I think everyone's experience with VoiceStream Wireless differs depending on:
1) Your geographical region.
2) Your calling habits, if you call long distance and roam a lot.
3) Your cell phone and your expectations of the company.
rootaxs (Houston, TX) and I (Portland, Oregon) haven't had any major problems with VoiceStream and are satisfied with the service we have received. We both posted in
this thread.
If you really want to gauge New Yorkers opinions of VoiceStream your best bet is to read the close to 200 posts in the UseNet NewsGroup
alt.cellular.gsm.carriers.voicestream (all 200 posts pertain to NY so there'll be a lot of reading).
Of course VoiceStream is far from perfect:
1) I wish they had better coverage in Oregon, especially between Portland and the coast.
2) I haven't really experienced a lot of rude CSRs since I rarely have to call them but they seem pretty clueless.
3) Even though my Nokia 6190 had a 1 year manufacturer's warranty, I was charged $70 to replace it 8 months after sending it in. I'm still in the process of disputing this charge with VoiceStream.
4) Nationwide coverage is no where as good as AT&T Wireless, Sprint PCS and Verizon.
5) If you do a lot of long distance calling and/or roam VoiceStream is NOT the most cost effective provider for you, look elsewhere.
Bang for buck I could not resist VoiceStream's 2,600 minutes a month for $39.99, 600 weekday anytime and 2,000 nationwide free long distance weekend minutes, great Nokia phones, online billing, SMS, the works!