*what if* you found a large diamond on the floor of an establishment...

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

BigSmooth

Lifer
Aug 18, 2000
10,484
12
81
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
You'd just hope that it's not one of these diamond. If you lose a diamond, how would you feel?

wow!!! are these prices the average prices? 1 karat diamont costs $14K!!!!!

damn you DeBeers

Those are artificial diamonds, a real one would cost you quite a bit more.
No it wouldn't. A real diamond of that size, even the highest quality diamond, would likely cost you quite a bit less than $14K.
 

ragazzo

Golden Member
Jan 9, 2002
1,759
0
0
the law states that you have to turn whatever you've found in an establishment. after 30 (or was it 90?) days and no one has come to claim it, then it's yours.

however, in your situation, you should get the thing appraised. if it's a real diamond, tell your manager that you've found a gem. if anyone comes looking for it, they should call you and tell them what was lost and the carat.
 

ragazzo

Golden Member
Jan 9, 2002
1,759
0
0
Originally posted by: BigSmooth
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
You'd just hope that it's not one of these diamond. If you lose a diamond, how would you feel?

wow!!! are these prices the average prices? 1 karat diamont costs $14K!!!!!

damn you DeBeers

Those are artificial diamonds, a real one would cost you quite a bit more.
No it wouldn't. A real diamond of that size, even the highest quality diamond, would likely cost you quite a bit less than $14K.

a nice 1 carat diamond can be had for about $5k.
 

hevnsnt

Lifer
Mar 18, 2000
10,868
1
0
Originally posted by: rh71
and you don't know if it's real but if it is - it's worth quite a few grand...

what do you do ?

rh71: I think you better do whatever it takes to find its owner.. Otherwise my opinion of you will be correct.
 

kranky

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
21,019
156
106
Originally posted by: kenshorin
All's I got to say to all the people who say they would do the "right" thing is... give me an f'in break. My ass would be at a pawn shop faster than you can say "It's all about the benjamins, baby".

It's interesting that while not only do you want to keep something that doesn't belong to you, you feel the need to ridicule people who would make an effort to return it.
 

sillymofo

Banned
Aug 11, 2003
5,817
2
0
Originally posted by: ragazzo
Originally posted by: BigSmooth
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
You'd just hope that it's not one of these diamond. If you lose a diamond, how would you feel?
wow!!! are these prices the average prices? 1 karat diamont costs $14K!!!!!
damn you DeBeers
Those are artificial diamonds, a real one would cost you quite a bit more.
No it wouldn't. A real diamond of that size, even the highest quality diamond, would likely cost you quite a bit less than $14K.
a nice 1 carat diamond can be had for about $5k.
You guys totally missed it, it's the sentimental value of wearing your loved one on a finger, not the diamond.

And to answer mugs' question about real vs artificial, try comparing girl to blow up dolls (may be not a very good analogy, but, you get the idea).
 

Rufio

Banned
Mar 18, 2003
4,638
0
0
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
Originally posted by: ragazzo
Originally posted by: BigSmooth
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
You'd just hope that it's not one of these diamond. If you lose a diamond, how would you feel?
wow!!! are these prices the average prices? 1 karat diamont costs $14K!!!!!
damn you DeBeers
Those are artificial diamonds, a real one would cost you quite a bit more.
No it wouldn't. A real diamond of that size, even the highest quality diamond, would likely cost you quite a bit less than $14K.
a nice 1 carat diamond can be had for about $5k.
You guys totally missed it, it's the sentimental value of wearing your loved one on a finger, not the diamond.

And to answer mugs' question about real vs artificial, try comparing girl to blow up dolls (may be not a very good analogy, but, you get the idea).

you're right...
that is a horrible analogy.

if you put a real and artifical diamond next to one another, i bet you most people can't tell the difference.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
Originally posted by: hevnsnt
Originally posted by: rh71
and you don't know if it's real but if it is - it's worth quite a few grand...

what do you do ?

rh71: I think you better do whatever it takes to find its owner.. Otherwise my opinion of you will be correct.
Heh, if that's the case, what do I have to lose ? :confused:
 

Shockwave

Banned
Sep 16, 2000
9,059
0
0
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
You'd just hope that it's not one of these diamond. If you lose a diamond, how would you feel?

wow!!! are these prices the average prices? 1 karat diamont costs $14K!!!!!

damn you DeBeers

Those are artificial diamonds, a real one would cost you quite a bit more.

The prices for these natural colored diamonds can easily top $100,000 per carat, with some reaching well over $1,000,000.

Artificial diamonds ARE "real" diamonds, they just aren't found in nature. I hope they catch on, I wouldn't mind seeing De Beers screwed over. I'm not sure if they've started making uncolored artificial diamonds yet, they started with the colored ones because there's so much more profit in them.

The only obstacle to artificial diamonds is people's preconceived notions that they're "not the same." Apparantly paying 10 times more for the same thing shows how much you really care though.

One downside to cheap diamonds would be that they'd probably become really popular with people who have terrible taste, and they'd lose some of their "special"ness

Gemesis. Theres one other but I cant think of the name of it right off. Supposedly the Gemesis diamonds are so good you cant tell the difference between them and the naturals. Also, thay say they can turn out a karat in like 3 days if I remember correctly. Ironically enough, the machines to make them? Russian. The Russians couldnt ever perfect the process, some guy bought the machines, had a few University smarty pants come computerize them and pow. There crankin out as good of diamonds as can be found.
 

Shockwave

Banned
Sep 16, 2000
9,059
0
0
I'd like to say I'd keep it. Normally I would just to work you guys up.
Fact is, I'm very concious of my actions. Hell, I give back change at the gas station/fast food place if I get too much..... :confused:

Sometimes morals suck :frown:
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,508
146
Originally posted by: Shockwave
I'd like to say I'd keep it. Normally I would just to work you guys up.
Fact is, I'm very concious of my actions. Hell, I give back change at the gas station/fast food place if I get too much..... :confused:

Sometimes morals suck :frown:

Morals never suck, because the odds are ALWAYS in your favor. You benefit far more from morality than you will ever lose to it. There is one of you, and billions of other people. The only reason you are alive and can claim any security in your property is the existence of morality.
 

Nanotech

Senior member
Mar 10, 2004
958
0
0
Originally posted by: rh71
and you don't know if it's real but if it is - it's worth quite a few grand...

what do you do ?

Take it to my friend who's father owns a Jewelry establishment and let there diamond expert determine its worth free of charge.

Too bad this didn't happen to me. I most likely could have just had them sell it for me as well.
 

Shockwave

Banned
Sep 16, 2000
9,059
0
0
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Shockwave
I'd like to say I'd keep it. Normally I would just to work you guys up.
Fact is, I'm very concious of my actions. Hell, I give back change at the gas station/fast food place if I get too much..... :confused:

Sometimes morals suck :frown:

Morals never suck, because the odds are ALWAYS in your favor. You benefit far more from morality than you will ever lose to it. There is one of you, and billions of other people. The only reason you are alive and can claim any security in your property is the existence of morality.

Yeah yeah, dont be gettin all sappy on me Amused. :p
 

sillymofo

Banned
Aug 11, 2003
5,817
2
0
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Gemesis. Theres one other but I cant think of the name of it right off. Supposedly the Gemesis diamonds are so good you cant tell the difference between them and the naturals. Also, thay say they can turn out a karat in like 3 days if I remember correctly. Ironically enough, the machines to make them? Russian. The Russians couldnt ever perfect the process, some guy bought the machines, had a few University smarty pants come computerize them and pow. There crankin out as good of diamonds as can be found.
I think I saw this in a Bond movie :D.

But, get back to the real vs fake. It's true that most people can't tell the difference between cubic zirconia vs a real diamond, let alone the different grades and colors and clarity. But, you do! The value of authenticity is not because it looks identical, but because the rarity of it.
 

Shockwave

Banned
Sep 16, 2000
9,059
0
0
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Gemesis. Theres one other but I cant think of the name of it right off. Supposedly the Gemesis diamonds are so good you cant tell the difference between them and the naturals. Also, thay say they can turn out a karat in like 3 days if I remember correctly. Ironically enough, the machines to make them? Russian. The Russians couldnt ever perfect the process, some guy bought the machines, had a few University smarty pants come computerize them and pow. There crankin out as good of diamonds as can be found.
I think I saw this in a Bond movie :D.

But, get back to the real vs fake. It's true that most people can't tell the difference between cubic zirconia vs a real diamond, let alone the different grades and colors and clarity. But, you do! The value of authenticity is not because it looks identical, but because the rarity of it.

Agreed. But, the point is if a less the upright company wanted to, they could dump "fake" "authentics" on the market and no one would know. Same composition, just different means to obtain it.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,508
146
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Shockwave
I'd like to say I'd keep it. Normally I would just to work you guys up.
Fact is, I'm very concious of my actions. Hell, I give back change at the gas station/fast food place if I get too much..... :confused:

Sometimes morals suck :frown:

Morals never suck, because the odds are ALWAYS in your favor. You benefit far more from morality than you will ever lose to it. There is one of you, and billions of other people. The only reason you are alive and can claim any security in your property is the existence of morality.

Yeah yeah, dont be gettin all sappy on me Amused. :p

No sap, just the cold, hard truth. If more people would take an objective look at why morality exists and why it is essential to any society we'd be a lot better off.

The problem is, people have no idea why morality exists and how it will ALWAYS benefit them far more then it will ever cost them. They are so short sighted they think they gain something by breaking morality when, in reality, the example they have set will cost them many times more than what they gained over the course of their life.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
being $10-$15k richer these days would change the course of my life. ;)
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,508
146
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
Originally posted by: Shockwave
Gemesis. Theres one other but I cant think of the name of it right off. Supposedly the Gemesis diamonds are so good you cant tell the difference between them and the naturals. Also, thay say they can turn out a karat in like 3 days if I remember correctly. Ironically enough, the machines to make them? Russian. The Russians couldnt ever perfect the process, some guy bought the machines, had a few University smarty pants come computerize them and pow. There crankin out as good of diamonds as can be found.
I think I saw this in a Bond movie :D.

But, get back to the real vs fake. It's true that most people can't tell the difference between cubic zirconia vs a real diamond, let alone the different grades and colors and clarity. But, you do! The value of authenticity is not because it looks identical, but because the rarity of it.

Agreed. But, the point is if a less the upright company wanted to, they could dump "fake" "authentics" on the market and no one would know. Same composition, just different means to obtain it.

The reality here is that if "fakes" can be made that are totally indistinguishable from the real ones, than diamonds will cease to be a precious commodity.

This happened to aluminum at one time in history as well.
 

Rufio

Banned
Mar 18, 2003
4,638
0
0
Originally posted by: Nanotech
Originally posted by: rh71
and you don't know if it's real but if it is - it's worth quite a few grand...

what do you do ?

Take it to my friend who's father owns a Jewelry establishment and let there diamond expert determine its worth free of charge.

Too bad this didn't happen to me. I most likely could have just had them sell it for me as well.

work with rh71 and get a cut!!

HHAHHAHAHA
diamond fencing!!
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,508
146
Originally posted by: rh71
being $10-$15k richer these days would change the course of my life. ;)

Yes, but how much will you pay in theft insurance over the course of your life? How much will you lose to thieves over the course of your life? How much in lost property will never be returned to you over the course of your life?

How much will be saved by others acting morally instead of taking your things when they have the chance?

The golden rule exists for a reason. That reason is not fear of a god or sappy sentiments, but the cold hard reality that you don't want people screwing you, therefore you cannot screw other people. It is the very backbone of a civilized society.
 

Kristi2k

Golden Member
Oct 25, 2003
1,364
4
81
Originally posted by: KarenMarie
Whomever lost it, will be absolutely crushed if it is real. I can only imagine what that would feel like. How long and hard someone had to work for the money.... yikes! It probably fell out of the setting.

I would have to say that I would tell the manager of the establishment that I foung a diamond and leave my number. If someone came looking for it, to call me.

I could never keep it or sell it knowing that someone else was heart broken.

Same here. It probably has a lot of meaning to it as well. Engagement ring.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: rh71
being $10-$15k richer these days would change the course of my life. ;)

Yes, but how much will you pay in theft insurance over the course of your life? How much will you lose to thieves over the course of your life? How much in lost property will never be returned to you over the course of your life?

How much will be saved by others acting morally instead of taking your things when they have the chance?

The golden rule exists for a reason. That reason is not fear of a god or sappy sentiments, but the cold hard reality that you don't want people screwing you, therefore you cannot screw other people. It is the very backbone of a civilized society.
I don't know if I personally take it that far. I personally just feel bad someone lost something that's not easily replaceable and would like to see if I can get it back to them. I don't believe in fate, nor God, nor "no good deed goes unnoticed", etc. I simply feel bad if I were to keep it without making an attempt first. Afterward, it's MINE baby.

I found a watch while in the dorms a few years back and I posted a sign on the girl's bathroom door (it was found in that hallway)... and a few days later, some girls came knocking and very grateful... but that's where it ended. It's a feel-good but too bad you don't get to keep it feeling.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,508
146
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: rh71
being $10-$15k richer these days would change the course of my life. ;)

Yes, but how much will you pay in theft insurance over the course of your life? How much will you lose to thieves over the course of your life? How much in lost property will never be returned to you over the course of your life?

How much will be saved by others acting morally instead of taking your things when they have the chance?

The golden rule exists for a reason. That reason is not fear of a god or sappy sentiments, but the cold hard reality that you don't want people screwing you, therefore you cannot screw other people. It is the very backbone of a civilized society.
I don't know if I personally take it that far. I personally just feel bad someone lost something that's not easily replaceable and would like to see if I can get it back to them. I don't believe in fate, nor God, nor "no good deed goes unnoticed", etc. I simply feel bad if I were to keep it without making an attempt first. Afterward, it's MINE baby.

The golden rule asks for nothing more than an honest attempt to find the real owner. Why? Because that is what you wish others would do if you lost something.

And morality must always be viewed by the big picture. Empathy is fine, and I'm glad you feel it, but many people have little to no empathy for others. Therefore the logical reason of why morality exists must be remembered and taught to others.
 

KarenMarie

Elite Member
Sep 20, 2003
14,372
6
81
Originally posted by: MustISO
I found an AMEX gold card last night. I turned it in because it's probably not easy to do anything with the card. Now a diamond or cash...

We got a phone call from on of the b/f's credit card companies the day before yesterday. they were a bit concerned cause ... well, they wanted to know if he made 1) a purchase of $2,645.00 from Tower Records and $6,500.00 purchase from Newegg, and a purchase for $699.00 for something else ... all were to be delivered to Michagan (we are in NJ)... needless to say that we did NOT make these purchases.

Hahaha!!
:)
 

Aharami

Lifer
Aug 31, 2001
21,205
165
106
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: Aharami
Originally posted by: cr4zymofo
You'd just hope that it's not one of these diamond. If you lose a diamond, how would you feel?

wow!!! are these prices the average prices? 1 karat diamont costs $14K!!!!!

damn you DeBeers

Those are artificial diamonds, a real one would cost you quite a bit more.

The prices for these natural colored diamonds can easily top $100,000 per carat, with some reaching well over $1,000,000.

Artificial diamonds ARE "real" diamonds, they just aren't found in nature. I hope they catch on, I wouldn't mind seeing De Beers screwed over. I'm not sure if they've started making uncolored artificial diamonds yet, they started with the colored ones because there's so much more profit in them.

The only obstacle to artificial diamonds is people's preconceived notions that they're "not the same." Apparantly paying 10 times more for the same thing shows how much you really care though.

One downside to cheap diamonds would be that they'd probably become really popular with people who have terrible taste, and they'd lose some of their "special"ness

yea i read the story on wired magazine a while back that talked about the 2 companies making artificial diamonds now (by 2 different methods) and how they have to constantly watch their back in fear of DeBeers "hitmen". They are taking away a lot of profit from DeBeers and DeBeers is not happy. It spoke about how Debeers is 10 times worse than MS in terms of monopolizing the market, but noone can do anything cuz they are too big, too rich, and too powerful.

as per your comment on
"The only obstacle to artificial diamonds is people's preconceived notions that they're "not the same." Apparantly paying 10 times more for the same thing shows how much you really care though."
I was talking to friend's gf (she's kinda high maintainance) and was telling her about what I read and how these cultured diamonds are more perfect than natural ones...even though it costs less...and she was like "Ew NO WAY. i want the real thing on my finger" I almost told her "yea, either way, you'll have a lump of good looking carbon on you finger"...but i didnt
i feel sorry for my friend