Originally posted by: DBL
I agree with you when you say that play money is not a good indicator of ones poker skills. However, it has nothing to do with it being a huge luck-fest IMO. With play money, since people will play horrible hands, it should be many times easier to win. It's just that you can't let that give you false confidence and move to real money assuming the competition is going to play as horribly as w/ play money. So, if you can't win w/ play money than don't waste your time w/ real money tables.
As for strategy in limit, the original poster claimed that his friend was making $400/week at .5/1 and he was doing this by folding anything less than Jx. Honestly, I have a hard time believing anybody could make that kind of return in limit .5/1 and certainly not when playing any hand better than Jx. In fact, Jx is a worse hand than the average hand of Q7. If he has in fact made that kind of money in a week, it is due only to luck, which will eventually even out.
One thing people need to realize is that the most profitable player over a given time period is not necessarily the best, but often only the luckiest. It is this same player who will start losing big when their luck changes. The best players are going to make a relatively consistent amount over a decent range of hands (5k - 10k) but never as much in a short time-frame as a poor player who has had the benefit of luck. This is simply b/c a good player will only play 20% - 30% of the time 10-handed and that includes the SB and BB.
IF you have $40 to spare, try this at the .5/1 level. Join two tables and with the exception of the BB and SB, and play hands according to the table located here
Starting Hands. This will require patience but you should see the benefit over a moderately long session. Of course, since there is a lot of luck involved, there is never any guarantee.