YAGT: Match day approaching, read her email

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

PingSpike

Lifer
Feb 25, 2004
21,758
603
126
Originally posted by: Drizzy
Originally posted by: PingSpike
You dumped a girl because she had a yeast infection? Maybe you should invest in a real doll.

I was 16, we were dating 2 months... there were plenty of other girls in HS - use your brain before you insult... of course I look book and see how stupid that was now... but in HS dating is for fun - not really a serious relationship (usually).

Its just a joke but...even in a non serious relationship, breaking up over a yeast infection that can be cured in like 7 days just seems...well you know.
 

Drizzy

Golden Member
Dec 12, 2003
1,229
0
0
Originally posted by: PingSpike
Originally posted by: Drizzy
Originally posted by: PingSpike
You dumped a girl because she had a yeast infection? Maybe you should invest in a real doll.

I was 16, we were dating 2 months... there were plenty of other girls in HS - use your brain before you insult... of course I look book and see how stupid that was now... but in HS dating is for fun - not really a serious relationship (usually).

Its just a joke but...even in a non serious relationship, breaking up over a yeast infection that can be cured in like 7 days just seems...well you know.

SHALLOW?! :) Yeah I know. Of course 10 years later I look at it and laugh but at the time it was like "gross!" and so there was other girls that werent "gross". And so now when I see how rude and cruel kids are I just have to remind myself that I wasnt mature enough until later in HS... so to give em a little slack.
 

Thegonagle

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2000
9,773
0
71
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
no
I don't know
I don't know, nor care. (Damn--that means I just wasted 25 seconds replying.)

EDIT: Sorry--I'm on spring break, I don't sleep nights, and I'm a little bit tipsy (yes, I'm well aware that it's 11:00 AM). You should ignore me. But I'd say it's wrong to go through all that e-mail--difficult not to finish once you start reading--but still wrong. If you find that you're not forgeting about it, and your comfort level is not returning to normal within a few weeks, you might need to spill your guts or it will kill the relationship. I think the key, though, is that your gut says she didn't cheat, and you should let that guide either your personal recovery from your own transgression, or let it guide your conversation with her about your transgression. (You see why I say I don't know whether you should tell her?) Well, good luck with this. Hope your dick doesn't fall off cuz she caught something cheating. J/K.
 

Dubb

Platinum Member
Mar 25, 2003
2,495
0
0
you're an ass and you don't deserve a female.

it's called privacy. respect it, ass.
 

Nitemare

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
35,461
4
81
Originally posted by: Doboji
I'm calming down.... and here's why.... I think we all have those remote "prospects" that we hold onto even deep into relationships... I have one or two myself.... but does that disrupt how deeply I feel for my GF?... no it really doesnt. I mean hell if she read some of my musings here on ATOT.... I'm sure she would be even more upset than I. The more I think about it, the more I'm sure she didn't do anything.... and as I calm down, I realize that everything I read fits into the internal conflict she's had going on, and has shared with me.

I think those of you who think this is suddenly over now.... are wrong. I'm gonna let this die... curiousity got to me.... the desire to look into the inner mind of the girl. I'm going to let it go now, pretend it never happened and relax.

-Max

Except thr fact that you have posted this on the internet for all the world to see, including her a few years down the row.

You two will laugh about it and you will find out that Jeff is actually a gay guy who all the women were after in high school and was nicknamed the prospect...She will tell you that she did behave in Arizona and that the only time she cheated with you was the one time she got drunk with your dad and he banged her 4 ways to kingdom come. You will both chuckle and start to see how silly you were and start to make wild passionate love by the fireplace while you imagine your dad screwing her....
 

Doboji

Diamond Member
May 18, 2001
7,912
0
76
Originally posted by: Nitemare
Originally posted by: Doboji
I'm calming down.... and here's why.... I think we all have those remote "prospects" that we hold onto even deep into relationships... I have one or two myself.... but does that disrupt how deeply I feel for my GF?... no it really doesnt. I mean hell if she read some of my musings here on ATOT.... I'm sure she would be even more upset than I. The more I think about it, the more I'm sure she didn't do anything.... and as I calm down, I realize that everything I read fits into the internal conflict she's had going on, and has shared with me.

I think those of you who think this is suddenly over now.... are wrong. I'm gonna let this die... curiousity got to me.... the desire to look into the inner mind of the girl. I'm going to let it go now, pretend it never happened and relax.

-Max

Except thr fact that you have posted this on the internet for all the world to see, including her a few years down the row.

You two will laugh about it and you will find out that Jeff is actually a gay guy who all the women were after in high school and was nicknamed the prospect...She will tell you that she did behave in Arizona and that the only time she cheated with you was the one time she got drunk with your dad and he banged her 4 ways to kingdom come. You will both chuckle and start to see how silly you were and start to make wild passionate love by the fireplace while you imagine your dad screwing her....


:laugh:
 

RbSX

Diamond Member
Jan 18, 2002
8,351
1
76
You're a loser, everyone has the temptation to be paranoid, but damn man you took it way to far.
 

Toasthead

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2001
6,621
0
0
Originally posted by: MartyMcFly3
Wow. No offense but Im pretty sure this will kill your relationship. It's called trust dude.

haha seriously. If you have to check up this much on someone...she's NOT the one.
 

Originally posted by: Doboji
Thursday I find out where she goes, and at this point I'm going completely off the deep end and need a way to calm down.

I did a terrible thing already... I went through her email... all of it, back to 2 years ago.... I freaked out at every single word of hesitency... I revisited the old pain of when I wasn't the only guy she was seeing. I've aroused probably ridiculous assumptions, and suspicions.... I'm losing my mind here.... I need a way to calm down.... I don't know what to do.

Details are this.... in her mailbox, the overwhelming majority of emails are to me, or about me... email after email showing pics to her friends of her and I.... email after email telling them how great I am, and that she's not sure if I'm the one, but that I might be.

We started dating in April 04. She made it clear in the beginning that it was not a relationship, and that it was not exclusive. In sept 04... she did a hospital rotation in Atlanta, GA. At that point we were "together"... but she made it very clear that if she had the opp to go on a date or two that she wanted to be free to do so. At this point in our relationship it's clear by her emails, and what I knew then, that she was very guarded to the possibility of her moving away....

Well in september I found an email to her relatives talking about me, but mentioning a "prospect" in Atlanta.... after sept it's all me me me in the emails....

Then in February she went on a cross country road trip with her girls for 3 weeks, including a stop for a wedding in arizona. On valentines day... february 14th, I see an email from her, to her best friend in India.

"Next week I'm going to Arizona, where I'll see Jeff again. Fun stuff."

no real mention of me. Her friend responds back and asks about me.

she responds...

"<friends name>, how am I going to be good at the wedding. I'm more and more into max now too and really don't want to mess things up, but at the same time, my mom even
told me on the phone yesterday (since max spent the day with my family),
that I'd become resentful of him for many of his traits and I know that's
true!"

So I cross reference the name Jeff, finding his name both on the mailing list for wedding people, and at the same time finding his name in a series of interchanges regarding her trip to atlanta. There is little doubt in my mind that this is the "prospect" from atlanta.

The night before the the wedding... we had this weird discussion about cheating, and bachelorette parties etc. She said some crap essentially saying she would forgive me if I did something bad while drunk. And I immed responded back with hell no, that wouldnt be ok under any circumstances.... regardless of alcohol, and the same applied to her.

The next day after the wedding I asked her point blank... did she behave herself at the wedding... and she said she did... and that she didnt even get drunk.

So my crazy head is screaming several things....

1. It was wrong to read her email

2. Should I dump her for dating another guy in september of last year when in my mind we were already knee deep in our relationship...

3. Do I tell her I read the emails

4. Did she cheat on me in Arizona, or did she "almost" cheat on me in Arizona.

Last night we spent 4 hours discussing Baby names.... and she is clearly very much deeply in love with me. I don't know what to do... I can't work, I can't eat... I'm losing my mind.

-Max
If there was ever any questions about your insanity, this clears it all up. It isn't even the jealousy, intrusion of privacy or stalking as much as how much you've revealed about yourself. Please seek help. You sound like you're literally going crazy. Your story is all over the place. This is sad.... With two "normal" people and one person just the bad guy, I would say she would just dump your a$$. But this one's beyond just dumping you. I would be scared if I were she. You have an entirely different perception of your relationship, which makes me question the depth of it. Perhaps it isn't as you think it, especially when she's told you that it isn't exclusive? Well, whatever it is, please get help because this goes beyond her, but your relationship is just a comfortable hiding place and a good scapegoat.

Edit: Oops! I don't know how a post intended for another thread got in here.
 

EyeMWing

Banned
Jun 13, 2003
15,670
1
0
Shut off your brain. Your gut is right, learn to be a man and trust your gut. Your brain is for things like figuring out how to best apply duct tape and WD-40. Your gut is for figuring out how relationships are going to happen.

You COMPLETELY NEGLECT TO INFORM HER that you read her emails. That is suicide. Your gut should tell you this if it is functioning properly.

She did not cheat on you. Period. If she had, it would've been damn clear that she had, women love telling stories. Consider it tit for tat with your idiotic move of reading her email. You fvcked up, she fvcked up, life goes on.

If you've discussed FVCKING BABY NAMES, you're her choice and you have no real grounds to fvck with that.

Oh, and while you're growing a pair, try to learn how to trust people. You don't have to trust everybody; in fact, don't trust anybody except her. It'll work out better that way.
 

machintos

Golden Member
Mar 1, 2003
1,652
0
0
reading her email was wrong.
I don't think you should tell her that you read her email, but whatever doubts you have, I think you shoul talk to your girl about it.
 

AMDZen

Lifer
Apr 15, 2004
12,589
0
76
OK I see that your all "done" with this, pretending it never happened, etc. But I still think she did cheat on you. Well, it depends on how you define "cheating". See for me, if my gf went off to a wedding, got drunk and then ended up talking to some guy, who then put the move on her, kissed her. At which time she kisses back, but then perhaps says no after 5 seconds or something and says "I have a BF and I love him". I could forgive that. After a healthy dose of screaming, and then make-up secks. But she could have done more then that, on that I can't tell.

What I am sure about, however, was the statement she made regarding YOUR behavior after drinking. A previous poster or two touched on this, and I completely agree with them. She wouldn't have said anything like that unless she had done something similar. Trust me on this.

I don't know if that means you can trust her or not, because she may feel the same way I do in that if she just kissed, for no longer then 5 seconds mind you ;) , then I could forgive that. And I would expect my gf to do the same for me. But she is hiding something. I would delve into why she asked that question a little personally, but you run the risk of it ending your relationship. Which is a must IMO, because I couldn't marry a girl that slept with another guy. Secks is too far, kissing is something that can be forgiven. You need to know which it was, because I'm 99.9% sure it was something. Pray it was just a kiss.
 
Jan 18, 2001
14,465
1
0
1) Be honest with yourself why you read and OBSESSED, over her emails. You are probably a very insecure person. In other words, you don't have the balls to trust another person, and will be insecure in any relationship until you get some cajones. You violated her privacy, and now you have feelings of guilt on top of the feelings of insecurity you started off with.

2) You should come clean with her, and if she has any sense at all, she will leave you for good. You should tell her everything anyways.
 

royaldank

Diamond Member
Apr 19, 2001
5,440
0
0
If you read her emails today, you'd see where I forwarded a link to this thread and a warning to get away.
 

Geekbabe

Moderator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Oct 16, 1999
32,229
2,539
126
www.theshoppinqueen.com
You sit her down and tell her that you cannot see quitting your job and moving with her to another city while she completes her resdincey without a clear cut agreement that you are exclusive. You might also now want to sit down and talk money with the lady as she is going to be a high earning doctor and you have only just begun making fiscal sacrifices
in the name of furthering her career.

I wouldn't move without an engagement being announced.
 

Mo0o

Lifer
Jul 31, 2001
24,227
3
76
You... should just dump her because obviously you dont trust her enough to have an equal relationship
 

Geekbabe

Moderator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Oct 16, 1999
32,229
2,539
126
www.theshoppinqueen.com
Originally posted by: sao123
You were never in a relationship, just merely friends with benefits and now your attached. Anyone who starts a relationship by insisting that she/he is open to still date other people has a committment problem which will never go away.
Cut your losses, and her too.

I disagree, doctors in training live hellish lives.She was wise to insist on remaining non-exclusive while she was in training.However, the OP is now talking about having to quit his own job, a job he likes a lot and move with her so that she might complete her residency.. that's a huge career hit in favor of her, the OP is naturally going to now be having issues. As far as being mad or worried that she "cheated" on him, I'd say the OP has no grounds to even discuss the issue as the relationship was not exclusive.

However, going forward I say he needs to clarify with the lady what her intentions are.If she's not ready to become engaged and exclusive he'd be a fool to move,to give up his interests in favor of supporting hers.
 

Yax

Platinum Member
Feb 11, 2003
2,866
0
0
Why don't you just stay with her, but start getting some on the side whenever the opportunity arises. Your relationship won't work out, but at least you won't be so attached when it crumbles.

 

shimsham

Lifer
May 9, 2002
10,765
0
0
seems to me youre taking this relationship way too seriously with her level of commitment. its obvious she has been clear about your status.

she was gone on valentines day, talking about resenting you and seeing another guy. youre not the one.
 

Gulzakar

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,074
0
0
Don't tellher what you did...it was a mistake, things happen...don't do it again. everyone gets paranoid from time to time.

What I would do>?

Sit down with her and ask her where you think "this" is going. If she asks where this is coming from, just tell you you've been thinking bout it for a while.

At that point, you'll nkow for certain. If she is hesitant at all, leave her.
 

Doboji

Diamond Member
May 18, 2001
7,912
0
76
*UPDATE* I'm running on zero sleep right now.... I went up there around 10 last night and we talked until the morning. I did not tell her I read her email.... and you guys can say whatever you want about that. It was a stupid thing to do... I will not do it again, it was wrong, but telling her will only do damage... it won't help anything.

I did however work my way to the issues that I found in the email... and as always the conclusion should have been. Don't jump to conclusions....

First to clear something up... we are NOT in an open relationship. She has a weird family... who believes that you should always be dating other people, and be on the lookout for someone better up until the point where you get engaged. This is a reality that has been pushed on her day in day out by her mother especially since the beginning of the relationship. The push to be able to date other guys has come from that... but she decided back in September... when she was supposed to date this guy "Jeff" who she was set up with... that she wasn't going to be with anyone but me. She did meet the guy Jeff, but it wasn't a date.... and NOTHING happened. She thought he was a cool guy, and was feeling pressure from all kinds of directions to date him, but she didnt she stayed loyal to me. AND I BELIEVE HER.

Then february she was at the wedding.... and in the past every wedding she went to was date prospecting heaven.... in this case this guy Jeff was there, and the pressure to approach was again applied. All her friends were taking bets on who was gonna make out with who... including her friends with boyfriends back home... This whole thing freaked her out and prompted her to call me... However the whole time the only guy she was thinking about was me... and again nothing even came close to happening. AND I BELIEVE HER.

She is still very shaky on whether I'm the "one". She's concerned about a couple of issues they are.... 1.) How I am with money, and if I'm a "go-getter". 2.) I'm messy.
This lead to a whole other discussion/problem... but thats the subject for another YAGT at another time.

So basically I was waaaay off base. And I feel like an asshole. You guys can flame me all you want... but this whole flipping your life upside down thing has me pretty twisted, and I just plain snapped a little there.

But it does seem I was jumping the gun a bit on the whole proposal thing.... we're not ready yet. I find out tommorow where she matches... and from that I'll have an idea exactly how much time we have left to get it right.

*Update*