YAGT: The "I Need Space" thread... *update 01/08*

Red

Diamond Member
Aug 22, 2002
3,704
0
0
Ok ok, this is not an attention whore thread... I honestly need some ideas/comments from those of you who have experience with long term relationships, please.

8 days ago, a Wedsneday, my fiancee and I went to a restaurant to eat. It was the first time we had seen each other in a couple days because I was working in the mornings, taking finals at night, and had some different organizational meetings in between. Needless to say, it was one of my busiest weeks of the year.
Anyway, so she basically tells me in the restaurant that she needs space. She said that it has nothing to do with me... she is not seeing anyone else, and doesn't plan on our relationship to end, she just needs some time and space away from me.

I called her that night before going to bed (like always) and she said that when she says she needs space, she doesn't want me to be calling her or asking her where she is because she just NEEDS SPACE. Anyway, that's been the common theme for the last 8 days. She normally calls me at night, normally around 11:00 or so, from home, and tells me good night. We had to go Christmas shopping together about 3 or 4 days ago to get our parents gifts, and she wouldn't let me hold her hand. We talked about it a couple days ago, and she told me she still needs space, but said I shouldn't worry about our relationship. She said the cause of the space is that she thinks we (she and I) have been taking life too seriously for 22 year olds. She said that she needs the space because she misses hanging out with her girlfriends as much as she used to, so she has been doing that the past couple of days. She said she needs the time to think things through and she wants to make sure that our relationship is what she wants for the rest of her life. She wants to decide now rather than 5 years from now when we're married and/or have kids.

I sent her this letter through e-mail a couple days ago: *removed*

And she hasn't replied yet... she only checks her e-mail about once a week though, so she probably hasn't read it yet. I'm worried she is trying to end our 3.5 year relationship and is waiting until Christmas is over... but I don't want to jinx myself, maybe she really just needs a break?

Update 12/24/04
So she called me last night around 8pm and said she was off work. She asked if I wanted to go out and get a bite to eat and spend the night at her house. I didn't want to be an ass right away and be like "Uhh, what about that space thing?" so I said that it sounded fun. Sooo, we went to eat. Only thing open was Penn Station! McDonalds, White Castle, this nice Mexican restaurant, etc, were all closed. So anyway, while we were eating, we talked some more.... and talked even more in the car on the way to her house. She explained in a little more detail why she NEEDS this space. She said that ever since she was a freshman in highschool she has been in relationships.... she's never been single since she was a young girl. So now that she is 22 and has been with me for 3.5 years, she wants some space to be herself.

She is adamant about us staying together.... I looked her straight in the eye and was like "Look... we're engaged... kind of. Taking space in a step back in the relationship. 3 weeks ago you said you wanted to hold off on the engagement until a year before we're married, and a week and a half ago you said you need space. I really feel like you're simple backing out of the relationship slowly and want to wait until after the holidays to break it off." She just smiled and said that she can understand while I feel that way but it is absolutely not the case. She just said she wants to be herself for a little while, while being committed to me.... IE, she doesn't want to have to call in check in with me, or her parents, or anyone, but doesn't want me to worry at the same time because she has no interest in anyone but me and wouldn't do anything to hurt me. She said she understands it will be hard, but she really feels this will work out and take us to the next level. She also said that "pressure" from her parents to get a second job, from me to do certain things, etc, is partly to blame for her wanting space. She just said that she feels that at 22 years old she shouldn't have as much pressure as she does and needs time away from everything to clear her mind.

Last night she was very affectionate while we slept... she held me, held my hand, rubbed my back and all that stuff, but we didn't mash genitalia. Fine with me, I was glad she explained everything. Still, she might just be telling me whatever she wants until she kicks me to curb after Christmas, but who knows? If we stay together, good, if not... good. I've always been the type to learn things the hard way (IE, experiencing them rather than taking advice) but I find that builds character maybe? Ah well, she wants me to come with her to her uncles Christmas Eve party tonight, we'll see how that goes.

Cliffs notes:
We've been together 3.5 years, been engaged for about 2 years. She needs space. Wouldn't let me hold her hand at the mall Christmas shopping for parents. No 'tang in 8 days, we are normally like rabbits. What's the worst case scenario / best case screnario / most probable scenario? I'd be really pissed if she is just delaying breaking up with me since it's Christmas time and she is waiting until after Christmas.

Update 01/8/05
Well, we spent the holidays together. We spent Christmas Eve together at one of her family get togethers and Christmas Day was spent partly at her parents home and my parents home. Last weekend we spent the entire week together... On News Years Eve (friday) we went with her family to horse races during the day. $1 draft beers, $1 horse bets. Megan and I drank about 6 or 7 eight oz cups over about a 4 hour period, so we had a decent buzz going the whole time. She asked me to kiss her, just out of the blue, and I did. She then said "sorry, I probably shouldn't have done that.." of course, I didn't mind. About an hour later she asked for another kiss and I said "Well, last time I kissed you, you said sorry...." and she said "You're right, we better not." After the horse races we went to her aunts house and drank some more. Played pool and darts until about 11:00pm. We drove down to her house after that and we watched the ball drop on TV. We weren't buzzing by that point, and when the ball dropped, we had a nice, sensual kiss. One that I hadn't had for about 2 and a half weeks. I spent the night and there was no affection. We spent all day Saturday together relaxing and hanging out, and I spent the night again. Once again, akwardly silent in the sack. AND, once again, we spent all day Sunday together, had a good time cooking dinner together and other stuff.

One thing I noticed that was odd is that she didn't want to go "out" anywhere. We went to the grocery store, but she declined my offers to go out and get a drink or go ice skating or whatever....

This week, from 1/1 to 1/8, it's been weird. We haven't talked much and we haven't seen each other yet this weekend, and it's Saturday night.

Quite the roller coaster. Last time we talked about, I asked her if she has changed her mind at ALL, either in favor of staying with me, or going her own way... since December 15th, and she said no, but that's because she really hasn't had space because of the holidays. So, we're still in the same boat that we were in Almost 30 days ago... she needs space and isn't sure if she wants to be with me. She goes to work, goes home, and talks to her friends a lot on her cell phone. But doesn't talk to me at all, really.
 
Oct 9, 1999
19,632
38
91
whatever happens, good luck.

sometimes you just miss having friends around, ive been there befor with my gf and so has she.
 

flamingelephant

Golden Member
Jun 22, 2001
1,182
0
76
A fiancee shouldn't be needing space.... you are planning to spend the rest of your lives together..... its a very bad sign. If she wants to spend more time with her friends then tell her she should, but that doesnt mean she should stop seeing you or hold your hand or stuff like that....... i'd do a quick check on your relationship-ejection-seat if things go downhill
 

maziwanka

Lifer
Jul 4, 2000
10,415
1
0
i can't believe this man. she's your fiancee and she acts like this? coupled with all the sh!t you had to put up with from before.....

i think ppl are fed up with your antics and how you constantly put yourself in these situations. you could have ended this a while back but you've prolonged it and you keep whining now and asking for advice. EVERYONE is going to tell you the same thing.

ill just say this: grow some fvcking balls.
 

GasX

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
29,033
6
81
You have been engaged for two years? Why aren't you married yet?

It sounds to me like she has some lingering doubts or something....
 

y2kc

Platinum Member
Sep 2, 2000
2,547
0
76
she's delaying breaking up with you until after christmas.

"space" is usually code for "i met a really hot guy when I was out drinking with my girlfriends and I want to hump him really badly but the confines of our relationship is a deterrant and i'd hate for you to catch me in flagrante delicto "
 

tallest1

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2001
3,474
0
0
Edit: hmm.... withholding judgement until I read second thread. I'm leaning towards her telling the truth but on Christmas!? hmmm.....
 

TheLonelyPhoenix

Diamond Member
Feb 15, 2004
5,594
1
0
Needing space or "time-off" is the kiss of death to every relationship.

I'm sorry that someone you've obviously been serious about for a long time has done this, but its clear that when she needs space, it means she's just backing out slowly.

Call her and say: "Either you give me a good reason why you don't want to be close to me and think you can put our relationship on a back burner, or I'm calling everything off now." Then its her choice from there. Don't let her jerk you around.
 

KK

Lifer
Jan 2, 2001
15,903
4
81
Yeah, definitely do not give her anything at christmas. Tell her she needs her space, thus that means you are using the money you would be spending on her, and using on yourself.
 

tallest1

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2001
3,474
0
0
Originally posted by: tallest1
Edit: hmm.... withholding judgement until I read second thread. I'm leaning towards her telling the truth but on Christmas!? hmmm.....


Okay, I think she WAS telling the truth but as time goes by you're giving her reason to break up with you. All she wants to do is hang out with her close female friends and you get angry at her in an argument AND write a non-masculine letter descibing her like a potentially failed science project AND then emailing her. Sounds like you're scaring her away man.
 

gscone

Senior member
Nov 24, 2004
489
0
71
DOnt want to sound like a hard ass, but IMHO and its just me, being engaged for a long time is a no no. Being too naive and soft to the significant other is also a no no.
You seem like a genuine person, but guard your front and expect anything to happen.

 

flamingelephant

Golden Member
Jun 22, 2001
1,182
0
76
Originally posted by: tallest1
Originally posted by: tallest1
Edit: hmm.... withholding judgement until I read second thread. I'm leaning towards her telling the truth but on Christmas!? hmmm.....


Okay, I think she WAS telling the truth but as time goes by you're giving her reason to break up with you. All she wants to do is hang out with her close female friends and you get angry at her in an argument AND write a non-masculine letter descibing her like a potentially failed science project AND then emailing her. Sounds like you're scaring her away man.

I love that.... potentially failed science project..... so true! that letter doesn't treat her very well, and you should in a letter like that, no matter your feelings.

btw. are their pics of her anywhere?
 

Pliablemoose

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
25,195
0
56
#1-you've been engaged too long, 1 year engagements are one of the predictors for a successful marriage
#2.-wasn't she recently drinking & banging some other guy?
#3-Please god, go to an AlAnon meeting.

CINCINNATI - Greater Cincinnati Info Serv (513-771-5959*) 2051 East Kemper Road, 45241
 

Tremulant

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2004
4,890
1
0
Originally posted by: TheLonelyPhoenix
Needing space or "time-off" is the kiss of death to every relationship.

I'm sorry that someone you've obviously been serious about for a long time has done this, but its clear that when she needs space, it means she's just backing out slowly.

Call her and say: "Either you give me a good reason why you don't want to be close to me and think you can put our relationship on a back burner, or I'm calling everything off now." Then its her choice from there. Don't let her jerk you around.

 

Red

Diamond Member
Aug 22, 2002
3,704
0
0
Originally posted by: Pliablemoose
#1-you've been engaged too long, 1 year engagements are one of the predictors for a successful marriage
#2.-wasn't she recently drinking & banging some other guy?
#3-Please god, go to an AlAnon meeting.

CINCINNATI - Greater Cincinnati Info Serv (513-771-5959*) 2051 East Kemper Road, 45241

#2 -- over summer she got drunk is south Texas and kissed a guy
#3 -- That thread was deleted because it was a parody. Mods deleted it when I posted about how I fooled people. This thread, however, is true.
 

sniperruff

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
11,644
2
0
she said she needs space, so don't email her, call her or see her for a while until she contacts you again.

she said everything is alright... are you guys engaged or not? don't you trust her? just give her some time away and you should enjoy some time on your own.
 
L

Lola

honestly, i know exactly where you are coming from.... my FI and i have been dating for 5 years and got engaged one year ago.

since our engagement, things were rough (more so than before) because i persoanlly was freaking out about getting married at a young age (we will be 22 & 23) and was worried that we were too young to and one or both of us would be resentful to the other after 5 years since we "wasted" the best years of our lives being married.

I did not realized i felt like that until we got into a fight. Things were brought out that were not talked about before. At one point, we thought it was ending, but deep down, we both really wanted to stay. It took a lot of opening up and talking to get things straightened out, but we did.

My point is... dont avoid something this large too long. you need to face it heads on.

Look at the worst case.... you break up. Will you be devistated, yeah, probably. Will that kill you? no. you will keep living. You know you will be able to get through it.

For someone to say they need space, usually is not a good thing. I am sure it probably doesnt have much to do with you. THis is how she feels. She is right... 22 is young. but its been done before many many times, successfully at that. Its also better that this is coming up right now than like you mentioned 5/10 years from now when you have kids, etc.

I am sorry this is happening to you, but talk to her about it and ask her what she thinks will happen if you do "give her space"... what will that solve? will it make it better/worse?
 

Double Trouble

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
9,270
103
106
Sorry to say it, but "need space" means "get away from me, I'm into someone else", or "you're too clingy, I'm just not into you". If you're going through these kinds of things before you're even married, your relationship is doomed.

Simple answer, just ignore her for a while. Don't call. Don't visit, don't acknowledge her existence. She'll either get the hint and leave, or she'll realize what she's losing and come to her senses.
 

Red

Diamond Member
Aug 22, 2002
3,704
0
0
Originally posted by: sniperruff
she said she needs space, so don't email her, call her or see her for a while until she contacts you again.

she said everything is alright... are you guys engaged or not? don't you trust her? just give her some time away and you should enjoy some time on your own.

You sound exactly like her... is that you Megan?

In all seriousness, she is telling me she just needs space, but it's very difficult when you spend so much time with your fiancee to all of a sudden cut communication. Especially with so much snow around here, I'm worried... wanna call, but then she'll get pissed that I'm not giving her space. Grr.
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
I guess Paco is back in town and she needs some latin lovin'

Tell her to go play hide and go fvck herself, then do her mom itb...


Seriously, though grow some cahones and dump the lyin cheatin ho