The end of customer service

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

MagnusTheBrewer

IN MEMORIAM
Jun 19, 2004
24,122
1,594
126
Customer service is not and, will never be dead. People by nature (with the possible exception of technogeeks) are social creatures. The level of customer service has declined both through automation and lack of training due to managements inability to link good customer service and profits. The sad part is that due to the decline of customer service and the change in society's view towards the value of providing good customer service, there is an entire generation who needs to be re-educated.

Good customer service is not common sense, it is the ability to put yourself in the customers shoes and use your intimate knowledge of your service to best meet the customer's needs. That training coupled with respect for tradition are the keystones to great customer service. It is a complicated skill which requires both knowledge and the gift of hospitality. Stores, restaurants and, hotels are in the customer service business no matter what product they sell.

Banks are not and never were in the customer service industry regardless of their marketing claims. They offer financial services period. The only reason banks even have B&M storefronts is part tradition and part "good will" marketing. All banks would survive quite well without the hassle of dealing with individual customers weekly paychecks.

It is common to denigrate the service positions in the stores/restaurants/inns we frequent but it is a much harder thing to quantify good service. True, simple politeness goes a long way but, it is that lack of value we put on service as a society that is the real issue. Until we value good service as a major contributor to revenue in the service industry, we will continue to suffer from poor returns on investment, lack of qualified employees and, long lines that technology can't solve like a human can.
 

Legendary

Diamond Member
Jan 22, 2002
7,019
1
0
A completely empty self checkout line is a haven for me in a crowded grocery store. As a former grocery store cashier, I can school those chumps in any and all bagging procedures.
Sadly not too many in NYC.
 

SuperjetMatt

Senior member
Nov 16, 2007
406
0
0
I hate self-checkout. It's always telling me that I didn't put something in the bag, to get something back out of the bag, etc etc ad nauseum.
 

bobsmith1492

Diamond Member
Feb 21, 2004
3,875
3
81
A local Meijers has nice self-checkout lanes, no limits, with conveyor wheels to roll stuff down to the end. Much faster than with a cashier and you don't have to stand there awkwardly watching them fumble with your toilet paper and whatnot. :)


Also, the only time I ever see or use cash anymore is while doing laundry since the machines take quarters.
 

slag

Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
10,473
81
101
Originally posted by: krunchykrome
Inspired by this article.

When I go to a grocery store, I specifically look for the self-checkout. Sometimes, I actually go out of my way to visit a grocery store that has the self-checkout machines. It's not because I want to privacy that the machine offers. It's more of a convenience to me to do it all myself and not rely on some potentially incompetent cashier. I actually find that I checkout much faster when I "do it myself", rather than letting a cashier check me out.

I actually wish more places would move forward with the self-checkout intiative. I'm not sure if I can think of a retail business where a self-checkout would not be feasible. Sure, it means less jobs for people, but why pay a human to do something that a machine can do in possibly less time. The article mentions that the machines recover their costs in about six months.

And with regards to true customer service, and the lack of it that these machines offer, I actually have a much more pleasant shopping experience with these machines than I do with most cashier human intereaction. I dont remember the last time I received good customer service. Now I understand that the retail industry does not pay well, and you can't expect to find a motivated employee who earns just $8 an hour. But any employee, regardless of hourly rate should know the difference between acceptable service and bad service. I actually expect more businesses to start using the self-checkout machines more.

I think many retail jobs will not exist in the near future. I believe that some banks have already started, however I havent seen any yet; my prediction is that bank tellers will not exist in 10 years. The job is really a systematic one, with each transaction involving very little difference.


Im the exact opposite of you. I loathe self checkout machines. I'll be damned if i'm going to not only shop at the store, but also check myself out. Thats why there are cashiers. Let them ring my stuff up ,figure out if its on the scale right, punch the buttons, scan the items, etc.. I have better things to do. If for some reason I was forced to use a self checkout machine, I'd better be compensated at that time for at least 15% off the total purchase for my trouble.
 

Jeff7

Lifer
Jan 4, 2001
41,596
20
81
I go to self-checkouts at Giant Eagle. I've tried them at Walmart, and they just aren't as good. Plus, at GE, there's generally someone there to bag your purchases.

I find that they can be efficient, too. In a regular checkout, you stand idle while a worker does all the work. In a self-checkout aisle, you are doing work while the store's employees are also doing work. The net result is more work done per unit time.:D
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,082
136
Not at stores.
The machine always messes up and I need a clerk to come over and fix it. Never once got through a self check out properly.

Also, at Home Depot they have just as many people monitoring checkouts as they have checkouts.
Why the hell dont they just run the things normally?
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Reasons I love self checkout lines at supermarket:
1) replaces union workers with an efficient machine
2) no more standing behind a tool who still writes checks to pay for groceries
 

BigJ

Lifer
Nov 18, 2001
21,330
1
81
Originally posted by: shortylickens
Also, at Home Depot they have just as many people monitoring checkouts as they have checkouts.
Why the hell dont they just run the things normally?

At Self Checkout, there's typically a regular cashier and a Head Cashier or Front End Supervisor (FES). Unless absolutely necessary, you will not see that HC or FES ringing due to them having to constantly attend to cashiers and customers.
 

JS80

Lifer
Oct 24, 2005
26,271
7
81
Originally posted by: Atomic Playboy
The problem I have with self-checkout is that it is yet another way for large companies to screw employees. Why pay 8 cashiers when you can pay 1 cashier to watch 8 self-checkout machines? It's screwing Americans out of jobs. It's the exact same thing that manufacturing plant workers have been complaining about for decades; machines come in, they do the work of 10 people, and all you need is one person to make sure the machine runs. So now 9 people are out of a job while the CEOs get a healthy bonus for "trimming the fat." It is absolute bullshit, and anyone who cares about American workers in any way, shape or form will realize that these machines are designed solely to reduce head count and generate more profit for the corporate elite at the expense of hard-working Americans. Fuck that.

We should get rid of traffic lights too and bring back traffic directors.
 

schizoid77

Senior member
Mar 4, 2008
357
0
0
There are still multiple problems with self check outs;
1. Incompetent customers that don't understand how it works and needs the supervisor to keep resetting the scales.
2. Customers that take full carts through and spend 30 minutes scanning, these machines are slower than the ones real cashiers use. They are also EXPRESS LANES. GTFO with your cart, people!
3. Buying alcohol. You need the supervisor to authorize it and they're not always standing there.
4. Fruits and vegetables, people spend 5 minutes looking for their arugula on that spinner, when most cashiers will have the codes memorized by now.

Other than these things and a few others, they are great. But it's mostly the customers that are ruining the experience for everyone.
 

videogames101

Diamond Member
Aug 24, 2005
6,783
27
91
I do groceries 10x faster myself, so yes, especially because most cashiers around here are complete morons.
 

Jawo

Diamond Member
Jun 15, 2005
4,125
0
0
Originally posted by: krunchykrome
Originally posted by: Anubis
Originally posted by: Ns1
While checking out, do think of each transaction as...


CR Sales
DR AR - KrunchyKrome
CR Inventory
DR Cogs
CR Sales
DR AR - KrunchyKrome
CR Inventory
DR Cogs
CR Sales
DR AR - KrunchyKrome
CR Inventory
DR Cogs
CR Sales
DR AR - KrunchyKrome
CR Inventory
DR Cogs
CR Sales
DR AR - KrunchyKrome
CR Inventory
DR Cogs

CR AR - KrunchyKrome
DR Cash




I do. And it frightens me.


What about the internal controls? If 1 out of every 100 transactions has an error, what type of impact will that have on the financial statements? Risk overstating sales? OH NOES.


Sorry, I'm really bored.

ermmm what?

:D I enjoyed it Ns1

So did I! :D
 

Scarpozzi

Lifer
Jun 13, 2000
26,392
1,780
126
I hate how self checkout machines ask all the stupid questions. I wish they'd just let me use a normal checkout machine. You can scan things 20 times faster and you don't have the stupid thing asking you if you have items under your cart.
 

EGGO

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2004
5,504
1
0
Hate them. If the bag I put my stuff in moves in the slightest bit, it stops and says to put an item back into the bag.
 

JC86

Senior member
Jan 18, 2007
694
0
0
I actually prefer these kiosks over the traditional checkout counters as well. With groceries, I've found that if i'm not buying bagged produce that don't have barcodes, self-checkout is definitely the way to go. However, If i'm buying fresh produce that needs to be bagged, it is PITA to scroll through the menu searching for the item. When that happens, I just go to a traditional checkout lane. The Lowes and HD self-checkouts are nice although occasionally you seem some idiot buying bulk items like lumber or pipes getting in line and trying to scan the items.
 

cherrytwist

Diamond Member
Apr 11, 2000
6,019
25
86
Originally posted by: Fern
Originally posted by: venkman
Originally posted by: Anubis
Originally posted by: Ns1
While checking out, do think of each transaction as...


CR Sales
DR AR - KrunchyKrome
CR Inventory
-snip-

I do. And it frightens me.


What about the internal controls? If 1 out of every 100 transactions has an error, what type of impact will that have on the financial statements? Risk overstating sales? OH NOES.


Sorry, I'm really bored.

ermmm what?

Must be Cashier speak

Nope, it's accounting speak. He's listing out all the journal entries in debits & credits (utilizing a perpetual inventory system).

Edit: yeah, I use the self-checkout a lot. Shorter line, all the luddites, tech-fearing geezers and illiterates are in the regular checkout ailse

Fern

...and the people who don't want to bag their own groceries.
 

Farang

Lifer
Jul 7, 2003
10,913
3
0
Self checkout is useless.. why would I want to bag my own groceries and ring everything up when there is some dumbass getting paid minimum wage to do it for me.
 

Farang

Lifer
Jul 7, 2003
10,913
3
0
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: Atomic Playboy
The problem I have with self-checkout is that it is yet another way for large companies to screw employees. Why pay 8 cashiers when you can pay 1 cashier to watch 8 self-checkout machines? It's screwing Americans out of jobs. It's the exact same thing that manufacturing plant workers have been complaining about for decades; machines come in, they do the work of 10 people, and all you need is one person to make sure the machine runs. So now 9 people are out of a job while the CEOs get a healthy bonus for "trimming the fat." It is absolute bullshit, and anyone who cares about American workers in any way, shape or form will realize that these machines are designed solely to reduce head count and generate more profit for the corporate elite at the expense of hard-working Americans. Fuck that.

We should get rid of traffic lights too and bring back traffic directors.

Let's get rid of all machinery so every one of us becomes a hard working American.. foraging for berries in loincloths in the forest.
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
i like them when they work. and when they have at least 4 stations.
i hate when some old woman just stares at the damn thing, same as at atms when old women take forever.
frankly i wish stores had more of them. never enough. nothing sucks like standing in a long line waiting for checkout. esp bad at prime time hours at grocery when there are full carts that take ages.
its not like workers are out of work. which would you rather be? the one standing at the center podium to watch over 4 self checkouts and help customers if a glitch happens or something doesn't scan, or standing stuck behind a single counter constantly scanning a buncha stuff old school assembly line style. its not fun, it hurts to stand like that for a long time. you can feel the impatience of the people and the pressure if theres a long line. it sucks hard. optimally they would almost all be self checkouts. as a worker covering a self checkout you'd be an administrator. working casher duty you are a drone. i don't care if i have to bag my own groceries. if it saves time, its not much of a price to pay. the most infuriating part of visiting stores like the grocers is the checkout. you know this is true. i dread it.