StormRider
Diamond Member
- Mar 12, 2000
- 8,324
- 2
- 0
Originally posted by: CADsortaGUY
Originally posted by: StormRider
Sorry but it's you who is using an irrational and emotional argument. Why do you only focus on this particular law and not any of the other laws out there that many people violate? This shows you are using emotion/bias and not logical and rational arguments.
The rational response would be to acknowledge that the law that "criminalizes" being in the US without official permission and working is unrealistic and in my opinion wrong. Yes, it's against the rules -- but "criminal"? I disagree with that.
What exactly is irrational and emotional about wanting the law to be followed? Also, hellfugginlo? This thread is about ILLEGALS - not murder, robbery, etc. Try keeping up.
lol, so exactly why do you feel it shouldn't be criminal? What else is it going to be? civil? Who has standing then? I'd really love to hear your defense of you last paragraph.
It's same rationale that makes me say that it is wrong to put a 19 year old man who had consensual sex with his 17 year old girlfriend in jail and labling him as a pedophile. I don't care what the law says. If the law says he is a criminal then I say the law is wrong and should be changed.
It's the same rationale that makes me say that past laws that prevent mix race couples from marrying is wrong. And that law was changed.
Similarly, I think it's wrong to treat someone who entered our country without official permission in order to work in the same way we treat someone who just mugged, raped or murdered someone. To me it's not in the same category and shouldn't be treated like a "criminal offense".
You are inconsistent in your beliefs. In other threads you want government out of the people's business and here you support the government in being a "big brother" telling people if they are allowed to work. Thing about it. So, it becomes a criminal offense to enter a country next door and accept $20 to help a guy move out of his apartment? Or pick some vegetables? This "crime" is enough to get your panties in a wad?
