Um, no
Let me start with, have any better ideas?
I work with a treat pysch patients everyday. Inpatient pysch. Just last week we had one that tried to jump out the window. Also tried to attack a nurse with a large shard of glass. A week previously, I treated a patient who destroyed video equipment and ripped brackets off the walls.
I work with every SSRI, SNRi, antipyschotic, MOAI, lithium, H2 blockers, wellbutrin and others. IV/IM and oral. You know what sucks? Having a patient tell you they are going to string you up by the shoelaces because they are acutely psychotic. How about the nurse that got an orbital fracture after getting a fist to the face because the patient is high on meth. The patient then asks if they hurt the nurse enough.
I've been sexually harassed, threatened, and mocked and yet I go to work because I freaking love it!
I hate putting people in restraints. I hate having to "drug" people. I hate we are understaffed.
And yet, here I am saving your guys' butts day-in-and-day-out. I use the tools available to me and guess what? It's not a lot! At the present moment, we don't have a large amount of drugs for pysch issues. We revolutionized pysch medicine with SSRIs!
You are very welcome to come do what I do. I work 22 twelve hour days a month and see 15-20 patients a day.
Don't you dare minimize what I do especially after what we went through with covid. We went through hell.
Oh my cry me a river. I have A LOT of experience with inpatient psych (long term) and I'd try to jump out of the window too with the way facilities treat people. Hell just out of shear boredom. Where would a patient get a large shard of glass in a psych ward? It would literally mean no one was around for a long time.
And I agree, I recommend everyone get a chance to have a stay at a nearby psych ward. Walk through the halls, stay for a few hours. What's the only thing you wont find? An actual doctor.
The nurses and support staff in the trenches can be angels but please don't delude yourself into thinking seeing a patient for 15 minutes, telling them to think positive, and writing them some script is saving anyone.
Revolutionized psych medicine? I ask about new breakthrough treatments like ketamine and it's like deer in headlights. You can honestly learn so much more via the internet and watching simple youtube videos than trying to get answers from anyone in the healthcare industry. No one has the time.
I do agree that you are 'overworked' and there arent enough staff but that is literally the medical groups own fault with how they hire and how they choose to staff a facility.
Beyond that I also agree you are using the only tools you have available I guess, but it really amounts to adult daycares that babysit crazy people. And my original point is really that there actually ARE things being done for mental health, as much as we can do in certain respects.
It's easier to ban guns but then we'd see the real crazies come out of the woodwork. Do I have better ideas? Nope, that's why I said we are just going to have to accept this as our new normal. It isn't going to get better.
If guns were treated like a single pill that needs to be given to a patient in a hospital that would be a start. How many times does a pill get scanned as it moves from supplier to user? Tylenol is more regulated.
Anyways I could go on and on