-update- I am back "home", sort of... still seeking advice

Page 8 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

EmperorIQ

Platinum Member
Sep 30, 2003
2,003
0
0
Originally posted by: StormRider
Good grief, I hope this isn't the typical asian household. My parents never hit or yelled at me -- Never. I, however, have yelled at my mom before -- something which I am not proud of.

I cannot relate to 90% of this story. An 18 year old running away without any shoes with his father chasing after him? That sounds weird. I've never heard of something like that in my family.

The thing I can relate to is that my parents also told me not to get a job and to just concentrate on studying while in college. No social life either. So, I basically did as told and spent practically all my time at Hornbake Library studying. When I graduated and got a job, my parents bought their own restaurant and I was expected to help out. I was hoping to be able to start having a social life -- but oh well. The years piled on and pretty soon I realized I was a 37 year old man who never really had a social life and became really resentful and angry at my parents. During the years, I had asked them if it would be okay if I stopped helping out so I could concentrate on my career and life for awhile. But they kind of ignored me and seemed to be more concerned with my younger brothers who were kind of going in the wrong path in life. My resentment grew as I saw them turn away applicants and telling them they didn't need help -- and yet they wanted me to help. During those years I felt that they were purposely holding me back to control me so I would always be there for them.

Then my mom asked me if I wanted help in finding a girl. She said my cousin had gone to China and gotten a wife and it was really easy. I kind of exploded and told her that she was the last person I would ask for help in that area -- that would be like a man accepting help to cross the street from the person who chopped his legs off. It was then that my mom finally understood how much I hated helping out at the restaurant all those years and I haven't had to work there for the last few years.

Luckily things are now much better between my parents and I. My anger and resentment are now pretty much gone and our relationship is pretty good (from my perspective). I eat dinner with them once a week and keep in touch all the time.

So, my advice is to put some distance between you and your parents. Hopefully in the future, you will be able to have a good relationship with them.


Originally posted by: jjyiz28
that is a typical asian household. seriously, suck it up. finished college. get a job, then move out and never see your parents again. pay them all back for what they have given you, then cut off communication and live your own life.

be a man, don't be such a crybaby. while ur living with them, just grit ur teeth.
them hitting you is not wrong if you are in the wrong. if they are int he wrong, AND they hit you, well that sucks, but sh!t like that happens alot in asian families. im mostly inthe right with my mom, my dad is koo. my parents never apologized for anything they did, or any mistakes they have done. while me i have to apologize even when i know i am right. grow up. they mean well. but when you get older, you can afford to cut off yoru ties and never see them again if you wish.

Not, talking to idontknow, but hey, i know how you felt about your parents making you help out with the family business. Same thing happened to me, However, i began to see what they were doing and realized that my parents were too caught up in "family", "Culture", and bla bla bla (stupid asian beliefs) to care that i had a social life, and being a teenager, i also felt that i was important that i got to know people and actually work for others so i can have some kind of record that i have had previous jobs. Me helping out at my parent's restaurant lasted a short time, i now do still help them out whenever they need it (big parties resreved, etc.) but they understand. Sorry, just wanted to share that. . . .
 

iamme

Lifer
Jul 21, 2001
21,058
3
0
just read your update :(

do you have any friends that you can stay with? maybe some who live in dorms?

be sure to take socks and shoes!
 

Wow, I think you need to contact your local PD again, and have them transfer you to a lieutenant or a sergeant. That's crazy...make sure you tell the police that they'll be responsible if anything happens to you, since you already tried calling them. They won't really be responsible, but it mght, at the least, light a fire under someone's ass. Also, have the police give you the number of your local health and human services/foster care agency. The most important thing for you now is to get into a warm, friendly home environment.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
Originally posted by: StormRider
I'm first generation Chinese -- I was born here but my parents were born in China. My parents have never hit me nor have they ever really yelled at me (although when I was young, I used to complain that my Dad yells -- but that's just the way he speaks English -- it sounds like he is raising his voice).

I've never seen this type of abuse in any of my cousin's family either. Never heard of such a thing. And I've been lucky in that my parents didn't constantly nag me about grades or comparing me with other asian kids who did better. In fact, in some ways they kind of did the opposite (wanting me to help out in the family restaurant instead of going off and doing my best academically and professionally).

I do not think yours is the stereotypical asian family.
Ahh... helping with the family business... the other side of the Chinese coin.

My mom was 1 of 6 kids... when she was still back in HK with all her bros/sisters, her dad (my grandfather) cared only about his business and "forced" them all to help him out. As a result a couple didn't make much of their education at all and are struggling here now in the US financially as well. Fortunately, my mom made use of what education she got and is living well enough to have given me a pretty good upbringing.

The two extremes.
 

Sunny129

Diamond Member
Nov 14, 2000
4,823
6
81
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: Sunny129
this is just ridiculous...what the hell is with the asian stereotype questions? i'm asian and i can't identify with any of you. my parents have never hit me. i've never even heard of that stereotype about asians. its news to me that asians are more likely to abuse their children...whatever.

and fvck all you people who have nothing helpful to say except to "suck it up" or "deal with it." i'll cast another vote for checking out the local churches for help. they can probably set you up with a social worker too...
What generation are your parents? Like someone said above... you're less likely to identify with this if you/your parents/your grandparents have been in America for a while.

I'm third generation myself (grandparents came here first) and still saw a little bit of the discipline... but I sure as hell won't treat my kids that way... so for my kids, they will be the same as you... never knowing what really happened "in the old days". I don't mean for it to sound so dramatic, but the truth is the truth.

i'm also 3rd generation like you...i'm Chinese, to be specific. i guess i'm just blown away that i've never known about this. i suppose i would have, but i was never the shy type who stuck to my own kind growing up...
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
Originally posted by: Sunny129
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: Sunny129
this is just ridiculous...what the hell is with the asian stereotype questions? i'm asian and i can't identify with any of you. my parents have never hit me. i've never even heard of that stereotype about asians. its news to me that asians are more likely to abuse their children...whatever.

and fvck all you people who have nothing helpful to say except to "suck it up" or "deal with it." i'll cast another vote for checking out the local churches for help. they can probably set you up with a social worker too...
What generation are your parents? Like someone said above... you're less likely to identify with this if you/your parents/your grandparents have been in America for a while.

I'm third generation myself (grandparents came here first) and still saw a little bit of the discipline... but I sure as hell won't treat my kids that way... so for my kids, they will be the same as you... never knowing what really happened "in the old days". I don't mean for it to sound so dramatic, but the truth is the truth.

i'm also 3rd generation like you...i'm Chinese, to be specific. i guess i'm just blown away that i've never known about this. i suppose i would have, but i was never the shy type who stuck to my own kind growing up...
Is your last name really Asher ?
 

MrColin

Platinum Member
May 21, 2003
2,403
3
81
The police can only help you when you want to report a particular incident of assault agianst you.
Make a copy of the extra key you used today, and like I said before try only to come home when your parents are asleep or at work, leave before they get up keep a bag packed with some non perishable food , maybe 2 meals, and a change of clothes & whatever else you might need for a quick evacuation of the house. Go to a bank and get your own account and get your money out of the joint account. Look for a job and get your paperwork in at the financial aid office at your school, update that to include student loans. Find someplace to live using those funds when they become available. Try to talk to your parents when you encounter them, without anger if possible, and tell them your plans. Instead of acting angry or making demands tell them that they are hurting you and that is why you need to leave.
PM me if you have any specific questions about how to achieve any of the above objectives, if you let people here know where you are they might offer you help in the form of rides or temporary lodging, don't be afraid.
 

Felix De Cat, I am 100% certain that it is not he, Mr. Code Dude. From my recollection, he was still in high school as of this year. Generally, people older than 18 aren't in high school, except if their real ages were hidden from the schools. Also, he's White according to his statements.

Storm Rider, thanks for explaining what should have been obvious to some. You're the man! ;)

I am at least 95% certain of who this is. You're the member who actively participates in parent related threads. However, from your past posts, you hardly indicated this much resentment. You did indicate that your parents had high expectations, but not this sign of assault/battery or anything like that. I suppose when you say you have no car, you are referring to the fact that the car you drove in the past was your parents'?

In any case, you are one of the few members I appreciate. I'm sorry about your situation. Here's the deal, for which I will not disclose your identity: Seek help in real life. From your update, it appears you have began seeking help. But wandering the streets is not the way to do it. I can understand though since you've described yourself as one who isn't fond of people. . . . What about your sibling? Have you tried to get refuge from him? Or is he as well a struggling student too poor to help you in any way? What about emotional support from your sibling? Or does he support your parents' views? You sounded so scared of your parents as if you were a minor under their spell. So I suppose contacting your relatives would be again putting you at the mercy of your parents? I guess it's moments like this that we come to realise the essence of friendship. Here's what I'll say: Sit down, ponder for a while, not under the spell of your parents. Then muster courage and speak to them. Take the courage to stand up for yourself, list things you resent that they have done to you. Speak angrily if you must. When you're done with that, I'm sure there's one thing you appreciate about them, say it. Then make it clear to them that under no circumstances will you accept that kind of behaviour if they lay a finger on you. Make clear what the consequences will be, such as charges of battery/assault if that should happen again.

You have to be able to wear courage in times like this and make the best of life. If you don't start with your parents and family, you won't be able to do it in the real world. Generally, when you step your foot down, even immigrant parents start to respect you and treat you better. However, if you cannot work things out with them, leave the expensive school you're in and go to a community college . . . well, I guess that wouldn't work for you since you've probably finished or are about to finish your GE courses. Try loans . . . you asked about that before, but speak to your advisor. Explain your circumstance and ask what options you have. You won't be able to get anything if you don't ask. As someone once said, the key to success in the USA is information. As others suggested, try non-profit organisations. If you know what available resources there are, then you are on your way to success with will power.

You're a cool person and I really wish the best for you. It's obvious from your past posts that you have never learned to be independent and still see yourself as the little kid depending upon his parents. Just calm down first and think. Using your past posts, I would think there's more story to it as far as why you have reacted this way and are so resentful . . . I mean a particular incident that led to this climax. Best of luck!

P.S.: How do you get access to the 'net? Through school, library, what? Has this whole thing affected your academic performance? I mean, how are you able to study, since this is still school time?
 

dvdrdiscs

Senior member
Oct 27, 2003
307
0
0
I'm not sure if you left your parents house yet but you should make SURE you got everything you NEED. Since this will probably be the last time you sneak back in, take all the stuff you will need like ID, Social Security card, etc. and put it in a bag. Take warm clothes too! I say at least 2 bags worth of clothes and at least 2 pairs of shoes. Don't forget to pack some food that won't perish easily as well as water.

And although I understand that you are not very sociable, now is the time to break that barrier. You NEED to get in contact with someone in case of a desperate emergency or for some assistance. If you don't have anyone's # handy, I suggest you post your location like many have suggested before. That way anyone that lives near you can maybe give you their ph# for you to have handy. Now isn't the time to keep to yourself. You NEED help which is why you're here. And I don't mean just advice.
 

PlatinumGold

Lifer
Aug 11, 2000
23,168
0
71
choosing to hide your identity is your right. but if you REALLY want help, it seems to me that you would reveal your identity. it's really difficult to give good advice based SOLELY on the info you have provided, if for NO other reason than because you have provided it at a very crucial juncture. things that you might have said when things weren't so bad are left unsaid.

again, it is your right to keep your identity hidden, but i'm curious as to why keeping your identity secret is so important where soo many more important things are happening in your life right now.
 

dvdrdiscs

Senior member
Oct 27, 2003
307
0
0
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold
choosing to hide your identity is your right. but if you REALLY want help, it seems to me that you would reveal your identity. it's really difficult to give good advice based SOLELY on the info you have provided, if for NO other reason than because you have provided it at a very crucial juncture. things that you might have said when things weren't so bad are left unsaid.

again, it is your right to keep your identity hidden, but i'm curious as to why keeping your identity secret is so important where soo many more important things are happening in your life right now.


remember he said he wasn't very sociable. i'm guessing it has to do with the way he has kept to himself.
 

PlatinumGold

Lifer
Aug 11, 2000
23,168
0
71
Originally posted by: dvdrdiscs
Originally posted by: PlatinumGold
choosing to hide your identity is your right. but if you REALLY want help, it seems to me that you would reveal your identity. it's really difficult to give good advice based SOLELY on the info you have provided, if for NO other reason than because you have provided it at a very crucial juncture. things that you might have said when things weren't so bad are left unsaid.

again, it is your right to keep your identity hidden, but i'm curious as to why keeping your identity secret is so important where soo many more important things are happening in your life right now.


remember he said he wasn't very sociable. i'm guessing it has to do with the way he has kept to himself.

mb i'm just being overly suspicious here, but it seems strange to me that he finds keeping his identity a secret soo important when there are so many more important issues at hand.

 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Originally posted by: IDoNotKnow
Yes I know I'm f*ckin writing like a f*ckin child alright!!

I'm not in the f*ckin right state of mind to type out all this sh1t in essay point format with perfect grammar and spelling. I'm shaking, I'm crying, I really don't know WTF to do anymore okay!

Pilalge, if you know who I am I hope you can respect another enough to not tell others and please remove any indiciation on showing who I am. THe mods could probably find out, maybe not, but I don't know. I jsut don't want people that I know in real life to know.

Listen, I am not trying to make excuses. I am not tryign to jsut whine. I'm really looking for advice. I"m just really damn f*ckin scared. I will plan on going back to try and get some stuff, some clothes and shoes. (ANd yes i f*ckin RAN, my dad was chasing me and would've beat me, he was alreayd grabbing stuff anytihng nearby that he can throw at me.) I will try to go to chruch first, but I don't know anyone there. I wil then try friends if nothign esle. THen army. I am so scared. i will NOT go back.

I have ran away before and I always came back. But nothing ever changed. NOthing wil change if I go back, thats why I wont'. I understand that now. I have gone through this before. But last time I said if it were to ever happen again, I will leave and never come back. I just can't do it anymore.

I think its wierd to some of you guys. Yes i hate my parents, but I don't wwnat them harm. My mom has recently been really depressed form her parents dying. I never felt sad for that, but sad that I didn't care really. I don't really care for them, but I don't want to harm them. THey are people, we are stupid, I am stupid. I'm probably at fault anyways, but f*ck, it jsut doesn't work.

jeesh now I know why they attack you...get therapy soon. You are unstable my friend, chances are your parents have a WAY different take on this situation than you are portraying.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
I've not been in your position but I really think it's best to go home to your parents and just pretend that they are right, even if they are not. Don't try to get your point across because it seems that your mother is a bit of a bitch (laughing at you then leaving and whatever else). I would simply put that stuff behind you and live with them in peace as long as is necessary for you to complete your education and move out with money and a plan.

As you've now learned going outside with no education and money sucks. Doing it puts you a c*&* hair away from being a homeless wreck on the street or suicide victim. No matter what, you don't want that.

Go home and every time your parents are giving you crap and you hate it just take it and revel in the fact that your time will come when you can leave and say screw you, but do it properly when you have a plan and future. And for that you need your education.

Plus, it's possible that with time you'll see more eye to eye. Teenagers are communcatively (new word?) incompatible with adults, but you may in time learn to understand why they do what they do (unless they are just stupid poo poo heads!).

In the meantime suck it up and go home. The alternative is not good.
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Oh yeah, my point is moot if you're being physically abused. In that case call the police because your parents deserve it.

Also, if you have to leave now the armed forces recommendations are top-notch. It's definitely the best place for an 18 year old to go if they have to run away from home and don't want to bust their ass in burger king living in a basement apartment for the rest of their lives. The armed forces will take care of you and the future is not dead end. And they'll pay for you to get the hell away from the 'rents!
 

MrColin

Platinum Member
May 21, 2003
2,403
3
81
The police told him to go find some cardboard, I know we all would like to think that help is just a phone call away, but what he needs is to fly the coop and start living independently. You can still go to college if you're independent of your parents, I did. You have to work about 30 hrs a week and maybe not finish as quickly and take loans, but it is doable.

There's no magic bullet for this and it will take years for him to resolve these issues. here are the steps to independence in outline form:
1. job
2. bank account
3. student loans
4. place to live
5. get ongoing counseling
6. sue the parents
 

DanTMWTMP

Lifer
Oct 7, 2001
15,908
19
81
i've been lurking this thread for awhile so now time to respond...

YGPM..
it's a long shot, but you said you're asian (and the last ATOT meet, 90% of 'em were asian lol)...so there's a good chance you live in so. cal.
so....if you live in so. cal...i can probably hook u up w/ some support...

i have korean parents and they were strict when i was little, but now they're pretty lenient..i'm really sorry to hear what you go through, and I understand that you do not want any harm to them...but i'll tell you this, if there is no closure btwn you and your parents now, u'll regret it forever after they die (as in when you get older and you're over 40-50+...)

it'll be just harder to talk to them over time...


so somehow, somehow you have to talk to them and clear things up....and i remember my dad despised me crying and such..he wanted me to grow up to be a strong man, and i'm sure that's the case w/ a lot of korean parents.....so try showing some courage, but don't show you're going against them in any way...but i'm sure you already know that.
 

Pepsei

Lifer
Dec 14, 2001
12,895
1
0
You watch out for luvly, she outed a few people's identity in the past.

As for Asian style parenting, my parents stop hitting me after sixth grade, but back then, even the teachers hit you.

I'm glad we moved to USA after that... no more spanking, and my parents gave me the chance to experience American education. From reading all the advices, I think you should go home, try to avoid any interactions with your parents, finish school and leave. You don't want to be another statistic.
 

Sunny129

Diamond Member
Nov 14, 2000
4,823
6
81
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: Sunny129
Originally posted by: rh71
Originally posted by: Sunny129
this is just ridiculous...what the hell is with the asian stereotype questions? i'm asian and i can't identify with any of you. my parents have never hit me. i've never even heard of that stereotype about asians. its news to me that asians are more likely to abuse their children...whatever.

and fvck all you people who have nothing helpful to say except to "suck it up" or "deal with it." i'll cast another vote for checking out the local churches for help. they can probably set you up with a social worker too...
What generation are your parents? Like someone said above... you're less likely to identify with this if you/your parents/your grandparents have been in America for a while.

I'm third generation myself (grandparents came here first) and still saw a little bit of the discipline... but I sure as hell won't treat my kids that way... so for my kids, they will be the same as you... never knowing what really happened "in the old days". I don't mean for it to sound so dramatic, but the truth is the truth.

i'm also 3rd generation like you...i'm Chinese, to be specific. i guess i'm just blown away that i've never known about this. i suppose i would have, but i was never the shy type who stuck to my own kind growing up...
Is your last name really Asher ?

yes, i'm only 1/2 chinese. my mom married an American. but my mom's sister's family is still 100% chinese, they have an only son who has never been hit by his parents.
 

"jeesh now I know why they attack you...get therapy soon. You are unstable my friend, chances are your parents have a WAY different take on this situation than you are portraying."

I was thinking the same thing, Alkemyst. It just sounds like a really weird story that would have to have been from extreme abuse case or similar. However, by his own admission even though he's been assaulted by his parents, it's not been severe cases. It's also rather odd that he hasn't mentioned seeking help from his sibling or family members, unless of course they always side with his parents and think he's got an issue.

Having uncovered his identity with now 99.99999999% assurance that it's he, I can understand his whole reaction. He's been on anti-depressant before and perhaps still is on it. Maybe his depression exacerbated his reaction to the incident in this case. In spite of that, I'm convinced that his parents' way of training has significantly affected his willingness and ability to fend for himself, speak up in circumstances such as this and handle the matter more maturely. I suspect he'll be back to normal soon, though. But I really do hope he starts to do things by himself to have some sense of independence.

Of course, the above is my opinion. Things seem to be getting better for him now that he's a little more relaxed, so good for him!
 

StormRider

Diamond Member
Mar 12, 2000
8,324
2
0
You walked six miles in barefoot?

What I don't understand is why your friend didn't loan you a pair of shoes...
 

OpTiX

Senior member
Mar 31, 2003
673
0
71
Originally posted by: StormRider
You walked six miles in barefoot?

What I don't understand is why your friend didn't loan you a pair of shoes...

same here