Originally posted by: Foxery
I must be missing something. What's the draw, beyond using cheats? And using those tends to ruin a game for me in a hurry.
Any play style is "possible" on live... though figuring out which of 200 servers has your perfect guild is another story.
Since most private servers are "accelerated" (ie more xp in less time, also easy access to phat loots) it's easier to experience big portions of the game that would otherwise be impossible to access for a casual player. That's certainly a draw; being able to see end-game content that is impossible to normally see for most people.
Also, when I played WoW sometimes I wanted to try a new class but didn't feel like going through the 70 levels of grind. And remember, you have to deal with assholes from the other side (I was Horde) constantly ganking your newbie. It's so frustrating. Instead, you can play on a private server and level up a character quickly, seeing all of the lower level content in a relatively short time span. It's pretty sweet if you want to try something new without the bullshit of a live server. That said, nothing beats a good raid guild on live WoW.
Actually, I remember leaving my favorite guild just so that I could see Hyjal and Black Temple. Yeah, it was that important to me. I was so disappointed with the experience (ie not being with my guild buddies) that I ended up quitting a month later. So yeah, being able to experience end-game content is a pretty big deal to some people.
I think Blizzard is taking a step in the right direction with Wrath of the Lich King, allowing players to organize 10-man instances for the end-game content instead of the obligatory 25, the only difference being loot tables. I don't mind if I'm getting shitty loot. I want to see the cool end-game content!