Originally posted by: tcsenter
Unfortunately, not even Affirmative Action's most ardent defenders can claim that AA is accomplishing its most basic intent: to give "disadvantaged" blacks an advantage in the selection process so the "playing field will be level".
Some 70% - 80% of all allocated Affirmative Action "slots" reserved for blacks in the nation's largest colleges and universities are being filled, not by blacks from "disadvantaged" schools or families, but by the children of well-to-do blacks whose incomes put them in the top 5% of black wage-earners in the United States.
Meaning, Affirmative Action is doing little more than giving a race-based advantage, not a means-based advantage, to black kids who have all of the "perceived" advantages that white kids enjoy - good schools, stable family environments, and parents who can afford their children's secondary education.
It is not lost on the Great List of all Things Ironic how it could do service to the concept of "equality" to give preferential treatment in academic selection to the child of a black physician who makes $250,000 annually and was never a slave over the child of a white Walmart cashier who makes $25,000 annually and never owned slaves, under the guise that the black child would not be able to compete with the white child because it is merely presumed that the white child has all these 'alleged' advantages.
What is also not lost is that, since the children of affluent blacks have all the advantages of affluent whites, they should not need preferential treatment in order to compete with the children of lower-earning and middle-class whites, but the academically mediocre children of affluent black families are given spots before the academically talented children of lower-income whites, rewarding blacks simply for being black, not for being "disadvantaged", and punishing whites for being white, not for being "advantaged".
If I didn't know any better, I'd swear I was on that Bizarro Superman Planet where up is down, the sky is green, and the grass is blue.