Depends on how the fight pans out. If its a FFA its anyones guess. In that case the SSD would probably lose cause everyone would gang bang the massive ship. Once it went down depending on how many transformers were left and how much damage the SDF-1 and Enterprise had taken it would be between 1 of those 3.
If however it was who would win 1-on-1 its still a toss up between Robotech and the SSD. The veritechs would have their hands full with all of the TIE fighters. SDF-1 with its super gun would be able to inflict some massive damage on the SSD. But it would NOT be able to kill it in 1 shot. If the SDF-1 can recharge quickly enough to fire 2 more shots for the kill they would win. But if they rechage too slow the super gun would get destroyed before it could fire again. Once that happens SDF-1 is toast and destroying all the veritechs is just a matter of time.
If however it was who would win 1-on-1 its still a toss up between Robotech and the SSD. The veritechs would have their hands full with all of the TIE fighters. SDF-1 with its super gun would be able to inflict some massive damage on the SSD. But it would NOT be able to kill it in 1 shot. If the SDF-1 can recharge quickly enough to fire 2 more shots for the kill they would win. But if they rechage too slow the super gun would get destroyed before it could fire again. Once that happens SDF-1 is toast and destroying all the veritechs is just a matter of time.
DainBramaged
Lifer
- Jun 19, 2003
- 23,454
- 41
- 91
So
Lifer
- Jul 2, 2001
- 25,923
- 17
- 81
I'd like to point out that the enterprise has no starfighters with which to get inside the shields of the SSD, so...they have to cruise inside the SSD's shields and they're dead from counter fire before you get to step 1. Remember, the starfighters did it b/c they were fast and tiny targets. Shuttlecraft could not do the same job.
Originally posted by: Optimus
Voltron: 5 lions / one robot. Would kick some arse but would be overwhelmed.
Transformers: How many are we talking? All of them would be, like, 300 robots. Thats pretty deadly. Or are we talking Gen 1 Decepticons only?
Robotech: Do you mean Valkyrie Squadrons? Or Valkyries, Ground Mech's, and enemy mecha all joined forces? Because thats a whole WAR's worth of robots, albeit piloted by humans (decreased accuracy and response times).
Power Rangers: Cannon fodder.
Enterprise: Would take out a couple enemies but would quickly be overwhelemed by the sheer number of Transformers and Robotech Mecha. Shields would hold long enough to do some real damage, but phasers are slow to target and fire against many smaller targets. Photon torpedos would take out some of the larger transformers like Galvatron and Omega Supreme. Likely they would focus on the Star Destroyer instead (see below).
Star Destroyer: Slow, but powerful. Would most likely engage the Enterprise in direct combat, but would lose based on the number of photon torpedos the Enterprise would get fired off before both ships were overwhelemed by Transformers and Valkyries.
In the end, the Power Rangers and Voltron would be toast within minutes of the battle starting. All battle long Robotech mecha and transformers would fall, likely at a rate of 10 to 1. Enterprise and the Star Destroyer would basically waste each other and be finished off by swarms of mecha and transformers. Then the whole thing would hinge on numbers as to whether the Robotech mecha could just overwhelm the better fighting transformers.
God I'm such a nerd.
Dude, the SSD has what? 240 Turbolasers? 120 Ion Cannons? Not to mention, 6 squadrons of TIE Fighters, 4 sqauds of TIE Interceptors, 2 squads of TIE bombers, etc. SSD pwns all.
So
Lifer
- Jul 2, 2001
- 25,923
- 17
- 81
Pfeh. The eclipse may have been impressive, but IIRC it wasn't that much bitter than a classic SSD (if I'm wrong I'll retract my statement) and it's superweapon couldn't fire frequently, considering that there were 5-20 SSD's built in the SW universe, say ~3 of them, with a competenet leader and a decent screen of ISDs providing cover should be able to take the eclipse down and cost less.
Yeah, if you got a fleet of SSDs together, it would pwn just about anything, but hell, there were 250+ SDs made, you get all those together and its mad pwnage.
And I retract my ESD statement. Give me a sun crusher.
haha sh!t, if you're bringing in all aspects of each "sci-fi universe" into play, that'd be one crazy battle royale...
also, if you were to, would you bring in both good and evil sides? i mean, unicron's a pretty crazy baby...
but if you were, you'd have a death star also...
but if you were to use Robotech, and have the SDF1, SDF2, SDF3, and that one ship that's 900 miles long, i'd imagine that'd be a formidable foe.
Star Trek would be crazy. get enterprise, voyager, all the stealth klingon ships, and the BORG. hmm.. assimilate everything...
K1052
Elite Member
- Aug 21, 2003
- 53,673
- 48,263
- 136
That depends on if the SSD's shields are keeping out projectiles in that particular scene.
If so, use Runabouts to get in close and take out the sheild generators.
If not, just torpedo the shield generators and start transporting quantum torpedos into she SSD's magazines and engine spaces.
Originally posted by: K1052
That depends on if the SSD's shields are keeping out projectiles in that particular scene.
If so, use Runabouts to get in close and take out the sheild generators.
If not, just torpedo the shield generators and start transporting quantum torpedos into she SSD's magazines and engine spaces.
Execpt one broad side from a SSD would pwn the enterprise. SSD=8 KILOMETERS long!
So
Lifer
- Jul 2, 2001
- 25,923
- 17
- 81
Originally posted by: K1052
That depends on if the SSD's shields are keeping out projectiles in that particular scene.
If so, use Runabouts to get in close and take out the sheild generators.
If not, just torpedo the shield generators and start transporting quantum torpedos into she SSD's magazines and engine spaces.
Since the enterprise never had runabouts, and they'd STILL probably get blown away by the SSD's close in AA, that seems unlikely. And clearly, there is some sort of projectile protection, or the Rebels would have just used their own proton torpedos.
Originally posted by: So
Originally posted by: K1052
That depends on if the SSD's shields are keeping out projectiles in that particular scene.
If so, use Runabouts to get in close and take out the sheild generators.
If not, just torpedo the shield generators and start transporting quantum torpedos into she SSD's magazines and engine spaces.
Since the enterprise never had runabouts, and they'd STILL probably get blown away by the SSD's close in AA, that seems unlikely. And clearly, there is some sort of projectile protection, or the Rebels would have just used their own proton torpedos.
Particle and Ray shields.
So
Lifer
- Jul 2, 2001
- 25,923
- 17
- 81
Originally posted by: L3p3rM355i4h
Originally posted by: K1052
That depends on if the SSD's shields are keeping out projectiles in that particular scene.
If so, use Runabouts to get in close and take out the sheild generators.
If not, just torpedo the shield generators and start transporting quantum torpedos into she SSD's magazines and engine spaces.
Execpt one broad side from a SSD would pwn the enterprise. SSD=8 KILOMETERS long!
(with, as I said above...hundreds of turbolasers, EACH capable of annhilating an asteroid -- so easily able to independantly pop the enterprise's shields and probably destory her.
TRENDING THREADS
-
Discussion Zen 5 Speculation (EPYC Turin and Strix Point/Granite Ridge - Ryzen 9000)- Started by DisEnchantment
- Replies: 25K
-
Discussion Intel Meteor, Arrow, Lunar & Panther Lakes + WCL Discussion Threads
- Started by Tigerick
- Replies: 24K
-
Discussion Intel current and future Lakes & Rapids thread- Started by TheF34RChannel
- Replies: 23K
-
-
Facebook
Twitter