The never ending battle, Startrek Vs. Starwars Vs. LOTR

[Czar]

What is your favorite series?

 

[Texmaster]

All right first voter!

Star Wars rules

 

[BD2003]

Hmm...second voter.

Kinda glad they left tom bombadil out of FOTR, he was the jar-jar of the series.

 

[yakko]

Star Wars. I only liked a few of the Star Trek movies and Peter Jackson screwed up The Lord Of The Rings.

 

[Ameesh]

star trek is the best. star wars has jar jar, lotr isnt science fiction.

 

[Texmaster]

<< star trek is the best. star wars has jar jar, lotr isnt science fiction. >>



Star Trek has Voyager and Enterprise. Clearly you are in the loosing column now

 

[JeffreyLebowski]

I went with Star Trek, because it has a much more detailed and fleshed out universe.
Star Wars is cool and all, but the new movies haven't impressed me.
LOTR just wan't very good IMHO

 

[SpecialEd]

star wars is the best mix fantasy/sci fi/action. LOTR will have the most emotional and dramatic movies. Star Trek will have the most losers in attendance to its movies.

 

[neomits]

hmmmm
It wasn't a toughy untill you through LOTRs in there. But I don't think it should even be there unless I guess if this is a geek fanboy vote.

I'd vote Starwars as the best Sci-Fi and LOTR as the best Fantasy but just one..... I guess SW

 

[tops2]

starwars all the way!

 

[Czar]

<<

<< star trek is the best. star wars has jar jar, lotr isnt science fiction. >>



Star Trek has Voyager and Enterprise. Clearly you are in the loosing column now >>


Voyager was pretty bad, but Enterprise is good

But nothing can beat the quality and "epic" of the LOTR series

 

[azazyel]

Star Wars:

-best movies
-best books
-best video games
-best comics
-best action figures

 

[AreaCode707]

I think it kind of depends on what type of movies you like. Star Trek is true scifi. Star Wars is almost a buddy movie type thing, along the same format of many westerns that were produced at the time (no one hurt me, I voted Star Wars!), and LOTR is a true epic.

 

[ElFenix]

<< Star Wars:
...
-best books >>

say what? LOTR whips it. sure, they're far better than the star trek books (except for anything by kevin j anderson and a couple others like the children of the jedi and the one where han and luke just whine about the good old days) but they can't even touch LOTR.

 

[azazyel]

The Timothy Zahn books were the best of SW. And you are right about LOTR...I was mostly comparing between SW & ST

 

[kami]

<< Star Wars:

-best books >>



you freaking imbecile!!!
say whatever you want but don't say that.

are you on crack? sh*t...

 

[b0mbrman]

Sorry to say that I've never seen any of these movies

 

[AaronP]

nothin is better than ST2-ST4

 

[Pundit]

Although I think the Star Wars movies are better than the Star Trek movies, I voted Trek because of how immersed I've been because of the TV series. Some of the Star Trek movies were very disappointing.

 

[Pundit]

<< nothin is better than ST2-ST4 >>


ST4 meaning The Voyage Home? You couldn't get much worse than that.

 

[NFS4]

STAR TREK OWNZ J00

LOTR is for squares

 

[StageLeft]

Star trek is i love you-land (no offense to bundles of twigs) incarnate and I mean that in the cleanest most crystal clear sense I can.

Star wars is about 4 milion times better than star trek and - in fact my god isn't that a dumb name? Star TREK? Come on now - so anyway yes and then LOTR is similar in coolness to Star Wars.

 

[Stiler]

good god, star trek has to be the suckiest thing that sucked the ever suck. so freaking boring and made about -1million sense. LOTR was simply awesome, Star wars is the best sci/fi flick lotr best fantasy flick, star trek best geek fest beam me up scotty crapola shiet.

 

[Theslowone]

LoTR is the best, and I would of liked to see tom bombadil in the movie, well I would of liked to see aragon carry the broken sword too, but who knows what they where thinking.

 

[StageLeft]

<< good god, star trek has to be the suckiest thing that sucked the ever suck. so freaking boring and made about -1million sense. LOTR was simply awesome, Star wars is the best sci/fi flick lotr best fantasy flick, star trek best geek fest beam me up scotty crapola shiet. >>

Eloquently put, but I agree. Star Trek is boring and geekish beyond all proportions. Bar none ever episode has at least one part where I'm like *GROAN* and I feel embarassed for the people on the show for something so interminably goofy they did.