Originally posted by: meltdown75
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: meltdown75
I wonder if you would have the same attitude if you were working on a line somewhere and went on strike only to have some scab come in and do your job for half the money.
That's the problem with union talk on this board. Most of the people that run unions and their members through the mud have never been a part of either. Put yourself in their position.
I'm not pro-union by any stretch but the anti-union attitude here is has always irked me.
I would realize I'm overpaid. If they can find someone just a as good as me for half the money, why shouldn't they? Wouldn't you?
A job is only worth as much as it takes to fill it. Setting artificially high wages is counter productive. Labor is, and always will be a commodity.
Hypothetical scenario: your union calls for a strike and the members agree and walk out. You are replaced by scabs. Everyone is pissed... except for you. You willingly concede that you were making too much money, drop your sign and go home.
Wow, man. The world either needs more people like you, or less - I can't decide which.
1. I would never belong to a union unless forced to in order to get a job (a reality I find absolutely despicable).
2. I would never actively protest.
3. "Scabs" are merely workers who have every right to do a job they were hired for.
4. A union's ONLY bargaining chip should be the cost of replacing and training new workers.
Unions create a sense of entitlement and low productivity when taken too far. Laws like this Canadian law only make that worse.
Hah, I like your stipulation on point #1. You wouldn't belong to a union UNLESS you were "forced to" for employment reasons. So you're no different than any union worker out there. Do you think their initial reason for seeking employment is to be part of a union? Of course it's not, it's for a paycheque and a living. Everyone's got their own boat to float, union members are no different. Geez, you make them sound like inferior creatures!
Unions create a sense of entitlement and low productivity when taken too far.
I couldn't agree more but they DO have their place in society and serve a purpose.
Anyway, it's not a "law" yet.