Wow ... Apple must be getting very desperate

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

EyeMWing

Banned
Jun 13, 2003
15,670
1
0
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: EyeMWing
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: rsd
Actually I thought it was a great commercial. I imagine this has happened to almost everyone with a laptop to some extent or another. If anything the point is that apple does design their laptops to consider careful details.

Yup. Apple provides premium computing. From the small details like the power cord to the best user interface developed yet, it's just better than other pc manufacturers. OP, you're a moron.

Best user interface my ass. Best LOOKING, sure, but from a usability standpoint, I'm writing a paper that completely and totally dismantles it (and no, it isn't just my opinion, I'm basing the whole thing on UI usability textbooks)

If you know how to use the keyboard shortcuts it is the best interface around. And it still is just your opinion, even if you're using textbooks. You could just be a bad student.

Yes, and an AS/400's user interface is even better if you know the shortcut keys. Hell, on the AS/400, they're even printed on the keyboard!!!!

Sorry, the only meaningful user interface from a software development standpoint is the graphical one, because that's the one most users identify with. And just so I'm not ignorant when I go back to writing this thing, what, exactly, are these shortcut keys and what do they do?
 

touchmyichi

Golden Member
May 26, 2002
1,774
0
76
I don't think "desperate" is the right word, as apple is one of the nation's hottest growth companies.
 

Descartes

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
13,968
2
0
It seems to me that it'd be a very successfull marketing campaign, but overall I don't think they're appealing to the right demographic for the Mac.

It seems they're just trying to ride the "Macs are cool; PCs are boring." That's obvious enough, but I think these campaigns would appeal to only younger consumers (teenagers, mainly) that have little real experience with technology. These are consumers more interested in looking cool at the coffee shop with the Mac than meaningful work, and their marketing caters to this.

I think the irony is that this demographic is probably the least likely to be able to make purchases in any meaningful number. Technologists don't listen to the FUD and are more likely to be turned off by it.

In short: I think it will backfire, but I don't think it's an act of desperation.
 

preslove

Lifer
Sep 10, 2003
16,754
64
91
Originally posted by: theprodigalrebel
Apple/Windows fights depress me.
Go away, preslove. The OP had a beef with Apple's advertising, not their software.

Troll.

This is a troll thread to begin with. How is apple desperate by highlighting a cool feature with their sh!tty add campaign?
 

secretanchitman

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2001
9,352
23
91
just saw it yesterday, quite stupid in my opinion.

and isn't the mac guy the main actor in the movie "accepted"?
 

bobdelt

Senior member
May 26, 2006
918
0
0
What Apple is doing is genius. Advertise to the young high school and college kids, who have a need to fit in, so they become Mac users for life. The past 3 years or so, the amount of macs on college campuses exploded.
 

TheChort

Diamond Member
May 20, 2003
4,203
0
76
Originally posted by: theprodigalrebel
Apple/Windows fights depress me.
Go away, preslove. The OP had a beef with Apple's advertising, not their software.

Troll.

qft
 

Insane3D

Elite Member
May 24, 2000
19,446
0
0
Originally posted by: secretanchitman
just saw it yesterday, quite stupid in my opinion.

and isn't the mac guy the main actor in the movie "accepted"?

I recognize him from Jeepers Creepers...

The PC guy is on the Daily Show now too..
 

preslove

Lifer
Sep 10, 2003
16,754
64
91
Originally posted by: EyeMWing
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: EyeMWing
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: rsd
Actually I thought it was a great commercial. I imagine this has happened to almost everyone with a laptop to some extent or another. If anything the point is that apple does design their laptops to consider careful details.

Yup. Apple provides premium computing. From the small details like the power cord to the best user interface developed yet, it's just better than other pc manufacturers. OP, you're a moron.

Best user interface my ass. Best LOOKING, sure, but from a usability standpoint, I'm writing a paper that completely and totally dismantles it (and no, it isn't just my opinion, I'm basing the whole thing on UI usability textbooks)

If you know how to use the keyboard shortcuts it is the best interface around. And it still is just your opinion, even if you're using textbooks. You could just be a bad student.

Yes, and an AS/400's user interface is even better if you know the shortcut keys. Hell, on the AS/400, they're even printed on the keyboard!!!!

Sorry, the only meaningful user interface from a software development standpoint is the graphical one, because that's the one most users identify with. And just so I'm not ignorant when I go back to writing this thing, what, exactly, are these shortcut keys and what do they do?

F9, F10, F11. OH NO THAT IS SO FVCKING HARD!!!!!!! Do you even know what expose is????

OSX is the best interface you can use if you are comfortable using shortcuts to get around. Period. If you don't believe me, or you think I'm a troll, ask the fvcking founder of this sight.

<a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2232&p=3">Text</a>

I quickly realized that although Apple had targeted the entry level computer user with the interface of OS X, the OS was far more tailored to the power user in my opinion.


Where to start? Customization is much more possible (and easy to do) under OS X than any variant of Windows that I have ever encountered. Icon sizes are just the beginning; through the view options menu alone, you can change the positioning of the labels on the icons, the text size as well as the normal array of Windows options. And any changes you make here occur in real time - no clicking "OK" or "Apply". Just check a box and it happens instantaneously; and uncheck it, and everything goes back to normal. It's a small thing, but as I soon found out, much of OS X's appeal to me came in tiny gems like this.

The other thing to point out, which is quite possibly the biggest draw to OS X for me, is the fact that just about everything under OS X has a keyboard shortcut associated with it. I've found that if you got your start with PCs in the DOS days, then you end up being much more of a keyboard junkie than someone who is reliant on the mouse. I use the mouse when I have to, but when it's quicker to use the keyboard, I feel much more comfortable firing off a few keystroke combinations to get my point across. If you are anything like me in that respect, then OS X will be your playground.

I can't possibly list all of the keystroke combinations that I use on a daily basis, but there are quite a few. For example, I am a big "ALT-TAB"-er in Windows, but ALT-TAB is only really useful for switching applications, not closing them. The ALT-TAB equivalent under OS X, Command-TAB (the Command key is positioned where you'd expect ALT to be, so it works out fine), works similarly, but here's the catch - hit "Q" while you've selected an application and it will quit automatically. Nice, but nothing major right?

Want to minimize a window? Command-M will take care of that. Want to hide an application without minimizing it? Command-H. Hidden windows will automatically move to the end of the Command-TAB list, so you don't switch to them after you've hidden them.

Want to open a new Finder window? Command-N. Want to create a new folder on your drive? Shift-Command-N. I've always wanted to be able to create new folders in Explorer without using the mouse. OS X was a dream come true in that respect.

OS X will even let you define your own keyboard shortcuts for any application through the keyboard preferences panel
 

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
yeah that commercial is dumb. i hate it. I have owned PC's for a long tiem and have NEVER knocked one over because of the power cord.
 

IGBT

Lifer
Jul 16, 2001
17,974
140
106
..they've turned into a gadget audio player company. Not to far off from the sharper image.
 

Babbles

Diamond Member
Jan 4, 2001
8,253
14
81
I get entertained when Mac Fanboys (e.g. preslove) clueless try to argue that every little thing Apple does is the best thing ever.

Oh, and "preslove" before you accuse others of reading comprehension problems, you may want to make sure that you do not have the same issue as well (see your last post where you quoted Anand using the phrase "in my opinion" - just think about that one for a while).
 

Fenixgoon

Lifer
Jun 30, 2003
33,289
12,850
136
Originally posted by: bobdelt
What Apple is doing is genius. Advertise to the young high school and college kids, who have a need to fit in, so they become Mac users for life. The past 3 years or so, the amount of macs on college campuses exploded.

their target segment is one often left out i agree, but the fact remains that apple tries to appear like a little fish in a big pond, saying "please help apple with its fight against corporate giant M$" but in reality, they're just as big as MS because they have the judicial system on their side (let MS bundle office with windows and see what happens - everyone will cry anti-trust in 5 seconds flat)
 

Cabages

Platinum Member
Jan 1, 2006
2,918
0
0
Originally posted by: bobdelt
What Apple is doing is genius. Advertise to the young high school and college kids, who have a need to fit in, so they become Mac users for life. The past 3 years or so, the amount of macs on college campuses exploded.


Wow, I have to admit I have been noticing this quite a bit. I dont know why, but they think it makes them cool. Theres a group of people in my school that are completely obsessed with macs now, but they dont know very much about computers. They always seem to throw back at us that macs come with Ilife and free software, but they always fail to mention what some of their macs dont include in the basic bundles.

Things like a monitor, keyboard and mouse. Basic things that if you buy directly from mac, could cost you quite a bit. And they think its so much better with the bundled software, when it doesnt have the essentials for even starting it up.

Have any of you noticed that Macs are becoming more and more prominent in movies?

Sad thing is, the people that dont know anything about computers, eat these adds up.
 

rsd

Platinum Member
Dec 30, 2003
2,293
0
76
Regardless of the commercial, I don't see why anyone wouldn't want one of those magnetic cords for their laptop. Anyone care to dispute that? (perhaps apple has a patent so its not feasible, but I wish they all had that).
 

preslove

Lifer
Sep 10, 2003
16,754
64
91
Originally posted by: Babbles
I get entertained when Mac Fanboys (e.g. preslove) clueless try to argue that every little thing Apple does is the best thing ever.

Oh, and "preslove" before you accuse others of reading comprehension problems, you may want to make sure that you do not have the same issue as well (see your last post where you quoted Anand using the phrase "in my opinion" - just think about that one for a while).

Um... I put the opinion of Anand way above any of the mac bashers in this thread. Most of them have never even used a new mac and have no idea what they are talking about. I'm not a fan boy, mac's have their problems, too, but the interface and the small touches make it a better experience.

http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2740&p=1

When I first started using a PowerBook G4 over a year ago it quickly turned into the best experience I'd ever had with a notebook.

That was using an obsolete, POS, ibm chip. And it was a better experience for him than any other notebook pc using superior hardware.

So, Is Anand a freaking fanboy, too? :roll:
 

Toastedlightly

Diamond Member
Aug 7, 2004
7,214
6
81
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: Babbles
I get entertained when Mac Fanboys (e.g. preslove) clueless try to argue that every little thing Apple does is the best thing ever.

Oh, and "preslove" before you accuse others of reading comprehension problems, you may want to make sure that you do not have the same issue as well (see your last post where you quoted Anand using the phrase "in my opinion" - just think about that one for a while).

Um... I put the opinion of Anand way above any of the mac bashers in this thread. Most of them have never even used a new mac and have no idea what they are talking about. I'm not a fan boy, mac's have their problems, too, but the interface and the small touches make it a better experience.

http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2740&p=1

When I first started using a PowerBook G4 over a year ago it quickly turned into the best experience I'd ever had with a notebook.

That was using an obsolete, POS, ibm chip. And it was a better experience for him than any other notebook pc using superior hardware.

So, Is Anand a freaking fanboy, too? :roll:

Was this about OSes? NO. ah heck off then.
 

EyeMWing

Banned
Jun 13, 2003
15,670
1
0
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: EyeMWing
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: EyeMWing
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: rsd
Actually I thought it was a great commercial. I imagine this has happened to almost everyone with a laptop to some extent or another. If anything the point is that apple does design their laptops to consider careful details.

Yup. Apple provides premium computing. From the small details like the power cord to the best user interface developed yet, it's just better than other pc manufacturers. OP, you're a moron.

Best user interface my ass. Best LOOKING, sure, but from a usability standpoint, I'm writing a paper that completely and totally dismantles it (and no, it isn't just my opinion, I'm basing the whole thing on UI usability textbooks)

If you know how to use the keyboard shortcuts it is the best interface around. And it still is just your opinion, even if you're using textbooks. You could just be a bad student.

Yes, and an AS/400's user interface is even better if you know the shortcut keys. Hell, on the AS/400, they're even printed on the keyboard!!!!

Sorry, the only meaningful user interface from a software development standpoint is the graphical one, because that's the one most users identify with. And just so I'm not ignorant when I go back to writing this thing, what, exactly, are these shortcut keys and what do they do?

F9, F10, F11. OH NO THAT IS SO FVCKING HARD!!!!!!! Do you even know what expose is????

OSX is the best interface you can use if you are comfortable using shortcuts to get around. Period. If you don't believe me, or you think I'm a troll, ask the fvcking founder of this sight.

<a target=_blank class=ftalternatingbarlinklarge href="http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2232&p=3">Text</a>

I quickly realized that although Apple had targeted the entry level computer user with the interface of OS X, the OS was far more tailored to the power user in my opinion.


Where to start? Customization is much more possible (and easy to do) under OS X than any variant of Windows that I have ever encountered. Icon sizes are just the beginning; through the view options menu alone, you can change the positioning of the labels on the icons, the text size as well as the normal array of Windows options. And any changes you make here occur in real time - no clicking "OK" or "Apply". Just check a box and it happens instantaneously; and uncheck it, and everything goes back to normal. It's a small thing, but as I soon found out, much of OS X's appeal to me came in tiny gems like this.

The other thing to point out, which is quite possibly the biggest draw to OS X for me, is the fact that just about everything under OS X has a keyboard shortcut associated with it. I've found that if you got your start with PCs in the DOS days, then you end up being much more of a keyboard junkie than someone who is reliant on the mouse. I use the mouse when I have to, but when it's quicker to use the keyboard, I feel much more comfortable firing off a few keystroke combinations to get my point across. If you are anything like me in that respect, then OS X will be your playground.

I can't possibly list all of the keystroke combinations that I use on a daily basis, but there are quite a few. For example, I am a big "ALT-TAB"-er in Windows, but ALT-TAB is only really useful for switching applications, not closing them. The ALT-TAB equivalent under OS X, Command-TAB (the Command key is positioned where you'd expect ALT to be, so it works out fine), works similarly, but here's the catch - hit "Q" while you've selected an application and it will quit automatically. Nice, but nothing major right?

Want to minimize a window? Command-M will take care of that. Want to hide an application without minimizing it? Command-H. Hidden windows will automatically move to the end of the Command-TAB list, so you don't switch to them after you've hidden them.

Want to open a new Finder window? Command-N. Want to create a new folder on your drive? Shift-Command-N. I've always wanted to be able to create new folders in Explorer without using the mouse. OS X was a dream come true in that respect.

OS X will even let you define your own keyboard shortcuts for any application through the keyboard preferences panel

"Power User" was a term invented by Apple marketing to describe the target segment for System 7.5 and referred to the sort of people with 4 hard drives and a ton of desktop publishing software installed.

Want to open a new Explorer Window? Win-E. GENIUS! Want to create a new folder in Explorer? Option-W-F (or Option-W-Enter for that matter) Option, then W, then enter is a more usability oriented keystroke pattern than Shift-Command-N because it requires at a minimum 1 finger, since it's sequential rather than simultaneous. Shift-Command-N requires 3 no matter how you do it. And guess what? A tiny variation on it can get you virtually any filetype.

The Command-Tab-Q thing is actually a side effect Apple's keyboard handling that causes it to invoke Command-Q in the currently focused Application. Windows does the same thing, the difference being that Alt-Tab does not change focus until AFTER you've made a selection. It wasn't an intentional design decision at all.

Windows can be operated entirely from the keyboard. Apple still requires you use the mouse for a whole lot of things.

Long ago I learned to not giveashit what Anand or Tom or Kyle thinks. There's money in it for them no matter what - the manufacturer may not be paying them, but indirectly, it's all about money.

And no, I don't have the slightest idea what Expose is, because I only got as far as documenting the issues with the OSX *INSTALLER* (yes, there are usability issues with the installer)

And yes, I have a real mac. It's a Mac Mini x86 that I scrounged up as a freebie from someone who got PO'd at it. I wiped the hard drive clean and started fresh with a retail OSX86 CD.
 

MrPickins

Diamond Member
May 24, 2003
9,125
792
126
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: Babbles
I get entertained when Mac Fanboys (e.g. preslove) clueless try to argue that every little thing Apple does is the best thing ever.

Oh, and "preslove" before you accuse others of reading comprehension problems, you may want to make sure that you do not have the same issue as well (see your last post where you quoted Anand using the phrase "in my opinion" - just think about that one for a while).

Um... I put the opinion of Anand way above any of the mac bashers in this thread. Most of them have never even used a new mac and have no idea what they are talking about. I'm not a fan boy, mac's have their problems, too, but the interface and the small touches make it a better experience.

http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2740&p=1

When I first started using a PowerBook G4 over a year ago it quickly turned into the best experience I'd ever had with a notebook.

That was using an obsolete, POS, ibm chip. And it was a better experience for him than any other notebook pc using superior hardware.

So, Is Anand a freaking fanboy, too? :roll:

The difference is that Anand realizes the difference between fact and opinion.

I'm not a fan boy, mac's have their problems, too, but the interface and the small touches make it a better experience.
Just so you know, this is an opinion. It may be a better experience for you, but maybe not for everyone.

And calling the OP a moron for having the nerve to comment on Apple's ad campain is what makes you a fanboy.
 

EyeMWing

Banned
Jun 13, 2003
15,670
1
0
Oh, and for the record, I started my computing life as a Mac user. I preferred it to Windows by far. And then, when things started getting all happy-homo in OS 8, I switched. I still kept tabs on the mac world until OS 9, and into the early days of OSX. Then I used OSX, and IMMEDIATELY wrote the entire thing off as the most godawful interface I'd ever used. Because it is. I'd rather use Windows 3.1 than OSX.
 

her209

No Lifer
Oct 11, 2000
56,336
11
0
Originally posted by: preslove
I quickly realized that although Apple had targeted the entry level computer user with the interface of OS X, the OS was far more tailored to the power user in my opinion.

Where to start? Customization is much more possible (and easy to do) under OS X than any variant of Windows that I have ever encountered. Icon sizes are just the beginning; through the view options menu alone, you can change the positioning of the labels on the icons, the text size as well as the normal array of Windows options. And any changes you make here occur in real time - no clicking "OK" or "Apply". Just check a box and it happens instantaneously; and uncheck it, and everything goes back to normal. It's a small thing, but as I soon found out, much of OS X's appeal to me came in tiny gems like this.

The other thing to point out, which is quite possibly the biggest draw to OS X for me, is the fact that just about everything under OS X has a keyboard shortcut associated with it. I've found that if you got your start with PCs in the DOS days, then you end up being much more of a keyboard junkie than someone who is reliant on the mouse. I use the mouse when I have to, but when it's quicker to use the keyboard, I feel much more comfortable firing off a few keystroke combinations to get my point across. If you are anything like me in that respect, then OS X will be your playground.

I can't possibly list all of the keystroke combinations that I use on a daily basis, but there are quite a few. For example, I am a big "ALT-TAB"-er in Windows, but ALT-TAB is only really useful for switching applications, not closing them. The ALT-TAB equivalent under OS X, Command-TAB (the Command key is positioned where you'd expect ALT to be, so it works out fine), works similarly, but here's the catch - hit "Q" while you've selected an application and it will quit automatically. Nice, but nothing major right?

Want to minimize a window? Command-M will take care of that. Want to hide an application without minimizing it? Command-H. Hidden windows will automatically move to the end of the Command-TAB list, so you don't switch to them after you've hidden them.

Want to open a new Finder window? Command-N. Want to create a new folder on your drive? Shift-Command-N. I've always wanted to be able to create new folders in Explorer without using the mouse. OS X was a dream come true in that respect.

OS X will even let you define your own keyboard shortcuts for any application through the keyboard preferences panel
I think it may be due to my bad reading comprehension again, but it sounds like OSX is an OS with a graphical user interface and those are shortcuts for OSX (I assume). Again, sorry for the poor reading comprehension skills. I will try to work on them.
 

preslove

Lifer
Sep 10, 2003
16,754
64
91
Originally posted by: MrPickins
Originally posted by: preslove
Originally posted by: Babbles
I get entertained when Mac Fanboys (e.g. preslove) clueless try to argue that every little thing Apple does is the best thing ever.

Oh, and "preslove" before you accuse others of reading comprehension problems, you may want to make sure that you do not have the same issue as well (see your last post where you quoted Anand using the phrase "in my opinion" - just think about that one for a while).

Um... I put the opinion of Anand way above any of the mac bashers in this thread. Most of them have never even used a new mac and have no idea what they are talking about. I'm not a fan boy, mac's have their problems, too, but the interface and the small touches make it a better experience.

http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=2740&p=1

When I first started using a PowerBook G4 over a year ago it quickly turned into the best experience I'd ever had with a notebook.

That was using an obsolete, POS, ibm chip. And it was a better experience for him than any other notebook pc using superior hardware.

So, Is Anand a freaking fanboy, too? :roll:

The difference is that Anand realizes the difference between fact and opinion.

The reasons for his high opinion of the mac's user interface are facts. OSX gives end user more and easier options for getting around in the os.

I'm not a fan boy, mac's have their problems, too, but the interface and the small touches make it a better experience.
Just so you know, this is an opinion. It may be a better experience for you, but maybe not for everyone.

And calling the OP a moron for having the nerve to comment on Apple's ad campain is what makes you a fanboy.[/quote]

He's a moron for calling a company with rapidly expanding market share "very desperate." Why would they be desperate?