Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Fern
Lemme see if I understand this.
Bills originate in the House, but they can't pass anything.
Filibusters apply to the Senate, not the House.
The Repubs don't actually have enough seats in the Senate to fillibusters.
But the Dems haven't passed anything in either the House or the Senate because of the (fictional) Repubs fillibuster?
Bwuhahahaha
Fern
What are you babbling about? The Democrats haven't tried to vote on a bill in the House yet, they most certainly haven't failed in any way, shape, or form. To say that they are 'unable' to pass a bill there is laughably false and you know it.
The Senate on the other hand may end up being 'unable' to pass a bill with a public option, but it most certainly would be due to a Republican filibuster on the issue. There are nearly certainly Democrats that would not vote for cloture, but who would never try and mount a filibuster of their own party's legislation. So yes, they would be unable to pass the bill because of a Republican filibuster. Do you really think the GOP would hesitate for a second to filibuster a bill with a public option? That would be incredibly naive of you.
As I said to our good friend RyanPaulShaffer, parties do not vote in tandem with one another in America. If this isn't civics 101, it's civics 201 at best. The most likely scenario is a public option bill from the House, and one without it from the Senate.