• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

YAGT: I did it, I told my dream crush that I liked her

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
Originally posted by: Zorba
Never tell a girl you like them, they have to find out for themselves 😉. You can ask them out, but don't straight say "I have a crush on you, you can have me anytime you want me."

<---- Actually I am working on a crush of mine right now 🙂

You know.. it is this principle... this system of "not telling her that you like her" is what really pisses me off.

I don't know about you guys but I hate friendships that are blind to these sort of things, it really puts confusion and anxiety in, and takes all the fun out of it, if you ask me.

I would rather just meet people that are upfront and honest about how they feel about me, instead of conforming to the stupid society method of 'keeping it a mystery'

Again... at this point I am more willing to remain myself, and do things the very upfront way, than to change because 'girls find mystery to be more sexy, bla bla'

I hate the chase. I absolutely hate it, I want it to be over with.

I'm sure you can find a fat chick fairly easy, but if you want to score with attractive girls you will have to deal with the "chase." It's life and you've got to deal with it. Unless you are super wealthy or very good looking you've got to play the game like the rest of us. Trust me, you aren't having any thoughts that any of us didn't, but it didn't mean we creeped people out over it.
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
Originally posted by: Zorba
Never tell a girl you like them, they have to find out for themselves 😉. You can ask them out, but don't straight say "I have a crush on you, you can have me anytime you want me."

<---- Actually I am working on a crush of mine right now 🙂

You know.. it is this principle... this system of "not telling her that you like her" is what really pisses me off.

I don't know about you guys but I hate friendships that are blind to these sort of things, it really puts confusion and anxiety in, and takes all the fun out of it, if you ask me.

I would rather just meet people that are upfront and honest about how they feel about me, instead of conforming to the stupid society method of 'keeping it a mystery'

Again... at this point I am more willing to remain myself, and do things the very upfront way, than to change because 'girls find mystery to be more sexy, bla bla'

I hate the chase. I absolutely hate it, I want it to be over with.

Heh, the upfront way for you being via electronic means over a large distance.
 
Ummm that was rather dumb move on your part..... you just completly creeped her out. First off you're not really close enough to be telling her anyhting like that
im not too sure what you mean by that
, second off all if you're not really in contact, saying somethign like that is just stupid.


What you should've done is wait around till she comes back and jsut ask her out "hey wanna go grab something to eat/ watch a movie etc". Telling her over email that youre madly in love with her and than you photoshopped composites of your future children is odd to say at least.

Oh well you'll grow some mojo eventually 😉
 
And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Take a few days and search on skywalker66's threads here in ATOT and then see if you still feel any sympathy.

Here is the formula for one of these:
YAGT: How to meet a girl
I am having an awful time meeting girls. Oh yeah, I never shower, so I smell really badly. Do you think that has anything to do with it?

***
500 replies of "Take a shower!" interspersed with "So do you really think taking a shower will help? I hate playing all these nonsense games...."

It's positively awful.
 
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.
 
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.



yeah well he could've worked it over the email, but sending her an email outta the blue saying that hes madly in love with her etc. is jsut idiotic and VERY mistimed
 
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.



yeah well he could've worked it over the email, but sending her an email outta the blue saying that hes madly in love with her etc. is jsut idiotic and VERY mistimed

You don't work anything with someone over e-mail unless you've fcked them before.
 
well what are you after here? a relationship?... thats quite personal if you ask me...

okay.. and i thought i got pretty personal in that email...
look, i didnt have the patience to wait for her to come back, alright? thats pretty much what it comes down to. I didnt want to keep thinking about her, I wanted to get some $hit outta the way.
 
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.



yeah well he could've worked it over the email, but sending her an email outta the blue saying that hes madly in love with her etc. is jsut idiotic and VERY mistimed

You don't work anything with someone over e-mail unless you've fcked them before.

oh bullsh!t, i sent my ex an email asking for help with some school related thing and threw in my aim screen name, and she replied and IMd me. Then I told her about some party over IM and we hung out there and i was in...


If you know how to work it, you can work it over anything. I could flirt with bongos and smoke signals if i had to...
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
well what are you after here? a relationship?... thats quite personal if you ask me...

okay.. and i thought i got pretty personal in that email...
look, i didnt have the patience to wait for her to come back, alright? thats pretty much what it comes down to. I didnt want to keep thinking about her, I wanted to get some $hit outta the way.

So, you're an impatient coward?
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
well what are you after here? a relationship?... thats quite personal if you ask me...

okay.. and i thought i got pretty personal in that email...
look, i didnt have the patience to wait for her to come back, alright? thats pretty much what it comes down to. I didnt want to keep thinking about her, I wanted to get some $hit outta the way.

So, you got tired of jerking off to her everynight, and figured an e-mail would make her fall magically in love with you?
rolleye.gif
 
oh bullsh!t, i sent my ex an email asking for help with some school related thing and threw in my aim screen name, and she replied and IMd me. Then I told her about some party over IM and we hung out there and i was in...

Big difference between a random IM saying "Want to go to a party?" and a random IM saying "I've had a crush on you for the longest time!"
 
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: halik
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.



yeah well he could've worked it over the email, but sending her an email outta the blue saying that hes madly in love with her etc. is jsut idiotic and VERY mistimed

You don't work anything with someone over e-mail unless you've fcked them before.

oh bullsh!t, i sent my ex an email asking for help with some school related thing and threw in my aim screen name, and she replied and IMd me. Then I told her about some party over IM and we hung out there and i was in...


If you know how to work it, you can work it over anything. I could flirt with bongos and smoke signals if i had to...

You actually *had* a relationship with that person. It wasn't someone you spooged to when they walked down the hall. Massive difference.
 
Originally posted by: Jzero
Originally posted by: skywalker66
Originally posted by: Jzero
So if this is all about "Being yourself," why would you want to "become good enough" for her?

because I want to improve for myself too. It's about becoming a better individual.. and as a side bonus, that will also allow me to get better girls in life.

If you really wanted to improve, you would have listened to some of the advice posted in your eleventy-billion YAGTs.
I'm afraid I must add you to the esteemed roll of people I chalk up as "Internet Performance Artists." You are just portraying a socially inept character to get a rise out of the folks here. No real human being can possibly be this linear. You're like imtim83's character, minus the asexual thing.

Note...

I am being entirely serious. I know that this new way of thinking I have adopted is different from most peoples, but that doesnt mean its wrong. And I thought i DID listen to some advice here on this forum, I did finally go out and ASK her! Better than doing nothing, right? better than waiting if you ask me, because i didnt want to wait, i just wanted to clear the ear and get things over with. maybe subconsciously I was looking for a way to get rejected so that I could just get her off my mind and focus on other girls that are around me.

And by the way, some people would have considered Jesus to be a linear individual, far from the norm, and yet he was still right, and the best guy to have walked this Earth.
 
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.

Get over your ego trip man. I think telling a woman you like her is tough no matter how you do it. Granted doing it through an email isn't exactly the best way, it still gets credit in my book. As for her being interested, I don't know about that. I think a lot of women don't really show if they like someone or not. Or if they do, they will do it in a subtle way.
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
well what are you after here? a relationship?... thats quite personal if you ask me...

okay.. and i thought i got pretty personal in that email...
look, i didnt have the patience to wait for her to come back, alright? thats pretty much what it comes down to. I didnt want to keep thinking about her, I wanted to get some $hit outta the way.

well at least you feel 'better' now... but when you really meet the girl you really like... you gotta be a lot smoother than that... girls arent as easy as yes or no... :beer:
 
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.

Get over your ego trip man. I think telling a woman you like her is tough no matter how you do it. Granted doing it through an email isn't exactly the best way, it still gets credit in my book. As for her being interested, I don't know about that. I think a lot of women don't really show if they like someone or not. Or if they do, they will do it in a subtle way.

Heh, I've got zero reason to be on an ego trip about women, but I do know how to be realistic about them, and the OP certainly isn't. It's not realistic to think an e-mail to a basic stranger is ballsy in any way. It's creepy.
 
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.

Get over your ego trip man. I think telling a woman you like her is tough no matter how you do it. Granted doing it through an email isn't exactly the best way, it still gets credit in my book. As for her being interested, I don't know about that. I think a lot of women don't really show if they like someone or not. Or if they do, they will do it in a subtle way.

Heh, I've got zero reason to be on an ego trip about women, but I do know how to be realistic about them, and the OP certainly isn't. It's not realistic to think an e-mail to a basic stranger is ballsy in any way. It's creepy.
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
How old are you?

I am 19, and a week from being 20, my friends

I'm going have to call BS. There is no way you have been alive for nearly 20 years and failed to grasp the very basic concepts of interpersonal relationships and communication.
 
Originally posted by: skywalker66
Remember that girl I was talking about who I said that I worked with at Dairy Queen one and a half years ago,
and then this fall I ended up going to the same college as her, and then I had mentioned
that this Spring she would unfortunately be in Ecuador?

Well, I'd tried talking to her in lunch, in the halls, etc. but it was hard because i didnt really have a forum at this school for getting to know her, except this club that really didnt meet that often.
So i figured that maybe by emailing her I could get to know her better, while she was in Ecuador, a longshot hope I guess, but I figured it'd be worth trying.

Well I sent her one before she left and she replied. And then i sent her one when she got down there and she replied, and I sent her one again and she didnt reply. Then a few weeks later she sent a "how things are going down there" reply to a bunch of people (mass email), and I wrote her back after that, didn't get a reply,
and then finally I did it...

Just for the heck of it, I sent her an email telling her that I had had a crush on her before, that she was an attractive girl in a lot of ways, and also seemingly pretty successful at life, and that I wanted to learn what a few of her tips are for being so successful and such a cool person, and also that i wanted to get to know her better,
so I asked her if she wanted to hang out some time in early May after she gets back.

And this time she replied right away the next morning. She thanked me for the compliments and told me that she indeed was surprised to get such an email, and that she'd be alright hanging out in 'some kind of a group setting' after she gets back, heck I'll just paste what she said specifically,
Here's the entire email she sent back (its not that long)..
--------------
hey steve-
how are you? um, thank you for your email, it was very nice, i was really
surprised to get it! well, it would be fun to hang out in a group of some sort
when i get back. im not too sure what you mean by that, i enjoy being friends
with you. i hope this semester is treating you well, hasta luego! Lydia
---------

so yea, i really dont know what to make of it. I sent her a reply back that hanging out in a group would be cool and i said some other general stuff, and havent heard from her since (I sent this one out about a couple days ago)

so... Are you guys proud of me? I'm proud of myself, what I did took balls and a lot of courage (i dont know if i could have done it without the tool of "emailing" at my hands.)
I'm thinking that hopefully I was able to grow from doing this. My plan for this semester is to meet more girls in my classes and such, and maybe try to hook up with somebody, we'll see how much time i have in my life. And if I dont succeed at getting girls in my classes, then this dream girl will always be back at around May, and maybe she'll wanna hang out over the summer (we both live around here)

Another big part of this tho, which sucks, is that a lot of the girls I am going after are pretty attractive, which means that i will probably have to work hard, to get in good shape to be elligable for them (havent been lifting or doing cardio for like the last 8 months) so i definately need to get on the ball, I've lost a little muscle and gained a lil fat.
So... cardio.. lifting.. and resisting nasty food temptations will definately be more things to focus on throughout the rest of this semester.
Maybe even working on a bit of a tan at the salons.

So yea.. I will definately have my work cut out for me over the next few months towards disciplining myself to look really good, working hard at my schoolwork (there will be a lot of it this semester), and also trying to meet girls in places, and getting to know them, particularly hot girls. (this is a trick)

So... wish me luck people! Cuz this next semester is going to SUCK!


Why did she call you Steve? Isn't your name Bill? That's what it says on the profile.
😕
 
yeah that was my entire point:
Ummm that was rather dumb move on your part..... you just completly creeped her out. First off you're not really close enough to be telling her anyhting like that

Quote:
im not too sure what you mean by that

second off all if you're not really in contact, saying somethign like that is just stupid.


What you should've done is wait around till she comes back and jsut ask her out "hey wanna go grab something to eat/ watch a movie etc". Telling her over email that youre madly in love with her and than you photoshopped composites of your future children is odd to say at least.

Oh well you'll grow some mojo eventually

 
I did finally go out and ASK her!
You most certainly did NOT "GO OUT" and do anything! You sat there in your bedroom and wrote an e-mail!
And by the way, some people would have considered Jesus to be a linear individual, far from the norm, and yet he was still right, and the best guy to have walked this Earth.

There is a perceptible difference. Real people have patterns and habits, but they have multiple dimensions. I don't want to give you too much info b/c you might make your character somewhat believable, but suffice it to say that even Jesus did some things that nobody was expecting.
 
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: Dissipate
Hey guys lighten up. I give skywalker mad props for sending this email. Sure its not as "personal" as a phone call or face to face, but who cares? The bottom line is he told her how he feels about her. And let's have some sympathy for him, he did kind of get rejected.

Skywalker, my advice to you is don't pursue her anymore. There are plenty of other "fish in the sea", and I think you would be better off meeting women in a better way, not through emails. When this girl gets back your best bet is to distance yourself from her, lest you get damaged again.

Give him props??? Sending an e-mail is honestly not that big of a deal, and will never ever have a good result when asking out someone you know in real life. Not only is it creepy and shows a lack of self-esteem, but it allows the girl to reject much easier. He was in the friends zone before he sent the e-mail. If she was interested he would of known.


Okay.. look, I HATE absolutely HATE the idea of a girl agreeing to go out with me to someplace, all just because I asked her in person and tjat she would have felt too ashamed to say no. Basically by going along with your guys method, I am getting accepted because she wants to be nice, even if that is only a small part of the equation I still dont want it to be part of the equation at all.
I want her to WANT me! From the beginning!

What kind of guy wouldnt want a girl to WANT him from the start? That attraction, that zing, is big! I feel like that helps solidify the relationship better, and makes her less likely to break up with you over another guy.
Because if you are just Mr. average Joe hooking up with this really hot girl through careful sneakiness, playing the game, playing the chase, etc, and then say all of the sudden the rich attractive dude with a good personality walks into the picture and wants this girl, then you are screwed.

Plus I feel like I am ripping a girl off, If she is hot, and I'm not. I dont like to rip people off.
 
Back
Top