer because they gobble resources much faster than normal cells.
 
sdifox said:
You see that? In 100g of honey there are 82g of carbohydrates. Out of those 82g, 0.2g is dietary fiber. Rest is sugar.

I can't believe you cannot read that...
Click to expand...

Check the sections on digestion of honey and glycemic index. Calling honey sugar is wrong coz the chemical structure is different and they are digested differently by the body. Sugar exacts more of a toll on the body before it can be utilized for energy.
 
sdifox said:
sure, ignore the fact that 80+ percent of honey is sugar. Let's look at other things...
Click to expand...

And most of the remainder is just water.

Honey only has trace elements. You'd get more phenolic compounds from a cup of black tea, with none of the sugar.

The studies all seem to be from the middle east, likely in support of local honey production...

Eating 70g of Honey, may be slightly better than 70g of table sugar, but even better would be having none of either and black cup of tea/coffee.

I drink all my tea/coffee black without creamers/sweetener. The only sweetener I use is "Black Strap Molasses", but I use that rarely ( like once/month I might add a teaspoon to my oatmeal).

Blackstrap molasses has actual functional amounts of some vitamins/minerals, not just trace amounts, and it's higher in antioxidants as well.

nationalviews.com

Know Why Blackstrap Molasses Is Far Superior then Honey!

Blackstrap molasses vs Honey: Know about black strap molasses. Also, check the nutritional comparison between blackstrap molasses & honey
nationalviews.com nationalviews.com

Clipboard01.png

But I still stress, that I would not Add any sweetener for nutrition purposes. It's best to reduce sweetener usage.
 
igor_kavinski said:

Check the sections on digestion of honey and glycemic index. Calling honey sugar is wrong coz the chemical structure is different and they are digested differently by the body. Sugar exacts more of a toll on the body before it can be utilized for energy.
Click to expand...
I'm sure cereal with its added powdered multivitamin supplement(because that's what they literally do, even down to pure iron flakes) is going to produce better numbers than drinking Coca-cola or pure sugar water(you will become deficient in everything but energy if you do a Coke diet while cereal will at least get you by for your first 20-30 years). Vitamins do matter but that's all these studies prove about honey. That organisms need more than just energy sources to function well.
 
Last edited:
Time to pick the scab of this one.

My pure honey test is buying from a local producer that everyone around here knows. The honey isn't blended, so it varies in color and flavor throughout the year.
I love the stuff, as long as I don't think about it as bee puss. Just thinking that makes my skin crawl.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top