*UPDATE* Argument with the gf - Am I coldhearted?

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

acemcmac

Lifer
Mar 31, 2003
13,712
1
0
I have a friend who's doing the same thing, except he's ADD with money... so... jury's still out on my help...
 

Yo Ma Ma

Lifer
Jan 21, 2000
11,635
2
0
My God, where did you meet your g/f, her family sounds like they qualify for the Maury Povich show?! The mom being 30'ish, her son-in-law is 20, her 16-yo daughter is cranking them out already too.

If you help them out at all, try to make it the 'teaching them to fish' not the 'giving them a fish' kind of help.
Originally posted by: lilcam
oh ... i'm really starting to rethink this relationship. even my mom is mad and tells me i deserve better. why i still stay with her i dont know.

Asian traditions are all fvcked up if you ask me. I'm sorry if I offend the other asian ppl on this board. I'm not saying all asian, but I've seen enough especially dealing with this personally and seeing my cousins going through the same sh!t before. They got married a little over a year ago after they thought she was pregnant. I think she had a miscarriage or something. So, then I heard these two were trying to get pregnant but couldnt because he kept smoking that herb or whatever he was on. Now she actually got pregnant and they'll be messed up cuz I know damn well the girl's mother will be taking care of that kid. The 16 y/o doesnt know any better.

The guy stated awhile back that his kid would be getting a free ride from welfare. Thats cool and all if you really need it, but to abuse it and not work because you get "free" money aint coo.

and what's messed up is her mom keeps saying we make lots of money and we should contribute some to her monthly. this woman is in her mid 30s and needs to freakign work!!! my mom is in her 40s and she's working like every other folks! why should she be any different. I can't imagine what it would be like if we were rich.

 

Geekbabe

Moderator Emeritus<br>Elite Member
Oct 16, 1999
32,229
2,539
126
www.theshoppinqueen.com
Originally posted by: Ameesh
Originally posted by: Geekbabe
Originally posted by: Ameesh
Originally posted by: Geekbabe
Originally posted by: lilcam
Originally posted by: Geekbabe
Originally posted by: digitalsm
Originally posted by: Geekbabe
Your g/friend's family isn't helping "the loser" they're helping the girl and most importantly the baby.
It is very common to not really need to buy anything after the birth of your 1st child because you get so much stuff,using family handme downs on expensive items like cribs is also common and makes sense on a lot of levels.

You have been asked to help by giving a total of 2 rides,yet you're going on and on as if you've been asked to do something huge.I say look upon it as a favor to your g/friend and if you can't bring yourself to give the guy a ride as a favor to her just say no.

If two dumbass kids 16 and 20 plan to have a baby, they full well should atleast have one income.

That's not the point here.His g/friend has requested that he give somebody a ride not that he fiscally back them for life.


it starts with the rides. next thing you know, they'll want clothes and formula. can you imagine if i had a kid and my kid was there for a day or so. my poor baby would have to share his formula with their kid! come on now!

she already asked me for some of my clothes cuz she couldn't fit her clothes when she was pregnant. how ridiculous is that? i take care of my gf so why can't he take care of his wife?!


It starts and ends where you decide that it does.Having boundaries and setting limits on what you will/will not do for others is healthy.Going off on a rant because you've been asked to give a total of two rides is not.

Has it ever occured to you that this girl's family might not like this situation but that they are doing what they can to help because of the baby and because the girl herself is young enough that she might mature and show better sense in the future?


if they had any brains or cared about her at all they wouldnt have let it happen in the first place.

How many children have you reared to adulthood?

What should happen and what does happen is very often two different things.Short of chaining her up (which will only get the parents jailed)there aren't a lot of legal options for parents of teenagers to control immoral behaviors.One can only hope that uf the girl was innoculated with any sort of value system as a young child,that as she matures good sense will return.

As a mother I can tell you that one doesn't simply write off a 16 yr old and throw them to the wolves for being stupid easily.

i don't need to have children to know that when i am a dad i will not let my 16 year old daughter ,date, fvck, marry, and get prego with a 20 year old piece of $hit. they obviously didn't raise here to think about the consequences of her actions nor are they smart enough to make the decisions for her. at 16 she is still a minor and her parents have some control over her. and i seriously doubt they started seeing eachother and got married and pregnant all when she was 16, i bet they were dating before that which makes me think that she is a slut, her parents are retards , and you are defending them for god knows what reasons.

How do you propose to keep your willful 16 yr old in line with your wishes as a parent? Please list only legal methods.You would be very surprised at the actually very small amount of real control the law gives you.I've been there,done that and as it was explained to me by the courts as a parent you have zero rights to anything,only responsiblities...there's a huge difference between those two things.

You cannot force birth control on a teenage minor or any other reproductive mdedical procedure for that matter, you cannot force or prevent an abortion,you cannot lock them in rooms,hit or curse at them.Running away and other soft delinquent activties have been deemed not criminal,our foster care system is set up to help abused children,not to deal with delinquent teens.Our reform school system has been disassembled and only boys who steal cars,rape,murder or set fires get beds in locked juvenille facilties.A judge can wag his finger at a sexually active 16 yr old but in reality that's all that's going to happen.

Btw,most teenage girls don't have sex because they're horny sluts,they do it generally to get love and approval from somebody they think they love.


As parents all you can do is to try to let your kids see you practicing the values you preach to them about.You also try to let natural consequences be a teacher with yourself as a safety net.In the end
when you're parenting a willful teen all you can do is to try to keep the lines of communication open and pray a lot for the maturation process to kick in.
 

MaDHaVoK

Senior member
Mar 7, 2001
601
0
0
People who abuse welfare and such are the scum of the world. I can't stand that crap, and I hope all those people get what the deserve.
 

EmperorIQ

Platinum Member
Sep 30, 2003
2,003
0
0
Originally posted by: pillage2001
Originally posted by: lilcam
oh ... i'm really starting to rethink this relationship. even my mom is mad and tells me i deserve better. why i still stay with her i dont know.

Asian traditions are all fvcked up if you ask me. I'm sorry if I offend the other asian ppl on this board. I'm not saying all asian, but I've seen enough especially dealing with this personally and seeing my cousins going through the same sh!t before. They got married a little over a year ago after they thought she was pregnant. I think she had a miscarriage or something. So, then I heard these two were trying to get pregnant -----WTF???:Q but couldnt because he kept smoking that herb or whatever he was on. Now she actually got pregnant and they'll be messed up cuz I know damn well the girl's mother will be taking care of that kid. The 16 y/o doesnt know any better.

The guy stated awhile back that his kid would be getting a free ride from welfare. Thats cool and all if you really need it, but to abuse it and not work because you get "free" money aint coo. <---WTF?? :Q

and what's messed up is her mom keeps saying we make lots of money and we should contribute some to her monthly <---Biggest WTF :Q . this woman is in her mid 30s and needs to freakign work!!! my mom is in her 40s and she's working like every other folks! why should she be any different. I can't imagine what it would be like if we were rich.


The last bolded statement is way out of hand. Who the fvck is her mother to ask you to contribute to her since you're making money?? Dude, you're in for a lot of trouble if you even think of marrying your current Gf now. Both you and her will be obligated to give a certain amount till she's in her grave.

This is one of the biggest most biggest reasons why i hate being asian. Hell, this is ABOUT 90% of why i dont' like being asian. They always feel that richer relatives should pay up for the poor useless ones. gawddamn people its america, not china (communism) if you're too damn retarded to do something with your life then hell go kill yourself. I had relatives leech off of my parents for 10 fvcking years, while they are also struggling to raise their 4 children (including me) my grandparents made my father feel guilty and he had to take care of his 3 sisters, his little brother and his little brother's wife and kids. All that added together is about 10 years+ of work from them. When we really had money problems and my parents were in debt due to a failed business, those bastards blamed my father and ignored him for a couple of months, and still because of his dumbass chinese heritage he feels that he should take care of them. It was only after i started to openly show that they weren't appreciated around my house that they slowly moved out!!

Dude, don't take care of your gf's family, do what you can for yourself. Yes you should help people out as much as you can, but if they are just retarded leeches, then why bother? let them rot!
 

Chrono

Diamond Member
Jan 2, 2001
4,959
0
71
Holy crap! I feel for you dude. Hope you resolve this situation soon. DUMP HER!
That is really crappy.
 

rh71

No Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
52,844
1,049
126
I feel for ya dude... I don't think you're cold-hearted. Even though you should help if you can, the guy isn't handicapped... and it's none of that is really your responsibility. If the [young] couple has any respect for others at all, they would not act so desperate for your help. If I were in the husband's shoes, I'd bust my @$$ to clean up my own mess.
 

slewfoot

Junior Member
Feb 28, 2002
21
0
0
I guess I see this more from Geekbabe's point of view. Sometimes we have to approach things as they are, not how we feel that they should be. This baby was wanted and I'm sure that this is a joyous occasion for the family and they are very exited about it. The errands your girlfriend wanted you to go on were part of the "festivities". I'm sure that you don't see it that way, but ask her and see.

As to you supporting the family, I do see that many times in immigrant families, not just Asian ones. The ones that are doing well are expected to help the others along. As was stated, you set the limits of how much if any assistance is given.

This does remind me of the guy on this board who was asked to give his girlfriends family $10,000 for a cousins education. I never heard how that came out.
 

gunblade

Golden Member
Nov 18, 2002
1,470
0
71
I don't think that you should break up with your girlfriend for this. She has no choice what kind of family she was born in. It really hurt that someone you love leave you just because of something you can't change.

Just make it clear to her that you two have your own life and can only do up to a limit to help.

Also, I think you should try to make it clear to your girlfriend's family that you do not agree with what the family does and let her know that you help them bacause of her.
 

Aquaman

Lifer
Dec 17, 1999
25,054
13
0
Originally posted by: slewfoot
I guess I see this more from Geekbabe's point of view. Sometimes we have to approach things as they are, not how we feel that they should be. This baby was wanted and I'm sure that this is a joyous occasion for the family and they are very exited about it. The errands your girlfriend wanted you to go on were part of the "festivities". I'm sure that you don't see it that way, but ask her and see.

As to you supporting the family, I do see that many times in immigrant families, not just Asian ones. The ones that are doing well are expected to help the others along. As was stated, you set the limits of how much if any assistance is given.

This does remind me of the guy on this board who was asked to give his girlfriends family $10,000 for a cousins education. I never heard how that came out.

This guy?

Cheers,
Aquaman
 

slewfoot

Junior Member
Feb 28, 2002
21
0
0
Yes, that is the guy. I'm glad that he saw the situation to a good conclusion. I just brought this up for the OP to beware of sob stories that may not ring true.
 

adelphi

Banned
Dec 28, 2003
564
0
0
one time my gf show up at my door, came in and got piss b'cos i was all reticent when she wants to discuss
'issues' so she went downstairs and left , cry in the car and use her cell to tell me she hates me and that i'm a
heartless bastard. so i said 'hey want to go see attack of the clones?' she sez thru sniffles 'ummm...okay'
and so we did.....went out but couldn't find parkin by the theater, so we went to the park and lie
in the grass instead.....surreal
 

Chaotic42

Lifer
Jun 15, 2001
34,600
1,760
126
Originally posted by: ohtwell
The fact that a 16 year old married a 20 year old, and they've just had a baby, bothers me. That's not the point of the thread though. I don't think you are cold hearted. I think that you have taken enough crap from them.


: ) Amanda
I agree. Stop this now.

Why doesn't the guy drive?

 

LuckyTaxi

Diamond Member
Dec 24, 2000
6,044
23
81
Originally posted by: Chaotic42
Originally posted by: ohtwell
The fact that a 16 year old married a 20 year old, and they've just had a baby, bothers me. That's not the point of the thread though. I don't think you are cold hearted. I think that you have taken enough crap from them.


: ) Amanda
I agree. Stop this now.

Why doesn't the guy drive?

he cant read the computer exam
 

Chaotic42

Lifer
Jun 15, 2001
34,600
1,760
126
Originally posted by: lilcam
he cant read the computer exam
Wait, so a 16 year old got married to, and pregnant by, an illiterate 20 year old who can't drive and doesn't know how to save money?

Jesus.

 

LuckyTaxi

Diamond Member
Dec 24, 2000
6,044
23
81
Originally posted by: Chaotic42
Originally posted by: lilcam
he cant read the computer exam
Wait, so a 16 year old got married to, and pregnant by, an illiterate 20 year old who can't drive and doesn't know how to save money?

Jesus.

you sir are correct ... now that he's working he's making some money but he's spending it on weed and whatever else he smokes
 

Czesia

Senior member
Nov 22, 2003
296
0
0
If you're willing to be so generous as to help them out in the first place, good for you. It's not your responsibility, but you're making the effort to help out. But you need to make it clear to them that you will help them while they are getting back up on their feet, and the help ends if there's no effort on their side. Her husband should be working fulltime and putting money into savings, and all of that can start right now. It's not shameful to ask for help when you really need it, but make it clear to them that they cannot rely on you because you're not their crutch; just trying to be a nice guy for now. :)
 

CChaos

Golden Member
Mar 4, 2003
1,586
0
0
Geekbabe--I think you need to put the maternal instincts aside. This isn't lilcam's family we're talking about, it's his girlfriend's. If his girlfriend's mother is in her 30's and the sister is 16, then this isn't a willfull teen, it's a child doing exactly what she's been taught. Everyone makes mistakes and everyone needs help sometimes, but this was intentional. Needing help from others is fine when you make a mistake, but it's a bit different when it's a way of life. It almost seems as if it was expected that this girl would have kids so young, just like the fact that the family would contribute to this child's upbringing. Well, it doesn't sound to me like lilcam signed on for that, and that's his choice.

Lilcam--I completely agree with your actions so far. If anyone says you should respect their choice to do something so irresponsible, then they should respect your choice not to support it. This sense of entitlement is what's fvcking up our country. Sixteen year old kids should be in school, and 20 year olds too, unless they are working. If someone will support you to do otherwise, then more power to you, but going on welfare means I'm one of the people supporting you. So, I get to chime in. You want my fvcking money? Well, that's my opinion. It's a package deal.
 

Pliablemoose

Lifer
Oct 11, 1999
25,195
0
56
Lilcam, tough call.

Problem with the situation is that your GF's family is her family & she loves them. Anything you do or say in a negative fashion will be brought up in arguments for the rest of your natural life. If you really love this girl, it wouldn't matter to you. It's that whole unconditional love thing.

I have a bro in law I don't really speak with because of a similar situation. If things were different, I'd ask for custody of his son, but in that alternate universe, I'd also end up killing bro in law (no joke).

Difference is that my wife is on board with the whole keeping him @ arm's distance, IE: he's never been to our house, but his son has multiple times, we give stuff to his son, but not to bro-in-law. Wife is completely on board with it & I really appreciate her judgment.
 

Ninjja

Golden Member
Sep 4, 2003
1,552
0
0
nah dude, you're doing the right thing. someone's gotta at least try and show them that they gotta start to help themselves.
 

Ameesh

Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
23,686
1
0
i think you are making a mistake and should just rid yourself of the whole thing, but if you wont do that be very upfront with your gf.
 

dquan97

Lifer
Jul 9, 2002
12,010
3
0
lilcam, I agree with you and would've done the same thing. There are limits to how much you can help someone, but the limits are more defined if the couple are able to help themselves. I see it as your gf is helping them be lazy.