"Tom Brady prefer his balls to feel a certain way" - balls underinflated

Page 10 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

should pats lose their spot to colts in the superbowl?

  • yes

  • no

  • RG3 is better than Luck


Results are only viewable after voting.

railer

Golden Member
Apr 15, 2000
1,552
69
91
"Oh, yeah, we looked into that but found no cause for concern."

roger-goodell-robert-kraft.jpg


(taken at the Kraft residence, the night before the AFC championship game)

Did Roger wet himself?
 

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,688
126
Just came into this thread to say that I can barely fathom what the rationale is for having the individual teams supply their own balls for offense, given that they are supposed to be identical. Baseball players have their own bats, and hockey players have their own sticks because that is personal equipment and there is legal variation.

I cannot think of any other situation where equipment that is supposed to be standard is self-supplied by the teams.

I'd say it was a dumb idea if BB is indeed found to be responsible but I don't think it had any impact on the game itself, if these balls were that badly under-inflated how did the Ref's go for an entire half without noticing it?. Also pretty sad for Indy when a local reporter is given "leaked" information to report about the investigation. Here's a better story, your team is vastly overrated and your a bunch of sore losers who had to watch a 45-7 debacle unfold in a championship game, come back next year with a real team.

Totally agree. Sore losers. If I was associated with the Colts in any way I'd be very vocal about distancing myself from this. It seems like many have done just that, and they deserve credit.
 

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,688
126
I am not a big fan of CNN but I thought this was well done. I hope this isn't a repost ...


"John Berman: I'm a Patriots fan -- shame on me"


http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/21/opinion/berman-patriots-deflate-gate/index.html

Oh god. Someone needs to sit this man-child down and explain that athletes are real, fallible people. Does he realize that on that Patriots roster that there are 53 imperfect human beings? Drug users? Wife beaters? Philanderers? Who knows? 42 is a little old to be figuring out that these guys are real people underneath. Pathetic.
 

Angry Irishman

Golden Member
Jan 25, 2010
1,883
1
81
i dont think anyone want them out of the sb, this is probably one of the best sb matchups of recent years. even though the seahawks are prolly the best team evar, the pats have the best chance of not making fools of themselves like denver did last year. im not gay r nuttin but brady is awesome

It actually causes me physical pain to read your posts.
 

crownjules

Diamond Member
Jul 7, 2005
4,858
0
76
Just came into this thread to say that I can barely fathom what the rationale is for having the individual teams supply their own balls for offense, given that they are supposed to be identical. Baseball players have their own bats, and hockey players have their own sticks because that is personal equipment and there is legal variation.

I cannot think of any other situation where equipment that is supposed to be standard is self-supplied by the teams.

Brady and Manning lobbied for this change in 2006. Before that it was the home team that supplied all the equipment. So for half their games, the visiting QB had to play with the other guy's balls. To people like you and I it probably doesn't seem like a big deal, but these guys have to handle these balls for a living and millions of dollars rest on each performance. Imagine you like your balls to feel rough but you go into the Meadowlands and have to play with Eli's balls which have been worn down over several months in preparation. Or in the case of Mr Brady who likes them a little soft it seems and he goes into Lambaugh Field where it's also well known that Aaron's balls are pumped up bigger than normal. It's already bad enough you have to worry about the hostile crowd around you but now you can't even get a good feel on the balls? It has to have caused some mishandling in the past and so they lobbied for the ability to bring their own balls wherever they play.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,420
1,600
126
Brady and Manning lobbied for this change in 2006. Before that it was the home team that supplied all the equipment. So for half their games, the visiting QB had to play with the other guy's balls. To people like you and I it probably doesn't seem like a big deal, but these guys have to handle these balls for a living and millions of dollars rest on each performance. Imagine you like your balls to feel rough but you go into the Meadowlands and have to play with Eli's balls which have been worn down over several months in preparation. Or in the case of Mr Brady who likes them a little soft it seems and he goes into Lambaugh Field where it's also well known that Aaron's balls are pumped up bigger than normal. It's already bad enough you have to worry about the hostile crowd around you but now you can't even get a good feel on the balls? It has to have caused some mishandling in the past and so they lobbied for the ability to bring their own balls wherever they play.

8/10
 

manimal

Lifer
Mar 30, 2007
13,559
8
0
lets forget the whole thing and have custom balls for each QB on each team. If Dave Kreig has small hands let him have a slightly smaller ball than say Warren Moon. Flutie would have been amazing with small balls.

I think many prospects with small hands could really play better with little balls.
 

BoomerD

No Lifer
Feb 26, 2006
66,670
15,068
146
lets forget the whole thing and have custom balls for each QB on each team. If Dave Kreig has small hands let him have a slightly smaller ball than say Warren Moon. Flutie would have been amazing with small balls.

I think many prospects with small hands could really play better with little balls.

Or better yet, have the NFL provide the balls for every game. BRAND NEW balls, not roughed up, not under or over-inflated...handled and controlled ONLY by NFL officials.
 

unixwizzard

Senior member
Jan 17, 2013
205
0
76
Or better yet, have the NFL provide the balls for every game. BRAND NEW balls, not roughed up, not under or over-inflated...handled and controlled ONLY by NFL officials.

this is what I thought happened.. up until just before the two championship games last Sunday..

I do recall in the week prior to those games, seeing 2 or 3 stories in the papers specifically about this subject - the balls and how they are prepped for the game, hell I remember they even had a short segment about it during the NFC Championship pre-game on Fox.

The skeptic in me makes me think that this was a setup all along. If not that at the very least it gave somebody an idea. Makes you wonder, if GB had won would there be griping about "overinflated" balls? Since we all know now how Rodgers likes his balls hard (try saying that with a straight face!).

I bet that had Indy won, this wouldn't even be a story. I think this story came (leaked) from either a disgruntled Indy fan or a Seahawks fan who is terrified his team will also be demolished by Brady in the big game. So let's get this story out there and hope that someone important gets suspended, if not at best then this will be a major distraction that hopefully causes the Patriots to lose. *shrug*
 

IndyColtsFan

Lifer
Sep 22, 2007
33,655
688
126
I'd say it was a dumb idea if BB is indeed found to be responsible but I don't think it had any impact on the game itself, if these balls were that badly under-inflated how did the Ref's go for an entire half without noticing it?. Also pretty sad for Indy when a local reporter is given "leaked" information to report about the investigation. Here's a better story, your team is vastly overrated and your a bunch of sore losers who had to watch a 45-7 debacle unfold in a championship game, come back next year with a real team.

Uh, bullshit.

We don't know what happened yet, but I suspect the Patriots did deflate the balls. I also suspect that even if they did, the NFL will sweep it under the carpet. Don't like being accused of cheating? Here's an easy way to avoid it -- how about NOT cheating? You guys who are saying things like "Uh, well, it didn't really affect the outcome so we should just ignore it" are completely and totally missing the point. Not surprising for Patriots fans, but I'll spell it out again: Outcome doesn't matter, intention does.

The fact that there are people in this thread saying "Oh, it didn't impact the outcome, so let's drop it" is a really, REALLY sad statement about the mentality here. I don't care if the Colts lost 70-0, if I heard they were pulling shenanigans like this, I'd want them punished. Patriots fans desperate for a SB win, however, apparently are willing to look past anything. You have a coach with a documented history of cheating and questionable behavior but as long as he keeps winning, you guys look beyond it. I really hope I don't hear any Patriots fans bashing Carroll over the next several days for his cheating in college, because he has nothing on Bill.

Good luck to you Patriots fans in the Super Bowl -- the shitstorm you're going to experience if they lose will probably cause half of you to jump off a building.
 
Last edited:

NoTine42

Golden Member
Sep 30, 2013
1,387
78
91
I'm guessing this started after Brady's embarrassing loss to KC where Brady was benched after 2 INT.

Brady probably complained about the ball, then someone took it on themselves to start down the underplayed path to "help" him out. That someone might have been a coach, or it may have just been an overzealous equipment manager.
 

Linflas

Lifer
Jan 30, 2001
15,395
78
91
Uh, bullshit.

We don't know what happened yet, but I suspect the Patriots did deflate the balls. I also suspect that even if they did, the NFL will sweep it under the carpet. Don't like being accused of cheating? Here's an easy way to avoid it -- how about NOT cheating? You guys who are saying things like "Uh, well, it didn't really affect the outcome so we should just ignore it" are completely and totally missing the point. Not surprising for Patriots fans, but I'll spell it out again: Outcome doesn't matter, intention does.

The fact that there are people in this thread saying "Oh, it didn't impact the outcome, so let's drop it" is a really, REALLY sad statement about the mentality here. I don't care if the Colts lost 70-0, if I heard they were pulling shenanigans like this, I'd want them punished. Patriots fans desperate for a SB win, however, apparently are willing to look past anything. You have a coach with a documented history of cheating and questionable behavior but as long as he keeps winning, you guys look beyond it. I really hope I don't hear any Patriots fans bashing Carroll over the next several days for his cheating in college, because he has nothing on Bill.

Good luck to you Patriots fans in the Super Bowl -- the shitstorm you're going to experience if they lose will probably cause half of you to jump off a building.

Given that as the story develops it is very likely this is not an isolated incident and balls like this were used in games before the Colts-Pats game. Evidently the Ravens alerted the Colts prior to the game regarding suspicions of deflated footballs and further the league was evidently aware of all this and planned to inspect the balls at half time even before the interception that raised the initial report from the Colts equipment guy.
 

manimal

Lifer
Mar 30, 2007
13,559
8
0
Given that as the story develops it is very likely this is not an isolated incident and balls like this were used in games before the Colts-Pats game. Evidently the Ravens alerted the Colts prior to the game regarding suspicions of deflated footballs and further the league was evidently aware of all this and planned to inspect the balls at half time even before the interception that raised the initial report from the Colts equipment guy.

Screw the league if they knew about it and only checked after the half. This shit needs to be regulated early and often. League is run by a bunch of idiots.



Can Godell go off into the sunset soon please?
 

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,688
126
Given that as the story develops it is very likely this is not an isolated incident and balls like this were used in games before the Colts-Pats game. Evidently the Ravens alerted the Colts prior to the game regarding suspicions of deflated footballs and further the league was evidently aware of all this and planned to inspect the balls at half time even before the interception that raised the initial report from the Colts equipment guy.

HAHAHA LMAO.

Yeah, the Pats might be cheating. Lets check at halftime. o_O
 

NoCreativity

Golden Member
Feb 28, 2008
1,735
62
91
Given that as the story develops it is very likely this is not an isolated incident and balls like this were used in games before the Colts-Pats game. Evidently the Ravens alerted the Colts prior to the game regarding suspicions of deflated footballs and further the league was evidently aware of all this and planned to inspect the balls at half time even before the interception that raised the initial report from the Colts equipment guy.

If that's the case, MIA, NYJ, DET, SD, KC, & DEN should all be chiming in as they all intercepted Brady during the season.
 

Kev

Lifer
Dec 17, 2001
16,367
4
81
Uh, bullshit.

We don't know what happened yet, but I suspect the Patriots did deflate the balls. I also suspect that even if they did, the NFL will sweep it under the carpet. Don't like being accused of cheating? Here's an easy way to avoid it -- how about NOT cheating? You guys who are saying things like "Uh, well, it didn't really affect the outcome so we should just ignore it" are completely and totally missing the point. Not surprising for Patriots fans, but I'll spell it out again: Outcome doesn't matter, intention does.

The fact that there are people in this thread saying "Oh, it didn't impact the outcome, so let's drop it" is a really, REALLY sad statement about the mentality here. I don't care if the Colts lost 70-0, if I heard they were pulling shenanigans like this, I'd want them punished. Patriots fans desperate for a SB win, however, apparently are willing to look past anything. You have a coach with a documented history of cheating and questionable behavior but as long as he keeps winning, you guys look beyond it. I really hope I don't hear any Patriots fans bashing Carroll over the next several days for his cheating in college, because he has nothing on Bill.

Good luck to you Patriots fans in the Super Bowl -- the shitstorm you're going to experience if they lose will probably cause half of you to jump off a building.

Yeah I take back anything I've ever said about BB being a great coach. This was the last straw, to me he is just a cheating scumbag now.
 

mcurphy

Diamond Member
Feb 5, 2003
4,150
8
81
This whole story has been blown waaay out of proportion. It is common for QBs to work footballs to their liking. Everyone does it, and has done it for years! I heard Scott Zolak talk on the radio today that some QBs would even go to the extent of completely deflating a ball and running it through a "ringer" to adjust it to his liking. The QB's in the league are now all PISSED off at the Colt's for whistle blowing a common practice. It is reported that Manning is more pissed off than anyone. Now QB's will all have to use the same "out-of-the-box" balls, and it is going to suck for them. Good job Colts! Good job!

Deflating footballs, dipping hockey pucks in water, scuffing a baseball....these are all common practices, and widely accepted in the in their respective leagues. Until some idiot team or player that can't compete, complains about it, and ruins it for everyone. Ridiculous.
 

KeithTalent

Elite Member | Administrator | No Lifer
Administrator
Nov 30, 2005
50,231
118
116
This whole story has been blown waaay out of proportion. It is common for QBs to work footballs to their liking. Everyone does it, and has done it for years! I heard Scott Zolak talk on the radio today that some QBs would even go to the extent of completely deflating a ball and running it through a "ringer" to adjust it to his liking. The QB's in the league are now all PISSED off at the Colt's for whistle blowing a common practice. It is reported that Manning is more pissed off than anyone. Now QB's will all have to use the same "out-of-the-box" balls, and it is going to suck for them. Good job Colts! Good job!

Deflating footballs, dipping hockey pucks in water, scuffing a baseball....these are all common practices, and widely accepted in the in their respective leagues. Until some idiot team or player that can't compete, complains about it, and ruins it for everyone. Ridiculous.

Yeah, I can't even believe this is still being discussed. Who gives a shit.

Wish we did not have to wait for another 10 days for the actual game.

KT
 

mcurphy

Diamond Member
Feb 5, 2003
4,150
8
81
Yeah, I can't even believe this is still being discussed. Who gives a shit.

Wish we did not have to wait for another 10 days for the actual game.

KT

Yep, exactly! Who gives a shit! From the discussion I heard this morning, everyone involved in Pro football is either laughing their ass off at the publicity this has gotten, or is pissed off because it could change how the game is played.