Question Windows 10 won't read DVD's. Aleady tried multiple online solutions

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
C

C1

Platinum Member
Feb 21, 2008
2,385
113
106
So what I found with my Lenovo laptop was that it is the CD/DVD drive that's the issue !

Had SATA 12+mm thick drive that I pulled from an old Dell lappy - different manufacturer - swapped it in to the Lenovo notebook & it works phenomenally.

Actually recently had a similar issue with a Fujitsu lappy (Model T 732) that I sort of have retired.

Based on what has happened, I'm pretty sure that you need to replace your CD/DVD drive.

Some advice though. You dont have to replace it with the exact same make/model/vintage.

In fact, that probably is not wise as that particular make/model & vintage (production line) may have had a manufacturing defect/problem (including even a firmware issue) & that's why they go bad (early).

If you're gonna replace it, then try for a newer version (ie, newer manufacturing date) and also that shows an updated firmware version. In this way, the expectation is that any production bugs reported on the earlier versions would have been corrected in subsequent releases (due to consumer complaints).

Also, dont hesitate to use a different drive manufacturer (but use drive with same or better capabilities). The form factor for drives in a class (eg, 9+mm or 12+mm ) is effectively standardized.

Good Luck !!!


Addendum:

Looks like (based on my experience) that optical drive problems can be really weird, intermittent and hard to pin down. If you can, see if you can just pull a drive from a lappy (as many have removable drives ) and temporarily plug it in to the SATA port of your problematic DVD/CD enclosure so that you can then just test the "system" to see if your issue(s) go away.
 
J

jamesdsimone

Senior member
Dec 21, 2015
907
251
136
C1 said:
So what I found with my Lenovo laptop was that it is the CD/DVD drive that's the issue !

Had SATA 12+mm thick drive that I pulled from an old Dell lappy - different manufacturer - swapped it in to the Lenovo notebook & it works phenomenally.

Actually recently had a similar issue with a Fujitsu lappy (Model T 732) that I sort of have retired.

Based on what has happened, I'm pretty sure that you need to replace your CD/DVD drive.

Some advice though. You dont have to replace it with the exact same make/model/vintage.

In fact, that probably is not wise as that particular make/model & vintage (production line) may have had a manufacturing defect/problem (including even a firmware issue) & that's why they go bad (early).

If you're gonna replace it, then try for a newer version (ie, newer manufacturing date) and also that shows an updated firmware version. In this way, the expectation is that any production bugs reported on the earlier versions would have been corrected in subsequent releases (due to consumer complaints).

Also, dont hesitate to use a different drive manufacturer (but use drive with same or better capabilities). The form factor for drives in a class (eg, 9+mm or 12+mm ) is effectively standardized.

Good Luck !!!


Addendum:

Looks like (based on my experience) that optical drive problems can be really weird, intermittent and hard to pin down. If you can, see if you can just pull a drive from a lappy (as many have removable drives ) and temporarily plug it in to the SATA port of your problematic DVD/CD enclosure so that you can then just test the "system" to see if your issue(s) go away.
Click to expand...
The laptop is new so there isn't an internal drive. I went ahead and ordered another external drive assuming there must be something wrong with the drive. I'm sure I'm dealing with Chinese quality control here.
 
C

C1

Platinum Member
Feb 21, 2008
2,385
113
106
re: The laptop is new so there isn't an internal drive. I went ahead and ordered another external drive assuming there must be something wrong with the drive. I'm sure I'm dealing with Chinese quality control here.


What I am suggesting is to open up the external drive & pull out the DVD/CD drive from the internal controller. (It should be a standard SATA interface - all my external drives - and I got a bunch of them both for SATA & IDE type drives and for size drives 3 1/2" to 2 1/2" .)

If you can get your hands on another DvD/CD drive then it may allow you to do a test to verify that it is the drive in the external enclosure that is bad, which now Im betting it is.
(For such test, you dont have to reassemble the enclosure. The whole mess can just set on a table with the circuit card with SATA controller plugged into a SATA DvD/CD drive. I do stuff like this all the time.)

If it turns out to be the drive (which Im also betting it is), then you can just buy a suitable replacement part off eBay to substitute into your existing enclosure. (You can pick up used to new drives on eBay for a song; eg, as low as $6 to $15.)

I do this all the time. (The bezels come off & are swappable as typically the CD/DvD drives are made to a standardized form factor including screw holes. Im actually in the process of doing this now for my current situation.)

You'll get it working again.
You'll be okay.
 
Muadib

Muadib

Lifer
May 30, 2000
18,103
904
126
mikeymikec said:
Which drive letter do you propose pointing VLC at when it doesn't show up in File Explorer?
Click to expand...
You may be right, but I had the same issue as the OP, and VLC found my drive. That was with Windows Vista though.
 
Last edited:
Brainonska511

Brainonska511

Lifer
Dec 10, 2005
27,634
12,044
136
I had this kind of thing happen in my Haswell -era HTPC previously - where it would work, and then suddenly stop working and the drive would be absent from File Explorer. The only fix was to do a restart of the system (not a shutdown and turn back on). Ultimately, I never figured out the cause, and I haven't seen the same issue popup since the drive was moved to a newer (Skylake) system.

I would check the connections, particularly if the drive is in a modular bay. Also, take a look in the BIOS - see if it shows up there.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

COMPANY
RESOURCES
FOLLOW
Top Bottom