What A Weigh To Go.

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

jagec

Lifer
Apr 30, 2004
24,442
6
81
Originally posted by: Mojoed
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: OdiN
wtf....

280 is overwieght and 300 is morbidly obese?

lol

umm...you honestly think 300 is a perfectly normal acceptable weight? The only people who can carry a "healthy" 300 are the truly massive football players...and they quickly go to crap once they retire and stop exercising all the time.

Besides, "morbid obesity" is defined as being >=100 lbs. overweight, or having a BMI of 40 or above. You can argue about the applicability of the BMI for some special cases, but for the vast majority of people that's a perfectly valid, medical definition. And it ain't healthy.

30 or above is actually considered obese. My BMI is 33.1. I am 6'3 and 265 lbs. and not fat at all. My resting heart rate is 48. I think BMI should just go away.

Again, special case. I bet the two in the article were "average Americans" in that they didn't exercise/lift weights...so in their case, it was indeed very unhealthy.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: Jeff7
The reigning champion was about the guy who walked a tightrope, by himself, across the Han river.

"Skywalker Crosses Han Solo"
For real? That's great!
Seems it was originally at Yahoo news, but has since expired. Just search for it on Google, with quotes around the entire headline.
 

OdiN

Banned
Mar 1, 2000
16,430
3
0
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: OdiN
wtf....

280 is overwieght and 300 is morbidly obese?

lol

umm...you honestly think 300 is a perfectly normal acceptable weight? The only people who can carry a "healthy" 300 are the truly massive football players...and they quickly go to crap once they retire and stop exercising all the time.

Besides, "morbid obesity" is defined as being >=100 lbs. overweight, or having a BMI of 40 or above. You can argue about the applicability of the BMI for some special cases, but for the vast majority of people that's a perfectly valid, medical definition. And it ain't healthy.

I never said it was healthy or anything.

Just that the disparity between the weights is not much at all. 20lbs.

I would think that if they want to call 300lbs morbidly obese, then 280 should seem like the same thing.

And it depends on the person.

Definitely unhealthy but just odd to see that.
 

Mojoed

Diamond Member
Jul 20, 2004
4,473
1
81
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: Mojoed
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: OdiN
wtf....

280 is overwieght and 300 is morbidly obese?

lol

umm...you honestly think 300 is a perfectly normal acceptable weight? The only people who can carry a "healthy" 300 are the truly massive football players...and they quickly go to crap once they retire and stop exercising all the time.

Besides, "morbid obesity" is defined as being >=100 lbs. overweight, or having a BMI of 40 or above. You can argue about the applicability of the BMI for some special cases, but for the vast majority of people that's a perfectly valid, medical definition. And it ain't healthy.

30 or above is actually considered obese. My BMI is 33.1. I am 6'3 and 265 lbs. and not fat at all. My resting heart rate is 48. I think BMI should just go away.

Again, special case. I bet the two in the article were "average Americans" in that they didn't exercise/lift weights...so in their case, it was indeed very unhealthy.

Understood. :beer:
 
Mar 10, 2005
14,647
2
0
Originally posted by: NeuroSynapsis
Originally posted by: BrokenVisage
Doesn't surprise me that most of you guys find it funny yet show no remorse about the deceased, that ironic stigma of "ATOT Against Fatties" rears is ugly head once again. Yes, I thought the headline was damn funny and a great play-on-words, but unlike most of you who are probably just interjecting all the taunting and being picked on you endured while growing up, I sincerely feel bad for these people and those who now have to handle the funeral arrangements for them.

their immediate family is going to have to weigh in on all their options

:Disgust;

that's really how i feel, "smileyfaceisgusted" good joke tho :D

100% true story:
friend #1 was sent to check up on the creepy old uncle. he brings friend #2. the house really does look like it fell straight out of a horror movie: huge, dilapidated, alone on a hill, ominous sky, the works. i lived across the street, but didn't meet these guys 'til a couple years later. the doors and windows are locked, and they can't see in the windows due to the filth and garbage piled high. they spot a window on the second floor that's cracked open. friend #2 (the skinny one) shimmies up the tree and in through the window. turns out, the window was in the creepy uncle's master bedroom. creepy uncle was laying dead in bed for maybe 2 weeks, in the middle of a hot summer, and the second floor was ripe as hell. when the coroners took him away, the body cracked open, dumping the liquified remains. my friends were there for that, and they say on a scale of 1-10, the disgust reached 15, maybe 20. the biohazard circus wasn't done, though. as the coroners took out the huge and now broken body, they kept knocking down, tripping on and falling over a century's worth of newspapers and porn piled from the first floor to the attic. i'm told the best was when a 7 or 8 foot stack toppled over onto the uncle, and everybody let out a giant "WTF?".

friend #1 and his dad moved into the house. lotsa good times partying in the house of horrors. i immediately became desensitized to pornography. ancient nudist magazines, fetish, you name it, creepy uncle subscribed to it. we found an 8mm projector and a box of films in the attic. among my gang of degenerates, the favorite was decided to be "Dog Bite" featuring a voluptuous redhead and a very big dog. the basement still contained a very large collection of multicolored jars, some translucent, some opaque. nobody dared open a single one.