You Get Pulled Over for Speeding... What are the best answers for the following questions?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

CZroe

Lifer
Jun 24, 2001
24,195
857
126
Originally posted by: waggy
Originally posted by: oldsmoboat
Originally posted by: LeadMagnet
Diarrhea!!!

They've never heard that one before.

i had it work for me though at 16-17. got hit with a 42 in a 35. cop came up and asked whats the rush. i told him.

he didnt beleive me until err a stinky amount excaped..the smell and sound was enought to have him tell me to go LOL

I'm not sure it counts when you were barely over the 5MPG grace period (yes, some states have *enforced* grace periods for city and county police to break up potentially corrupt citation-trap districts). Hell, my motorcycle has a speedometer error greater than that at higher speeds.
 

LeadMagnet

Platinum Member
Mar 26, 2003
2,348
0
0
I just jump out of the car swearing at the officer, erratically waving my arms, and approach him in a threatening manner.
 

Capt Caveman

Lifer
Jan 30, 2005
34,543
651
126
As the cop is walking up to my vehicle, I start blasting NWA's 'Fu*ck the Police' from my stereo.
 
T

Tim

True story from my life:

Cop: I've been waiting for you all day.
Me: I got here as fast as I could.

He let me go with a warning.
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: Perknose
Excuse me, Vic. Pull WHAT sort of thing? You JUST repeated your own woefully wrong statement, even after several of us have testified otherwise, and the only two cops presently on OT immediately gave my post thumbs up.

In fact, as SEVERAL of us have tried to tell you and two actual cops have seconded, being polite and respectful and honest CAN get you out of the consequences of breaking the law.

It has for me.

It has for Olds.

It has for Eli.

It has for Capt Caveman.

Our two working police officers said, and I quote:

Originally posted by: JLee
Originally posted by: MartyMcFly3
Exactly. :thumbsup:

:thumbsup:


You happen to be wrong on this one. It happens to the best of us.

Oh sure, it has for me too. Everyone has gotten off with a warning once or twice in their lives. That proves nothing. Get back to me when you've been nice and polite and confessed and still gotten the ticket. That's happened to me more than once. In fact, more often than not, I'd say, and I have a pretty clean driving record (only 1 ticket that's stuck in the past 8 years).

As for the resident police officers, they have ulterior motives. Nothing sinister, just making their jobs easier. Police cruisers have dash cams, and they know that people who confess to try to get out of a ticket don't try to fight in court later, even if they really were innocent. How can they?
 

Captante

Lifer
Oct 20, 2003
30,353
10,876
136
Originally posted by: Pliablemoose
It's usually always a verbal trap, I just fess up...


In addition the ONLY times I've been issued a warning (written or verbal) have been when I told the officer who pulled me over the truth ... once I even said "for driving like an asshole" & got let off.
 

2Xtreme21

Diamond Member
Jun 13, 2004
7,044
0
0
The only time I was pulled over so far was the very last day of the month at about 11pm. It was a Sunday night and I was coming back from my Grandfather's viewing... I had probably a 30 mile drive home and I could count the number of cars I saw on two hands. I'm trucking along at ~75 in a 65, and the second you cross into my county, the speed limit changes to 55. Sure enough, state trooper sitting next to the speed limit sign pulls out, lights on. I pull over, and before I even have a chance to say anything he goes "I clocked you going 78 in a 55, please give me your license and registration." I pull them out, he looks at it, writes the ticket in front of me, has me sign it, gets back in his car and backs up along the shoulder back to where he was sitting.

Anyone who says quotas don't exist is full of it.
 

rivan

Diamond Member
Jul 8, 2003
9,677
3
81
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: Perknose
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: oldsmoboat
I always admit I was speeding and blame it on inattention because of xxx.
I am polite and respectful. I get out of the ticket a vast majority of the time.

Whether or not you get out of a ticket depends mostly on the severity of the infraction, your driving record (which on the police computer includes previous unticketed stops), and the officer's 'quota.' Your politeness and respectfulness factor very little into it (although I recommend that everyone always be as polite and respectful as possible of course).

Politeness and respectfulness (and straightforward honesty) DO factor into this, Vic.

Cops get stupidly lied to and stupidly disrespected all the damn time, and truy appreciate someone who comes at them with neither, and can and do cut you a break based solely on how you respond.

I know. I've been told explicitly so by the officer who pulled me over. I have SEEN a cop's demeanor and approach completely change based on how I responded to him.

I'm not saying all those other factors don't pertain, just that you have no firm basis for saying how you approach the officer is a tiny factor. It isn't.

Please re-read my post again. You should know better IMO than to pull this kind of thing.

Being impolite and disrespectful will get you a ticket every time, but being polite and respectful will NOT get out you of a ticket in most cases, and Oldsmoboat was trying to say that it would.
If the infraction is relatively severe (like 20 or more over), if you have a bad driving record (or even just a history of multiple stops), or if the officer is under quota (and yes, they do exist), then it would extremely unlikely that you will be able to talk your way out of a ticket. And some police depts, especially state patrol, have a 'ticket every stop' policy, so it's not up to the officer's discretion at all.

IOW, always be polite and respectful to the police. They deserve it. But don't fool yourself into believing that just by being polite and respectful (and more importantly, openly confessing) will allow you to get out of the consequences of breaking the law.

I'd argue that if being polite, honest and respectful doesn't get you out of a ticket, it's a ticket you deserve and aren't going to get out of no matter what comes out of your mouth.
 

Axoliien

Senior member
Mar 6, 2002
342
0
0
It depends on the officer. Being nice to one officer may get you out of a ticket, but being nice to another may do absolutely nothing. Just be respectful, you'll probably get a ticket, and those who are speeding and deserve it then call the police "pigs" and "power hungry" will just get another one later while I drive on by.
 

Saint Nick

Lifer
Jan 21, 2005
17,722
6
81
I saw a video made by the ACLU that told you how to get out of a lot of stuff, essentially. It wasn't really a video about "how to get out of getting in trouble", but more like a "here are your rights and civil liberties" type of video.
 

ryan256

Platinum Member
Jul 22, 2005
2,514
0
71
One time I got pulled over. Cop gave me a ticket for going 59 in a 45. He was doing me a favor though because I was really going closer to 69.
 

NoCreativity

Golden Member
Feb 28, 2008
1,735
62
91
I have only gotten 1 ticket, 84 in a 65, though written up as 5 over (just being stupid kid). In the notes section of the ticket the officer wrote that I was very polite.

I've also been pulled over a few times (4 or 5 maybe) for random things where I deserved to get a ticket but didn't. Always polite and honest with the officer.

So being polite and honest doesn't get you out of a ticket, but I think it greatly increases your chances.
 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
167
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
Originally posted by: MartyMcFly3
I'm more likely to give someone a warning when they admit they did something wrong and apologize than when they pull the "Are you sure I was speeding? I didn't think I was going that fast. My speedometer says I was doing the speed limit" when I clock them at 20 mph over or "I know I stopped at that stop sign" when I saw them completely blow right through it.

Sometimes honesty gets you farther. I know, shocker.

I didn't reply with "are you sure I was speeding", I replied with "you're wrong" and proved my point at the side of the road (I was going about 62 with cruise control on in a 55; he "paced" me going much much faster. Newer officer, and I was as polite as possible. At first, he seemed to have the attitude that it wasn't possible that he made a mistake. He tried to convince me at first that it was possible my speedometer was off by that much because I had newer tires (fail.) But, after several minutes, I think I sufficiently explained to him how his version of how he "paced" me was physically impossible (it was.) Good thing I teach physics :p

But now, you have me worried that there's a record that I was even stopped for speeding. The stop was completely unjustified, unless they're stopping cars for going 62 in a 55 on this route, and afaik, no one has ever been stopped at that speed unless there was another reason.

Originally posted by: NoCreativity
I have only gotten 1 ticket, 84 in a 65, though written up as 5 over (just being stupid kid). In the notes section of the ticket the officer wrote that I was very polite.
I've only ever gotten one moving violation - decades ago, I accelerated in view of a 55mph zone sign just as a trooper came around a bend in front of me. As I almost always go 61 or 62 in a 55, road conditions permitting, I was still accelerating when I hit the 55mph zone. Unfortunately, he clocked me at 59 while I was still in the 45 (feet before the 55). As he was writing up the ticket, I asked him if he could make it 54 in a 45 so I wouldn't receive as many points on my license. He was nice and did so. In court, the judge looked at the ticket and said, "road reduction, I see." "Huh?" "A road reduction is when they write it for less than you were actually going. Otherwise, I'd never see a ticket for 9 over in this courtroom."

Oh wait, I had another ticket - failure to obey a traffic control device. The river had flooded and several roads were under water. I went around one of the barriers and drove as fast as I could over the flooded road in my old 4 wheel drive jeep cherokee. That was fun!! But "dangerous" in the eyes of the law enforcement who were hiding in the bushes on the other end of the flooded road. If it was so "dangerous", why did they allow me to drive down the road before pulling out of their hiding spot?? :p
 

Zenmervolt

Elite member
Oct 22, 2000
24,514
44
91
Originally posted by: AccruedExpenditure
You Get Pulled Over for Speeding... What are the best answers for the following questions?

A.) Do you know why I pulled you over?
B.) Do you know how fast you were going?

-AE

A.) No, Officer, I do not.
B.) I'm honestly not sure, I was just trying to match the speed of traffic. I will pay closer attention in the future.

ZV
 

secretanchitman

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2001
9,352
23
91
1. yes.
2. yes..give an approximation.

i always come clean (only had 1 ticket though) and the officer was sympathetic with me.
 

Kyteland

Diamond Member
Dec 30, 2002
5,747
1
81
Originally posted by: CZroe
I'm not sure it counts when you were barely over the 5MPG grace period (yes, some states have *enforced* grace periods for city and county police to break up potentially corrupt citation-trap districts). Hell, my motorcycle has a speedometer error greater than that at higher speeds.
That typo's getting to be more and more common these days.

:p
 

jjones

Lifer
Oct 9, 2001
15,424
2
0
In my experience, it doesn't matter what I've said. I either get a ticket or don't.

The only time I've ever not been given a ticket was when in response to those type of questions, I said:

"Well, my best guess is for speeding."

"Not really; I was just cruising along on my way home." (I was going about 105 mph or so when he pulled me - speed limit was 65 mph)

"Yes, I had a couple of beers, but that was several hours ago."

The cop just said keep the speed down and be careful. I was stunned that he let me go with just a mild warning. Every other time I've ever been pulled for speeding I've been ticketed.
 
Feb 19, 2001
20,155
23
81
Originally posted by: DrPizza
Originally posted by: MartyMcFly3
I'm more likely to give someone a warning when they admit they did something wrong and apologize than when they pull the "Are you sure I was speeding? I didn't think I was going that fast. My speedometer says I was doing the speed limit" when I clock them at 20 mph over or "I know I stopped at that stop sign" when I saw them completely blow right through it.

Sometimes honesty gets you farther. I know, shocker.

I didn't reply with "are you sure I was speeding", I replied with "you're wrong" and proved my point at the side of the road (I was going about 62 with cruise control on in a 55; he "paced" me going much much faster. Newer officer, and I was as polite as possible. At first, he seemed to have the attitude that it wasn't possible that he made a mistake. He tried to convince me at first that it was possible my speedometer was off by that much because I had newer tires (fail.) But, after several minutes, I think I sufficiently explained to him how his version of how he "paced" me was physically impossible (it was.) Good thing I teach physics :p

But now, you have me worried that there's a record that I was even stopped for speeding. The stop was completely unjustified, unless they're stopping cars for going 62 in a 55 on this route, and afaik, no one has ever been stopped at that speed unless there was another reason.

Originally posted by: NoCreativity
I have only gotten 1 ticket, 84 in a 65, though written up as 5 over (just being stupid kid). In the notes section of the ticket the officer wrote that I was very polite.
I've only ever gotten one moving violation - decades ago, I accelerated in view of a 55mph zone sign just as a trooper came around a bend in front of me. As I almost always go 61 or 62 in a 55, road conditions permitting, I was still accelerating when I hit the 55mph zone. Unfortunately, he clocked me at 59 while I was still in the 45 (feet before the 55). As he was writing up the ticket, I asked him if he could make it 54 in a 45 so I wouldn't receive as many points on my license. He was nice and did so. In court, the judge looked at the ticket and said, "road reduction, I see." "Huh?" "A road reduction is when they write it for less than you were actually going. Otherwise, I'd never see a ticket for 9 over in this courtroom."

Oh wait, I had another ticket - failure to obey a traffic control device. The river had flooded and several roads were under water. I went around one of the barriers and drove as fast as I could over the flooded road in my old 4 wheel drive jeep cherokee. That was fun!! But "dangerous" in the eyes of the law enforcement who were hiding in the bushes on the other end of the flooded road. If it was so "dangerous", why did they allow me to drive down the road before pulling out of their hiding spot?? :p

They wanted to see your car fail or some epic fail LiveLink-worthy material and then come to the rescue and when you think you just got saved you get slapped with a ticket. I guess that didn't happen so they could only do the ticket part =P