YAGT: Going after a girl with a bf? *UPDATE 4*

Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
I know, this is very scummy. But there's this girl I really dig who's been dating this guy for a few months. We're very friendly and we hang out every now and then and, lately, I've been thinking about making my attraction clear. Now, if I don't do anything forceful (like kissing the taken girl), would this be so scummy? She's cute, smart, and fun to be around and I don't think her bf gives her the respect that she deserves anyways. The guy's a tool..

UPDATE - 4/7/2005
Very odd turn of events. So, this girl calls me last night hysterically crying. I ask her what's wrong and she can barely talk. She said that she's feeling alone and that she wanted to come over. I drive down to her apartment and pick her up. We go out for coffee and she explains that she's going through a really rough time and that her bf is being very cold and distant to her. Her mom recently died and she really needed some compassion but her BF keeps telling her to grow up. A total tool. Anyway, I take her back to my place and make her tea and we end up talking until 6 AM. Firstly, I told her that I was very attracted to her and that I shouldn't give her advice about her BF, one way or another as I'll be biased. Then I suggested that she not base her self worth on her bf and that she seriously talk to him - that they've been together for so long that she shouldn't throw it away based on one thing. We then watch a few simpsons episodes and I sleep on the couch.

I guess this was closure in a weird way. I proved mature enough not to take advantage of her when I easily could have. Then I insisted that she speak it over with her bf even though I really want that position... Finally, this night cemented my position as the asexual best friend. I'm bitter sweet about the whole thing. I'm glad that I'm that one person she decided to call but now know that I have absolutely no chance with her. But I feel like I did the right thing, as frustrating as that is.

UPDATE 2
So my little adventure with this wonderful girl is over for now. She slept over while I was at work and I came home to see her pretty face. It was nice, even if she was just there as a friend in need. We watched some tv, had some dinner, and then I drove her home. I convinced her to talk things over with her boyfriend and to be rational and weigh all of the factors before doing something that she'd regret. We had a long hug goodbye and I felt really good about the whole thing. We are going to the zoo on saturday but I have no alterior motives.. i learned so much about this girl and respect her so much after this odd 24 hours... she got a 1530 on her SATs! Ha, for some reason i think she's even hotter knowing that.. Anyway, whatever happens, happens... I'm just happy that I have her in my life at all. She's smart, beautiful, and probably has cute friends too ;)

Thanks to the ATOTers who were unusually patient and respectful. Sometimes you guys piss me off and other times you guys are a loving bunch with thoughtful advice.

UPDATE - 4/8/2005
So she had a long talk with her boyfriend and her words to me where "I need to forget about him." I'm going to continue to be the good guy and wait things over before making a move but I sure as fvck am going to try to get out of the friend boat. I asked her if I can pamper her tomorrow since she's been so stressed out, "a minivacation filled with foot rubs and smelly animals" which she laughed at and accepted. I don't know if that's a date but I'm at least trying to get out of this friend situation. it's moving too quickly though, I know. I expect her boyfriend to come back with an apology but it's so shaky that I don't feel bad for being a little flirty right now.

UPDATE - 4/10/2005
We had a very fun day at the zoo today. She also took me to her old neighborhood and gave me a little tour followed by dinner. Was very cool and I enjoyed the time with her. I didn't make a move, it just didn't feel right. We had a blast and I know she knows that I have feelings for her. I joked once that I'm so serious about losing weight right now because there's this girl that I adore that I'm trying hard to deserve - i said it with a little wink. She said "I don't deserve anything" - an apathetic reply due to her current upset state of mind. my line sounds really forward and stuff but it was in the context of a much longer conversation.. she knows...that's what's important to me... i also know that she has some healing to do, so I'm not going to be pushy...i'm seeing her tomorrow but only for an audition - i'm not going to invite her to anything for a while since I don't want to seem too pushy...
 

Czar

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
28,510
0
0
You would be breaking the man code, and you just dont breake the man code!
 

NuclearNed

Raconteur
May 18, 2001
7,873
364
126
Just let the girl know that she has an option to her current situation, but otherwise don't be pushy.
 

isasir

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2000
8,609
0
0
Uh, are you asking us to smack you around, or you just telling us the assholish move you're planning on doing?
 

AdamSnow

Diamond Member
Nov 21, 2002
5,736
0
76
Why do people even need to ask something like this ?

Stay the fvck away dude.
 

Drakkon

Diamond Member
Aug 14, 2001
8,401
1
0
Originally posted by: loic2003
Depends, if you're 13 -> 17 it's cool. 18+ and it's not.
yup yup...and if you are 13->17 be prepared to throw down at lunchtime :D
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
i should mention that her bf and her are fighting right now and, well, i wouldn't want her to cheat on him, perhaps dump him sooner? ;)
 

Jzero

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
18,834
1
0
If there's no ring on her finger, she's fair game. We are all free agents and if she dumps her boyfriend, she does it of her own free will. Of course if she leaves him for you, there's a solid chance she'll do it again when she gets bored with you - just keep that in mind.

Oh, and don't try anything physical until AFTER she breaks up with him.
 

richardycc

Diamond Member
Apr 29, 2001
5,719
1
81
/me waits for a parody from her bf asking what to do with a tool trying to score his gf...
 

gigapet

Lifer
Aug 9, 2001
10,005
0
76
whoa whoa whoa slow down here guys......this man has a valid concern

She is not married. No ring!!! The guy is not his friend so he would not be violating any kind of code there.

Utlimately he can try and persuade her if he wants to but it is her decision on what move to make and he cannot be held accountable for that. If she hooks up with him before breaking up with her man then that is just untrustworthy and he should be careful.



'just cuz there is a goalie does not mean you can't score!'
 

OVERKILL

Platinum Member
Jan 28, 2005
2,103
2
0
Originally posted by: HardcoreRobot
just be ok with it when she does the same thing to you


I strongly support this reply.


Also, it's totally wrong to go after another guys woman. If she's getting treated like crap, thats her business, not yours.
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
Originally posted by: Jzero
If there's no ring on her finger, she's fair game. We are all free agents and if she dumps her boyfriend, she does it of her own free will. Of course if she leaves him for you, there's a solid chance she'll do it again when she gets bored with you - just keep that in mind.

Oh, and don't try anything physical until AFTER she breaks up with him.

Those are my thoughts exactly. and I don't care if she leaves me after a fun week, month, whatever.. it's the nature of dating, isn't it? i don't even feel like i have a chance, I just wonder if I should mention it, not push it.
 

Pacfanweb

Lifer
Jan 2, 2000
13,155
59
91
Who cares? Unless the BF is a friend, all unmarried women are fair game. It's up to THEM to tell YOU that they are not available.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
Originally posted by: OVERKILL
Originally posted by: HardcoreRobot
just be ok with it when she does the same thing to you


I strongly support this reply.


Also, it's totally wrong to go after another guys woman. If she's getting treated like crap, thats her business, not yours.

 
Oct 9, 1999
19,632
38
91
do what you want but if it was my girl, you sir, would have your ass handed to you, on a silver plate.


gg
 

dug777

Lifer
Oct 13, 2004
24,778
4
0
nah, its just not on.

if you tried to cut my lunch, i'd king hit so hard you wouldn't know which way was up for a month.

ok?