Yes, completely impossible when you've lived in your house for less than a year and they look similar.
http://newsone.com/2291223/caleb-gordley-virginia/
Video states he was two doors down and it pans and shows they look extremely similar (1:40 in the video)
google view aerial view (no street view)
But the kid committed breaking and entering. He had to forcefully remove/break the window screen. And then he had to ignore the alarm going off. And then he had to ignore the "warning" shot.
It's sad, but I don't really buy he just thought it was the wrong house. More like a burglary gone wrong.