Trump and House Republicans trying to kill deal underway on the border.

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
29,842
30,607
136
Why do we need a new border deal? We have a border. It's illegal to cross that border anywhere but the established points of entry. The federal government is responsible for defending the border and preventing illegal entry. No new legislation is necessary. The laws and duty's are clearly established, all that needs to happen is for the federal government to do their job.
How specifically is the government NOT doing their job? They are detaining record numbers of people and applying appropriate laws when they detain them to determine next steps. Are you of the opinion that "defending the border" means we need to shoot anyone who crosses it?
 

trenchfoot

Lifer
Aug 5, 2000
15,772
8,347
136
Trump's version of the Berlin Wall is what MAGAts want because it's what Trump told them to want. It's so much more emotionally fulfilling than balancing the budget (of which the GOP heads of state are such hypocrites about).

The Republican party is built on a foundation of hate. They need enemies to dispense their propagandized hate on and alleviate the fear they've been brain fucked into feeling and believing. They need this hate and fear as a means to rally themselves against a perceived common enemy. They need religiously endorsed racism as a method of defining themselves as a group. They need to be constantly lied to by their cadre so as to be perfectly fine with being lied to because those lies become their truths, their made up version of why they need to keep fighting against whomever or whatever their corporate sponsored stooges in gov't tell them fight against.

Crazy is as Crazy does. The crazier the better. Off they go down that MAGAt red brick road of mayhem and chaos to fuck things up for Biden and the Democrats worse than Trump did to America.
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,934
55,280
136
Why do we need a new border deal? We have a border. It's illegal to cross that border anywhere but the established points of entry.
That is false. Individuals seeking asylum are able to request it regardless of where they enter the US. This is longstanding federal law and it's confusing how frequently conservatives try and spread falsehoods about it. Trump even lost several court cases making this absurd claim!


The federal government is responsible for defending the border and preventing illegal entry. No new legislation is necessary. The laws and duty's are clearly established, all that needs to happen is for the federal government to do their job.
Those administering the federal government say the resources provided are insufficient to do the job in a timely and effective manner.

Imagine having a police department of one person and then passing all sorts of laws to make things illegal. Then you say 'those are already illegal, our town sheriff just needs to do his job and arrest everyone.' All this of course ignores the fact that our immigration legislation as it is is awful and we need to make it much, much easier to legally immigrate to the US, which would require new legislation.

The problem is that Republicans affirmatively do not want to resolve the immigration situation, which is why they keep torpedoing every attempt to do so. The problem you're complaining about? Republicans LOVE it and want it to continue forever. If you want to solve it, vote for Democrats.
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,934
55,280
136
How specifically is the government NOT doing their job? They are detaining record numbers of people and applying appropriate laws when they detain them to determine next steps. Are you of the opinion that "defending the border" means we need to shoot anyone who crosses it?
I do remember how pcgeek used apprehension figures to claim that the border patrol wasn't doing its job. This logic would indicate if they didn't arrest anyone pcgeek would think they were doing an excellent job.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Fenixgoon

eelw

Lifer
Dec 4, 1999
10,333
5,487
136
Lol Repugican governors, 25 of the 26 wrote letter approving of Abbott ignoring SCOTUS ruling that his use of razor wire is illegal and must be removed. Come on D states, just ban guns.
 

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
29,842
30,607
136
I do remember how pcgeek used apprehension figures to claim that the border patrol wasn't doing its job. This logic would indicate if they didn't arrest anyone pcgeek would think they were doing an excellent job.
Yeah those were good times.
 

JD50

Lifer
Sep 4, 2005
11,918
2,883
136
"Current immigration law is fine" from the people who scream loudest about illegal immigration certainly is something I wasn't expecting to see.
 

gothuevos

Diamond Member
Jul 28, 2010
3,438
2,397
136
I do remember how pcgeek used apprehension figures to claim that the border patrol wasn't doing its job. This logic would indicate if they didn't arrest anyone pcgeek would think they were doing an excellent job.

Their rationale/argument is if that many are being encountered, apprehended, etc, then how many more are slipping through?

I'm not saying I agree with it, but that is their entire argument and there's zero way to quantify "who's slipping through."
 

gothuevos

Diamond Member
Jul 28, 2010
3,438
2,397
136
"Current immigration law is fine" from the people who scream loudest about illegal immigration certainly is something I wasn't expecting to see.

Yes I have lost track of what the right is even mad about?

It's simultaneously an invasion that can wait until Trump is in office to fix it, yet also the current immigration laws are enough to take care of it if they're enforced, which they appear to be?

Is this all because of "remain in Mexico" being in limbo?
 

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,934
55,280
136
Their rationale/argument is if that many are being encountered, apprehended, etc, then how many more are slipping through?

I'm not saying I agree with it, but that is their entire argument and there's zero way to quantify "who's slipping through."
Right, but that is an illogical argument. By that measure if the border patrol apprehended no one then that would indicate the border is the most secure it can possibly be.

Similarly, that would mean in any city when the cops got better at catching criminals it would indicate the crime rate went up. It's transparently stupid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: [DHT]Osiris

ch33zw1z

Lifer
Nov 4, 2004
39,747
20,322
146
Start a rumor that trans rights activists are coming over the border. In a week, they’ll be cramming that bill down our throats
 

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
30,976
2,677
126
Start a rumor that trans rights activists are coming over the border. In a week, they’ll be cramming that bill down our throats
People trans across the border daily, its just that millions never go back home. We want them to trans back across and apply for citizenship or asylum in their country of origin.
 

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,494
16,972
136
People trans across the border daily, its just that millions never go back home. We want them to trans back across and apply for citizenship or asylum in their country of origin.

That’s not how the current law works. Are we a nation of laws or are we not?
 

Indus

Lifer
May 11, 2002
15,944
11,103
136
To show people on the right don’t really care about immigration reform.

Just as many if not more people get into this country illegally by Visa overstays yet they never mention it

Because they were vetted originally and likely had financial means to support themselves rather than ending up public charges.

You won't believe how strict the visa process actually is.. it's not easy to get a visa, so they tend to make headlines of the ones that cheat the visa system and ignore border laws.

Best way to think of it is as breaking and entering vs overstaying and not paying the rent (needing an eviction).
 
  • Like
Reactions: FelixDeCat

fskimospy

Elite Member
Mar 10, 2006
87,934
55,280
136
Because they were vetted originally and likely had financial means to support themselves rather than ending up public charges.

You won't believe how strict the visa process actually is.. it's not easy to get a visa, so they tend to make headlines of the ones that cheat the visa system and ignore border laws.

Best way to think of it is as breaking and entering vs overstaying and not paying the rent (needing an eviction).
So then it’s not really about the law, just as he said.

Regardless, most visa overstays are from tourist visas, which are not at all difficult to get.