It is important what you are looking when playing a game. Pretty sure all the old consoles you consider being the best are so because of the age. take an old one and try to play it now and tell me how many hours do you stay on it!
I've been playing Secret of Mana 2 and Chrono Trigger on my SNES. And lots of Street Fighter II Turbo. When I first got my RGB SCART cable put together for the SNES I stayed up till 2 AM on a work night playing Street Fighter 2, and the next day running a 96* complete game of Super Mario World.
Did a full play through of Vay on Sega CD a week ago. Gave up trying to get a "perfect game" when I hit level 110 and was still gaining experience... can't look at Shining Force CD again until my Sega CD backup RAM cart shows up.
Lately I've be running through all the Sonic games on the Genesis just dropping my jaw at how awesome 16 bit looks with RGB SCART on a Sony PVM RGB broadcast monitor and how awesome it sounds on my old Klipsch 400 watt ProMedia 4.1 system. Well the SNES does... poor Genesis always sounded like a dying cat yowling through a fan blade. Originally I had bought S-video cables to hook them all up since it's the lowest thing I have wired in the wall plate to the projector. But it looked like CRAP, so I went RGB CRT for anything pre-480p minimum. It's amusing seeing all the tricks they got away with from crappy NTSC like the water falls and pipes in Sonic not actually being transparent. Being a programmer myself, esp graphics and game programming, I KNEW the Genesis couldn't do real color addition/subtration all along, but still just actually seeing the live video feed from a real console NOT being mutilated by NTSC takes it to a whole 'nother level.
In fact I've gotten such a retro hard on I just bought a complete Sega Master System lot with every possible accessory and a bunch of games. Should be exciting as that is one console I never actually owned or played much on, if at all. It supports RGB too out of the box, same cable as the Genesis model 1. I think the original Phantasy Star is what I'll play first.
Not 50 feet away from me where I set up my retro gaming room is a 106" 1080p screen courtesy a AE4000U projector and a Denon THX DTS 7.1 receiver powering 200 lb 5 foot tall Definitive Technology 1000 watt powered towers. And there
sits my XBox 360 and a Wii, and even my PS2, Dreamcast, Gamecube, with about 3-4 dozen of the best games for the newest of the bunch the 360. Hasn't been powered on in about 3 months now. I did have the Wii on for Final Fantasy IV After Years a couple months ago though, I think that's what started my current retro binge actually. Oh wait, I had a GTA3 San Andreas binge earlier this year on the 360... only realized how terribad emulation is when I tried it in my original XBox with a 16x DVD drive on a regular 19" shitty CRT just to see. I got bored quickly with Modern Warfare and Black Ops... it's like... didn't I play this stuff on my PC 10 years ago?
I just got tired of all the recycled ADHD garbage on the new consoles. Game companies know it too. That's why they are pushing out all their old games on consoles and portables, (in addition to the something for nothing profit model for re releasing old stuff I'm sure). All it did for me was remind me how awesome the 16 bit era was and dig out my old stuff all over again. And here I am checking the shipping status of the $200 Pier Solar RPG cartridge I just bought for the Sega Genesis.
Walked into a game store here looking to snag some deals on some used games I missed for the newer systems... sad how the employees are talking about the latest games and are pissing their pants excited because "you can blow stuff up and shoot people and it's realistic!1!!". Yeah... k... today's ADHD kids buy it up because they don't know any better, content with their 13 versions of Call of Duty and Rock Band have no clue how good things used to be before EA and Activision starting pulling the strings with their franchising. Yea lets buy up all the small outfits making *good* games, take the one following the safest generic formula that posts sales in the first hour, milk it to the ground and dump and cancel everything else while never releasing the rights so the original devs can finish the project.
I remember being hyped and crazy over Final Fantasy 7 just like everyone else and had it the day it was out rushing home to play... sadly disappointed compared to 4, 5, and 6. That reminds me, need a Sony PSx SCART cable so I can play Xenogears on a REAL PS1 for the first time instead of that horribad jerky stuttering emulation that the PS2 provides.
16 bit > *