Boy I'd love to see you guys take on Alan Dershowitz or the other constitutional scholars who have all been saying this ruling is completely partisan and not based on any kind of constitutional law. If you think they're all liberals think again. There are a lot of conservatives who can actually see past their petty victory and realize that it was a hollow one.
"University of Chicago law professor Cass Sunstein, who considers himself to be an admirer of the Rehnquist court, said that his faith in the justices has been shaken. 'The good thing you can say about this case is that it settled things in the leat messy way. But ass a matter of law it is a real embarrassment. It's the worst moment for the court, atleast since Roe," Sunstein said, referring to the 1973 ruling in Roe vs. Wade that upheld the right to abortion.
'The equal protection holding is a bolt out of the blue. There is no precedent for it and there's no support in history for this type of ruling,' Sunstein said. 'And for it come now in a 5-4 decision, it's just very hard to explain"
He doesn't exactly sound like a liberal whining does he?
"University of Virginia law professor A.E. dick Howrd also said that he finds the ruling difficult to explain on legal grounds.
'This is a remarkable use of the equal protection clause. It is not consistent with anything they have done in the past 25 years,' Howard said. 'No one even claimed there was intentional discrimination here.'"
I love the republican's word for truth they don't like, "spin". A day or two ago there was a thread about how RUSS is always right. Maybe that's cause at times like this when he's wrong, he's smart enough to not say anything besides "haha". I guess you can't be wrong just saying, "haha", but you're pretty damn far from being right. Rehnquist had said that he would like to retire with a republican president and last fall Scalia said that he would retire if Gore was elected because he wouldn't have a shot at becoming Chief Justice. I guess these guys do sound pretty unbiased. Hehe, you think we're whining? Wrong again bub, we're just letting you guys know that even though Bush is going to become president, he definitely didn't win. He was elected by the supreme court which had conservative majority and used it to put their guy in office. If you think there ruling was fair than apparently you haven't looked over all the cases in the past dealing with this clause and seen how this goes against every ruling and belief that these conservative justices have made clear. You guys are the ones whining because you're guy is going to be president, but we won't acknowledge the fact that he won. Well that's cause he didn't.