Why should we learn spanish in the USA

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

dmcowen674

No Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
54,889
47
91
www.alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mo0o
I agree that we shouldn't be forced to learn Spanish as a second language , but it doesn't hurt to know it anyways. Having a little booklet at a Sonic isn't going to destroy our culture, but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools.

" but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools"

GANG VIOLENCE IN RURAL GEORGIA: A COMMUNITYS' FIGHT

Because 85% of the population is Mexican, they've been forced to teach classes only in Spanish.

85% of the population is NOT Mexican.

From your own article: "According to the census report, 85 percent of Hall County's foreign-born residents are not citizens of the United States. Just how many of the 19,100 foreign-born residents are here legally is not known."

Hall County Population: 156,101 Link

That's about 19.6% Hispanic. Stop making sh!t up, Dave.

Hey, I lived there. There are now entire massive subdivisions of 100% Mexican Hispanics.

Go there and see for yourself.

Yeah and you are the biggest fvcking liar on this forum. Census information doesn't lie. :roll:

Ahahahaha, you actually believe the Census would count 20 illegal Mexican to a house and trailers???
:confused:
 

Mill

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
28,558
3
81
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mo0o
I agree that we shouldn't be forced to learn Spanish as a second language , but it doesn't hurt to know it anyways. Having a little booklet at a Sonic isn't going to destroy our culture, but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools.

" but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools"

GANG VIOLENCE IN RURAL GEORGIA: A COMMUNITYS' FIGHT

Because 85% of the population is Mexican, they've been forced to teach classes only in Spanish.

85% of the population is NOT Mexican.

From your own article: "According to the census report, 85 percent of Hall County's foreign-born residents are not citizens of the United States. Just how many of the 19,100 foreign-born residents are here legally is not known."

Hall County Population: 156,101 Link

That's about 19.6% Hispanic. Stop making sh!t up, Dave.

Hey, I lived there. There are now entire massive subdivisions of 100% Mexican Hispanics.

Go there and see for yourself.

Yeah and you are the biggest fvcking liar on this forum. Census information doesn't lie. :roll:

Ahahahaha, you actually believe the Census would count 20 illegal Mexican to a house and trailers???
:confused:

Actually, they do. They also use simulation and patterns to come up with an accurate number. If they are off by much, they probably are off by 1-3%.
 

Neurorelay

Platinum Member
Jul 21, 2004
2,195
0
0
No one should learn to talk and just keep to themselves. As long as communication is necessary, learn whatever language(s) are necessary...to be so ethnocentric is silly.
 

dmcowen674

No Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
54,889
47
91
www.alienbabeltech.com
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mo0o
I agree that we shouldn't be forced to learn Spanish as a second language , but it doesn't hurt to know it anyways. Having a little booklet at a Sonic isn't going to destroy our culture, but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools.

" but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools"

GANG VIOLENCE IN RURAL GEORGIA: A COMMUNITYS' FIGHT

Because 85% of the population is Mexican, they've been forced to teach classes only in Spanish.

85% of the population is NOT Mexican.

From your own article: "According to the census report, 85 percent of Hall County's foreign-born residents are not citizens of the United States. Just how many of the 19,100 foreign-born residents are here legally is not known."

Hall County Population: 156,101 Link

That's about 19.6% Hispanic. Stop making sh!t up, Dave.

Hey, I lived there. There are now entire massive subdivisions of 100% Mexican Hispanics.

Go there and see for yourself.

Yeah and you are the biggest fvcking liar on this forum. Census information doesn't lie. :roll:

Ahahahaha, you actually believe the Census would count 20 illegal Mexican to a house and trailers???
:confused:

Actually, they do. They also use simulation and patterns to come up with an accurate number. If they are off by much, they probably are off by 1-3%.

I doubt that he Census people went to Con-Agra and Pilgrims Pride Chicken trailers and counted all the people living in them.
 

Mill

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
28,558
3
81
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mill
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Mo0o
I agree that we shouldn't be forced to learn Spanish as a second language , but it doesn't hurt to know it anyways. Having a little booklet at a Sonic isn't going to destroy our culture, but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools.

" but ill definitely protest if we ever tried to impliment spanish as requried curriculum in our schools"

GANG VIOLENCE IN RURAL GEORGIA: A COMMUNITYS' FIGHT

Because 85% of the population is Mexican, they've been forced to teach classes only in Spanish.

85% of the population is NOT Mexican.

From your own article: "According to the census report, 85 percent of Hall County's foreign-born residents are not citizens of the United States. Just how many of the 19,100 foreign-born residents are here legally is not known."

Hall County Population: 156,101 Link

That's about 19.6% Hispanic. Stop making sh!t up, Dave.

Hey, I lived there. There are now entire massive subdivisions of 100% Mexican Hispanics.

Go there and see for yourself.

Yeah and you are the biggest fvcking liar on this forum. Census information doesn't lie. :roll:

Ahahahaha, you actually believe the Census would count 20 illegal Mexican to a house and trailers???
:confused:

Actually, they do. They also use simulation and patterns to come up with an accurate number. If they are off by much, they probably are off by 1-3%.

I doubt that he Census people went to Con-Agra and Pilgrims Pride Chicken trailers and counted all the people living in them.

I'm sure the DDR MCPs counted them though. :roll:
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
common language is fundamental to the unity of a people. without it ..sh1t goes from ugly to hellish. look around the world for ethnic strife where people segregate their cultures in a country...lack of common language being a big contributer to misunderstanding/isolation from other. humans are humans ... we aren't high minded unemotional beings unaffected by things like the feeling of belonging to a country, which is just an extention of family.. of tribe. when you become alien in your own country because of language barriers, you lose all connection...your countryman becomes meaningless as someone on the other side of the world.

plus its plain inconsiderate. come to a country, learn to speak to the people there. its like coming to live as a permanent guest in someones home and telling the people to f*ck off, i don't want anything to do with u, let alone be in your family.
 

Rock Hydra

Diamond Member
Dec 13, 2004
6,466
1
0
The cost for people that are not even in school to be forced to learn English would be enourmous. This idea would never stand. Many people talk about wasting money on dumb ideas. I believe this is certainly one of them. How about worrying about the kids that are in school, who have more potential than those who come here and work for petty wages.
 

mwtgg

Lifer
Dec 6, 2001
10,491
0
0
Originally posted by: RockHydra11
The cost for people that are not even in school to be forced to learn English would be enourmous. This idea would never stand. Many people talk about wasting money on dumb ideas. I believe this is certainly one of them. How about worrying about the kids that are in school, who have more potential than those who come here and work for petty wages.

My great-grandparents came over from Italy in 1921. Guess what, they learned English. If you didn't, you couldn't work. Why should we kowtow to those who come to America and don't even respect us enough to learn the language?
 

Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: RockHydra11
The cost for people that are not even in school to be forced to learn English would be enourmous. This idea would never stand. Many people talk about wasting money on dumb ideas. I believe this is certainly one of them. How about worrying about the kids that are in school, who have more potential than those who come here and work for petty wages.

My great-grandparents came over from Italy in 1921. Guess what, they learned English. If you didn't, you couldn't work. Why should we kowtow to those who come to America and don't even respect us enough to learn the language?
Exactly. I think that foreigners SHOULD learn English, but simply seeing another language on a childrens' learning toy isn't cause for alarm. Like I said earlier, it's good for them.
 

mrgoblin

Golden Member
Jul 28, 2003
1,075
0
0
Im going to make this simple. If you expect to speak spanish only in America, you will never have a good job, never live outside of a spanish town and never be treated as an equal in the business world
 

illustri

Golden Member
Mar 14, 2001
1,490
0
0
Originally posted by: mrgoblin
Im going to make this simple. If you expect to speak spanish only in America, you will never have a good job, never live outside of a spanish town and never be treated as an equal in the business world

But few first generation hispanic immigrants kid themselves about getting much of that anyway.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
You shouldn't. Having a mediocre command of two languages is inferior to a superior command of one. Given that English is a better, more popular language - nevermind the fact that it's the language spoken by most in the US - and one has no good reason for people to learn Spanish. Any immigrants should learn English immediately. That's simply good immigration practice on the immigrant's part.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Originally posted by: illustri
better? wth do you mean better? careful where you're going with this
Better because I speak it :)

Actually better because it's far more popular. Multiple languages throughout the world is silly anyway, but anyhow this is an English speaking country. Learning spanish is a waste of time unless you work in landscaping (oops, I didn't say that :D).

 

illustri

Golden Member
Mar 14, 2001
1,490
0
0
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: illustri
better? wth do you mean better? careful where you're going with this
Better because I speak it :)

Actually better because it's far more popular. Multiple languages throughout the world is silly anyway, but anyhow this is an English speaking country. Learning spanish is a waste of time unless you work in landscaping (oops, I didn't say that :D).

If you bring the "world" into your arguement than mandarin is easily the best language with twice the speakers than english. so go ahead and waste your time speaking english
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Originally posted by: illustri
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: illustri
better? wth do you mean better? careful where you're going with this
Better because I speak it :)

Actually better because it's far more popular. Multiple languages throughout the world is silly anyway, but anyhow this is an English speaking country. Learning spanish is a waste of time unless you work in landscaping (oops, I didn't say that :D).

If you bring the "world" into your arguement than mandarin is easily the best language with twice the speakers than english. so go ahead and waste your time speaking english
Mandarin is not the national language in the US.

 

illustri

Golden Member
Mar 14, 2001
1,490
0
0
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: illustri
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: illustri
better? wth do you mean better? careful where you're going with this
Better because I speak it :)

Actually better because it's far more popular. Multiple languages throughout the world is silly anyway, but anyhow this is an English speaking country. Learning spanish is a waste of time unless you work in landscaping (oops, I didn't say that :D).

If you bring the "world" into your arguement than mandarin is easily the best language with twice the speakers than english. so go ahead and waste your time speaking english
Mandarin is not the national language in the US.

neither is english
 

mwtgg

Lifer
Dec 6, 2001
10,491
0
0
Originally posted by: jumpr
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: RockHydra11
The cost for people that are not even in school to be forced to learn English would be enourmous. This idea would never stand. Many people talk about wasting money on dumb ideas. I believe this is certainly one of them. How about worrying about the kids that are in school, who have more potential than those who come here and work for petty wages.

My great-grandparents came over from Italy in 1921. Guess what, they learned English. If you didn't, you couldn't work. Why should we kowtow to those who come to America and don't even respect us enough to learn the language?
Exactly. I think that foreigners SHOULD learn English, but simply seeing another language on a childrens' learning toy isn't cause for alarm. Like I said earlier, it's good for them.

Yeah, but when they get to be like manuals where the instructions are ordered from "Spanish to Chinese to ... to English" it gets outrageous.
 

illustri

Golden Member
Mar 14, 2001
1,490
0
0
Originally posted by: mwtgg


Yeah, but when they get to be like manuals where the instructions are ordered from "Spanish to Chinese to ... to English" it gets outrageous.

you do realize those products aren't only for sale in the US or England right?
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Originally posted by: illustri
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: illustri
Originally posted by: Skoorb
Originally posted by: illustri
better? wth do you mean better? careful where you're going with this
Better because I speak it :)

Actually better because it's far more popular. Multiple languages throughout the world is silly anyway, but anyhow this is an English speaking country. Learning spanish is a waste of time unless you work in landscaping (oops, I didn't say that :D).

If you bring the "world" into your arguement than mandarin is easily the best language with twice the speakers than english. so go ahead and waste your time speaking english
Mandarin is not the national language in the US.

neither is english
Practically speaking yes it is.

 

imthebadguy

Platinum Member
Aug 14, 2004
2,703
0
0
I totally agree, I attend a University where it is REQUIRED to take 4 semesters of a foreign language, I find that to be total BS, first off I am Indian and I can speak my language(which they dont acknowledge), secondly i have no interest whatsoever to learn spanish, and i find it really hard to do (mostly cause I dont give a fvck...) but anywho, I guess this is just a rant....It pisses me off that I have to learn spanish, I will 99pct never use it in my life......
 

illustri

Golden Member
Mar 14, 2001
1,490
0
0
skoorb

Practically? Only if you're 1)educated 2)relatively assimilated and 3)in an constant english speaking context. Do you think that the average immigrant from mexico, uneducated even in his own language, is going to strive to 1)go to school 2)give up everything in his culture and 3)get a job in an office?

My neighborhood of newly developed luxury houses looks like a barrio in the work day time. When I want my goddamn pool fountain shifted or my driveway paved differently you think I go talk to any of the twenty or more guys working on my property? No, I make a phone call.
 
Dec 4, 2002
18,211
1
0
Originally posted by: Skoorb
You shouldn't. Having a mediocre command of two languages is inferior to a superior command of one. Given that English is a better, more popular language - nevermind the fact that it's the language spoken by most in the US - and one has no good reason for people to learn Spanish. Any immigrants should learn English immediately. That's simply good immigration practice on the immigrant's part.

Why not have a superior command of one and an inferior of another? What is the harm?