Traded in the 350z for a Challenger, the wife is taking it over.

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Cuda1447

Lifer
Jul 26, 2002
11,757
0
71
It's an auto. Wife can't drive stick.

Jlee - Mileage I'm not sure yet. We just got it Sunday and I've only driven it once since then. I suspect I'll get around 20 mpg with regular driving.
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
72,409
32,993
136
If I put on my Daisy Duke's will you let me drive that? I really want to drive a Challenger for a day. Not own one, just drive it, really fast and with little thought to consequences.
 

Cuda1447

Lifer
Jul 26, 2002
11,757
0
71
If I put on my Daisy Duke's will you let me drive that? I really want to drive a Challenger for a day. Not own one, just drive it, really fast and with little thought to consequences.

Haha, it depends on what you look like in those Daisy Dukes. I suspect you'll look like a guy... in which case..... LOL
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
It's an auto. Wife can't drive stick.

Jlee - Mileage I'm not sure yet. We just got it Sunday and I've only driven it once since then. I suspect I'll get around 20 mpg with regular driving.

Ah, that's not terrible. I'm averaging 15.9 at the moment..heh.

Not everyone is trying to be racer boy on public streets.

What does this have to do with anything?
 

Ferzerp

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,438
107
106
My '11 SRT is a fat pig, and you know what, until you drive it, you can't judge it by its weight alone. The 08-10 SRTs, sure, fat piggy cars that drive like fat piggy cars, but that's been fixed. It's still huge, but it drives like it weighs 600 or so lbs less. (Actually one review went so far as to claim 1,000 lbs less, but that's BS.)

Not everyone wants little toy cars (i.e. miata).
 
May 13, 2009
12,333
612
126
Ah, that's not terrible. I'm averaging 15.9 at the moment..heh.



What does this have to do with anything?

Because only racer boy wannabes care about that crap. Having a fast car with great handling means jack squat to 99.5% of the driving population. The .5% are usually middle aged men lacking penor size or it's a 17 year old with a 15 year old camaro with fake duals racing around.
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
Because only racer boy wannabes care about that crap. Having a fast car with great handling means jack squat to 99.5% of the driving population. The .5% are usually middle aged men lacking penor size or it's a 17 year old with a 15 year old camaro with fake duals racing around.

Hmm, I guess I'm in the mysterious 0.00% that spends time at drag strips, autocrosses, and race tracks while simultaneously not existing. :rolleyes:
 
May 13, 2009
12,333
612
126
Hmm, I guess I'm in the mysterious 0.00% that spends time at drag strips, autocrosses, and race tracks while simultaneously not existing. :rolleyes:

I don't remember the guy mentioning wanting to take the car to an autocross.:rolleyes:
At least you take your car to the track so I can see the point in having a sports car.
 

Ferzerp

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,438
107
106
Jlee - Mileage I'm not sure yet. We just got it Sunday and I've only driven it once since then. I suspect I'll get around 20 mpg with regular driving.


I get 12-13 on mine, average, but it's the 6.4L
 

JackBurton

Lifer
Jul 18, 2000
15,993
14
81
Auto Challengers are faster than the manuals in most scenarios. The manuals have some overly aggressive torque management on shift that pulls timing by way too much for way too long each time you shift.

That may be, but taking the manual shifting out of a muscle car is like taking out a piece of its soul. It's just not the spirit of a muscle car.

My wife didn't know how to drive a stick, but she learned. She learned because she wanted a full out, no compromise Mustang 5.0. Once she was comfortable driving a stick (practiced for about a year on my truck), we bought the car. And she's VERY happy she got the car the way she did. The auto would just be boring and not nearly as fun to drive.
 

JulesMaximus

No Lifer
Jul 3, 2003
74,561
968
126
and your daily driver is what?

I said and will say again, not everyone cares about max performance.

Those that do, are usually financially constrained.

People who care about max performance are financially constrained? :confused: Care to tell us how you came up with this wildly idiotic notion?
 

satyajitmenon

Golden Member
Apr 3, 2008
1,911
9
81
Auto Challengers are faster than the manuals in most scenarios. The manuals have some overly aggressive torque management on shift that pulls timing by way too much for way too long each time you shift.

Wat? Is that cos they're afraid the tranny won't hold up to shift shock or something?

Is there a way to disable that?
 

Cuda1447

Lifer
Jul 26, 2002
11,757
0
71
Wat? Is that cos they're afraid the tranny won't hold up to shift shock or something?

Is there a way to disable that?

I think a lot of new cars are starting to become like that. If I'm not mistaken the auto 7 speed 370z is faster than the 6 speed manual.
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
I think a lot of new cars are starting to become like that. If I'm not mistaken the auto 7 speed 370z is faster than the 6 speed manual.

It used to be that autos pulled timing during shifts...sad to see it happening to manuals. Just build stronger transmissions! :p
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,136
622
126
More like people need to be less stupid...

ie the Subaru "glass trans"....because a transmission should be strong enough to withstand a clutch drop given the AWD drivetrain.

Same reason some cars have a clutch delay valve to limit how quickly the clutch engages.
 

IcePickFreak

Platinum Member
Jul 12, 2007
2,428
9
81
Too bad you couldn't find a Furious Fuschia (the Panther Pink throwback color) for her. :)
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
More like people need to be less stupid...

ie the Subaru "glass trans"....because a transmission should be strong enough to withstand a clutch drop given the AWD drivetrain.

Same reason some cars have a clutch delay valve to limit how quickly the clutch engages.

To be fair, the STi's 6 speed is much stronger than the WRX's 5 speed - but we're not even talking about AWD cars here. The Toyota E153 (MR2 Turbo) transmission can hold 700+rwhp with sticky tires, and that's 20yo tech!
 

Ferzerp

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
6,438
107
106
Wat? Is that cos they're afraid the tranny won't hold up to shift shock or something?

Is there a way to disable that?


Even for the 08-10 models that have tuner support, the torque management can't be disabled (if I recall correctly). The 11-12 models aren't cracked yet.
 

MattRobertson

Junior Member
Feb 7, 2012
19
0
0
It looks cool but too bad it's so heavy.

I prefer a car that can go around corners well too.

These cars will go around corners *extremely* well, with a few mods.

You can do it on the cheap with an SRT take-off suspension. Find them on EBay with sways for about $400 + shipping. Its a direct bolt-in, and since its a passenger car suspension made for a car that is designed to be a weekend track car, you get a very nice, comfortable compromise that will give an amazing boost in cornering performance. They will lower the vehicle and its center of gravity by 0.5". Which SRT they come off of matters. Challenger SRT is the softest, then the 300, then the Magnum and stiffest is the Charger. All are different only by a teeny bit in the rear except the Challenger SRT which is softer by a bigger margin on all four corners.

Next step up is coilovers and drop the ride height - as aggressive as you want to get. 1" is safe. 2" is aggressive but most effective. Lowering springs are a terrible idea on these cars. Kills the (cheap) stock shocks. Best most survivable coilovers are KW Variant 2. Then put on Hotchkis sways. Do it all at once to save on install headache. The KW's alone are around $1600 street price though. Maybe $350 for the bars. At that point you have an extremely well-handling car whose already super-stiff chassis and independent rear suspension conspire to make that heavy car extraordinarily capable in the corners.

If you have the money and the desire, urethane bushings are awesome. Sway bar end links are a help (and stiffer ones alleviate a failure point as the stock links will bend under extreme circumstances on track). There's more but going past coilovers and sways only make sense on a tracked car.

stick or auto?

that automatic transmission you have is the WA580 - a 5-speed Mercedes AMG transmission taken off the parts shelf back when Daimler owned Chrysler. It is *incredibly* robust. Reportedly rated for about 800 hp. With the right computer modifications you can use it as part of your braking system, which is necessary when tracking a 4400 lb behemoth. So I have dropped from 3rd into 2nd at about 90 mph down to about 35 while standing on the brakes and the tranny takes it just fine.

Thats great on track. for your wife's car it means you will never lose the tranny unless whoever had the car before you abused it.

BTW since thats an AMG transmission you can hook paddle shifters up to it. On the older LX cars that share basically everything with the Challenger, all we had to do was wire into the existing connections (even the steering wheel clockspring had the unused contacts). In a street environment this is surprisingly useful in stop/go traffic-jam traffic. Makes it super easy to putt along. Otherwise not much use for it on the street except in the mountains. the newer Challengers don't have the contacts anymore but there is a setup that uses the AMG paddles and a transmitter/receiver. Moroso makes a verson too but it is expensive, has exposed wires and looks like crap.

Wat? Is that cos they're afraid the tranny won't hold up to shift shock or something?

Is there a way to disable that?
Mercedes-Benz provided the software. Its about ride comfort. Your average driver doesn't want the tranny banging between gears and chirping tires.

It can be defeated. There is the Mopar Performance Transmission Control Module for the earlier 5.7's. Reportedly it will work for the newer vehicles as well but its not rated for them. This reduces TM a lot and more importantly keeps the tranny locked up, even in 1st gear, so you can do the engine braking I mentioned. Can't happen with a stock TCM. You can also get hold of blue-top Mercedes solenoids that will do incredible things. Too incredible if you already have the MPTCM. there is also a very nice TCM reprogrammer, but I don't think it works with the new stuff.

The older cars are fully tunable. The newer ones aren't, in part because they use a rotating encryption key. Mopar just announced they are getting into the tuning market and we'll see what it brings. My bet is on limited, canned tunes but I know that a tuning provider has been given access to the decryption protocol under NDA for a special project. We'll see if Chrysler's issues with regulation are overcome by their desire to support the aftermarket.

HOWEVER, newer cars can become tunable by swapping the PCM and TCM from an older model year. That is how Arrington is making their 'new' 392-based strokers work.

For the OP, a cheap and fun mod is to put an intake on. You will be shocked at how badass it sounds compared to stock, and the sound level will still be perfectly comfortable. I developed an easy-to-assemble intake that can be had for a fraction of a commercial product. Google 'Frankentake IV'. There are literally hundreds of them out in the wild.
 
Last edited: